Prognostic value of cortical magnetic stimulation in spinal cord injury

Neuromuscular consequences of spinal cord injury: New mechanistic insights and clinical considerations

The spinal cord facilitates communication between the brain and the body, containing intrinsic systems that work with lower motor neurons (LMNs) to manage movement. Spinal cord injuries (SCIs) can lead to partial paralysis and dysfunctions in muscles below the injury. While traditionally this paralysis has been attributed to disruptions in the corticospinal tract, a growing body of work demonstrates LMN damage is a factor. Motor units, comprising the LMN and the muscle fibers with which they connect, are essential for voluntary movement. Our understanding of their changes post-SCI is still emerging, but the health of motor units is vital, especially when considering innovative SCI treatments like nerve transfer surgery. This review seeks to collate current literature on how SCI impact motor units and explore neuromuscular clinical implications and treatment avenues. SCI reduced motor unit number estimates, and surviving motor units had impaired signal transmission at the neuromuscular junction, force-generating capacity, and excitability, which have the potential to recover chronically, yet the underlaying mechanisms are unclear. Furthermore, electrodiagnostic evaluations can aid in assessing the health lower and upper motor neurons, identify suitable targets for nerve transfer surgeries, and detect patients with time sensitive injuries. Lastly, many electrodiagnostic abnormalities occur in both chronic and acute SCI, yet factors contributing to these abnormalities are unknown. Future studies are required to determine how motor units adapt following SCI and the clinical implications of these adaptations.

Transcranial magnetic motor evoked potentials and magnetic resonance imaging findings in paraplegic dogs with recovery of motor function

Background

Transcranial magnetic motor evoked potentials (TMMEP) are associated with severity of clinical signs and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings in dogs with spinal cord disease.

Hypothesis

That in initially paraplegic dogs with thoracolumbar intervertebral disc herniation (IVDH), MRI findings before surgery and TMMEPs obtained after decompressive surgery are associated with long‐term neurological status and correlate with each other.

Animals

Seventeen client‐owned paraplegic dogs with acute thoracolumbar IVDH.

Methods

Prospective observational study. TMMEPs were obtained from pelvic limbs and MRI (3T) of the spinal cord was performed at initial clinical presentation. Follow‐up studies were performed ≤ 2 days after reappearance of motor function and 3 months later. Ratios of compression length, intramedullary hyperintensities' length (T2‐weighted hyperintensity length ratio [T2WLR]), and lesion extension (T2‐weighted‐lesion extension ratio) in relation to the length of the 2nd lumbar vertebral body were calculated.

Results

TMMEPs could be elicited in 10/17 (59%) dogs at 1st and in 16/17 (94%) dogs at 2nd follow‐up. Comparison of TMMEPs of 1st and 2nd follow‐up showed significantly increased amplitudes (median from 0.19 to 0.45 mV) and decreased latencies (from 69.38 to 40.26 ms; P = .01 and .001, respectively). At 2nd follow‐up latencies were significantly associated with ambulatory status (P = .024). T2WLR obtained before surgery correlated with latencies at 2nd follow‐up (P = .04).

Conclusions

TMMEP reflect motor function recovery after severe spinal cord injury.

Intensive exercise program after spinal cord injury ("Full-On"): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

Background

Rehabilitation after spinal cord injury (SCI) has traditionally involved teaching compensatory strategies for identified impairments and deficits in order to improve functional independence. There is some evidence that regular and intensive activity-based therapies, directed at activation of the paralyzed extremities, promotes neurological improvement. The aim of this study is to compare the effects of a 12-week intensive activity-based therapy program for the whole body with a program of upper body exercise.

Methods/Design

A multicenter, parallel group, assessor-blinded randomized controlled trial will be conducted. One hundred eighty-eight participants with spinal cord injury, who have completed their primary rehabilitation at least 6 months prior, will be recruited from five SCI units in Australia and New Zealand. Participants will be randomized to an experimental or control group. Experimental participants will receive a 12-week program of intensive exercise for the whole body, including locomotor training, trunk exercises and functional electrical stimulation-assisted cycling. Control participants will receive a 12-week intensive upper body exercise program. The primary outcome is the American Spinal Injuries Association (ASIA) Motor Score. Secondary outcomes include measurements of sensation, function, pain, psychological measures, quality of life and cost effectiveness. All outcomes will be measured at baseline, 12 weeks, 6 months and 12 months by blinded assessors. Recruitment commenced in January 2011.

