A diagnostic HIV-1 tropism system based on sequence relatedness

Adapting the geno2pheno[coreceptor] tool to HIV-1 subtype CRF01_AE by phenotypic validation using clinical isolates from South-East Asia

OBJECTIVES

Geno2pheno[coreceptor] is a widely used tool for the prediction of coreceptor usage (viral tropism) of HIV-1 samples. For HIV-1 CRF01_AE, a significant overcalling of X4-tropism is observed when using the standard settings of Geno2pheno[coreceptor]. The aim of this study was to provide the experimental backing for adaptations to the geno2pheno[coreceptor] algorithm in order to improve coreceptor usage predictions of clinical HIV-1 CRF01_AE isolates STUDY DESIGN: V3-sequences of 20 clinical HIV-1 subtype CRF01_AE samples were sequenced and analyzed by geno2pheno[coreceptor]. In parallel, coreceptor usage was determined for these samples by replicative phenotyping in human cells in the presence of specific X4- or R5-inhibitors.

RESULTS

The sole introduction of the CRF01_AE V3 region into a full-length otherwise subtype B provirus failed to produce replication-competent viral progeny. A successive genome-replacement strategy revealed that also CRF01_AE derived gag and pol sequences are necessary to generate HIV genomes with sufficient replication competence. Subsequent phenotypic analysis confirmed overcalling of X4-tropism for CRF01_AE viruses using the current version and the standard cut-off at 10% false positive rate (FPR) of geno2pheno[coreceptor]. Lowering the FPR cut-off to 2.5% reduced the X4-overcalling in our sample collection, while still allowing a safe administration of Maraviroc (MCV).

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates the successful adjustment of geno2pheno[coreceptor] rules for subtype CRF01_AE. It also supports the unique strength of combining complementing methods, namely phenotyping and genotyping, for validating new bioinformatics tools prior to application in diagnostics.

Coreceptor Tropism and Maraviroc Sensitivity of Clonally Derived Ethiopian HIV-1C Strains Using an in-house Phenotypic Assay and Commonly Used Genotypic Methods

OBJECTIVES

Genotypic Tropism Testing (GTT) tools are generally developed based on HIV-1 subtype B (HIV-1B) and used for HIV-1C as well but with a large discordance of prediction between different methods. We used an established phenotypic assay for comparison with GTT methods and for the determination of in vitro maraviroc sensitivity of pure R5-tropic and dual-tropic HIV-1C.

METHODS

Plasma was obtained from 58 HIV-1C infected Ethiopians. Envgp120 was cloned into a luciferase tagged NL4-3 plasmid. Phenotypic tropism was determined by in house method and the V3 sequences were analysed by five GTT methods. In vitro maraviroc sensitivity of R5-tropic and dual-tropic isolates were compared in the TZMbl cell-line.

RESULTS

The phenotypes were classified as R5 in 92.4% and dual tropic (R5X4) in 7.6% of 79 clones. The concordance between phenotype and genotype ranged from 64.7% to 84.3% depending on the GTT method. Only 46.9% of the R5 phenotypes were predicted as R5 by all GTT tools while R5X4 phenotypes were predicted as X4 by four methods, but not by Raymond's method. All six tested phenotypic R5 clones, as well as five of six of dual tropic clones, showed a dose response to maraviroc.

CONCLUSION

There is a high discordance between GTT methods, which underestimates the presence of R5 and overestimates X4 strains compared to a phenotypic assay. Currently available GTT algorithms should be further improved for tropism prediction in HIV-1C. Maraviroc has an in vitro activity against most HIV-1C viruses and could be considered as an alternative regimen in individuals infected with CCR5-tropic HIV-1C viruses.

Performance Evaluation of a Genotypic Tropism Test Using HIV-1 CRF01_AE Isolates in Japan

Geno2Pheno (coreceptor), a genotypic tropism test, demonstrates excellent agreement with the phenotypic tropism test for subtype B and some other subtypes. However, potential X4-overcalling for CRF01_AE might occur with the present version. To confirm X4 overcalling for AE and to optimize the algorithm for use with AE, we compared the tropism of 22 AE samples by both genotypic and phenotypic methods. The env V3 region was analyzed by bulk sequencing, and tropism was evaluated using the Geno2Pheno algorithm. PhenXR, a phenotypic tropism test, was performed in parallel to determine chemokine receptor preferences. A high X4-overcalling for select samples and a low rate of R5-concordant samples (9.1%) were observed for AE with the current version of Geno2Pheno (coreceptor). On the other hand, the new version, namely, Geno2Pheno (Sanger), showed a high concordance rate of 81.8%, with PhenXR. Because majority of the samples were selected based on discrepancies in the genotypic tropism calls between the present version Geno2Pheno (coreceptor) (FPR<10%) and the new version Geno2Pheno (Sanger) (X4-risk<36), it remains to be determined whether the new version provides improved R5-calls for the AE sequences in general or only in this setting. Further clinical validation studies are warranted.

