Establishment of knockout adult sea urchins by using a CRISPR‐Cas9 system

More than a colour; how pigment influences colourblind microbes

Many animals have pigments when they themselves cannot see colour. Perhaps those pigments enable the animal to avoid predators, or to attract mates. Maybe even those pigmented surfaces are hosts for microbes, even when the microbes do not see colour. Do some pigments then serve as a chemical signal for a good or bad microbial substrate? Maybe pigments attract or repel various microbe types? Echinoderms serve as an important model to test the mechanisms of pigment-based microbial interactions. Echinoderms are marine benthic organisms, ranging from intertidal habitats to depths of thousands of metres and are exposed to large varieties of microbes. They are also highly pigmented, with a diverse variety of colours between and even within species. Here we focus on one type of pigment (naphthoquinones) made by polyketide synthase, modified by flavin-dependent monoxygenases, and on one type of function, microbial interaction. Recent successes in targeted gene inactivation by CRISPR/Cas9 in sea urchins supports the contention that colour is more than it seems. Here we dissect the players, and their interactions to better understand how such host factors influence a microbial colonization. This article is part of the theme issue 'Sculpting the microbiome: how host factors determine and respond to microbial colonization'.

CRISPR-Cas9-Mediated Gene Knockout in a Non-Model Sea Urchin, Heliocidaris crassispina

Sea urchins have been used as model organisms in developmental biology research and the genomes of several sea urchin species have been sequenced. Recently, genome editing technologies have become available for sea urchins, and methods for gene knockout using the CRISPRCas9 system have been established. Heliocidaris crassispina is an important marine fishery resource with edible gonads. Although H. crassispina has been used as a biological research material, its genome has not yet been published, and it is a non-model sea urchin for molecular biology research. However, as recent advances in genome editing technology have facilitated genome modification in non-model organisms, we applied genome editing using the CRISPR-Cas9 system to H. crassispina. In this study, we targeted genes encoding ETS transcription factor (HcEts) and pigmentation-related polyketide synthase (HcPks1). Gene fragments were isolated using primers designed by inter-specific sequence comparisons within Echinoidea. When Ets gene was targeted using two sgRNAs, one successfully introduced mutations and impaired skeletogenesis. In the Pks1 gene knockout, when two sgRNAs targeting the close vicinity of the site corresponding to the target site that showed 100% mutagenesis efficiency of the Pks1 gene in Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus, mutagenesis was not observed. However, two other sgRNAs targeting distant sites efficiently introduced mutations. In addition, Pks1 knockout H. crassispina exhibited an albino phenotype in the pluteus larvae and adult sea urchins after metamorphosis. This indicates that the CRISPRCas9 system can be used to modify the genome of the non-model sea urchin H. crassispina.

Cold storage and cryopreservation methods for spermatozoa of the sea urchins Lytechinus pictus and Strongylocentrotus purpuratus

BACKGROUND

Sea urchins have contributed greatly to knowledge of fertilization, embryogenesis, and cell biology. However, until now, they have not been genetic model organisms because of their long generation times and lack of tools for husbandry and gene manipulation. We recently established the sea urchin Lytechinus pictus, as a multigenerational model Echinoderm, because of its relatively short generation time of 4-6 months and ease of laboratory culture. To take full advantage of this new multigenerational species, methods are needed to biobank and share genetically modified L. pictus sperm.

RESULTS

Here, we describe a method, based on sperm ion physiology that maintains L. pictus and Strongylocentrotus purpuratus sperm fertilizable for at least 5-10 weeks when stored at 0°C. We also describe a new method to cryopreserve sperm of both species. Sperm of both species can be frozen and thawed at least twice and still give rise to larvae that undergo metamorphosis.

CONCLUSIONS

The simple methods we describe work well for both species, achieving >90% embryo development and producing larvae that undergo metamorphosis to juvenile adults. We hope that these methods will be useful to others working on marine invertebrate sperm.

