Efficacy of serotherapy in scorpion sting: a matched-pair study

Scorpion Sting Management at Tertiary and Secondary Care Emergency Departments

Objectives

We sought to review the management of scorpion stings in tertiary and secondary care emergency departments in Oman and determine physician’s knowledge of management protocols.

Methods

We conducted a retrospective study of all scorpion stings cases seen in Sultan Qaboos University Hospital (SQUH) emergency department (ED) from March 2016 to July 2017. Additionally, we conducted a survey of ED physicians regarding their management of scorpion stings in three different EDs including SQUH.

Results

The total number of scorpion stings seen at SQUH during the study period was 128. Localized pain was seen in 97.7% (n = 125), swelling in 14.8% (n = 19), and local redness in 7.0% (n = 9) of patients. Around 13.0% (n = 17) of patients were found to have systemic symptoms with tachycardia being the most common. Bedside clotting test was done for 11.7% (n = 15) of patients. The most commonly used treatment was local anesthesia (54.7%, n = 70). No patient received scorpion antivenom. In the 89 surveyed physicians the main management method used was analgesia (88.8%, n = 71) followed by local anesthesia (81.1%, n = 65). Most physicians (80.0%, n = 64) believed that local anesthesia was the most effective management. However, 32.5% (n = 26) ordered a whole blood bedside clotting test, 69.2% (n = 18) of which were junior doctors.

Conclusions

Most scorpion sting cases managed in SQUH had local symptoms. Tachycardia was the most common systemic manifestation. Bedside clotting test was not commonly ordered and mainly requested by junior doctors. Local anesthesia infiltration is the recommended management for scorpion sting. Analgesia was the main management followed by local anesthesia.

Saudi medicinal plants for the treatment of scorpion sting envenomation

Scorpion sting envenoming poses major public health problems. The treatment modalities include antivenoms, chemical antidotes and phytotherapy, with varying degrees of effectiveness and side effects. In this investigation, we reviewed the use of Saudi medicinal plants for the treatment of scorpion sting patients. The relevant literature was collected using the online search engines including Science Direct, Google and PubMed with the help of specific keywords. We also used the printed and online resources at our institutional library to gather the relevant information on the use of medicinal plants for the treatment of scorpion sting patients. A descriptive statistics was used for data compilation and presentation. The results of this survey showed the use of at least 92 medicinal plants with beneficial effects for treating victims of stings of different scorpion species. These commonly used herbs spanned to 37 families whilst different parts of these plants were employed therapeutically for alleviation of envenomation symptoms. The application of leaves (41%) was preferred followed by roots (19%), whole plant (14%) and seeds (9%). The use of latex (4%), stem (3%), flowers (3%) and bark (3%) was also reported. In some cases, tannin (2%), rhizome (1%) and shoot (1%) were also used. In conclusion, herbal medicines are effectively used for the treatment of patients with scorpion envenomation. This type of medication is free from side effects as observed with chemical antidotes or antivenom therapy. It is important to identify the active ingredients of herbal drugs for improving their therapeutic potential in traditional medicine.

Management of scorpion envenoming: a systematic review and meta-analysis of controlled clinical trials

BACKGROUND

Scorpion stings cause an estimated 3000 deaths per annum worldwide. We conducted a systematic review of all controlled clinical trials related to scorpion sting management.

METHODS

We searched PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus, Web of Science and CINAHL and included controlled prospective clinical trials (randomized or non-randomized). The following interventions were assessed: adults and children with scorpion stings treated with (a) steroids vs. placebo, (b) different methods of pain relief, (c) antivenom vs. supportive treatment, (d) prazosin vs. supportive treatment, (e) antivenom vs. prazosin and (f) antivenom plus prazosin vs. prazosin alone. When trials had comparative outcomes, they were combined in a meta-analysis. Data was analysed with Review Manager 5. Dichotomous data were compared with relative risk (RR), and continuous data were compared with mean differences using a fixed effect model. There is no PROSPERO registration number for this study.

RESULTS

Antivenom against Centruroides sp. are effective in reversing the clinical syndrome faster than no antivenom treatment in children (RR, 0.02; 95% CI, 0.01 to 0.06; 322 participants; three trials). Antivenom (against Mesobuthus tamulus) and prazosin combination is better than prazosin alone for faster resolution of symptoms (mean difference, -12.59 h; 95% CI, -14.01 to -11.17; 173 participants; three trials).

CONCLUSIONS

The polyvalent antivenom against Centruroides sp. in USA/Mexico and the monovalent antivenom against M. tamulus in India are effective for rapid resolution of symptoms. Prazosin is useful as an add-on therapy for M. tamulus stings.

Scorpion envenomation and antivenom therapy

Scorpion envenomation is a dangerous and common global event that can result in a variety of toxic clinical effects. These are typically managed with supportive care or antivenom. Antivenom use is controversial because of conflicting evidence of effectiveness for adrenergic toxicity. However, both controlled and uncontrolled studies have shown that antivenom is effective in resolving neuromotor toxicity associated with envenomations by the scorpions of genus Centruroides.

