The cause of slowed forearm median conduction velocity in carpal tunnel syndrome

The Effects of Physiotherapy in the Treatment of Cubital Tunnel Syndrome: A Systematic Review

Background: To date, various forms of physiotherapy are used in the treatment of cubital tunnel syndrome (CuTS). The effectiveness of physiotherapy for CuTS is inconclusive. The aim of this systematic review was to evaluate the effects of physiotherapy in the conservative treatment of CuTS. Methods: The six databases were searched from December 2020 to March 2022. The inclusion criteria were randomised controlled trials, case series, and case reports that evaluate the effects of physiotherapy in the treatment of adult participants with diagnosis CuTS. A total of 11 studies met the eligibility criteria, capturing a total of 187 participants. Results: In three types of papers, pain, muscle strength, and limitation of upper limb function were the most frequently assessed characteristics. Physiotherapy was most often based on manual therapy, neurodynamic techniques, and electrical modalities. One clinical trial rated the risk of bias “high” and the other two “some concerns”. In case-series designs, five studies rated the risk of bias as “serious” and three as “moderate”. Most of the studies showed a significant improvement in the clinical condition, also in the follow-up study. Only one clinical trial showed no therapeutic effect. Conclusion: There is no possibility of recommending the best method of physiotherapy in clinical practice for people with CuTS based on the results of this systematic review. More high-quality studies are required.

Reduction in median nerve cross-sectional area at the forearm correlates with axon loss in carpal tunnel syndrome

•

The median nerve CSA at the forearm is smaller when CTS is involved with axon loss.

•

WFR of the median nerve is highest when CTS causes slight axon loss.

•

Axon loss of the median nerve in CTS hampers the diagnostic value of wCSA and WFR.

Objective

To explore the relationship between axon loss and measured cross-sectional areas of the median nerve (MN) in severe carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS).

Methods

In this retrospective study of 158 examined wrists, we compared axon loss to the ultrasound parameters MN cross-sectional area at the wrist (wCSA), MN cross-sectional area at the forearm (fCSA) and wrist-to-forearm ratio (WFR), in patients with moderate to extreme CTS. Axon loss was evaluated by needle electromyography (EMG) of the abductor pollicis brevis muscle (spontaneous activity and reduction of interference pattern).

Results

Both the spontaneous activity and interference pattern reduction correlated negatively to fCSA (r = −0.189, p = 0.035; r = −0.210, p = 0.019; respectively). In moderate CTS, both the spontaneous activity and interference pattern reduction correlated positively to WFR (r = 0.231, p = 0.048; r = 0.232, p = 0.047; respectively). The WFR was highest when slight spontaneous activity was detected. Neither wCSA nor WFR correlated with axon loss in severe and extreme CTS.

Conclusions

The fCSA is smaller when axon loss in CTS is more prominent. The WFR is highest when CTS is associated with slight axon loss of the MN.

Significance

CTS might cause retrograde axonal atrophy detected as small fCSA. Prominent axon loss in CTS may reduce the diagnostic value of WFR.

Characteristics of forearm mixed nerve conduction study in carpal tunnel syndrome: Comparison with ultrasound assessments

This study aimed to characterize forearm mixed nerve conduction study (NCS) findings in carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). Eighty-two patients with CTS and 48 healthy controls were enrolled. We directly compared the forearm mixed NCS and ultrasonography results from CTS patients with those from the controls. Correlation analyses were performed to identify the relationship between forearm mixed NCS parameters and ultrasound measurements in CTS. We observed reduced forearm mixed nerve amplitude and increased cross-sectional area (CSA) of the median nerve at the proximal carpal tunnel (CT) inlet in CTS. The forearm mixed nerve amplitude negatively correlated with the CSA at the proximal CT inlet. We found a negative correlation between Bland's neurophysiological grade and the forearm mixed nerve amplitude as well as a positive correlation between the CSA of the median nerve at the proximal CT inlet and Bland's neurophysiological grade. We confirmed that the reduced median mixed nerve amplitude is the distinguishing feature of forearm mixed NCS in CTS. Our findings suggest that the forearm mixed NCS is potentially useful in evaluating its severity.