Discussion

The results of this trial will determine the effectiveness of a 12-week program of intensive exercise for the whole body in improving neurological recovery after spinal cord injury.

Trial registration

NCT01236976 (10 November 2010), ACTRN12610000498099 (17 June 2010).

Spinal Cord Injury

Background. The description of the natural course of recovery from a spinal cord injury (SCI) with spontaneous improvement of neurological, neurophysiological, and functional measures is an important prerequisite in appraising effects of upcoming interventional therapies. Objective. To describe the spontaneous evolution of motor-evoked potentials of the anterior tibial muscle (TA-MEP) and their relation to outcomes of lower extremity motor scores (LEMS) and walking function in patients recovering from an acute SCI. Methods. TA-MEPs were assessed in 255 SCI subjects within 5 time intervals throughout the first year after SCI with combined neurological and functional measures. Tibial nerve conduction studies were performed to screen for peripheral nerve damage. Results. TA-MEP allowed stratification of SCI according to lesion severity and outcome. As MEP amplitudes increased over 12 months after SCI, this was paralleled by a significant improvement of LEMS and walking function. TA-MEP latencies remained usually stable. Conclusion. Clinical outcome and walking function after SCI can be predicted independent of clinical measures by assessment of TA-MEP reflecting corticospinal tract integrity.

Functional evaluation of paraplegic monkeys (Macaca mulatta) over fourteen months post-lesion

We report on the neurological and neurophysiological findings obtained from two adult Macaca mulatta sustaining complete spinal cord transections at T8-T9. We performed periodic neurological exams, recorded motor evoked potentials (MEPs) following transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), and recorded electromyograms (EMGs) during the execution of a lower limb motor test. The main observations were: (1) the spinal shock period lasted less than a week; tendon, cutaneous and withdrawal reflexes were uneven in range and occurrence, and Babinski's sign was not observed; (2) a protracted functional lesion in the tibial and common peroneal nerves appeared bilaterally early in the post-lesional period; (3) MEPs were elicited by TMS in the quadriceps muscle of both monkeys; they were recorded as early as the 5th week after lesion in one of the monkeys, and they persisted throughout the post-lesional period in both monkeys; and (4) motor unit action potentials in the quadriceps muscle recorded by EMG were simultaneous with attempts to perform intentional lower limb movements from post-lesion month 11 to 13.5 in both monkeys. The last two sets of observations argue in favor of a partial cortico-spinal functional gain and suggest that spinal cord regeneration can occur after complete spinal cord injury in primates.

Functional and electrophysiological changes after graded traumatic spinal cord injury in adult rat

A graded contusion spinal cord injury (SCI) was created in the adult rat spinal cord using the Infinite Horizons (IH) impactor to study the correlation between injury severity and anatomical, behavioral, and electrophysiological outcomes. Adult Fisher rats were equally divided into five groups and received contusion injuries at the ninth thoracic level (T9) with 100, 125, 150, 175, or 200 kdyn impact forces, respectively. Transcranial magnetic motor-evoked potentials (tcMMEPs) and BBB open-field locomotor analyses were performed weekly for 4 weeks postinjury. Our results demonstrated that hindlimb locomotor function decreased in accordance with an increase in injury severity. The locomotor deficits were proportional to the amount of damage to the ventral and lateral white matter (WM). Locomotor function was strongly correlated to the amount of spared WM, which contains the reticulospinal and propriospinal tracts. Normal tcMMEP latencies were recorded in control, all of 100-kdyn-injured and half of 125-kdyn-injured animals. Delayed latency responses were recorded in some of 125-kdyn-injured and all of 150-kdyn-injured animals. No tcMMEP responses were recorded in 175- and 200-kdyn-injured animals. Comparison of tcMMEP responses with areas of WM loss or demyelination identified the medial ventrolateral funiculus (VLF) as the location of the tcMMEP pathway. Immunohistochemical and electromicroscopic (EM) analyses showed the presence of demyelinated axons in WM tracts surrounding the lesion cavities at 28 days postinjury. These data support the notion that widespread WM damage in the ventral and lateral funiculi may be a major cause for locomotor deficits and lack of tcMMEP responses after SCI.