Direct vs. mediated effects of scorpion venom: an experimental study of the effects of a second challenge with scorpion venom

OBJECTIVE

To assess the respective roles of venom and of catecholamines following scorpion envenomation and to verify whether a second challenge with scorpion venom induces the same consequences than a first one.

DESIGN AND SETTING

Controlled animal study in a university research laboratory.

SUBJECTS

Anesthetized and ventilated dogs.

INTERVENTIONS

Fifteen dogs received intravenously a sublethal dose of scorpion venom (0.05 mg/kg). In the reenvenomated group (n=5) a second venom challenge with one-half sublethal venom dose was performed 30 min after the first one. The control group (n=10) received saline. Five additional animals served as sham.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

Plasma toxin and catecholamine levels and a set of usual hemodynamic measurements were repeatedly measured in the first hour following envenomation. In the reenvenomated group another set of measurements was performed 5 min after the second challenge. Changes in toxin, catecholamines, and the main hemodynamic parameters were compared between the study groups. Initial peak toxin levels were similar in the two groups. They induced a striking increase in circulating catecholamines, a fall in heart rate, and an increase in mean arterial and pulmonary artery occluded pressures and in systemic vascular resistance. In the reenvenomated group the second challenge with scorpion venom achieved a toxin blood level similar to the first peak. However, it was not associated with a significant effect either on catecholamines release or on hemodynamics. Subsequent trends in hemodynamic changes were similar to those observed in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

These data emphasize the limited role of direct effects of scorpion venom on the cardiovascular system and the key role of catecholamines.

A canine study of immunotherapy in scorpion envenomation

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effects of scorpion venom and antivenom in experimental envenomation.

DESIGN

Prospective, controlled animal study.

SETTING

University research laboratory

SUBJECTS

Twenty-nine anesthetized and ventilated dogs.

INTERVENTIONS

The first group of animals had venom alone (0.05 mg/kg). Animals from the second group had simultaneous administration of 10 ml of scorpion antivenom (SAV). In the third and fourth groups, 10 ml and 40 ml SAV, respectively, were injected 10 min following venom.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

Hemodynamic parameters using right heart catheter were recorded and dosage of catecholamines, neuropeptide Y (NPY), endothelin-1, and atrial natriuretic peptide (ANP) were performed at baseline and during 60 min following envenomation. In the control group, at 5 min, there was a sharp increase in pulmonary artery occluded pressure (PAOP, from 2 mmHg to 23 mmHg), mean arterial pressure (MAP, from 125 mmHg to 212 mmHg) and systemic vascular resistance (SVR, from 2450 dyn sec(-1 )m(5) to 5775 dyn sec(-1 )m(5), P<0.05 for all). Heart rate, cardiac output, and stroke volume decreased. There was a 40-fold increase in epinephrine and norepinephrine plasma concentrations. Circulating NPY and ANP dosages increased too. PAOP and MAP decreased thereafter to reach baseline levels. Simultaneous administration of SAV with venom totally offset the hallmarks of scorpion envenomation. Delayed administration of SAV at any dosage failed to alter the features of scorpion envenomation.

CONCLUSION

While simultaneous administration of SAV and scorpion venom is effective in preventing scorpion envenomation-related manifestations, delayed administration of SAV, either at standard or elevated dosages, failed to alter any of the scorpion envenomation features.

Antivenom treatment in arachnidism

Envenomation by arachnids causes significant medical illness worldwide. Scorpion sting is the most important arachnid envenomation causing adult morbidity and pediatric mortality. Important groups of spiders include the widow spiders (Latrodectus spp.), the recluse spiders (Loxosceles spp.), and two spiders confined to single countries: the Australian funnel web spider (Atrax and Hadronyche spp.) and the armed spider (Phoneutria spp.) from Brazil. There are four widow spider antivenoms available, including the Australian redback spider antivenom and the American black widow antivenom. Despite good in vitro animal work demonstrating effective neutralization with these antivenoms, and cross-reactivity between many species, there continues to be a reluctance to use them in some countries. They are both associated with a relatively low rate of allergic reactions. Redback antivenom is routinely used by the intramuscular route, which may not be as effective as intravenous use based on clinical experience and animal studies. Antivenoms are available for Loxosceles spp., but there is little evidence to support their effectiveness, particularly against local effects. The Australian funnel web spider causes severe neurotoxic envenomation, and antivenom appears to be effective in reported cases. An antivenom exists for the Brazilian armed spider, but is used in only a minority of cases. Many scorpion antivenoms exist worldwide, but there remains significant controversy regarding their efficacy. Animal and human venom level studies demonstrate neutralization of circulating venom in systemic envenomation. Clinical experience in countries where antivenom has been introduced suggests it has reduced pediatric mortality. However, three controlled trials demonstrated that antivenom was not effective, but these included few severe cases. Until controlled trials of antivenom in systemically envenomated patients are undertaken, antivenom use appears justified in severe envenomation. Although envenomation from arthropods is common, no antivenoms exist for these, excepting Lonomia caterpillars in South America, and Ixodes paralysis ticks in Australia.

