Statistical and radiobiological analysis of the so-called thyroid stunning

Response to Surgery Assessments for Sparing Radioiodine Remnant Ablation in Intermediate-risk Papillary Thyroid Cancer

CONTEXT

Using response to surgery upon tailoring radioiodine (RAI) therapy for papillary thyroid cancer (PTC) is valued while lacking prospective validation.

OBJECTIVE

To spare RAI thyroid-remnant ablation among intermediate-risk PTCs by three-tiered assessments with response to surgery highlighted besides the risk of the recurrence stratification and TNM staging.

DESIGN, SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS

Patients with no evidence of disease (NED) identified as excellent response (ER) or indeterminate response (IDR) to surgery were spared from RAI thyroid-remnant ablation after informed consent and prospectively enrolled under active surveillance. Those involved in other trials or without sufficient follow-up data were excluded. Dynamic responses were followed and compared longitudinally.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

NED presenting as durable ER or IDR for over 12 months.

RESULTS

Of the enrolled 215 patients, 47.4% (102/215) ER and 52.6% (113/215) IDR were identified upon RAI decision-making. After a median of 23.6 (IQR 13.8-31.6) months, the share of ER increased to 82.8%(178/215) and IDR decreased to 16.3% (35/215), with 85 patients shifting from IDR to ER over time, only 0.5% (1/215) structural and 0.5% (1/215) biochemical incomplete response observed. Successful remnant ablation was observed in 27.7%(26/94) of the patients completing two diagnostic whole-body scannings after a median interval of 13.0 months, indicating a theranostic effect. In the 173 patients followed for over 12 months, the NED rate didn't differ between ER and IDR subgroups (100% vs. 97.9%, P = 0.20).

CONCLUSIONS

Through the three-tiered assessments with response to surgery highlighted, postoperative ER and IDR spared from RAI remnant ablation may indicate similar favorable responses in intermediate-risk PTC patients during 23.6 months follow-up.

Personalized Dosimetry in Targeted Radiation Therapy: A Look to Methods, Tools and Critical Aspects

Targeted radiation therapy (TRT) is a strategy increasingly adopted for the treatment of different types of cancer. The urge for optimization, as stated by the European Council Directive (2013/59/EURATOM), requires the implementation of a personalized dosimetric approach, similar to what already happens in external beam radiation therapy (EBRT). The purpose of this paper is to provide a thorough introduction to the field of personalized dosimetry in TRT, explaining its rationale in the context of optimization and describing the currently available methodologies. After listing the main therapies currently employed, the clinical workflow for the absorbed dose calculation is described, based on works of the most experienced authors in the literature and recent guidelines. Moreover, the widespread software packages for internal dosimetry are presented and critical aspects discussed. Overall, a selection of the most important and recent articles about this topic is provided.

Utility of outpatient fractionated radioiodine therapy for Graves disease involving a large goiter measuring more than 100 mL in volume

Contrary to large multinodular goiters, reports on ¹³¹I radioiodine therapy (RIT) for Graves disease (GD) involving a large goiter are scarce. We retrospectively reviewed a total of 71 consecutive patients (25 males, 46 females) with GD involving a large goiter (>100 mL) who had received RIT in our clinic. Patients with a history of thyroid surgery or with large thyroid nodules and those who had dropped out less than one year after the initial RIT session were excluded. A fixed ¹³¹I activity of 481 MBq was administered in most cases. RIT was repeated at intervals of 1-47 months, typically 3-6 months. The follow-up duration after the initial RIT session was 13-233 (median: 81) months. The thyroid volume was estimated using ultrasound. The number of ¹³¹I doses were 1 dose in 13 patients, 2 doses in 29, 3 doses in 17, 4 doses in 5, 5 doses in 5, 6 doses in 1, and 8 doses in 1. Sixty-six patients had remission from overt hyperthyroidism after RIT: overt hypothyroidism in 45 patients, subclinical hypothyroidism or euthyroidism in 13, and subclinical hyperthyroidism in 8. Their thyroid volume decreased from 101-481 (median: 126) mL to 1.4-37 (8.2) mL. Three patients still had overt hyperthyroidism under treatment with methimazole after one to three doses, and two dropped out less than six months after the third or sixth dose. Even in GD patients with a large goiter (>100 mL), repeated RIT with an activity of 481 MBq could sufficiently shrink goiters and remit overt hyperthyroidism.

