Is carbon dioxide laser vaporization a valuable tool in the management of oral leukoplakia? A survey at an oncology hospital

Laser excision of oral leukoplakia: Does it affect recurrence and malignant transformation? A systematic review and meta-analysis

Oral leukoplakia (OL) is a white lesion with high potential of recurrence and malignant transformation. The variable clinical and histopathological features of OL may potentially impact both treatment and prognosis. Current literature shows that post treatment rates of recurrence and malignant transformation vary widely. The use of surgical lasers have been proposed with the objective of improving outcomes. We performed a systematic review and a comprehensive meta-analysis dedicated to pooling the rates of recurrence and malignant transformation of OL lesions treated using the main types of surgical lasers available. Scopus, MEDLINE/PubMed, and Embase were searched electronically. A total of 36 articles met the inclusion criteria. Selected studies included OL lesions that were treated by evaporation or excision using Nd:YAG laser, Er:YAG laser, CO2 laser, KTP laser, or diode laser. The results of this systematic review and meta-analysis suggest that surgical laser excision of OL may decrease recurrence rates but have no effect on the malignant transformation of OL when compared with conventional treatments.

Outcome of CO2 laser vaporization for oral potentially malignant disorders treatment

Background

Oral cancer is a public health issue worldwide. Oral potentially malignant disorders (OMPDs) are lesions of the oral mucosa that are predisposed to malignant transformation. The mainstay of OMPDs treatment around the world is now the carbon dioxide (CO2) laser but the reported recurrence and malignant transformation rates vary widely in the literature. We aimed to estimate the recurrence and the malignant transformation rates of OPMDs treated with CO2 laser at the University Hospital of Bordeaux, in France, from 2010 to 2014, and to identify associated factors with recurrence or malignant transformation.

Material and Methods

We conducted a retrospective study in patients with a minimum follow-up of 12 months. Collected variables included characteristics of the patients (gender, age, alcohol and tobacco consumption, previous diagnosis of graft-versus-host disease, previous treatments for OPMD or for upper aerodigestive tract cancers and human immunodeficiency virus infection), characteristics of the lesions (form, colour, size, location, degree of dysplasia), laser treatment outcome (complications, recurrence, malignant transformation).

Results

Twenty-five patients were included. Mean follow-up was 28.9 months. Recurrence was observed in 11 patients (44%). Annual recurrence rate was 18.3% and annual malignant transformation rate was 1.7%. Hyperplasia without dysplasia was the only factor found to be statistically associated with recurrence.

Conclusions

Our results suggest that OMPDs treated by CO2 laser vaporization have high recurrence rates, particularly those presenting hyperplasia. A standardized definition of recurrence would be necessary for inter-study comparisons. Long-term follow-up is recommended in order to detect and treat squamous cell carcinoma in its early stages.

Key words:CO2 lasers, precancerous conditions, malignant transformation, oral cancer, recurrence.

Oral leukoplakia treatment with the carbon dioxide laser: A systematic review of the literature

We conducted a systematic review of the literature to evaluate treatment of oral leukoplakia with the carbon dioxide (CO2) laser. A comprehensive search of studies published between 1981 and 2015 and listed in the PubMed (National Library of Medicine, NCBI) database yielded 378 articles which were screened in detail. Relevant studies were selected according to predetermined inclusion and exclusion criteria. A total of 33 articles met the final inclusion criteria and were analysed in detail in accordance with the PRISMA-P statement. These full-text papers were classified as synopses (n = 7), recurrence and malignant transformation studies (n = 17), comparative studies between CO2 laser and cold knife surgery (n = 3) and studies evaluating the efficacy of CO2, Nd:YAG and KTP lasers. According to the literature the CO2 laser is the workhorse of oral leukoplakia treatment due to its effectiveness and low associated morbidity. However, randomized clinical trials are needed to compare CO2 laser with other lasers. The results of our systematic review showed that there is no consensus regarding the factors involved in higher recurrence and malignization rates, so further studies are needed.