Concentric FRET: a review of the emerging concept, theory, and applications

Multiplexed DNA and Protease Detection with Orthogonal Energy Transfer on a Single Quantum Dot Scaffolded Biosensor

Almost all pathogens, whether viral or bacterial, utilize key proteolytic steps in their pathogenesis. The ability to detect a pathogen's genomic material along with its proteolytic activity represents one approach to identifying the pathogen and providing initial evidence of its viability. Here, we report on a prototype biosensor design assembled around a single semiconductor quantum dot (QD) scaffold that is capable of detecting both nucleic acid sequences and proteolytic activity by using orthogonal energy transfer (ET) processes. The sensor consists of a central QD assembled via peptidyl-PNA linkers with multiple DNA sequences that encode complements to genomic sequences originating from the Ebola, Influenza, and COVID-19 viruses, which we use as surrogate targets. These are hybridized to complement strands labeled with a terbium (Tb) chelate, AlexaFluor647 (AF647), and Cy5.5 dyes, giving rise to two potential FRET cascades: the first includes Tb → QD → AF647 → Cy5.5 (→ = ET step), which is detected in a time-gated modality, and QD → AF647 → Cy5.5, which is detected from direct excitation. The labeled DNA-displaying QD construct is then further assembled with a RuII-modified peptide, which quenches QD photoluminescence by charge transfer and is recognized by a protease to yield the full biosensor. Each of the labeled DNAs and peptides can be ratiometrically assembled to the QD in a controllable manner to tune each of the ET pathways. Addition of a given target DNA displaces its labeled complement on the QD, disrupting that FRET channel, while protease addition disrupts charge transfer quenching of the central QD scaffold and boosts its photoluminescence and FRET relay capabilities. Along with characterizing the ET pathways and verifying biosensing in both individual and multiplexed formats, we also demonstrate the ability of this construct to function in molecular logic and perform Boolean operations; this highlights the construct's ability to discriminate and transduce signals between different inputs or pathogens. The potential application space for such a sensor device is discussed.

Spectrotemporal characterization of photoluminescent silicon nanocrystals and their energy transfer to dyes

Silicon nanocrystals (SiNCs) are a promising material for applications in bioanalysis and imaging. Compared to other types of semiconductor nanocrystals, the development and characterization of energy transfer (ET) configurations with SiNCs has been far more limited, resulting in an equally limited understanding of this process and its SiNC-specific nuances. Here, we present a systematic and detailed study of ET between SiNCs and dyes. A combination of spectroelectrophoresis and time-gated and time-resolved photoluminescence measurements were used to characterize the photophysical properties of ensembles of SiNCs and gain insight into how these properties varied as a function of nanocrystal size. ET between SiNC donors and a series of non-fluorescent Black Hole Quencher (BHQ) dyes and fluorescent sulfo-Cyanine 5.5 dye acceptors was evaluated in terms of spectral properties, wavelength-resolved efficiencies, trends with spectral overlap integral, and differences between two methods of BHQ association with the SiNCs. The overall results were consistent with a Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) mechanism where the polydispersity of the SiNCs had a significant impact on the observed ET: the choice of wavelength and timing parameters were important, and ensemble measurements represented an average of heterogeneous ET behaviors. Prospective advantages and disadvantages of SiNCs as ET donors are discussed. This study serves as a foundation for the continued and optimized development of ET configurations with SiNCs.

Tetrameric Antibody Complexes and Affinity Tag Peptides for the Selective Immobilization and Imaging of Single Quantum Dots