Detection of TALEN-mediated genome cleavage during the early embryonic stage of the starfish Patiria pectinifera

BACKGROUND

Echinoderms have long been utilized as experimental materials to study the genetic control of developmental processes and their evolution. Among echinoderms, the molecular study of starfish embryos has received considerable attention across research topics such as gene regulatory network evolution and larval regeneration. Recently, experimental techniques to manipulate gene functions have been gradually established in starfish as the feasibility of genome editing methods was reported. However, it is still unclear when these techniques cause genome cleavage during the development of starfish, which is critical to understand the timeframe and applicability of the experiment during early development of starfish.

RESULTS

We herein reported that gene functions can be analyzed by the genome editing method TALEN in early embryos, such as the blastula of the starfish Patiria pectinifera. We injected the mRNA of TALEN targeting rar, which was previously constructed, into eggs of P. pectinifera and examined the efficiency of genome cleavage through developmental stages from 6 to 48 hours post fertilization.

CONCLUSION

The results will be key knowledge not only when designing TALEN-based experiments but also when assessing the results.

The crucial role of CTCF in mitotic progression during early development of sea urchin

CCCTC-binding factor (CTCF), an insulator protein with 11 zinc fingers, is enriched at the boundaries of topologically associated domains (TADs) in eukaryotic genomes. In this study, we isolated and analyzed the cDNAs encoding HpCTCF, the CTCF homolog in the sea urchin Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus, to investigate its expression patterns and functions during the early development of sea urchin. HpCTCF contains nine zinc fingers corresponding to fingers 2-10 of the vertebrate CTCF. Expression pattern analysis revealed that HpCTCF mRNA was detected at all developmental stages and in the entire embryo. Upon expressing the HpCTCF-GFP fusion protein in early embryos, we observed its uniform distribution within interphase nuclei. However, during mitosis, it disappeared from the chromosomes and subsequently reassembled on the chromosome during telophase. Moreover, the morpholino-mediated knockdown of HpCTCF resulted in mitotic arrest during the morula to blastula stage. Most of the arrested chromosomes were not phospholylated at serine 10 of histone H3, indicating that mitosis was arrested at the telophase by HpCTCF depletion. Furthermore, impaired sister chromatid segregation was observed using time-lapse imaging of HpCTCF-knockdown embryos. Thus, HpCTCF is essential for mitotic progression during the early development of sea urchins, especially during the telophase-to-interphase transition. However, the normal development of pluteus larvae in CRISPR-mediated HpCTCF-knockout embryos suggests that disruption of zygotic HpCTCF expression has little effect on embryonic and larval development.

DANGER analysis: risk-averse on/off-target assessment for CRISPR editing without a reference genome

Motivation

The CRISPR-Cas9 system has successfully achieved site-specific gene editing in organisms ranging from humans to bacteria. The technology efficiently generates mutants, allowing for phenotypic analysis of the on-target gene. However, some conventional studies did not investigate whether deleterious off-target effects partially affect the phenotype.

Results

Herein, we present a novel phenotypic assessment of CRISPR-mediated gene editing: Deleterious and ANticipatable Guides Evaluated by RNA-sequencing (DANGER) analysis. Using RNA-seq data, this bioinformatics pipeline can elucidate genomic on/off-target sites on mRNA-transcribed regions related to expression changes and then quantify phenotypic risk at the gene ontology term level. We demonstrated the risk-averse on/off-target assessment in RNA-seq data from gene-edited samples of human cells and zebrafish brains. Our DANGER analysis successfully detected off-target sites, and it quantitatively evaluated the potential contribution of deleterious off-targets to the transcriptome phenotypes of the edited mutants. Notably, DANGER analysis harnessed de novo transcriptome assembly to perform risk-averse on/off-target assessments without a reference genome. Thus, our resources would help assess genome editing in non-model organisms, individual human genomes, and atypical genomes from diseases and viruses. In conclusion, DANGER analysis facilitates the safer design of genome editing in all organisms with a transcriptome.

