Treatment of urethral stricture disease in women: A multi‐institutional collaborative project from the SUFU research network

Female ventral-onlay buccal mucosal graft urethroplasty supported with martius labial fat pad flap: early results

PURPOSE

There is a growing interest in reconstructive urology and female urethroplasty. We aimed to report our experience in ventral-onlay buccal mucosa graft (BMG) urethroplasty supported with Martius flap (MF) in treating female urethral stricture disease.

METHODS

We retrospectively evaluated data of 18 female patients (ages 35-78) who were diagnosed with urethral stricture disease and underwent ventral-onlay BMG urethroplasty supported with MF by single surgeon in a tertiary referral centre between February 2019 and October 2022. Detailed history, international prostate symptom score (IPSS), pelvic examination, urine flow rate (rate and pattern), post void residual (PVR), storage and voiding phase urodynamic study, and voiding cystourethrography were recorded. At the last visit; the number of urethral dilatations before urethroplasty, time from urethral dilation to urethroplasty, hospital stay, urethral catheterization time, postoperative IPSS, PVR and uroflowmetry values were recorded.

RESULTS

The presenting symptoms were obstructive voiding symptoms in 16 patients. While the mean number of urethral dilatation was 2.11 ± 1.93 (1-7), the mean time from dilatation to urethroplasty was 5.83 ± 5.00 (1-19 months) months. Maximum flow rate increased from 8.36 ± 3.26 ml/sec in preoperative uroflowmetry to 21.45 ± 5.27 ml/sec at the last follow-up (p < 0.001). Post-void residual urine (PVR) decreased from preoperative mean 116.66 ± 105.88 cc to 26.94 ± 22.69 cc postoperatively (p < 0.004). None of the patients developed stricture recurrence, incontinence or vaginal fistula until the last follow-up. The mean follow-up period was 17.28 ± 11.65 (1-35) months.

CONCLUSIONS

A ventral-onlay BMG urethroplasty supported with MF represents an effective and reproducible treatment option for FUS in the present study.

Surgery for female urethral stricture

BACKGROUND

Female urethral stricture (FUS) is a rare entity that causes great morbidity and suffering in those affected. As the available scientific data is sparce, there are no formal guidelines or standard of care for this disease.

METHODS

This is a narrative review of the surgical management for female urethral stricture. The literature review was performed on PubMed. Articles were limited to English, but there was no limitation in terms of date.

RESULTS

Management of FUS is divided between endoscopic and open surgical repair. Urethral dilation with or without urethrectomy can be offered as a first-line treatment. However, the rate of success of this procedure remains inferior to open surgical repair, and its efficacy decreases with the number of previous dilations. For distal urethral strictures, distal urethrectomy and advancement meatoplasty may be considered. Vaginal flaps are readily available, easy to harvest, well-vascularized, and allow for a dorsal or ventral orientation urethroplasty. The results of this procedure are promising, but most studies are small and retrospective. Labia flaps are easily accessible, wet, hairless, and elastic. The main limitations with the use of vaginal or labial tissues are co-existing conditions such as lichen sclerosis or vaginal atrophy, which may affect future results. Vaginal and labial graft urethroplasty can be used when it is not possible to mobilize an adequate flap. Stricture-free rates of this technique are variable. In cases of more severe stricture, an augmentation urethroplasty using buccal mucosa graft may be necessary. The techniques used in FUS replicate those for male urethral strictures, where both ventral and dorsal approaches can be utilized.

CONCLUSIONS

Although there is growing interest in the field, the optimal management of FUS remains to be determined.

Female urethroplasty with dorsal onlay buccal mucosal graft: a single institution experience

PURPOSE

Female urethral stricture disease is frequently unrecognized or misdiagnosed, with controversy in the literature regarding the definition of strictures and approach to management. The purpose of this study is to report our institutional experience with female urethroplasty and add our experience to the growing body of research.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective review of patients undergoing female urethroplasty with dorsal onlay BMG at the University of Colorado between March 2015 and December 2021 performed by two surgeons (BF and JO). The primary outcome measure was surgical success, defined as no stricture recurrence. The secondary outcome measure was the incidence of de novo urinary incontinence.

RESULTS

23 patients were included in our data analysis. The median duration of lower urinary tract symptoms prior to urethroplasty was 16 years. 87% had undergone previous dilations. At a median follow-up of 12.2 months (range 1-81 months), four patients required a secondary procedure for obstruction with an overall success rate of 83%. One patient developed de novo stress urinary incontinence and one patient developed urge urinary incontinence. Subgroup analysis was performed comparing the patients that developed stricture recurrence (N = 4) to those that did not (N = 19). Those with stricture recurrence had a longer duration of symptoms and more dilations prior to urethroplasty.