Colloidal semiconductor quantum dots (QDs) are of widespread interest as fluorescent labels for bioanalysis and imaging applications. Single-particle measurements have proven to be a very powerful tool for better understanding the fundamental properties and behaviors of QDs and their bioconjugates; however, a recurring challenge is the immobilization of QDs in a solution-like environment that minimizes interactions with a bulk surface. Immobilization strategies for QD-peptide conjugates are particularly underdeveloped within this context. Here, we present a novel strategy for the selective immobilization of single QD-peptide conjugates using a combination of tetrameric antibody complexes (TACs) and affinity tag peptides. A glass substrate is modified with an adsorbed layer of concanavalin A (ConA) that binds a subsequent layer of dextran that minimizes nonspecific binding. A TAC with anti-dextran and anti-affinity tag antibodies binds to the dextran-coated glass surface and to the affinity tag sequence of QD-peptide conjugates. The result is spontaneous and sequence-selective immobilization of single QDs without any chemical activation or cross-linking. Controlled immobilization of multiple colors of QDs is possible using multiple affinity tag sequences. Experiments confirmed that this approach positions the QD away from the bulk surface. The method supports real-time imaging of binding and dissociation, measurements of Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), tracking of dye photobleaching, and detection of proteolytic activity. We anticipate that this immobilization strategy will be useful for studies of QD-associated photophysics, biomolecular interactions and processes, and digital assays.

Plasmonic quenching and enhancement: metal-quantum dot nanohybrids for fluorescence biosensing

Plasmonic metal nanoparticles and semiconductor quantum dots (QDs) are two of the most widely applied nanomaterials for optical biosensing and bioimaging. While their combination for fluorescence quenching via nanosurface energy transfer (NSET) or Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) offers powerful ways of tuning and amplifying optical signals and is relatively common, metal-QD nanohybrids for plasmon-enhanced fluorescence (PEF) have been much less prevalent. A major reason is the competition between fluorescence quenching and enhancement, which poses important challenges for optimizing distances, orientations, and spectral overlap toward maximum PEF. In this feature article, we discuss the interplay of the different quenching and enhancement mechanisms (a mixed distance dependence of quenching and enhancement - "quenchancement") to better understand the obstacles that must be overcome for the development of metal-QD nanohybrid-based PEF biosensors. The different nanomaterials, their combination within various surface and solution based design concepts, and their structural and photophysical characterization are reviewed and applications toward advanced optical biosensing and bioimaging are presented along with guidelines and future perspectives for sensitive, selective, and versatile bioanalytical research and biomolecular diagnostics with metal-QD nanohybrids.

Triple-FRET multi-purpose fluorescent probe for three-protease detection

A new, robust and reliable methodology for three-protease screening in a single-enzyme mode has been developed and verified, employing a multi-purpose peptide probe with three selectively cleavable sites furnished with four fluorophores. A triple-FRET-based single-excitation quadruple-emission concept for unambiguous sensing of trypsin, chymotrypsin and caspase-8 in the lowest detectable concentrations of 0.5 ng mL^-1, 0.2 μg mL^-1, and 2 U mL^-1, respectively, has been applied and graphically depicted. Then the developed 4-dye probe has been also studied from the perspective of simultaneous two-protease screening, which was found only partially feasible, primarily due to unselective chymotrypsin cleavage.

Nanoscale 3D spatial addressing and valence control of quantum dots using wireframe DNA origami

Control over the copy number and nanoscale positioning of quantum dots (QDs) is critical to their application to functional nanomaterials design. However, the multiple non-specific binding sites intrinsic to the surface of QDs have prevented their fabrication into multi-QD assemblies with programmed spatial positions. To overcome this challenge, we developed a general synthetic framework to selectively attach spatially addressable QDs on 3D wireframe DNA origami scaffolds using interfacial control of the QD surface. Using optical spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulation, we investigated the fabrication of monovalent QDs of different sizes using chimeric single-stranded DNA to control QD surface chemistry. By understanding the relationship between chimeric single-stranded DNA length and QD size, we integrated single QDs into wireframe DNA origami objects and visualized the resulting QD-DNA assemblies using electron microscopy. Using these advances, we demonstrated the ability to program arbitrary 3D spatial relationships between QDs and dyes on DNA origami objects by fabricating energy-transfer circuits and colloidal molecules. Our design and fabrication approach enables the geometric control and spatial addressing of QDs together with the integration of other materials including dyes to fabricate hybrid materials for functional nanoscale photonic devices.