Silicon-photomultiplier-based PET/CT reduces the minimum detectable activity of iodine-124

The radioiodine isotope pair 124I/131I is used in a theranostic approach for patient-specific treatment of differentiated thyroid cancer. Lesion detectability is notably higher for 124I PET (positron emission tomography) than for 131I gamma camera imaging but can be limited for small and low uptake lesions. The recently introduced silicon-photomultiplier-based (SiPM-based) PET/CT (computed tomography) systems outperform previous-generation systems in detector sensitivity, coincidence time resolution, and spatial resolution. Hence, SiPM-based PET/CT shows an improved detectability, particularly for small lesions. In this study, we compare the size-dependant minimum detectable 124I activity (MDA) between the SiPM-based Biograph Vision and the previous-generation Biograph mCT PET/CT systems and we attempt to predict the response to 131I radioiodine therapy of lesions additionally identified on the SiPM-based system. A tumour phantom mimicking challenging conditions (derived from published patient data) was used; i.e., 6 small spheres (diameter of 3.7-9.7 mm), 9 low activity concentrations (0.25-25 kBq/mL), and a very low signal-to-background ratio (20:1). List-mode emission data (single-bed position) were divided into frames of 4, 8, 16, and 30 min. Images were reconstructed with ordinary Poisson ordered-subsets expectation maximization (OSEM), additional time-of-flight (OSEM-TOF) or TOF and point spread function modelling (OSEM-TOF+PSF). The signal-to-noise ratio and the MDA were determined. Absorbed dose estimations were performed to assess possible treatment response to high-activity 131I radioiodine therapy. The signal-to-noise ratio and the MDA were improved from the mCT to the Vision, from OSEM to OSEM-TOF and from OSEM-TOF to OSEM-TOF+PSF reconstructed images, and from shorter to longer emission times. The overall mean MDA ratio of the Vision to the mCT was 0.52 ± 0.18. The absorbed dose estimations indicate that lesions ≥ 6.5 mm with expected response to radioiodine therapy would be detectable on both systems at 4-min emission time. Additional smaller lesions of therapeutic relevance could be detected when using a SiPM-based PET system at clinically reasonable emission times. This study demonstrates that additional lesions with predicted response to 131I radioiodine therapy can be detected. Further clinical evaluation is warranted to evaluate if negative 124I PET scans on a SiPM-based system can be sufficient to preclude patients from blind radioiodine therapy.

Dependency of the remnant 131I-NaI biokinetics on the administered activity in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer

PURPOSE

To study the dependency of the effective half-life on the administered activity and the correlation between the time-integrated activity and the remnant uptake at 2d and 7d in patients treated for DTC with 1.11 GBq, 3.7 GBq or 5.55 GBq of ¹³¹I-NaI.

METHODS

Ninety-two patients undergoing total thyroidectomy and lymph node removal were included. If cancer had not spread to lymph nodes, patients received 1.11 GBq of ¹³¹I-NaI when the lesion maximal diameter was smaller than 4 cm, and 3.7 GBq for bigger sizes. If cancer had spread to lymph nodes patients received 5.55 GBq. There were 30, 49 and 13 patients respectively treated with 1.11 GBq(Group 1), 3.7 GBq(Group 2) and 5.55 GBq(Group 3). Two SPECT/CT scans were performed at 2d and 7d after radioiodine administration for each patient to determine the thyroid remnant activities and effective half-lives of the radioiodine.

RESULTS

Statistical analysis showed significant differences (p < 0.05) in the effective half-life among patients treated with 1.11 GBq, 3.7 GBq and 5.55 GBq. A high positive correlation (ρ > 0.95) was found between the time-integrated activity and the remnant activity at 2d for the three groups of patients.

CONCLUSIONS

There were significant differences in the effective half-life of the radioiodine in remnants of patients treated with activities of 1.11 GBq, 3.7 GBq or 5.55 GBq. The high positive linear correlation found between the time-integrated activity and the remnant activity at 2d for the three groups of patients indicate that the time-integrated activity could be estimated from one time-point.