CONCLUSION

Female urethroplasty with BMG is effective at treating female urethral stricture disease, with excellent outcomes at over a year of follow-up and minimal risk of stress incontinence postoperatively.

An Update on Female Urethral Stricture Disease

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To provide an overview of female urethral stricture disease and updates on surgical outcomes.

RECENT FINDINGS

In a large retrospective case series, women reported significant improvements in urinary symptoms and quality of life following treatment of their urethral stricture. Both vaginal flap and buccal mucosal graft urethroplasty have higher short- and long-term success rates than urethral dilation. Female urethral stricture disease is rare and surgical reconstruction has the highest likelihood of long-term success. Due to the complexity of reconstruction, referral to a reconstructive trained urologist should be considered.

Benefits and Harms of Conservative, Pharmacological, and Surgical Management Options for Women with Bladder Outlet Obstruction: A Systematic Review from the European Association of Urology Non-neurogenic Female LUTS Guidelines Panel

CONTEXT

While the management of bladder outlet obstruction (BOO) in men has been a topic of several systematic reviews and meta-analyses, no such evidence base exists for female BOO.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this systematic review was to evaluate the benefits and harms of therapeutic interventions for the management of BOO in women.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

This systematic review was conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) statement. The study protocol was registered with PROSPERO (CRD42020183839). A systematic literature search was performed and updated by a research librarian in May 2021. The study population consisted of adult female patients diagnosed with BOO, who underwent treatment.

EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS

Out of 6344 records, we identified 33 studies enrolling 1222 participants, of which only six randomized controlled trials (RCTs) were found. One placebo-controlled crossover randomized trial assessed the role of baclofen in 60 female patients with dysfunctional voiding. The trial met its primary endpoint with a significantly greater decrease in the number of voids per day in the baclofen group (-5.53 vs -2.70; p = 0.001). The adverse events were mild and comparable in both groups (25% vs 20%). One placebo-controlled crossover randomized trial assessed the role of sildenafil in 20 women with Fowler's syndrome. There were significant improvements from baseline in maximum urinary flow rate (Qmax), International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), and postvoid residual (PVR), but with no statistically significant difference when compared with placebo. In a large RCT including 197 female patients with functional BOO, the alpha-blocker alfuzosin significantly improved IPSS, Qmax, and PVR compared with baseline, but the differences were not statistically significant compared with the placebo group. Several small single-arm prospective series reported improvement of BOO-related symptoms and voiding parameters with urethroplasty, sling revision, urethral dilation, vaginal pessary, and pelvic organ prolapse repair.

CONCLUSIONS

Evidence to support the use of conservative, pharmacological, and surgical treatments for BOO is scarce.

PATIENT SUMMARY

According to the present systematic review of the literature, evidence to support the use of conservative, pharmacological, and surgical treatments for either anatomical or functional bladder outlet obstruction is scarce.

Histologic Analysis of Urethral Stricture in 9 Patients Following Dorsal Vaginal Graft Urethroplasty

OBJECTIVE

To present the pathologic analysis of female urethral strictures obtained during reconstructive urethroplasty.

METHODS

Nine separate female urethral tissue specimens were obtained during dorsal vaginal graft urethroplasty by a single surgeon (S.P.P.). Samples were serially sectioned and fixed in 10% formalin 6 to 12 hours before routine processing in paraffin blocks. Serial 5-µm sections were subjected to H&E, Masson trichrome, and elastin staining. End point analysis included evaluation for epithelial hyperplasia and cell type, mucosal edema, degree of fibroblast/inflammatory cell infiltrate, and elastin fiber density and distribution.

RESULTS

Nine specimens were examined. Six specimens had epithelial linings of stratified squamous epithelium overlying fibrosis (67%), 1 had mixed squamous and urothelial epithelium, and 2 had only urothelial epithelium. Two specimens (29%) showed acute injury with prominent squamous papillary hyperplasia, focal erosion, and patchy mucosal hemorrhage. Areas of urethral stricture were variably thickened, with increased, densely packed collagen fibers and associated mucosal lymphocytic inflammation ranging from mild and patchy to focally dense with lymphoid aggregates. The highest elastin fiber density appeared to be associated with vessels and overlying muscle bundles in the submucosa.

CONCLUSIONS

Further elucidation of histopathologic characteristics may illuminate more appropriate therapeutic pathways for female urethral stricture disease management.

Quality of life is improved after urethroplasty in women with urethral stricture

INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS

To evaluate the quality of life (QoL) in women who underwent urethroplasty for urethral stricture.

METHODS

Twenty-two women who underwent ventral labium minus graft urethroplasty were included. Patients were assessed with uroflowmetry, urethral caliber and post-voiding residual urine (PVR). American Urological Association (AUA) symptom score, Urogenital Distress Inventory (UDI)-6 and Short Form-36 (SF-36) were used to evaluate QoL. Preoperative values were compared with patients' last visit data. The cure of the surgery was defined as a maximum flow rate > 15 ml/s in uroflowmetry and no need for any further intervention.