Motor evoked potentials (MEP) and evoked pressure curves (EPC) from the urethral compressive musculature (UCM) by functional magnetic stimulation in healthy volunteers and patients with neurogenic incontinence

AIMS

The aim of this study is to assess neurogenic lesions of the somatomotor efferent nervous pathway to the urethral compressive musculature (UCM) by means of motor evoked potentials (MEP) and simultaneously recorded evoked pressure curves (EPC).

METHODS

Nine healthy subjects and 33 patients (15 spinal cord injury, 14 cauda equina lesion, and 4 multiple sclerosis (MS)) with neurogenic urinary incontinence were prospectively examined by means of urodynamics and electrophysiology. MEP responses from the UCM were evoked after transcranial (tc) and lumbosacral (ls) single pulse magnetic stimulation. A ratio out of tx/ls latencies was calculated to distinguish between central (i.e., spinal) and peripheral lesions. The mechanical UCM pressure responses (=EPC) were recorded simultaneously with electromyographic (EMG) recordings using a microtip pressure transducer catheter with integrated bipolar surface electrodes.

RESULTS

In nine healthy subjects the central latency was 19.0 msec, the peripheral latency was 4.25 msec, and the ratio was 4.4. In patients with incomplete spinal cord lesion the central latency was significantly delayed (22.7 msec), whereas the peripheral responses were normal. The ratio (5.5) was increased. Thirteen of these 15 patients suffered from neurogenic incontinence. Patients with a complete spinal lesion showed no UCM reaction after tc stimulation, whereas peripheral responses were normal. Patients with MS showed significantly prolonged central latencies (25.5 msec). The increased ratio of 6.0 indicated a spinal lesion. Ten patients with incomplete cauda equina lesions and urinary incontinence had normal central latencies but prolonged peripheral latencies of 6.7 msec. The ratio of 3.4 indicated a lesion of the sacral caudal roots. In patients with complete cauda injury neither central nor peripheral responses could be evoked. Tc evoked mechanical pressure responses (i.e., contractions) from the UCM could only be recorded in intact or incompletely injured spinal and peripheral motor nervous pathways, whereas they could be evoked after ls stimulation only in cases with partially preserved sacral caudal roots independent of a spinal lesion.

CONCLUSIONS

MEP and EPC from the UCM proved to be a well tolerated disgnostic tool in patients with neurogenic incontinence that distinguished central and peripheral lesions of the motor efferent pathways to the UCM.

Vestibular-evoked muscle responses in patients with spinal cord injury

The vestibular system was activated by galvanic electrical stimulation in 22 patients with spinal cord injury. Three patients were studied standing and all were studied sitting. Electromyographic responses recorded in soleus (standing patients) and the erectores spinae (all patients) were compared with data from 18 control subjects. The vestibular stimulus polarity and head position were arranged so as to produce excitatory medium latency muscle responses in the controls. Responses in the patient group were present bilaterally, present unilaterally or absent below the level of injury. The amplitude of response recorded in erectores spinae at lumbar levels below the lesion in 21 patients (left and right side responses summed) and five control subjects was positively correlated with American Spinal Injuries Association (ASIA) grade: the smallest amplitudes were found in patients with the most severe impairment (Spearman rank correlation coefficient rs = 0.59; P = 0.002, two-tailed). The latency of response (averaged for both sides) was negatively correlated with ASIA grade in 21 patients: the longest latencies were found in patients with the most severe impairment (rs = -0.57; P < 0.01, two-tailed). Amplitude and latency were negatively correlated (rs = -0.72, P < 0.002, two-tailed). The latencies of responses recorded in the erectores spinae at different vertebral levels were linearly related to the vertical distance from the inion to the recording site in both patient and control groups. The conduction velocities of the spinal pathways activated by vestibular stimulation were 4.6 and 10.4 m/s in patient (recording below lesion) and control groups, respectively. Both clinical status (patients recording below lesion, patients recording above lesion and controls) and distance were significant predictors of latency (general linear model, P < 0.0005). It is concluded that measurement of vestibular-evoked responses could provide information on the level and density of spinal cord lesions.