Developing FRET Networks for Sensing

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is a widely used fluorescence-based sensing mechanism. To date, most implementations of FRET sensors have relied on a discrete donor-acceptor pair for detection of each analytical target. FRET networks are an emerging concept in which target recognition perturbs a set of interconnected FRET pathways between multiple emitters. Here, we review the energy transfer topologies and scaffold materials for FRET networks, propose a general nomenclature, and qualitatively summarize the dynamics of the competitive, sequential, homoFRET, and heteroFRET pathways that constitute FRET networks. Implementations of FRET networks for sensing are also described, including concentric FRET probes, other single-vector multiplexing, and logic gates and switches. Unresolved questions and future research directions for current systems are discussed, as are potential but currently unexplored applications of FRET networks in sensing.

A Dendrimer-Based Time-Gated Concentric FRET Configuration for Multiplexed Sensing

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is widely used for the development of biological probes and sensors. In this context, the norm for multiplexed detection is deployment of multiple probes, each a discrete donor-acceptor pair. Concentric FRET (cFRET) probes enable multiplexed sensing with a single vector but, to date, have only been developed around semiconductor quantum dots, which may limit the scope of biological applications for such probes. Here, we demonstrate that dendrimers labeled with a luminescent terbium complex (Tb) are a viable and advantageous alternative platform for cFRET probes. Polyamidoamine dendrimers were functionalized with Tb, biotin, NeutrAvidin, and three types of dye-labeled oligonucleotide probes to establish a network of competitive and sequential Tb-to-dye and dye-to-dye FRET pathways. These probes were characterized physically and photophysically, and a time-gated multiplexed assay for DNA targets was demonstrated. The time-gating offered by the Tb allowed the rejection of background autofluorescence from serum. More broadly, this dendrimer-based architecture shows that cFRET is a general concept and is an important step toward a new generation of probes for biological sensing.

Activatable MRI probes for the specific detection of bacteria

Activatable fluorescent probes have been successfully used as molecular tools for biomedical research in the last decades. Fluorescent probes allow the detection of molecular events, providing an extraordinary platform for protein and cellular research. Nevertheless, most of the fluorescent probes reported are susceptible to interferences from endogenous fluorescence (background signal) and limited tissue penetration is expected. These drawbacks prevent the use of fluorescent tracers in the clinical setting. To overcome the limitation of fluorescent probes, we and others have developed activatable magnetic resonance probes. Herein, we report for the first time, an oligonucleotide-based probe with the capability to detect bacteria using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The activatable MRI probe consists of a specific oligonucleotide that targets micrococcal nuclease (MN), a nuclease derived from Staphylococcus aureus. The oligonucleotide is flanked by a superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticle (SPION) at one end, and by a dendron functionalized with several gadolinium complexes as enhancers, at the other end. Therefore, only upon recognition of the MRI probe by the specific bacteria is the probe activated and the MRI signal can be detected. This approach may be widely applied to detect bacterial infections or other human conditions with the potential to be translated into the clinic as an activatable contrast agent.

Understanding Förster Resonance Energy Transfer in the Sheet Regime with DNA Brick-Based Dye Networks

Controlling excitonic energy transfer at the molecular level is a key requirement for transitioning nanophotonics research to viable devices with the main inspiration coming from biological light-harvesting antennas that collect and direct light energy with near-unity efficiency using Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET). Among putative FRET processes, point-to-plane FRET between donors and acceptors arrayed in two-dimensional sheets is predicted to be particularly efficient with a theoretical 1/r⁴ energy transfer distance (r) dependency versus the 1/r⁶ dependency seen for a single donor-acceptor interaction. However, quantitative validation has been confounded by a lack of robust experimental approaches that can rigidly place dyes in the required nanoscale arrangements. To create such assemblies, we utilize a DNA brick scaffold, referred to as a DNA block, which incorporates up to five two-dimensional planes with each displaying from 1 to 12 copies of five different donor, acceptor, or intermediary relay dyes. Nanostructure characterization along with steady-state and time-resolved spectroscopic data were combined with molecular dynamics modeling and detailed numerical simulations to compare the energy transfer efficiencies observed in the experimental DNA block assemblies to theoretical expectations. Overall, we demonstrate clear signatures of sheet regime FRET, and from this we provide a better understanding of what is needed to realize the benefits of such energy transfer in artificial dye networks along with FRET-based sensing and imaging.

