How will next generation sequencing (NGS) improve the diagnosis of congenital hemolytic anemia?

Current Status of Molecular Diagnosis of Hereditary Hemolytic Anemia in Korea

Hereditary hemolytic anemia (HHA) is considered a group of rare hematological diseases in Korea, primarily because of its unique ethnic characteristics and diagnostic challenges. Recently, the prevalence of HHA has increased in Korea, reflecting the increasing number of international marriages and increased awareness of the disease. In particular, the diagnosis of red blood cell (RBC) enzymopathy experienced a resurgence, given the advances in diagnostic techniques. In 2007, the RBC Disorder Working Party of the Korean Society of Hematology developed the Korean Standard Operating Procedure for the Diagnosis of Hereditary Hemolytic Anemia, which has been continuously updated since then. The latest Korean clinical practice guidelines for diagnosing HHA recommends performing next-generation sequencing as a preliminary step before analyzing RBC membrane proteins and enzymes. Recent breakthroughs in molecular genetic testing methods, particularly next-generation sequencing, are proving critical in identifying and providing insight into cases of HHA with previously unknown diagnoses. These innovative molecular genetic testing methods have now become important tools for the management and care planning of patients with HHA. This review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of recent advances in molecular genetic testing for the diagnosis of HHA, with particular emphasis on the Korean context.

Identification of the molecular etiology in rare congenital hemolytic anemias using next-generation sequencing with exome-based copy number variant analysis

OBJECTIVES

In congenital hemolytic anemias (CHA), it is not always possible to determine the specific diagnosis by evaluating clinical findings and conventional laboratory tests. The aim of this study is to evaluate the utility of next-generation sequencing (NGS) and clinical-exome-based copy number variant (CNV) analysis in patients with CHA.

METHODS

One hundred and forty-three CHA cases from 115 unrelated families referred for molecular analysis were enrolled in the study. Molecular analysis was performed using two different clinical exome panels in 130 patients, and whole-exome sequencing in nine patients. Exome-based CNV calling was incorporated into the traditional single-nucleotide variant and small insertion/deletion analysis pipeline for NGS data in 92 cases. In four patients from the same family, the PK Gypsy variant was investigated using long-range polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

Molecular diagnosis was established in 86% of the study group. The most frequently mutated genes were SPTB (31.7%) and PKLR (28.5%). CNV analysis of 92 cases revealed that three patients had different sizes of large deletions in the SPTB and six patients had a deletion in the PKLR.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, NGS provided a high molecular diagnostic rate in cases with rare CHA. Analysis of the CNVs contributed to the diagnostic success.

Hereditary Spherocytosis: Can Next-Generation Sequencing of the Five Most Frequently Affected Genes Replace Time-Consuming Functional Investigations?

Congenital defects of the erythrocyte membrane are common in northern Europe and all over the world. The resulting diseases, for example, hereditary spherocytosis (HS), are often underdiagnosed, partly due to their sometimes mild and asymptomatic courses. In addition to a broad clinical spectrum, this is also due to the occasionally complex diagnostics that are not available to every patient. To test whether next-generation sequencing (NGS) could replace time-consuming spherocytosis-specific functional tests, 22 consecutive patients with suspected red cell membranopathy underwent functional blood tests. We were able to identify the causative genetic defect in all patients with suspected HS who underwent genetic testing (n = 17). The sensitivity of the NGS approach, which tests five genes (ANK1 (gene product: ankyrin1), EPB42 (erythrocyte membrane protein band4.2), SLC4A1 (band3), SPTA1 (α-spectrin), and SPTB (β-spectrin)), was 100% (95% confidence interval: 81.5-100.0%). The major advantage of genetic testing in the paediatric setting is the small amount of blood required (<200 µL), and compared to functional assays, sample stability is not an issue. The combination of medical history, basic laboratory parameters, and an NGS panel with five genes is sufficient for diagnosis in most cases. Only in rare cases, a more comprehensive functional screening is required.

A stepwise diagnostic approach for undiagnosed Anemia in children: A model for low-middle income country

BACKGROUND

Reaching a precise diagnosis in rare inherited anemia is extremely difficult and challenging, especially in areas with limited use of genetic studies, which makes undiagnosed anemia a unique clinical entity in tertiary hematology centers. In this study, we aim at plotting a stepwise diagnostic approach in children with undiagnosed anemia while identifying indications for genetic testing.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A one-year cross-sectional study involved 44 children and adolescents with undiagnosed anemia after undergoing an initial routine panel of investigations. They were classified based on mean corpuscular volume (MCV) into 3 groups: microcytic (n = 19), normocytic (n = 14) and macrocytic (n = 11). An algorithm that included four levels of investigations was devised for each category.

