Variation in Disease Severity Caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi, P. plurivora, and Pythium cryptoirregulare on Two Rhododendron Cultivars

Temperature and Fungicide Sensitivity in Three Prevalent Phytophthora Species Causing Phytophthora Root Rot in Rhododendron

Temperature is an important environmental variable affecting Phytophthora spp. biology. It alters the ability of species to grow, sporulate, and infect their plant host, and it is also important in mediating pathogen responses to disease control measures. Average global temperatures are increasing as a consequence of climate change, yet there are few studies that compare the effects of temperature on Phytophthora spp. that are important to the nursery industry. To address this, we conducted a series of experiments to evaluate how temperature affects the biology and control of three soilborne Phytophthora spp. prevalent in the nursery industry. In the first set of experiments, we evaluated the mycelial growth and sporulation of several Phytophthora cinnamomi, P. plurivora, and P. pini isolates at temperatures ranging from 4 to 42°C for different amounts of time (0 to 120 h). In the second set of experiments, we evaluated the response of three isolates of each species to the fungicides mefenoxam and phosphorous acid at temperatures ranging from 6 to 40°C. Results showed that each species responds differently to temperature, with P. plurivora having the greatest optimal temperature (26.6°C), P. pini the least (24.4°C), and P. cinnamomi was intermediate between the two (25.3°C). P. plurivora and P. pini had the lowest minimum temperatures (approximately 2.4°C) compared with P. cinnamomi (6.5°C), while all three species had a similar maximum temperature (approximately 35°C). When tested against mefenoxam, all three species were generally more sensitive to mefenoxam at cool temperatures (6 to 14°C) than at warmer temperatures (22 to 30°C). P. cinnamomi was also more sensitive to phosphorous acid at cool temperatures (6 to 14°C). However, both P. plurivora and P. pini tended to be more sensitive to phosphorous acid at warmer temperatures (22 to 30°C). These findings help define the temperatures at which these pathogens will be the most damaging and help delineate the temperatures at which fungicides should be applied for maximum efficacy.

Phytophthora cinnamomi causing root rot on Rhododendron lapponicum and control it using potential biocontrol agents

Rhododendron lapponicum (R. lapponicum) is a dwarf Rhododendron species, which is severely infected with root rot and wilt in Yunnan province, China. However, the causal agent causing these symptoms was unknown. An isolate, Pci-1 was identified as Phytophthora cinnamomi, based on its morphology and the sequences of β-tubulin, internal transcribed spacer, and Ypt1 genes and verified according to the Koch's postulate. We found that this pathogen could infect 14 species of plants, including Althaea rosea, Viburnum cylindricum, and Brassica napus. Strain Pci-1 could cause R. lapponicum to wither and die; and it grows best in an oat medium with pH 7.0 - 8.0 and an optimum temperature of 27°C. We suggest that the rhizosphere of R. lapponicum treated with biocontrol strains Paenibacillus polymyxoides P2-5 and Trichoderma asperellum Tv-1 showed a significant inhibitory effect on pathogen Pci-1. The inhibitory effect of 70% dimethomorph + cymoxanil was significantly higher with EC₅₀ and EC₉₀ values of 0.1894 and 0.3618 a.i. µg/ml, respectively. Greenhouse experiments revealed that the pathogen load is decreased in the presence of potential antagonists. This study provides fundamentals on risk assessment and theoretical support for the management of P. cinnamomi pathogen and contributes significantly to the planting of forest and horticultural crops in a disease-free environment.

Is Disease Induced by Flooding Representative of Nursery Conditions in Rhododendrons Infected with Phytophthora cinnamomi or P. plurivora?

The degree of flooding commonly used to induce disease in Phytophthora root rot studies rarely occurs in container nurseries. Instead, over-irrigation and poor drainage result in plants periodically sitting in shallow pools of water. Rhododendron plants were grown in a noninfested substrate or substrate infested with Phytophthora cinnamomi or P. plurivora to determine whether root rot induced by flooding represents disease that occurs under simulated nursery conditions when plants are in a shallow pool of water (saucers), or are allowed to freely drain and maintained at ∼75% container capacity (CC). Generally P. cinnamomi caused more disease than P. plurivora, and all water treatments were conducive to root rot. In experiment 1, the amount of disease caused by flooding was similar to that in the saucer treatment (75% CC not tested) while in experiment 2, flooding often caused more rapid and severe disease than the saucer or 75% CC treatment. Pathogens differed in their response to water treatments. P. cinnamomi caused more disease in treatments with >90% substrate moisture for either a short (flood) or long duration (saucer), while P. plurivora was less capable of causing disease when soil moisture was maintained >90% than when substrate moisture was maintained at a more moderate level (flood, 75% CC). Our results indicate that it is not necessary to flood plants to induce disease under experimental conditions and that disease induced by flooding can represent disease in container nurseries when containers are in pools of water or maintained at ∼75% CC. In addition, our results suggest that P. cinnamomi is a more aggressive pathogen than P. plurivora in nursery conditions where drainage is poor; however, both species are capable of causing a similar amount of disease under more typical irrigation management.