Availability and implementation

The Script for the DANGER analysis pipeline is available at https://github.com/KazukiNakamae/DANGER_analysis. In addition, the software provides a tutorial on reproducing the results presented in this article on the Readme page. The Docker image of DANGER_analysis is also available at https://hub.docker.com/repository/docker/kazukinakamae/dangeranalysis/general.

Optimizing CRISPR/Cas9-based gene manipulation in echinoderms

The impact of new technology can be appreciated by how broadly it is used. Investigators that previously relied only on pharmacological approaches or the use of morpholino antisense oligonucleotide (MASO) technologies are now able to apply CRISPR-Cas9 to study biological problems in their model organism of choice much more effectively. The transitions to new CRISPR-based approaches could be enhanced, first, by standardized protocols and education in their applications. Here we summarize our results for optimizing the CRISPR-Cas9 technology in a sea urchin and a sea star, and provide advice on how to set up CRISPR-Cas9 experiments and interpret the results in echinoderms. Our goal through these protocols and sharing examples of success by other labs is to lower the activation barrier so that more laboratories can apply CRISPR-Cas9 technologies in these important animals.

Generation of a homozygous mutant drug transporter (ABCB1) knockout line in the sea urchin Lytechinus pictus

Sea urchins are premier model organisms for the study of early development. However, the lengthy generation times of commonly used species have precluded application of stable genetic approaches. Here, we use the painted sea urchin Lytechinus pictus to address this limitation and to generate a homozygous mutant sea urchin line. L. pictus has one of the shortest generation times of any currently used sea urchin. We leveraged this advantage to generate a knockout mutant of the sea urchin homolog of the drug transporter ABCB1, a major player in xenobiotic disposition for all animals. Using CRISPR/Cas9, we generated large fragment deletions of ABCB1 and used these readily detected deletions to rapidly genotype and breed mutant animals to homozygosity in the F2 generation. The knockout larvae are produced according to expected Mendelian distribution, exhibit reduced xenobiotic efflux activity and can be grown to maturity. This study represents a major step towards more sophisticated genetic manipulation of the sea urchin and the establishment of reproducible sea urchin animal resources.

Sea Urchin Polyketide Synthase SpPks1 Produces the Naphthalene Precursor to Echinoderm Pigments

Nearly every animal species on Earth contains a unique polyketide synthase (PKS) encoded in its genome, yet no animal-clade PKS has been biochemically characterized, and even the chemical products of these ubiquitous enzymes are known in only a few cases. The earliest animal genome-encoded PKS gene to be identified was SpPks1 from sea urchins. Previous genetic knockdown experiments implicated SpPks1 in synthesis of the sea urchin pigment echinochrome. Here, we express and purify SpPks1, performing biochemical experiments to demonstrate that the sea urchin protein is responsible for the synthesis of 2-acetyl-1,3,6,8-tetrahydroxynaphthalene (ATHN). Since ATHN is a plausible precursor of echinochromes, this result defines a biosynthetic pathway to the ubiquitous echinoderm pigments and rewrites the previous hypothesis for echinochrome biosynthesis. Truncation experiments showed that, unlike other type I iterative PKSs so far characterized, SpPks1 produces the naphthalene core using solely ketoacylsynthase (KS), acyltransferase, and acyl carrier protein domains, delineating a unique class of animal nonreducing aromatic PKSs (aPKSs). A series of amino acids in the KS domain define the family and are likely crucial in cyclization activity. Phylogenetic analyses indicate that SpPks1 and its homologs are widespread in echinoderms and their closest relatives, the acorn worms, reinforcing their fundamental importance to echinoderm biology. While the animal microbiome is known to produce aromatic polyketides, this work provides biochemical evidence that animals themselves also harbor ancient, convergent, dedicated pathways to carbocyclic aromatic polyketides. More fundamentally, biochemical analysis of SpPks1 begins to define the vast and unexplored biosynthetic space of the ubiquitous animal PKS family.