RESULTS

Median age was 55 (40-66) years. Cure was achieved in 20 (90.3%) patients with median 37 (13-52) months follow-up duration. The median Qmax increased from 4 (0-5) ml/s to 27.5 (8-55) ml/s (p < 0.001). Median post-void residual volume (PVR) decreased from 52.5 (0-120) ml to 20(0-60) ml (p = 0.011). Both AUA symptom score [from median 30 (24-35) to 4.5 (0-20), p < 0.001] and AUA-QoL score [from median 5 (4-6) to 0(0-3), p < 0.001] decreased after surgery. Median UDI summary score at the last follow-up was 0 (0-44.4), which was 33.3 (22.2-61.05) at baseline visit. Improvement was observed in all domains except the 'Energy/Fatigue' domain of the SF-36.

CONCLUSIONS

Urethroplasty is an effective surgical method to improve patients' QoL which is impaired because of female urethral stricture.

Dorsal Onlay Oral Mucosa Graft Urethroplasty for Female Urethral Stricture

OBJECTIVE

To describe and assess the outcomes of dorsal onlay oral mucosa graft urethroplasty for female urethral stricture.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the charts of all female patients who underwent dorsal onlay oral (buccal or lingual) mucosa urethroplasty for urethral stricture between 2011 and 2020 at two academic institutions. The primary endpoint was clinical success defined as any subjective improvement in LUTS self-assessed by the patients 1-3 months after catheter removal. Four surgeons performed the urethroplasties using a standardized technique: suprameatal incision, dissection and longitudinal opening of the dorsal aspect of the urethra, harvest of the oral mucosa graft, graft onlay sutured into the urethral opening.

RESULTS

Nineteen patients were included. The clinical success rate was 94.7% at 1-3 months and 90.9% at 1 year. After a median follow-up of 12 months (range 1-49) there was one recurrence (5.3%), clinical success was achieved in 17 patients (89.5%) and both the maximum urinary flow rate and post void residual were significantly improved (15.2 vs 7.4 ml/s preoperatively; P = .008 and 71.5 vs 161.1 ml preoperatively; P = .001 respectively). The de novo stress urinary incontinence rate was 15.7% at 1-3 months and 9.1% at 1 year.

CONCLUSION

Dorsal onlay oral mucosa graft urethroplasty for female urethral stricture appears feasible across multiple surgeons and is associated with a low perioperative morbidity, satisfactory functional outcomes and a low recurrence rate. Other series with larger sample size and longer follow-up are needed to confirm these findings.

[Female voiding dysfunction: Clean intermittent catheterization is not the only option]

Female voiding dysfunction exists but are largely underdiagnosed, especially in France. They can result from two different mechanisms: detrusor underactivity or bladder outlet obstruction, with very different pathophysiology and therapeutic management. There are many different therapeutic options, including surgical treatments, to offer as alternative to clean intermittent catheterization which are often burdensome for patients. Seeking voiding dysfunction in female patients with lower urinary tract symptoms and searching for their etiology to tackle it could lead to a paradigm change in these women: from standardized treatment to individualized treatment. In their practice, nurses can detect warning symptoms suspect of voiding dysfunction, and have thus a role to play in the improvement of patients' screening, education other healthcare providers, and management of female voiding dysfunction.

The outcomes of three buccal mucosal graft urethroplasty techniques in women with urethral stricture disease

AIM

The purpose of this paper is to present the outcomes of three buccal mucosal graft (BMG) urethroplasty techniques in female patients with urethral strictures.

METHODS

We included all patients who had BMG urethroplasty for female urethral strictures (FUS) disease between January 2015 and June 2020. Patient age, comorbidities, stricture etiology, stricture length, the number of previous treatments, preoperative and postoperative uroflowmetry data, postvoid residual volumes, and the operation and postoperative course details were documented.

RESULTS

A total of 34 patients were included in this study. There were 8 patients in vaginal-sparing inlay BMG, 12 for ventral onlay BMG, and 14 for Aybek-Zumrutbas (AZ) technique groups. The mean age of the study population was 56.1 years. The length of urethral strictures varied between one and 4.5 cm. All patients had a previous history of endoscopic treatment or dilatations. The preoperative mean maximal flow rate (Qmax) was 6.9 ml/s. The median postoperative follow-up time was 24.6 months. Twelve months after surgery, the mean Qmax was 25 (range: 14-32) ml/s. There were no significant complications in any patients. The success rates were 83.3% for ventral onlay BMG, 87.5% for vaginal-sparing, and 100% for AZ technique.