EANM position paper on the role of radiobiology in nuclear medicine

With an increasing variety of radiopharmaceuticals for diagnostic or therapeutic nuclear medicine as valuable diagnostic or treatment option, radiobiology plays an important role in supporting optimizations. This comprises particularly safety and efficacy of radionuclide therapies, specifically tailored to each patient. As absorbed dose rates and absorbed dose distributions in space and time are very different between external irradiation and systemic radionuclide exposure, distinct radiation-induced biological responses are expected in nuclear medicine, which need to be explored. This calls for a dedicated nuclear medicine radiobiology. Radiobiology findings and absorbed dose measurements will enable an improved estimation and prediction of efficacy and adverse effects. Moreover, a better understanding on the fundamental biological mechanisms underlying tumor and normal tissue responses will help to identify predictive and prognostic biomarkers as well as biomarkers for treatment follow-up. In addition, radiobiology can form the basis for the development of radiosensitizing strategies and radioprotectant agents. Thus, EANM believes that, beyond in vitro and preclinical evaluations, radiobiology will bring important added value to clinical studies and to clinical teams. Therefore, EANM strongly supports active collaboration between radiochemists, radiopharmacists, radiobiologists, medical physicists, and physicians to foster research toward precision nuclear medicine.

Radioiodine in Differentiated Thyroid Carcinoma: Do We Need Diagnostic Pre-Ablation Iodine-123 Scintigraphy to Optimize Treatment?

Changing insights regarding radioiodine (I-131) administration in differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC) stir up discussions on the utility of pre-ablation diagnostic scintigraphy (DxWBS). Our retrospective study qualitatively and semi-quantitatively assessed posttherapy I-131 whole-body scintigraphy (TxWBS) data for thyroid remnant size and metastasis. Findings were associated with initial treatment success after nine months, as well as clinical, histopathological, and surgical parameters. Possible management changes were addressed. A thyroid remnant was reported in 89 of 97 (92%) patients, suspicion of lymph node metastasis in 26 (27%) and distant metastasis in 6 (6%). Surgery with oncological intent and surgery by two dedicated thyroid surgeons were independently associated with a smaller remnant. Surgery at a community hospital, aggressive tumor histopathology, histopathological lymph node metastasis (pN1) and suspicion of new lymph node metastasis on TxWBS were independently associated with an unsuccessful treatment. Thyroid remnant size was unrelated to treatment success. All 13 pN1 patients with suspected in situ lymph node metastases on TxWBS had an unsuccessful treatment, opposite 19/31 (61%) pN1 patients without (p = 0.009). Pre-ablative knowledge of these TxWBS findings had likely influenced management in 48 (50%) patients. Additional pre-ablative diagnostics could optimize patient-tailored I-131 administration. DxWBS should be considered, especially in patients with pN1 stage or suspected in situ lymph node metastasis. Dependent on local surgical expertise, DxWBS is not recommended to evaluate thyroid remnant size.

Comparing lesion detection efficacy and image quality across different PET system generations to optimize the iodine-124 PET protocol for recurrent thyroid cancer

Background

In recurrent differentiated thyroid cancer patients, detectability in ¹²⁴I PET is limited for lesions with low radioiodine uptake. We assess the improvements in lesion detectability and image quality between three generations of PET scanners with different detector technologies. The results are used to suggest an optimized protocol.

Methods

Datasets of 10 patients with low increasing thyroglobulin or thyroglobulin antibody levels after total thyroidectomy and radioiodine therapies were included. PET data were acquired and reconstructed on a Biograph mCT PET/CT (whole-body, 4-min acquisition time per bed position; OSEM, OSEM-TOF, OSEM-TOF+PSF), a non-TOF Biograph mMR PET/MR (neck region, 4 min and 20 min; OSEM), and a new generation Biograph Vision PET/CT (whole-body, 4 min; OSEM, OSEM-TOF, OSEM-TOF+PSF). The 20-min image on the mMR was used as reference to calculate the detection efficacy in the neck region. Image quality was rated on a 5-point scale.