TrBase: A genome and transcriptome database of Temnopleurus reevesii

Sea urchins have a long history as model organisms in biology, but their use in genetics is limited because of their long breeding cycle. In sea urchin genetics, genome editing technology was first established in Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus, whose genome has already been published. However, because this species also has a long breeding cycle, new model sea urchins that are more suitable for genetics have been sought. Here, we report a draft genome of another Western Pacific species, Temnopleurus reevesii, which we established as a new model sea urchin recently since this species has a comparable developmental process to other model sea urchins but a short breeding cycle of approximately half a year. The genome of T. reevesii was assembled into 28,742 scaffold sequences with an N50 length of 67.6 kb and an estimated genome size of 905.9 Mb. In the assembled genome, 27,064 genes were identified, 23,624 of which were expressed in at least one of the seven developmental stages. To provide genetic information, we constructed the genome database TrBase (https://cell-innovation.nig.ac.jp/Tree/). We also constructed the Western Pacific Sea Urchin Genome Database (WestPac-SUGDB) (https://cell-innovation.nig.ac.jp/WPAC/) with the aim of establishing a portal site for genetic information on sea urchins in the West Pacific. This site contains genomic information on two species, T. reevesii and H. pulcherrimus, and is equipped with homology search programs for comparing the two datasets. Therefore, TrBase and WestPac-SUGDB are expected to contribute not only to genetic research using sea urchins but also to comparative genomics and evolutionary research.

Temnopleurus reevesii as a new sea urchin model in genetics

Echinoderms, including sea urchins and starfish, have played important roles in cell, developmental and evolutionary biology research for more than a century. However, since most of them take a long time to mature sexually and their breeding seasons are limited, it has been difficult to obtain subsequent generations in the laboratory, resulting in them not being recognized as model organisms in recent genetics research. To overcome this issue, we maintained and obtained gametes from several nonmodel sea urchins in Japan and finally identified Temnopleurus reevesii as a suitable model for sea urchin genetics. Genomic and transcriptomic information was obtained for this model, and the DNA database TrBase was made publicly available. In this review, we describe how we found this species useful for biological research and show an example of CRISPR/Cas9 based knockout sea urchin.

Establishment of homozygous knock-out sea urchins

Yaguchi et al. establish a homozygous knock-out sea urchin line by applying the CRISPR-Cas9 system to a new model species, Temnopleurus reevesii, whose breeding cycle takes about half a year.

Chromosomal-Level Genome Assembly of the Painted Sea Urchin Lytechinus pictus: A Genetically Enabled Model System for Cell Biology and Embryonic Development

The painted urchin Lytechinus pictus is a sea urchin in the family Toxopneustidae and one of several sea urchin species that are routinely used as an experimental research organism. Recently, L. pictus has emerged as a tractable model system for establishing transgenic sea urchin lines due to its amenability to long term laboratory culture. We present the first published genome of L. pictus. This chromosomal-level assembly was generated using Illumina sequencing in conjunction with Oxford Nanopore Technologies long read sequencing and HiC chromatin conformation capture sequencing. The 998.9-Mb assembly exhibits high contiguity and has a scaffold length N50 of 46.0 Mb with 97% of the sequence assembled into 19 chromosomal-length scaffolds. These 19 scaffolds exhibit a high degree of synteny compared with the 19 chromosomes of a related species Lytechinus variegatus. Ab initio and transcript evidence gene modeling, combined with sequence homology, identified 28,631 gene models that capture 92% of BUSCO orthologs. This annotation strategy was validated by manual curation of gene models for the ABC transporter superfamily, which confirmed the completeness and accuracy of the annotations. Thus, this genome assembly, in conjunction with recent high contiguity assemblies of related species, positions L. pictus as an exceptional model system for comparative functional genomics and it will be a key resource for the developmental, toxicological, and ecological biology scientific communities.