Optimizing Inoculum Production Methods for Infesting Soil with Phytophthora Species

Inoculum production is an important part of conducting research with soilborne Phytophthora species. One common method is to incubate Phytophthora cultures in nutrient-amended vermiculite. However, inoculum levels often vary among batches of inoculum, even when production methods remain the same, and incubation typically takes ≥6 weeks, increasing risks for delayed experiments if the resulting inoculum level is too low. A more reliable and rapid method is needed for future studies. Experiments were conducted to determine inoculum levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi and Phytophthora plurivora after incubation in V8 juice-amended vermiculite (standard method); evaluate how inoculum viability was affected by air-drying; develop a modified method that takes less time to produce a vermiculite-based inoculum; and evaluate the effect of storage on inoculum viability. Results showed that the standard method produced inoculum levels from 716 to 1,808 colony forming units (CFUs)/g and that drying to <78% moisture content significantly reduced viability. The modified method used 2-week-old Phytophthora cultures to infest vermiculite at 80% moisture content and produced inoculum levels from 214 to 525 CFU/g. Storage for >1 day generally reduced inoculum viability. Although inoculum levels from the modified method were lower than the standard method, inoculum levels for each isolate were more consistent between trials, and the modified method was 6 to 8 weeks faster. Production with the modified method can also be easily scaled up by infesting a greater volume of vermiculite with additional cultures of Phytophthora. These results are important because they help explain variability in soilborne Phytophthora inoculum production and storage and provide a new method for producing inoculum more quickly.

Virulence of Five Phytophthora Species Causing Rhododendron Root Rot in Oregon

Phytophthora root rot is a destructive disease of rhododendron that causes substantial losses of this nursery crop in infested field and container production areas. Historically, Phytophthora cinnamomi was considered the main causal agent of the disease. However, a recent survey of soilborne Phytophthora species from symptomatic rhododendrons in Oregon revealed that P. plurivora is more common than P. cinnamomi, and that several other Phytophthora species may be involved. We investigated the ability of the five most abundant species from the survey to cause root rot: P. plurivora, P. cinnamomi, P. pini, P. pseudocryptogea, and P. cambivora. Three to four isolates were selected for each species from across six Oregon nurseries. Media of containerized Rhododendron catawbiense 'Boursault' was infested with single isolates in a randomized complete block design in a greenhouse. Phytophthora cinnamomi, P. pini, and P. plurivora rapidly caused ≥90% of severe root rot, whereas P. pseudocryptogea caused more moderate disease (46% of severe root rot). Phytophthora cambivora failed to produce enough inoculum and was used at a lower inoculum density than the other four species; however, occasionally, it caused severe root rot (5% incidence). No differences in virulence were observed among isolates of the same species, except for one isolate of P. plurivora that caused less disease than other P. plurivora isolates. This study demonstrates that all five Phytophthora species, which were representative of 94% of the survey isolates, are capable of causing severe root rot and plant death, but that not all species are equally virulent.

Growth, Sporulation, and Pathogenicity of the Raspberry Pathogen Phytophthora rubi Under Different Temperature and Moisture Regimes

Phytophthora root rot of raspberry, which is mostly caused by Phytophthora rubi, is a significant issue for the Washington State red raspberry industry. Considered a cool weather pathogen, it is often assumed that it is most active and infective during the cool, wet winters of the region when soil temperatures range from 5 to 10°C; however, there are little data to support this view. More recent research has found that symptoms of root disease during late summer were strongly associated with P. rubi. Therefore, experiments were conducted at four temperatures from 5 to 20°C to evaluate the effects of temperature on P. rubi mycelial growth and sporulation and the effects of both temperature and soil moisture on the pathogenicity of P. rubi on red raspberry. At 20°C, P. rubi grew fastest and sporulated the most heavily. However, disease was most severe at both 15 and 20°C. The soil moisture parameters tested did not affect the pathogenicity results. These results show that P. rubi is more likely to infect during the spring and summer months (from May through September), when soil temperatures are consistently in the range of 15 to 20°C.