The diagnostic value of motor evoked potentials

OBJECTIVE

To assess the diagnostic usefulness of motor evoked potentials (MEPs) and to identify the optimal method for calculating the central conduction time. The test results were evaluated in a prospective study of 1023 neurological patients.

METHODS

We evaluated the correlation between clinical and electrophysiological findings, the accuracy, the sensitivity, the percentage of subclinical abnormalities and the false negative rates of MEPs in different neurological disorders. In patients with lower motor neuron involvement, we compared the central conduction time calculated as the difference between the latency of the cortical and magnetic root stimulation responses with that calculated using the F-wave method.

RESULTS

The agreement index between electrophysiological and clinical findings was 87%. The overall accuracy of the test was 0.97. The higher sensitivity values were demonstrated in spinal cord disorders (0.85), hereditary spastic paraplegia (0.80) and motor neuron diseases (0.74). The higher percentages of subclinical abnormalities were found in motor neuron disorders (26%) muscular diseases (24%), multiple sclerosis (13.5%) and spinal cord diseases (12.5%). The higher false negative rates were found in sylvian stroke (0.36) and hereditary spastic paraplegia (0.16). Central conduction study using magnetic paravertebral stimulation but not using the F-wave method, resulted in 12% and 10% of false positive values in lower limb multiradiculopathies and in neuropathies, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

MEPs represent a highly accurate diagnostic test. MEP clinical value is maximum in motor neuron, muscle and spinal cord diseases. In patients with lower motor neuron involvement, the gold standard for central conduction determination is the F-wave method.

Predicting neurologic recovery in traumatic cervical spinal cord injury

OBJECTIVE

Traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI) affects 8,000 to 10,000 individuals per year in the United States. One of the most difficult tasks confronting the clinician is the discussion of neurologic recovery and prognosis with the patient and/or family. Our objective is to provide a guide for practitioners to accurately predict neurologic outcome in acute traumatic cervical SCI (tetraplegia).

DATA SOURCE

Published reports obtained through MEDLINE search, texts, and studies presented at national conferences.

STUDY SELECTION

Peer reviewed studies, in English language, that discussed prognosis after traumatic SCI.

CONCLUSION

A comprehensive physical examination of the acute SCI patient is essential in determining the initial level and classification of the injury and is the most accurate method to predict neurologic recovery. Other diagnostic tests, including somatosensory evoked potentials, magnetic resonance imaging, and transcranial magnetic stimulation, may be helpful in further determining outcome when used in association with the clinical examination. The understanding of neurologic recovery should help predict ultimate functional capability and potential needs.

Latency of changes in spinal motoneuron excitability evoked by transcranial magnetic brain stimulation in spinal cord injured individuals

OBJECTIVES

To examine the basis for delay in the excitatory effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) of motor cortex on motoneuron pools of muscles left partially-paralyzed by traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI).

METHODS

The effect of subthreshold transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) on just-suprathreshold H-reflex amplitude was examined in subjects (n = 10) with incomplete cervical SCI, and in able-bodied (AB) subjects (n = 20) for comparison. EMG activity was recorded from the soleus and the abductor hallucis muscles, and H-reflex was elicited by stimulation of the tibial nerve behind the knee. Comparison of the peak-to-peak amplitude of the TMS-conditioned H-reflex to that of the H-reflex alone (i.e. unconditioned H-reflex) was made for different conditioning-test intervals with multivariate analysis of variance and (when called for) t testing.

RESULTS

The absolute latencies of motor responses to suprathreshold TMS delivered during a weak voluntary contraction of the soleus and abductor hallucis were significantly prolonged in the SCI group relative to AB subjects. For the TMS-conditioned H-reflex, the time-course effect of TMS on the H-reflex amplitude in different AB subjects included an early effect (typically facilitation, but occasionally inhibition) seen between -5 and 0 ms, followed by a later period (i.e. >5 ms) of H-reflex facilitation. In contrast, the earliest indication of a TMS effect on H-reflex excitability in SCI subjects was between 5 and 10 ms after TMS. This difference between SCI and AB subjects of approximately 10 ms was similar to the prolongation of TMS-evoked response latencies in the soleus and the abductor hallucis muscles of the SCI subjects.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that motor conduction slowing after traumatic SCI most likely occurs across the population of the descending tract axons mediating the TMS-evoked motor responses.