Results

All detected lesions were in the neck region. Detection efficacy was 8/9 (Vision OSEM-TOF and OSEM-TOF+PSF), 4/9 (Vision OSEM), 3/9 (mMR OSEM and mCT OSEM-TOF+PSF), and 2/9 (mCT OSEM and OSEM-TOF). Median image quality was 4 (Vision OSEM-TOF and OSEM-TOF+PSF), 3 (Vision OSEM, mCT OSEM-TOF+PSF, and mMR OSEM 20-min), 2 (mCT OSEM-TOF), 1.5 (mCT OSEM), and 1 (mMR OSEM 4 min).

Conclusion

At a clinical standard acquisition time of 4 min per bed position, the new generation Biograph Vision using a TOF-based image reconstruction demonstrated the highest detectability and image quality and should, if available, be preferably used for imaging of low-uptake lesions. A prolonged acquisition time for the mostly affected neck region can be useful.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s40658-021-00361-y.

Individualized dosimetry in children and young adults with differentiated thyroid cancer undergoing iodine-131 therapy

Objectives The amount of Iodine-131 to treat young patients with differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) has not been established so far. The purpose of this study was to perform and compare blood dosimetry by "Hanscheid's approach"and lesion dosimetry by "Maxon's approach". Methods Seventy-one DTC patients ≤21 years were given diagnostic activity of 74 MBq 131I followed by whole-body scan (WBS) at 2 h (pre-void), 24 h, 48 h, and ≥72 h. Pre-therapy blood and lesion dosimetry were conducted to determine the absorbed doses to blood and lesions and to predict the therapeutic activity. The administered activities were varied from 1.11-5.55 GBq of 131I depending on disease extent. Post therapy dosimetries were again performed by acquiring WBS data at 24 h, 48 h, and ≥72 h. Results In blood dosimetry, the difference between predicted therapy activity (PTA) and actual therapeutic activity (ATA) was statistically significant in remnant and lung lesions but insignificant in nodal metastases (p=0.287). In lesion dosimetry, the difference between PTA and ATA was statistically significant for lung metastasis patients; however, not significant in remnant (p=0.163) and nodal metastases (p=0.054). The difference between predicted and observed absorbed dose was insignificant in blood dosimetry whereas, significant in lesion dosimetry. Conclusions The PTA based on 0.3 Gy recommendations of Hanscheid et al. may be adequate for patients with remnant or nodal metastases but inadequate for lung metastases. Lesion dosimetry demonstrated that there is scope to decrease the 131I empiric ATA for remnant and nodal metastases; at the same time, there is scope to increase in lung metastasis patients.

Thyroid stunning in radioiodine-131 therapy of benign thyroid diseases

PURPOSE

Existence and cause of thyroid stunning was controversially discussed for decades but the underlying mechanism remains unclear. Numerous studies describe thyroid stunning in radioiodine-131 therapy (RIT) of differentiated thyroid carcinoma. However, there are no studies evaluating thyroid stunning in benign thyroid diseases caused by the radioiodine uptake test (RIUT). Therefore, the influence of pre-therapeutic tracer radiation dose on therapeutic iodine-131 uptake was evaluated retrospectively.

METHODS

A total of 914 RIT patients were included. Exclusion criteria were anti-thyroid drugs, pre- and/or intra-therapeutic effective half-lives (EHL) beyond 8.04 days and externally performed RIUT or 24 h RIUT. All patients received RIUT 1 week before RIT. Thyroid volume was estimated via ultrasound. Tracer radiation dose to the thyroid was calculated retrospectively. The dependence of changes in the pre-therapeutic to the therapeutic extrapolated-maximum-¹³¹I-uptake (EMU) from the dose in RIUT was evaluated statistically.

RESULTS

EMU in RIUT ranged from 0.10 to 0.82 (median: 0.35) and EMU in RIT ranged from 0.10 to 0.74 (median: 0.33). Averaged over the whole cohort the therapeutic EMU decreased significantly (2.3% per Gray intra-thyroidal tracer radiation dose). A disease-specific evaluation showed dose-dependent thyroid stunning from 1.2% per Gray in solitary toxic nodules (n = 327) to 21% per Gray in goiters (n = 135) which was significant for the subgroups of disseminated autonomies (n = 114), multifocal autonomies (n = 178) and goiters (p < 0.05) but not for Graves' diseases (n = 160) and solitary toxic nodules (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The presented data indicate for the first time a significant dependence of pre-therapeutic radiation dose on thyroid stunning in goiter and disseminated and multifocal autonomy. To achieve the desired intra-thyroidal radiation dose, RIT activity should be adapted depending on the dose in RIUT.