Phytophthora Species Differ in Response to Phosphorous Acid and Mefenoxam for the Management of Phytophthora Root Rot in Rhododendron

Phytophthora root rot, caused by many soilborne Phytophthora spp., is a significant disease affecting the $42 million rhododendron nursery industry. Rhododendron growers have increasingly reported failure by two systemic fungicides, phosphorous acid and mefenoxam, to adequately control root rot. Both fungicides may be applied as a foliar spray or soil drench but it is unknown how application method, fungicide chemistry, or pathogen diversity affects disease control. Therefore, two experiments were conducted to (i) determine whether differences in application method or fungicide chemistry affect control of root rot caused by P. cinnamomi and P. plurivora and (ii) evaluate the sensitivity of Phytophthora spp. and isolates from the rhododendron industry to each fungicide. Results demonstrated that soil drenches of either fungicide were more effective than foliar sprays for control of P. cinnamomi but were ineffective for P. plurivora. Furthermore, Phytophthora spp. and isolates varied in sensitivity to phosphorous acid and mefenoxam, and there were multiple fungicide-insensitive isolates, especially within P. plurivora. Differences in sensitivity were also observed among isolates from different nurseries and production systems, with some nurseries having less sensitive isolates than others and with container systems generally having less sensitive isolates than field systems. Our results provide three potential reasons for why fungicide control of Phytophthora root rot might fail: (i) the fungicide can be applied to the wrong portion of the plant for optimal control, (ii) there are differences in fungicide sensitivity among soilborne Phytophthora spp. and isolates infecting rhododendron, and (iii) fungicide-insensitive isolates are present in the rhododendron nursery industry.

Soilborne Phytophthora and Pythium Diversity From Rhododendron in Propagation, Container, and Field Production Systems of the Pacific Northwest

Rhododendron root rot is a severe disease that causes significant mortality in rhododendrons. Information is needed about the incidence and identity of soilborne Phytophthora and Pythium species causing root rot in Pacific Northwest nurseries in order to better understand the disease etiology and to optimize disease control strategies. The last survey focusing solely on soilborne oomycete pathogens in rhododendron production was conducted in 1974. Since then, advances in pathogen identification have occurred, new species may have been introduced, pathogen communities may have shifted, and little is known about Pythium species affecting this crop. Therefore, a survey of root-infecting Phytophthora and Pythium species was conducted at seven nurseries from 2013 to 2017 to (i) document the incidence of root rot damage at each nursery and stage of production, (ii) identify soilborne oomycetes infecting rhododendron, and (iii) determine whether there are differences in pathogen diversity among nurseries and production systems. Rhododendrons from propagation, container, and field systems were sampled and Phytophthora and Pythium species were isolated from the roots and collar region. Root rot was rarely evident in propagation systems, which were dominated by Pythium species. However, severe root rot was much more common in container and field systems where the genus Phytophthora was also more prevalent, suggesting that Phytophthora species are the primary cause of severe root rot and that most contamination by these pathogens comes in after the propagation stage. In total, 20 Pythium species and 11 Phytophthora species were identified. Pythium cryptoirregulare, Pythium aff. macrosporum, Phytophthora plurivora, and Phytophthora cinnamomi were the most frequently isolated species and the results showed that Phytophthora plurivora has become much more common than in the past. Phytophthora diversity was also greater in field systems than in propagation or container systems. Risks for Phytophthora contamination were commonly observed during the survey and included placement of potting media in direct contact with field soil, the presence of dead plants that could serve as continuous sources of inoculum, and the presence of excess water as a result of poor drainage, overirrigation, or malfunctioning irrigation equipment. In the past, research on disease development and root rot disease control in rhododendron focused almost exclusively on Phytophthora cinnamomi. More research is needed on both of these topics for the other root-infecting species identified in this survey.

Population Structure of Phytophthora plurivora on Rhododendron in Oregon Nurseries

Phytophthora plurivora is a recently described plant pathogen, formerly recognized as P. citricola. Recent sampling of Pacific Northwest nurseries frequently encountered this pathogen, and it has been shown to be among the most damaging Phytophthora pathogens on ornamentals. We characterized the population structure of P. plurivora in a survey of four Oregon nurseries across three different counties with focus on Rhododendron hosts. Isolates were identified to the species level by Sanger sequencing and/or a PCR-RFLP assay of the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region. We used genotyping-by-sequencing to determine genetic diversity. Variants were called de novo, resulting in 284 high-quality variants for 61 isolates after stringent filtering. Based on F_st and AMOVA, populations were moderately differentiated among nurseries. Overall, population structure suggested presence of one dominant clonal lineage in all nurseries, as well as isolates of cryptic diversity mostly found in one nursery. Within the clonal lineage, there was a broad range of sensitivity to mefenoxam and phosphorous acid. Sensitivity of the two fungicides was correlated. P. plurivora was previously assumed to spread clonally, and the low genotypic diversity observed within and among isolates corroborated this hypothesis. The broad range of fungicide sensitivity within the P. plurivora population found in PNW nurseries has implications for managing disease caused by this important nursery pathogen. These findings provide the first perspective into P. plurivora population structure and phenotypic plasticity in Pacific Northwest nurseries.