Thymic malignancies treated with active scanning proton beam radiation and Monte Carlo planning: early clinical experience

Secondary Malignancy Risk Following Proton vs. X-ray Radiotherapy of Thymic Epithelial Tumors: A Comparative Modeling Study of Thoracic Organ-Specific Cancer Risk

Simple Summary

Proton beam radiotherapy (PBT) offers the possibility to significantly reduce dose to surrounding organs at risk due to their physical advantages compared to X-ray based techniques. The aim of this analysis was to demonstrate whether PBT reduces secondary malignancy risks in patients with thymic malignancies compared to 3D conformal and intensity-modulated radiotherapy with photons. By using two different mechanistic calculation models we could demonstrate significant reductions of secondary malignancy risks with the use of PBT for all independent thoracic organs analyzed with the exception of the thyroid gland. This technology-driven improvement might translate into clinically relevant benefits for patients with thymic malignancies.

Abstract

Background: Proton beam radiotherapy (PBT) offers physical dose advantages that might reduce the risk for secondary malignancies (SM). The aim of the current study is to calculate the risk for SM after X-ray-based 3D conformal (3DCRT) radiotherapy, intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT), and active pencil beam scanned proton therapy (PBS) in patients treated for thymic malignancies. Methods: Comparative treatment plans for each of the different treatment modalities were generated for 17 patients. The risk for radiation-induced SM was estimated using two distinct prediction models—the Dasu and the Schneider model. Results: The total and fatal SM risks estimated using the Dasu model demonstrated significant reductions with the use of PBS relative to both 3DCRT and IMRT for all independent thoracic organs analyzed with the exception of the thyroid gland (p ≤ 0.001). SM rates per 10,000 patients per year per Gy evaluated using the Schneider model also resulted in significant reductions with the use of PBS relative to 3DCRT and IMRT for the lungs, breasts, and esophagus (p ≤ 0.001). Conclusions: PBS achieved superior sparing of relevant OARs compared to 3DCRT and IMRT, leading to a lower risk for radiation-induced SM. PBS should therefore be considered in patients diagnosed with thymic malignancies, particularly young female patients.

Hadrontherapy for Thymic Epithelial Tumors: Implementation in Clinical Practice

Radiation therapy is part of recommendations in the adjuvant settings for advanced stage or as exclusive treatment in unresectable thymic epithelial tumors (TETs). However, first-generation techniques delivered substantial radiation doses to critical organs at risk (OARs), such as the heart or the lungs, resulting in noticeable radiation-induced toxicity. Treatment techniques have significantly evolved for TET irradiation, and modern techniques efficiently spare normal surrounding tissues without negative impact on tumor coverage and consequently local control or patient survival. Considering its dosimetric advantages, hadrontherapy (which includes proton therapy and carbon ion therapy) has proved to be worthwhile for TET irradiation in particular for challenging clinical situations such as cardiac tumoral involvement. However, clinical experience for hadrontherapy is still limited and mainly relies on small-size proton therapy studies. This critical review aims to analyze the current status of hadrontherapy for TET irradiation to implement it at a larger scale.