Responses of thenar muscles to transcranial magnetic stimulation of the motor cortex in patients with incomplete spinal cord injury

OBJECTIVE

To investigate changes in electromyographic (EMG) responses to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) of the motor cortex after incomplete spinal cord injury in humans.

METHODS

A group of 10 patients with incomplete spinal cord injury (motor level C3-C8) was compared with a group of 10 healthy control subjects. Surface EMG recordings were made from the thenar muscles. TMS was applied with a 9 cm circular stimulating coil centred over the vertex. The EMG responses to up to 50 magnetic stimuli were rectified and averaged.

RESULTS

Thresholds for compound motor evoked potentials (cMEPs) and suppression of voluntary contraction (SVC) elicited by TMS were higher (p < 0.05) in the patient group. Latency of cMEPs was longer (p < 0.05) in the patient group in both relaxed (controls 21.3 (SEM 0.5) ms; patients 27.7 (SEM 1.3) ms) and voluntarily contracted (controls 19.8 (SEM 0.5) ms; patients 27.6 (SEM 1.3) ms) muscles. The latency of SVC was longer (p < 0.05) in the patients (51.8 (SEM 1.8) ms) than in the controls (33.4 (SEM 1.9) ms). The latency difference (SVC-cMEP) was longer in the patients (25.3 (SEM 2.4) ms) than in the controls (13.4 (SEM 1.6) ms).

CONCLUSION

The longer latency difference between cMEPs and SVC in the patients may reflect a weak or absent early component of cortical inhibition. Such a change may contribute to the restoration of useful motor function after incomplete spinal cord injury.

Functional outcome following spinal cord injury: significance of motor-evoked potentials and ASIA scores

OBJECTIVE

Prediction of outcome of ambulatory capacity and hand function in tetraplegic patients with spinal cord injury (SCI) using neurologic examination, according to the protocol of the American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) and motor-evoked potentials (MEP).

DESIGN

Correlation study on a prospective cohort.

SETTING

SCI center, university hospital.

PATIENTS

Thirty-six patients with acute and 34 with chronic SCI.

OUTCOME MEASURES

(1) ASIA motor and sensory scores, (2) MEP recordings of upper and lower limb muscles, and (3) outcome of ambulatory capacity and hand function.

RESULTS

In acute and chronic SCI, both the initial ASIA scores and the MEP recordings were significantly related (p < .0001) to the outcome of ambulatory capacity and hand function. In tetraplegic patients, the MEP of the abductor digiti minimi muscle (Spearman correlation coefficient, .75; p < .0001) and the ASIA motor score for the upper limbs (Spearman correlation coefficient, .83; p < .0001) were most related to the outcome of hand function. Ambulatory capacity could be predicted by the ASIA motor score of the lower limbs (Spearman correlation coefficient, .78; p < .0001) and by MEP recordings of the leg muscles (Spearman correlation coefficient, .77; p < .0001). In patients with acute SCI, for the period 6 months posttrauma, the ASIA motor score increased significantly (ANOVA, p < .05), whereas the ASIA sensory scores and MEP recordings were unchanged (ANOVA, p > 0.1).

CONCLUSION

Both ASIA scores and MEP recordings are similarly related to the outcome of ambulatory capacity and hand function in patients with SCI. MEP recordings are of additional value to the clinical examination in uncooperative or incomprehensive patients. The combination of clinical examination and MEP recordings allows differentiation between the recovery of motor function (hand function, ambulatory capacity) and that of impulse transmission of descending motor tracts.