CRISPR/Cas9 mutagenesis reveals a role for ABCB1 in gut immune responses to Vibrio diazotrophicus in sea urchin larvae

The ABC transporter ABCB1 plays an important role in the disposition of xenobiotics. Embryos of most species express high levels of this transporter in early development as a protective mechanism, but its native substrates are not known. Here, we used larvae of the sea urchin Strongylocentrotus purpuratus to characterize the early life expression and role of Sp-ABCB1a, a homolog of ABCB1. The results indicate that while Sp-ABCB1a is initially expressed ubiquitously, it becomes enriched in the developing gut. Using optimized CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing methods to achieve high editing efficiency in the F0 generation, we generated ABCB1a crispant embryos with significantly reduced transporter efflux activity. When infected with the opportunistic pathogen Vibrio diazotrophicus, Sp-ABCB1a crispant larvae demonstrated significantly stronger gut inflammation, immunocyte migration and cytokine Sp-IL-17 induction, as compared with infected control larvae. The results suggest an ancestral function of ABCB1 in host-microbial interactions, with implications for the survival of invertebrate larvae in the marine microbial environment.

Conditional gene knockdowns in sea urchins using caged morpholinos

Echinoderms are important experimental models for analyzing embryonic development, but a lack of spatial and temporal control over gene perturbations has hindered developmental studies using these animals. Morpholino antisense oligonucleotides (MOs) have been used successfully by the echinoderm research community for almost two decades, and MOs remain the most widely used tool for acute gene knockdowns in these organisms. Echinoderm embryos develop externally and are optically transparent, making them ideally-suited to many light-based approaches for analyzing and manipulating development. Studies using zebrafish embryos have demonstrated the effectiveness of photoactivatable (caged) MOs for conditional gene knockdowns. Here we show that caged MOs, synthesized using nucleobase-caged monomers, provide light-regulated control over gene expression in sea urchin embryos. Our work provides the first robust approach for conditional gene silencing in this prominent model system.

In vitro transcribed mRNA for expression of designer nucleases: Advantages as a novel therapeutic for the management of chronic HBV infection

Chronic infection with the hepatitis B virus (HBV) remains a significant worldwide medical problem. While diseases caused by HIV infection, tuberculosis and malaria are on the decline, new cases of chronic hepatitis B are on the rise. Because often fatal complications of cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma are associated with chronic hepatitis B, the need for a cure is as urgent as ever. Currently licensed therapeutics fail to eradicate the virus and this is attributable to persistence of the viral replication intermediate comprising covalently closed circular DNA (cccDNA). Elimination or inactivation of the viral cccDNA is thus a goal of research aimed at hepatitis B cure. The ability to engineer nucleases that are capable of specific cleavage of a DNA sequence now provides the means to disable cccDNA permanently. The scientific literature is replete with many examples of using designer zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs), transcription activator-like effector nucleases (TALENs) and RNA-guided endonucleases (RGENs) to inactivate HBV. However, important concerns about safety, dose control and efficient delivery need to be addressed before the technology is employed in a clinical setting. Use of in vitro transcribed mRNA to express therapeutic gene editors goes some way to overcoming these concerns. The labile nature of RNA limits off-target effects and enables dose control. Compatibility with hepatotropic non-viral vectors is convenient for the large scale preparation that will be required for advancing gene editing as a mode of curing chronic hepatitis B.