Low sensitivity of F-wave in the electrodiagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome

OBJECTIVE

Previous studies showed "F-wave inversion" (F-INV) as a sensitive method in the electrodiagnosis of early stage of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). This study aimed at evaluating the sensitivity and specificity of F-wave and nerve conduction velocity (NCV) testing in CTS.

METHODS

We consecutively enrolled 244 cases and 108 controls. F-waves analysis included: Fwave minimum and mean latencies, F-wave persistence and chronodispersion, mean-F/CMAP amplitude ratio, F-INV. Specificity and sensitivity of F-waves parameters were calculated in the whole sample of CTS patients and by grouping the patients according to CTS severity. Multivariate logistic regression was also performed using F-INV as a dependent variable.

RESULTS

In the whole sample the sensitivity of F-mean-INV and of median-ulnar NCV comparative testing was 50.8% and 93.7%, respectively. F-INV sensitivity dropped to 8% in CTS early stage. F-INV could be predicted only by distal motor latency of the median nerve. The sensitivity of all F-wave parameters increased only in the most severe stages of CTS.

CONCLUSIONS

This study does not confirm the electrodiagnostic usefulness of F-INV in early stage of CTS. All F-wave parameters, including F-INV, are much less sensitive than conventional NCV in CTS electrodiagnosis. F-wave does not add further useful information specifically related to CTS.

Technical considerations for measurement of median nerve conduction velocity at wrist

Nerve conduction velocity (NCV) testing for the median nerve is the gold standard for diagnosing carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS), which affects about 6% of the general population. However, NCV equipment is relatively expensive and not always available at outpatient clinics. This study investigated the effects of different sampling rates and electrode placements on the NCV values of the median nerve to establish the practical significance of those specifications. The NCV of the median nerve at the wrist was measured in 30 healthy subjects with sampling rates of 2 kHz or 10 kHz and wide or narrow spacing of the electrode; Paired t-tests were used to compare the NCV values acquired by the different testing protocols. We found that the sampling rate had a statistically significant effect on the NCV values (P < 0.01), while the electrode placements did not significantly affect the NCV values (P > 0.05). The findings of this study have implications for improving the cost-effectiveness and technical applicability of NCV instruments.

Ultrasound evaluation of patients with moderate and severe carpal tunnel syndrome

The objective of this study is to determine cut-off points for the crosssectional areas of the median nerve proximal and distal to carpal tunnel in moderate and severe Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS) and compare the results of our study with those available in the literature. Forty-three patients with upper limb pain other than CTS and 36 patients with idiopathic CTS enrolled into the study. The diagnosis and categorization of CTS were based on electrophysiologic criteria of the American Academy of Neurology. Median nerve cross-sectional areas were measured. Arithmetic mean values and standard deviation of each variable were measured. Student t-test and chi-squared test were applied to compare continuous and dichotomous variables between CTS and non-CTS control groups. Ultimately the diagnostic performances of the test characteristics including sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values were measured. Mean cross-sectional area of the nerve is higher in moderate than severe CTS proximal and distal to carpal tunnel. We accepted cut-off points of 11.5 mm² and 13.5 mm² for cross-sectional areas of the proximal and distal portions of carpal canal respectively. The sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values for the proximal inlet are 83%, 90.7%, 65.5% and 55.7%; and for the distal outlet are 36.1%, 93%, 81.2% and 63.4% respectively. We suggest that ultrasound is a good diagnostic modality for patients referred to tertiary care centers which categorized as moderate CTS.