CONCLUSIONS

All three BMG urethroplasty techniques applied in this study had a success rate of over 80% in a median follow-up of approximately 2 years. In females, urethroplasty with BMG provided high rates of cure, and the recently described two techniques (vaginal-sparing inlay BMG, and AZ technique) showed promise in FUS treatment.

Treatment of Urethral Stricture Disease in Women: Nonsystematic Review of Surgical Techniques and Intraoperative Considerations

Female urethral strictures are rare, but underdiagnosed pathologies that can cause voiding dysfunction. These strictures are best managed with open reconstruction, as endoscopic treatments have high rates of failure. A flap urethroplasty can be performed with vaginal, labial or bladder tissue. Meanwhile, graft urethroplasties can utilize vaginal, labial, buccal or lingual tissue. It is important to consider the etiology and type of stricture, local vascularity, and prior attempts at repair when selecting the type of repair. Multiple different techniques have been described with theoretical advantages to each one. While some studies have reviewed a few of the reconstructive techniques to treat female urethral strictures, no single study has accounted for each individual technique. In this review, we discuss techniques captured by a number of systematic reviews and other articles. We will herein focus on reviewing and describing each unique technique of reconstruction in the setting of female urethral stricture.

[Contemporary management of urethral strictures in women]

Urethral strictures in women are rare and patients may present with varying symptoms. Hence, clinical guidelines regarding diagnostic algorithms and treatment approaches are scarce. Several small case series have presented results for several operative techniques, but patient cohorts are generally heterogeneous and relatively small, which hampers reliable comparability across institutions. The present narrative review aims to provide a contemporary overview of the literature regarding the clinical and therapeutical approach in women with urethral strictures.Iatrogenic reasons such as previous catheterization or genitourinary surgical interventions are the most common cause of female urethral strictures. In daily clinical routine, physical examination is the cornerstone for differential diagnosis and may aid in the decision to expand diagnostic workup by urethrocystoscopy, urethrography, or magnetic resonance imaging in case of suspected anatomic or morphologic cause of voiding disorder. Endoscopic approaches such as dilation or urethrotomy only provide short-term symptomatic relief and open urethroplasty is more commonly associated with durable long-term success. Regarding the surgical approach, there are comparable operative techniques at hand, using vaginal or labial flaps or oral mucosal grafts. Given the relative rarity of female urethral strictures with only small case series published, a statement regarding the superiority of one approach over the other is hardly possible. As for all rare disorders, multi-institutional, large patient series are needed to generate reliable evidence and to improve standards in the perioperative care of women with urethral strictures.

Female Urethroplasty: Anterior Vaginal Wall Flap (Blandy Flap) - Simpler Tends to Be Better

Urethral stricture is a rare condition in women, representing a diagnostic challenge for the urologist. Its main etiology is traumatic or due to labor. Definitive treatment can be by means of dilations or urethroplasty using both local flaps and free grafts. In this study, we report the case of a patient with voiding symptoms during a period of 9 years after childbirth, despite an attempt of urethral dilation and chronic self-catheterization. The patient was finally diagnosed of a long distal urethral stricture, and she underwent urethroplasty with an anterior vaginal wall flap with satisfactory results. We take the opportunity to briefly review the diagnostic pathway in women with obstructive symptoms and the main female urethroplasty techniques.

Changes in patient reported outcome measures after treatment for female urethral stricture

INTRODUCTION

There is a paucity of patient reported outcome measure (PROM) data for women with urethral strictures. To address this gap, we aim to evaluate change in PROM among women who underwent surgery for a stricture.

METHODS

American Urological Association Symptom Index (AUA-SI) and Urogenital Distress Inventory (UDI-6) data from a multi-institutional retrospective cohort study of women treated for urethral stricture was assessed.

RESULTS

Fifty-seven women had either AUA-SS or UDI-6 and 26 had baseline and postoperative data for either. Most women underwent urethroplasty (77%) and the majority (73%) remained stricture free at median follow-up of 21 months (interquartile range [IQR] 7-37). The median baseline AUA-SI was 21 (IQR 12-28) and follow-up was 10 (IQR 5-24). After treatment, there was a median decrease of 12 (IQR -18 to -2) in AUA-SI (p = 0.003). The median AUA Quality of life (QOL) score at baseline and follow-up were 6 (IQR 4-6) and 3 (IQR 2-5), respectively. There was a median AUA-QOL improvement of 2 points (-5,0; p = 0.007) from a baseline 5 (unhappy) to 3 (mixed). Median UDI-6 scores were 50 (IQR 33-75) at baseline and 17 (IQR 0-39), at follow-up. After treatment, there was a median decrease of 19 (-31 to -11; p = 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Women with urethral strictures have severe lower urinary tract symptoms which improved after surgery. This study substantiates the claims that recognizing and treating women with urethral stricture disease greatly improves lower urinary tract symptoms and QOL.