Preparation and Characterization of Quantum Dot-Peptide Conjugates Based on Polyhistidine Tags

Quantum dots (QDs) offer bright and robust photoluminescence among several other advantages in comparison to fluorescent dyes. In order to leverage the advantageous properties of QDs for applications in bioanalysis and imaging, simple and reliable methods for bioconjugation are required. One such method for conjugating peptides to QDs is the use of polyhistidine tags, which spontaneously bind to the surface of QDs. We describe protocols for assembling polyhistidine-tagged peptides to QDs and for characterizing the resultant QD-peptide conjugates. The latter include both electrophoretic and FRET-based protocols for confirming successful peptide assembly, estimating the maximum peptide loading capacity, and measuring the assembly kinetics. Sensors for protease activity and intracellular delivery are briefly noted as prospective applications of QD-peptide conjugates.

Photoluminescent Nanoparticles for Chemical and Biological Analysis and Imaging

Research related to the development and application of luminescent nanoparticles (LNPs) for chemical and biological analysis and imaging is flourishing. Novel materials and new applications continue to be reported after two decades of research. This review provides a comprehensive and heuristic overview of this field. It is targeted to both newcomers and experts who are interested in a critical assessment of LNP materials, their properties, strengths and weaknesses, and prospective applications. Numerous LNP materials are cataloged by fundamental descriptions of their chemical identities and physical morphology, quantitative photoluminescence (PL) properties, PL mechanisms, and surface chemistry. These materials include various semiconductor quantum dots, carbon nanotubes, graphene derivatives, carbon dots, nanodiamonds, luminescent metal nanoclusters, lanthanide-doped upconversion nanoparticles and downshifting nanoparticles, triplet-triplet annihilation nanoparticles, persistent-luminescence nanoparticles, conjugated polymer nanoparticles and semiconducting polymer dots, multi-nanoparticle assemblies, and doped and labeled nanoparticles, including but not limited to those based on polymers and silica. As an exercise in the critical assessment of LNP properties, these materials are ranked by several application-related functional criteria. Additional sections highlight recent examples of advances in chemical and biological analysis, point-of-care diagnostics, and cellular, tissue, and in vivo imaging and theranostics. These examples are drawn from the recent literature and organized by both LNP material and the particular properties that are leveraged to an advantage. Finally, a perspective on what comes next for the field is offered.

Accelerating biological insight for understudied genes

The rapid expansion of genome sequence data is increasing the discovery of protein-coding genes across all domains of life. Annotating these genes with reliable functional information is necessary to understand evolution, to define the full biochemical space accessed by nature, and to identify target genes for biotechnology improvements. The vast majority of proteins are annotated based on sequence conservation with no specific biological, biochemical, genetic, or cellular function identified. Recent technical advances throughout the biological sciences enable experimental research on these understudied protein-coding genes in a broader collection of species. However, scientists have incentives and biases to continue focusing on well documented genes within their preferred model organism. This perspective suggests a research model that seeks to break historic silos of research bias by enabling interdisciplinary teams to accelerate biological functional annotation. We propose an initiative to develop coordinated projects of collaborating evolutionary biologists, cell biologists, geneticists, and biochemists that will focus on subsets of target genes in multiple model organisms. Concurrent analysis in multiple organisms takes advantage of evolutionary divergence and selection, which causes individual species to be better suited as experimental models for specific genes. Most importantly, multisystem approaches would encourage transdisciplinary critical thinking and hypothesis testing that is inherently slow in current biological research.