The role of forearm mixed nerve conduction study in the evaluation of proximal conduction slowing in carpal tunnel syndrome

OBJECTIVE

A decrease of forearm median motor conduction velocity (CV) is a common electrophysiological finding in carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS), ascribed to two possible mechanisms: either conduction block or slowing of the fastest myelinating fibers in the carpal tunnel, or retrograde axonal atrophy (RAA) with retrograde conduction slowing (RCS). We hope to utilize both direct and derived forearm median mixed nerve conduction studies to clarify the mechanism of the decrease of forearm median motor CV in CTS.

METHODS

Seventy-five CTS patients and 75 age-matched control subjects received conventional motor and sensory nerve conduction studies of median and ulnar nerves and forearm median mixed nerve conduction techniques. First, direct measurement of forearm median mixed conduction velocity (Forearm mixed CV) and nerve action potential amplitude (Forearm mixed amplitude) was determined with recording at elbow and stimulation at wrist. Then, stimulating electrode was placed over palm and recording at elbow and then at wrist to calculate the derived Forearm mixed CV. Electrophysiological parameters, including direct Forearm mixed CV and amplitude and derived Forearm mixed CV, were compared between CTS patients and controls.

RESULTS

CTS patients had significantly prolonged wrist-palm sensory and motor conduction, significantly decreased forearm median motor CV, and normal ulnar nerve conduction. The direct Forearm mixed amplitude was significantly decreased in CTS patients. The direct Forearm mixed CV was similar in CTS patients and controls, but there was a significant decrease in derived Forearm mixed CV in CTS group. The difference between direct and derived Forearm mixed CV was significantly greater in the CTS, suggesting that direct and derived Forearm mixed CV represent CV from different nerve fibers, one passing outside carpal tunnel without undergoing RAA or the other through the carpal tunnel with occurrence of RAA.

CONCLUSION

A decrease of direct Forearm mixed amplitude really occurs in CTS, implying that RAA and RCS will develop over proximal median nerve at distal nerve injury and the decreased forearm median motor CV is best ascribed to RAA and RCS. Furthermore, in CTS, the direct Forearm mixed CV measures the CV from undamaged nerve fibers without passing through carpal tunnel, resulting in the misinterpretation of the cause of proximal conduction slowing secondary to conduction block or slowing over the wrist.

SIGNIFICANCE

We provide a direct evidence of the occurrence of RAA and RCS that would explain the cause of proximal median nerve conduction slowing. However, the clinical significance of RAA and RCS is uncertain.

Correlation of median forearm conduction velocity with carpal tunnel syndrome severity

OBJECTIVE

Median nerve entrapment neuropathy at the wrist can be accompanied by slowed motor conduction within the forearm. Existing studies conflict regarding a correlation between the severity of the entrapment neuropathy in carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) and slowing of median motor nerve conduction velocity (MNCV) in the forearm. Here, it was asked if there is a correlation between markers of CTS severity and median forearm MNCV, and if there is an explanation for the preceding conflicting results.

METHODS

Median MNCV in the forearm was correlated with neurophysiologic markers of severity of a median neuropathy at the wrist in 91 hands from 64 patients with clinical and electrodiagnostic evidence of CTS.

RESULTS

Median MNCV within the forearm segment was negatively correlated with the median nerve distal motor latency (r=-0.64, P<0.001, n=91) and positively correlated with the CMAP amplitude of the abductor pollicis brevis muscle (r=0.45, P<0.001, n=91). These correlations only occurred in patients with a prolonged median distal motor latency. Previous investigations that failed to find such correlations used variable or non-standardized methods or analyzed smaller numbers of patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Slowing of median MNCV in the forearm is related to the severity of the entrapment of median motor fibers at the wrist.

SIGNIFICANCE

Slowed forearm median MNCV can be a marker of motor nerve injury at the wrist.

Does retrograde axonal atrophy really occur in carpal tunnel syndrome patients with normal forearm conduction velocity?