Comparing pre-therapeutic 124I and 131I uptake tests with intra-therapeutic 131I uptake in benign thyroid disorders

PURPOSE

¹²⁴I-PET/CT can be used for pre-therapeutic assessment of radioactive iodine uptake in benign thyroid disorders, however systematic comparisons with intra-therapeutic uptake are still lacking for these disorders. The goals of this study were to compare ¹²⁴I RAIU and conventional ¹³¹I RAIU tests with each other; to compare both tests with intra-therapeutic uptake (reference); and to verify the time course of radioactive iodine uptake at three time points (30, 102, and 336 h [14 days] post administration; p.a.).

METHODS

Thirteen patients with benign thyroid diseases underwent ¹³¹I RAIU test and ¹²⁴I RAIU test one after another before the intra-therapeutic ¹³¹I uptake (reference) was measured via short-range and long-range measurements. After correction for decay, relative uptake differences were calculated and subjected to the Bland-Altman method for the evaluation of levels of agreement.

RESULTS

Radioactive iodine uptake tests with ¹²⁴I-PET/CT and ¹³¹I probe did not show systematic deviations at any time point. Likewise, at 30 and 102 h p.a. there was no systematic discrepancy between pre-therapeutic and intra-therapeutic uptake levels. At 14 days p.a., however, both pre-therapeutic tests tended to overestimate the uptake compared to reference. Findings showed, for the first time with ¹²⁴I, that radioiodine therapy has some early radiobiological effects possibly limiting the accuracy of pre-therapeutic dosimetry.

CONCLUSIONS

¹²⁴I RAIU tests represent a feasible alternative to standard ¹³¹I RAIU tests. The additional benefits of ¹²⁴I-PET/CT (e.g., functional topography, inclusion of retrosternal areas, possibility to enable fusion imaging) may thus increase the scope of this technology in benign thyroid disorders.

Whole-remnant and maximum-voxel SPECT/CT dosimetry in 131 I-NaI treatments of differentiated thyroid cancer

PURPOSE

To investigate the possible differences between SPECT/CT based whole-remnant and maximum-voxel dosimetry in patients receiving radio-iodine ablation treatment of differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC).

METHODS

Eighteen DTC patients were administered 1.11 GBq of 131 I-NaI after near-total thyroidectomy and rhTSH stimulation. Two patients had two remnants, so in total dosimetry was performed for 20 sites. Three SPECT/CT scans were performed for each patient at 1, 2, and 3-7 days after administration. The activity, the remnant mass, and the maximum-voxel activity were determined from these images and from a recovery-coefficient curve derived from experimental phantom measurements. The cumulated activity was estimated using trapezoidal-exponential integration. Finally, the absorbed dose was calculated using S-values for unit-density spheres in whole-remnant dosimetry and S-values for voxels in maximum-voxel dosimetry.

RESULTS

The mean absorbed dose obtained from whole-remnant dosimetry was 40 Gy (range 2-176 Gy) and from maximum-voxel dosimetry 34 Gy (range 2-145 Gy). For any given patient, the activity concentrations for each of the three time-points were approximately the same for the two methods. The effective half-lives varied (R = 0.865), mainly due to discrepancies in estimation of the longer effective half-lives. On average, absorbed doses obtained from whole-remnant dosimetry were 1.2 ± 0.2 (1 SD) higher than for maximum-voxel dosimetry, mainly due to differences in theS-values. The method-related differences were however small in comparison to the wide range of absorbed doses obtained in patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Simple and consistent procedures for SPECT/CT based whole-volume and maximum-voxel dosimetry have been described, both based on experimentally determined recovery coefficients. Generally the results from the two approaches are consistent, although there is a small, systematic difference in the absorbed dose due to differences in the S-values, and some variability due to differences in the estimated effective half-lives, especially when the effective half-life is long. Irrespective of the method used, the patient absorbed doses obtained span over two orders of magnitude.