Antivenom serotherapy and volume resuscitation partially improve peripheral organ ischemia in dogs injected with scorpion venom

We tested the hypothesis that fluid resuscitation combined with antivenom serotherapy given after injection of scorpion venom may increase cardiac output (CO) and blood pressure (BP) and prevent the decline in bicarbonate, pH and gastric perfusion. Seventeen anesthetized, mechanically ventilated dogs were given 0.1 mg/kg i.v. venom of the scorpion Leiurus quinquestriatus. The dogs were randomized into three groups: six dogs were given venom alone; three dogs were given 6 ml of antivenom 1 minute before venom injection; eight dogs were given 6 ml of antivenom and 20 ml/kg of synthetic colloid solution, 20 min after venom injection. Parameters reflecting respiratory and circulatory functions were determined at baseline and 120 min after venom injection. Scorpion venom caused a decrease in CO, BP, pH and HCO3-. Gastric mucosal perfusion was severely affected as assessed by mucosal pH (pHi) and the gradient between mucosal and arterial pCO2 (delta pCO2). Antivenom given before venom injection prevented all the effects induced by the venom. Antivenom and fluid given 20 min after venom injection caused a marked increase in CO and BP, but had no effect on pH and HCO3- decline (compared with venom alone). Gastric perfusion slightly improved as the increase in delta pCO2 was attenuated. The combination therapy of antivenom and fluid in this dog model is superior to the therapy of each of them alone. The marked and long-standing improvement of CO is promising and may suggest improvement in HCO3- and pH with time.

Human and animal bites and venomous stings

Human and animal bites and venomous stings demand careful handling. Immediate resuscitation may be necessary. Severe tissue damage from larger animals frequently requires urgent haemorrhage control, followed by debridement. Subsequent reconstruction is commonly necessary. Smaller bites, and particularly human bites, may easily be underestimated, and can have significant infective sequellae, with particular attention being paid to the potential finger joint injury. Surgical exploration is frequently indicated, debridement, irrigation and antimicrobial therapy being required. Viral transmission, as well as bacterial infection, can result from bites.

With regard to envenomation, often a great deal of time and effort is directed at identifying the offending animal and focusing on a specific toxin. It is important to ensure effective general resuscitation first. Thereafter, specific antivenom and antianaphylaxis measures may be taken.

A description of the three common envenomation symptom complexes -cyto-complex, neuro-complex and haemo-complex - is presented, along with some causative sources. Principles of resuscitation, wound care and general treatment measures are indicated, and then appropriate specific treatments are recommended.

Bites and envenomations vary in different parts of the world and it is important that emergency departments develop appropriate protocols relevant to their locations. Common poisonous animal sources should be identified and symptom complexes anticipated. Specific antivenom therapy, appropriate to the area, should be available. However, the general principles of resuscitation and wound care have pride of place.

Serotherapy in scorpion envenomation: a randomised controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Evidence for the benefit of scorpion antivenom, the only specific treatment for scorpion envenomation, is scarce, despite its common use. We did a prospective, randomised, controlled trial to assess the efficacy of routine administration of scorpion antivenom to scorpion-stung patients, irrespective of clinical severity.

METHODS

We included 825 consecutive patients older than 10 years, who presented to the accident and emergency department of the hospital in Tozeur, Tunisia. We graded severity by absence (grade I) or presence (grade II) of systemic manifestations of scorpion envenomation. Patients were randomly assigned placebo (n=413) or 20 mL bivalent intraveneous scorpion antivenom (n=412). All patients were observed for 4 h. Patients who developed life-threatening symptoms were admitted to the intensive-care unit. At the end of 4 h observation we reassessed grade and discharged grade II patients and admitted grade II patients. We assessed the preventive and curative effects of scorpion antivenom by prevention of worsening grade or by improvement from grade II to grade I.

FINDINGS

Distribution of severity grades was similar in the two groups at baseline, as were the cure rates (55% scorpion antivenom, 66% placebo, absolute difference, 11% [95% CI -4.8 to 26.8]; p=0.234). Preventive effects were seen in 94% and 96% of patients in the scorpion antivenom and placebo groups, respectively, who were initially grade I and who remained symptom-free (absolute difference, 2% [-1.27 to 5.27]; p=0.377). Time from scorpion sting to administration of scorpion antivenom did not affect curative and preventive effects.

INTERPRETATION

We found no benefit in routine administration of scorpion antivenom after scorpion sting, irrespective of clinical severity. Future studies should focus on patients with the most severe symptoms and signs.