Regulation of dynamic pigment cell states at single-cell resolution

Cells bearing pigment have diverse roles and are often under strict evolutionary selection. Here, we explore the regulation of pigmented cells in the purple sea urchin Strongylocentrotus purpuratus, an emerging model for diverse pigment function. We took advantage of single cell RNA-seq (scRNAseq) technology and discovered that pigment cells in the embryo segregated into two distinct populations, a mitotic cluster and a post-mitotic cluster. Gcm is essential for expression of several genes important for pigment function, but is only transiently expressed in these cells. We discovered unique genes expressed by pigment cells and test their expression with double fluorescence in situ hybridization. These genes include new members of the fmo family that are expressed selectively in pigment cells of the embryonic and in the coelomic cells of the adult - both cell-types having immune functions. Overall, this study identifies nodes of molecular intersection ripe for change by selective evolutionary pressures.

Genetic manipulation of the pigment pathway in a sea urchin reveals distinct lineage commitment prior to metamorphosis in the bilateral to radial body plan transition

Echinoderms display a vast array of pigmentation and patterning in larval and adult life stages. This coloration is thought to be important for immune defense and camouflage. However, neither the cellular nor molecular mechanism that regulates this complex coloration in the adult is known. Here we knocked out three different genes thought to be involved in the pigmentation pathway(s) of larvae and grew the embryos to adulthood. The genes tested were polyketide synthase (PKS), Flavin-dependent monooxygenase family 3 (FMO3) and glial cells missing (GCM). We found that disabling of the PKS gene at fertilization resulted in albinism throughout all life stages and throughout all cells and tissues of this animal, including the immune cells of the coelomocytes. We also learned that FMO3 is an essential modifier of the polyketide. FMO3 activity is essential for larval pigmentation, but in juveniles and adults, loss of FMO3 activity resulted in the animal becoming pastel purple. Linking the LC-MS analysis of this modified pigment to a naturally purple animal suggested a conserved echinochrome profile yielding a pastel purple. We interpret this result as FMO3 modifies the parent polyketide to contribute to the normal brown/green color of the animal, and that in its absence, other biochemical modifications are revealed, perhaps by other members of the large FMO family in this animal. The FMO modularity revealed here may be important in the evolutionary changes between species and for different immune challenges. We also learned that glial cells missing (GCM), a key transcription factor of the endomesoderm gene regulatory network of embryos in the sea urchin, is required for pigmentation throughout the life stages of this sea urchin, but surprisingly, is not essential for larval development, metamorphosis, or maintenance of adulthood. Mosaic knockout of either PKS or GCM revealed spatial lineage commitment in the transition from bilaterality of the larva to a pentaradial body plan of the adult. The cellular lineages identified by pigment presence or absence (wild-type or knock-out lineages, respectively) followed a strict oral/aboral profile. No circumferential segments were seen and instead we observed 10-fold symmetry in the segments of pigment expression. This suggests that the adult lineage commitments in the five outgrowths of the hydropore in the larva are early, complete, fixed, and each bilaterally symmetric. Overall, these results suggest that pigmentation of this animal is genetically determined and dependent on a population of pigment stem cells that are set-aside in a sub-region of each outgrowth of the pentaradial adult rudiment prior to metamorphosis. This study reveals the complex chemistry of pigment applicable to many organisms, and further, provides an insight into the key transitions from bilateral to pentaradial body plans unique to echinoderms.

The biosynthetic diversity of the animal world

Secondary metabolites are often considered within the remit of bacterial or plant research, but animals also contain a plethora of these molecules with important functional roles. Classical feeding studies demonstrate that, whereas some are derived from diet, many of these compounds are made within the animals. In the past 15 years, the genetic and biochemical origin of several animal natural products has been traced to partnerships with symbiotic bacteria. More recently, a number of animal genome-encoded pathways to microbe-like natural products have come to light. These pathways are sometimes horizontally acquired from bacteria, but more commonly they unveil a new and diverse animal biochemistry. In this review, we highlight recent examples of characterized animal biosynthetic enzymes that reveal an unanticipated breadth and intricacy in animal secondary metabolism. The results so far suggest that there may be an immense diversity of animal small molecules and biosynthetic enzymes awaiting discovery. This biosynthetic dark matter is just beginning to be understood, providing a relatively untapped frontier for discovery.