Unique Phenotypic Characteristics of Recently Transmitted HIV-1 Subtype C Envelope Glycoprotein gp120: Use of CXCR6 Coreceptor by Transmitted Founder Viruses

Adequate information on the precise molecular and biological composition of the viral strains that establish HIV infection in the human host will provide effective means of immunization against HIV infection. In an attempt to identify the transmitted founder (TF) virus and differentiate the biological properties and infectious potential of the TF virus from those of the population of the early transmitted viruses, 250 patient-derived gp120 envelope glycoproteins were cloned in pMN-K7-Luc-IRESs-NefΔgp120 to obtain chimeric viruses. Samples were obtained from eight infants who had recently become infected with HIV through mother-to-child transmission (MTCT) and two adults who acquired infection through the heterosexual route and were in the chronic stage of infection. Among the 250 clones tested, 65 chimeric viruses were infectious, and all belonged to HIV-1 subtype C. The 65 clones were analyzed for molecular features of the envelope, per-infectious-particle infectivity, coreceptor tropism, drug sensitivity, and sensitivity to broadly neutralizing antibodies. Based on genotypic and phenotypic analysis of the viral clones, we identified 10 TF viruses from the eight infants. The TF viruses were characterized by shorter V1V2 regions, a reduced number of potential N-linked glycosylation sites, and a higher infectivity titer compared to the virus variants from the adults in the chronic stage of infection. CXCR6 coreceptor usage, in addition to that of the CCR5 coreceptor, which was used by all 65 chimeric viruses, was identified in 13 viruses. The sensitivity of the TF variants to maraviroc and a standard panel of neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (VRC01, PG09, PG16, and PGT121) was found to be much lower than that of the virus variants from the adults in the chronic stage of infection.IMPORTANCE Tremendous progress has been made during the last three and half decades of HIV research, but some significant gaps continue to exist. One of the frontier areas of HIV research which has not seen a breakthrough yet is vaccine research, which is because of the enormous genetic diversity of HIV-1 and the unique infectious fitness of the virus. Among the repertoire of viral variants, the virus that establishes successful infection (transmitted founder [TF] virus) has not been well characterized yet. An insight into the salient features of the TF virus would go a long way toward helping with the design of an effective vaccine against HIV. Here we studied the biological properties of recently transmitted viruses isolated from infants who acquired infection from the mother and have come up with unique characterizations for the TF virus that establishes infection in the human host.

Phenotypic co-receptor tropism and Maraviroc sensitivity in HIV-1 subtype C from East Africa

Genotypic tropism testing (GTT) for co-receptor usage is a recommended tool for clinical practice before administration of the CCR5-antagonist maraviroc. For some isolates, phenotypic tropism testing (PTT) revealed discordant results with GTT. In this study, we performed a comparative study between GTT and PTT in HIV-1C from East Africa (HIV-1C_EA) and compared the data with HIV-1B and 01_AE and described the maraviroc susceptibility in the CCR5-tropic strains. Patient-derived HIV-1 envgp120 region was cloned into a modified pNL4-3 plasmid expressing the luciferase gene. rPhenotyping dissected single clones from 31 HIV-1C_EA infected patients and four strains with known phenotype. Additionally, 68 clones from 18 patients (HIV-1B: 5, 01_AE: 7, HIV-1C_EA: 6) were used to determine the PTT in GHOST cell line. The respective V3-sequences were used for GTT. R5-tropic strains from HIV-1C_EA (n = 20) and non-C (n = 12) were tested for maraviroc sensitivity in TZMbl cell line. The GTT falsely called a higher proportion of X4-tropic strains in HIV-1C_ET compared to PTT by both rPhenotyping and the GHOST-cell assay. When multiple clones were tested in a subset of patients’ samples, both dual-tropic and R5-tropic strains were identified for HIV-1C. Relatively higher EC₅₀ values were observed in HIV-1C strains than the non-C strains (p = 0.002).

Role of phenotypic investigation in the era of routine genotypic HIV-1 drug resistance testing

The emergence of drug resistance can seriously compromise HIV type-1 therapy and decrease therapeutic options. Resistance testing is highly recommended to guide treatment decisions and drug activity can be accurately predicted in the clinical setting through genotypic assays. While phenotypic systems are not suitable for monitoring drug resistance in routine laboratory practice, genotyping can misclassify unusual or complex mutational patterns, particularly with recently approved antivirals. In addition, phenotypic assays remain fundamental for characterizing candidate antiretroviral compounds. This review aims to discuss how phenotypic assays contributed to and still play a role in understanding the mechanisms of resistance of both licensed and investigational HIV type-1 inhibitors.

Correlating HIV tropism with immunological response under combination antiretroviral therapy

OBJECTIVES

A significant percentage of patients infected with HIV-1 experience only suboptimal CD4 cell recovery while treated with combination therapy (cART). It is still unclear whether viral properties such as cell tropism play a major role in this incomplete immune response. This study therefore intended to follow the tropism evolution of the HIV-1 envelope during periods of suppressive cART.

METHODS

Viruses from two distinct patient groups, one with good and another one with poor CD4 recovery after 5 years of suppressive cART, were genotypically analysed for viral tropism at baseline and at the end of the study period.

RESULTS

Patients with CCR5-tropic CC-motif chemokine receptor 5 viruses at baseline tended to maintain this tropism to the study end. Patients who had a CXCR4-tropic CXC-motif chemokine receptor 4 virus at baseline were overrepresented in the poor CD4 recovery group. Overall, however, the majority of patients presented with CCR5-tropic viruses at follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data lend support to the hypothesis that tropism determination can be used as a parameter for disease progression even if analysed long before the establishment of a poorer immune response. Moreover, the lasting predominating CCR5-tropism during periods of full viral control suggests the involvement of cellular mechanisms that preferentially reduce CXCR4-tropic viruses during cART.