Central cord syndrome of cervical spinal cord injury: widespread changes in muscle recruitment studied by voluntary contractions and transcranial magnetic stimulation

Muscle recruitment after central cord syndrome (CCS), a cervical spinal cord injury leading to a weaker motor function in the upper limbs versus the lower limbs, was examined in 14 individuals by means of voluntary muscle contractions and transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS). Previously obtained data from able-bodied (AB) and non-CCS spinal cord injured subjects were used for comparison. Surface EMG was recorded from as many as six pairs of affected muscles. Individual muscle EMG activity was scored from 0 to 5. Cortical stimulation was applied while subjects maintained a weak contraction in each muscle. When CCS subjects attempted to produce a maximal voluntary contraction of an isolated muscle, this frequently resulted in cocontraction of nonsynergists in the same limb or/and in other limbs. Although the EMG scores in both upper and lower extremity muscles improved within postinjury time, in general, the lower extremity muscles, particularly the distal ones, demonstrated better recovery than the upper extremity muscles. CCS and AB subjects showed a similar high probability of "well-defined" responses to TMS (amplitude >150 microV) in all studied muscles. In contrast, latencies to TMS-evoked motor responses were prolonged by significant amounts after CCS. The delays in muscle responses were not significantly different from those observed in subjects with more severe cervical injury. Despite improvement in EMG scores, repeated measurements of TMS-evoked muscle response latencies in the same CCS subjects did not reveal significant shortening in central conduction latency. This argues against remyelination as an important contributor to the recovery process.

Muscle weakness, paralysis, and atrophy after human cervical spinal cord injury

Muscle weakness and failure of central motor drive were assessed in triceps brachii muscles of individuals with chronic cervical spinal cord injury (SCI) and able-bodied controls. Electrical stimuli were applied to the radial nerve during rest and during triceps submaximal and maximal voluntary contractions (MVCs). The mean forces and integrated EMGs generated by SCI subjects during MVCs were significantly less than those produced by controls (P < 0.01), with 74 and 71% of muscles generating <10% control force and EMG, respectively. There was an inverse linear relationship between the evoked and voluntary forces (n = 32 muscles of SCI subjects) which, when extrapolated to zero evoked force, also showed significant whole muscle weakness for SCI compared to control subjects (P < 0. 01). Severe muscle atrophy was revealed which might reflect disuse and/or muscle denervation subsequent to motoneuron loss. Many triceps muscles of SCI subjects showed no force occlusion (n = 41) or were impossible to stimulate selectively (n = 61). Force was always evoked when the radial nerve was stimulated during MVCs of SCI subjects. The force elicited by single magnetic shocks applied to the motor cortex at Cz' during voluntary contractions of SCI subjects was also inversely related to the voluntary triceps force exerted (n = 18), but usually no force could be elicited during MVCs. Thus central motor drive was probably maximal to these muscles, and the force evoked during MVCs by below-lesion stimulation must come from activation of paralyzed muscle. SCI subjects also had significantly longer mean central nervous system (CNS) conduction times to triceps (P < 0.01) suggesting that the measured deficits reflect CNS rather than peripheral nervous system factors. Thus, the weak voluntary strength of these partially paralyzed muscles is not due to submaximal excitation of higher CNS centers, but results mainly from reduction of this input to triceps motoneurons.

Assessment of corticospinal function in spinal cord injury using transcranial motor cortex stimulation: a review

Other than clinical examination, few methods exist for assessing the functional condition of descending long tracts of the spinal cord in humans. This review covers neurophysiological examination of the corticospinal system using transcranial electrical and magnetic motor cortex stimulation. The neurophysiological basis for the motor evoked potentials (MEPs) and the differences between the two methods are discussed followed by a review of their use in individuals with spinal cord injury (SCI). Transcranial motor cortex stimulation is used to monitor descending spinal cord tract condition during spinal surgeries and could be useful for assessing central nervous system trauma, especially in the unconscious multitrauma patient. In the chronic phase of SCI, recordings of MEPs have enabled the estimation of central conduction times that relate to the condition of axons passing through the injured segment of the spinal cord. They were found to correlate well with clinical examination scores but as predictors of outcome, the reports have been mixed. The use of transcranial motor cortex stimulation to modify segmental reflexes and in combination with volitional attempts have also provided evidence of conduction across the lesion in paralyzed SCI subjects. However, MEPs can be absent in some SCI individuals who may be able to volitionally activate muscles below the level of the spinal cord lesion. Such findings are useful in elucidating the neural mechanisms underlying the performance of a volitional movement and may serve to guide and monitor the effects of future treatments for paralysis in SCI and other neurological disorders.