OBJECTIVE

The cause of decreased median forearm motor conduction velocity (FMCV) in carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) is best ascribed to retrograde axonal atrophy (RAA); however, the relationships between the occurrence of RAA and electrophysiological or clinical severity remains controversial. We attempt to determine whether RAA really occurs in CTS patients with normal median FMCV and to investigate any relationships between RAA and severity of compression at the wrist.

METHODS

Consecutive CTS patients were enrolled and age-matched volunteers served as controls. We performed conventional nerve conduction studies (NCS) and measured median and ulnar distal motor latencies (DML), FMCV, compound muscle action potential (CMAP) amplitudes, distal sensory latencies (DSL), and sensory nerve action potential (SNAP) amplitudes. Furthermore, palmar median stimulation was done to calculate the wrist-palm motor conduction velocity (W-P MCV). Patients included for analysis should have normal FMCV and needle examination. We compared each electrodiagnostic parameters between the patient group and controls.

RESULTS

The mean+/-SD of the W-P MCV for patients and controls were 33.26+/-6.74 and 52.14+/-5.85 m/s and those of median FMCV were 55.26+/-3.56 and 57.82+/-3.9 m/s, respectively. There was a significant reduction in the W-P MCV (36.2%, P<0.00001), significant decrease in the median FMCV (4.43%, P<0.00001) and SNAP amplitudes, and an increase of the DML and DSL in the patient group (P<0.00001) compared to the controls; however, there were no differences in median and ulnar CMAP amplitudes, ulnar FMCV and DML between the controls and patients.

CONCLUSIONS

RAA and relatively slowed median FMCV do occur in CTS patients with normal median FMCV, regardless of severity of clinical manifestations and electrophysiological abnormalities.

SIGNIFICANCE

This article provides new information for research of the electrophysiological changes of the proximal nerve part at distal injury.

The reason for forearm conduction slowing in carpal tunnel syndrome: an electrophysiological follow-up study after surgery

BACKGROUND

The exact cause of decreased forearm median motor conduction velocity (FMMCV) in carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) is still a subject of controversy. A conduction block or an axonal loss in the large myelinating fibers upon wrist compression, or retrograde axonal atrophy, is suspected.

METHODS

In order to attempt a determination of the cause, 10 patients with clinical symptoms and signs of CTS, confirmed using standard electrodiagnosis and with a slowed FMMCV <50m/s, were included in this study. Serial standard median motor conduction studies were performed at baseline, 1 week, 2 weeks, 4 weeks, 8 weeks, and 12 weeks after endoscopic ligament release. Serial median motor distal latencies (MMDL), compound muscle action potential (CMAP) amplitudes, and FMMCV, were determined and compared.

RESULTS

Significant improvement in MMDL had occurred at the 1-week follow-up examination; however, no such improvement in FMMCV was observed. Furthermore, a significant increase in CMAP amplitude was evidenced beginning 4 weeks after surgery. The results revealed an improvement in median motor conduction, across the wrist segment, that did not parallel the increase in FMMCV, suggesting that a conduction block or axonal loss at wrist compression was not the likely cause of the decreased FMMCV.

CONCLUSIONS

Retrograde axonal atrophy, not selective damage to the large myelinating fibers at the wrist, is the direct cause of decreased FMMCV in CTS.

Forearm mixed nerve conduction velocity: questionable role in the evaluation of retrograde axonal atrophy in carpal tunnel syndrome

The objective of this study was to determine whether forearm mixed nerve conduction velocity (Fmix) reflects the real conduction velocity of forearm motor nerve (Fmot) and forearm sensory nerve (Fsen) fibers passing through the carpal tunnel. Forearm mixed nerve conduction velocity is presumed to be indicative of the conduction velocity of the median nerve over the forearm. Therefore, Fmix is used widely to assess the causes of slowing forearm conduction velocity in carpal tunnel syndrome. However, some authors claim that Fmix comes chiefly from the undamaged fibers in carpal tunnel syndrome, and thus cannot replace Fmot or Fsen in the evaluation of retrograde axonal atrophy. Patients with clinical symptoms and signs of carpal tunnel syndrome confirmed with standard electrodiagnosis were included. Age-matched volunteers served as control subjects. Conduction velocities across the wrist and over the forearm were measured, including those of the wrist sensory (Wsen), wrist motor (Wmot), and wrist mixed nerves (Wmix); and forearm mixed (Fmix), forearm motor (Fmot), and forearm sensory nerves (Fsen). The authors compared and correlated Wsen, Wmot, and Wmix; and Fmix, Fmot, and Fsen respectively. The mean values of Wsen, Wmot, Wmix, Fmix, Fmot, and Fsen of the control subjects less those of corresponding conduction velocity of carpal tunnel syndrome patients were designated Wsen N, Wmot N, Wmix N, Fmix N, Fmot N, and Fsen N respectively and were compared and correlated again. Wrist motor nerve conduction velocity, Wsen, and Wmix were significantly lower in carpal tunnel syndrome patients, and Fmot and Fsen but not Fmix were reduced significantly when compared with control subjects. Mean wrist sensory nerve conduction velocity, Wmot N, and Wmix N; and Fsen N and Fmot N showed good correlation except for Fmix N, suggesting that Fmix reflects the conduction velocity of undamaged fibers in carpal tunnel syndrome. Forearm mixed nerve conduction velocity cannot replace Fmot or Fsen in the assessment of retrograde axonal atrophy in carpal tunnel syndrome. In the disease state, Fmix possibly represents the conduction velocity of the palmar cutaneous branch.

Does direct measurement of forearm mixed nerve conduction velocity reflect actual nerve conduction velocity through the carpal tunnel?

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to determine whether forearm (wrist-elbow) mixed nerve conduction velocity (W-Emix) represents the actual nerve conduction velocity (CV) of nerve fibers passing through the carpal tunnel.

BACKGROUND

W-Emix is presumed to reflect the actual forearm CV through the carpal tunnel. However, it has been argued that W-Emix chiefly originates from the nerve fibers passing outside the carpal tunnel. Therefore, the direct measurement of W-Emix cannot be used to assess retrograde axonal atrophy in carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS).

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Thirty patients with clinical signs and symptoms of CTS were recruited and the diagnosis was confirmed with standard electrodiagnosis. Fifty age-matched volunteers served as control. Recording electrodes were placed over the elbow and index finger for mixed nerve and sensory nerve conduction studies, respectively. Stimulation was applied at the palm and wrist for the measurement of mixed nerve wrist-palm CV (W-Pmix), wrist-elbow CV (W-Emix), and elbow-palm CV (E-Pmix). Stimulation was applied at the elbow, wrist, and palm for the measurement of wrist-elbow sensory CV (W-Esen), wrist-palm CV (W-Psen), and elbow-palm CV (E-Psen). Comparisons were made between W-Pmix and W-Psen, W-Emix and W-Esen, and E-Pmix and E-Psen.

RESULTS

Correlations between W-Emix and W-Esen, E-Pmix and E-Psen, and W-Pmix and W-Psen were good in the control. In the patient group, there was a strong positive correlation between W-Pmix and W-Psen, and between E-Pmix and E-Psen. However, W-Esen correlated weakly with W-Emix, suggesting that W-Emix chiefly represents the CV of fibers passing outside the carpal tunnel. Therefore, the direct measurement of W-Emix cannot be used to assess retrograde axonal atrophy. Furthermore, the reduction in W-Psen was more marked than the reduction in W-Esen, implying that a conduction block at the wrist is the least likely cause of proximal slowing in CTS.

CONCLUSIONS

W-Emix does not reflect the actual CV of the nerve fibers passing through the carpal tunnel. In addition, retrograde axonal atrophy appears to be the primary cause of decreased forearm CV in CTS.