RESULTS

After applying a systematic diagnostic approach, 33 patients (75 %) were diagnosed of whom 7 (15 %) had combined diagnoses, while 11 (25 %) patients remained undiagnosed. Based on the first, second, third and fourth levels of investigations, patients were diagnosed, respectively, as follows: of the 11 patients, 7 were microcytic, 3 normocytic and 1 macrocytic; of the 7 patients, 2 were microcytic, 2 normocytic, and 3 macrocytic; of 10 patients, 5 were microcytic, 4 normocytic and 1 macrocytic; finally, of the 16 patients, 8 were microcytic, 6 normocytic and 2 macrocytic. Numbers recorded appear higher than the actual number of the patients because some of them were diagnosed by more than one level of investigation. The diagnoses obtained in the microcytic group showed hemoglobinopathies, iron refractory iron deficiency anemia (IRIDA), membrane defects, sideroblastic anemia, hypo-transferrinemia, a combined diagnosis of sickle cell trait and pyropoikilocytosis. The diagnoses also showed a combined diagnosis of hereditary spherocytosis (HS) and alpha thalassemia minor, and a combined diagnosis of iron deficiency anemia and beta thalassemia minor, while 15 % remained undiagnosed. In the normocytic group, the diagnosis revealed autosomal recessive (AR) HS, vitamin B12 deficiency, pyruvate kinase deficiency (PKD), congenital dyserythropoietic anemia (CDA) type I, Diamond Blackfan anemia and beta thalassemia major. In addition, it showed a combined diagnosis of AR HS and CDA type II, a combined diagnosis of AR HS and PKD, and a combined diagnosis of dehydrated stomatocytosis (DHS) and G6PD carrier, meanwhile 20 % remained undiagnosed. Finally, the macrocytic group was diagnosed by vitamin B12 deficiency, sideroblastic anemia, PKD, a combined diagnosis of PKD and G6PD deficiency carrier, while 45 % remained undiagnosed.

CONCLUSION

Conducting a stepwise approach with different levels of investigations may help reach the diagnosis of difficult anemia without having to resort to unnecessary investigations. Combined diagnosis is an important cause of undiagnosed anemia, especially in countries with high frequency of consanguinity. The remaining 25 % of the patients continued to be undiagnosed, requiring more sophisticated investigations.

Molecular diagnosis of hereditary hemolytic anemias: Recent updates

Hereditary hemolytic anemia (HHA) is a heterogeneous group of disorders due to genetically caused defects in red blood cell membrane structure, enzymes, heme and globin synthesis, erythroid proliferation, and differentiation. Traditionally, the diagnostic process is complex and includes a plethora of tests from routine to highly specialized ones. The inclusion of molecular testing has significantly improved the diagnostic yield. The value of molecular testing is broader than just rendering the correct diagnosis, as it may also guide therapeutic decisions. As more molecular modalities become available for clinical use, it is imperative to understand their benefits and disadvantages pertaining to the HHA diagnostics. Re-evaluation of the traditional diagnostic workflow may also bring forth additional benefits. This review focuses on the current state of molecular testing for HHA.

Clinical utility of targeted next-generation sequencing panel in routine diagnosis of hereditary hemolytic anemia: A national reference laboratory experience

INTRODUCTION

Hereditary hemolytic anemias (HHA) comprise a heterogeneous group of disorders resulting from defective red blood cell (RBC) cytoskeleton, RBC enzyme deficiencies, and hemoglobin (Hb) synthesis disorders such as thalassemia or sideroblastic anemia.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Our hemolytic anemia diagnostic next-generation sequencing (NGS) panel includes 28 genes encoding RBC cytoskeletal proteins, membrane transporter, RBC enzymes, and certain bilirubin metabolism genes. The panel covers the complete coding region of these genes, splice junctions, and, wherever appropriate, deep intronic or regulatory regions are also included. Four hundred fifty-six patients with unexplained hemolytic anemia were evaluated using our NGS panel between 2015 and 2019.

RESULTS

We identified pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants in 111/456 (24%) patients that were responsible for the disease phenotype (e.g., moderate to severe hemolytic anemia and hyperbilirubinemia). Approximately 40% of the mutations were novel. As expected, 45/456 (10%) patients were homozygous for the promoter polymorphism in the UGT1A1 gene, A(TA)₇ TAA (UGT1A1*28). 8/45 homozygous UGT1A1*28 cases were associated with additional pathogenic mutations causing hemolytic anemia, likely exacerbating hyperbilirubinemia. The most common mutated genes were membrane cytoskeleton genes SPTA1, and SPTB, followed by PKLR. Complex interactions between SPTA1 low expression alleles, alpha-LELY and alpha-LEPRA alleles, and intragenic SPTA1 variants were associated with hereditary pyropoikilocytosis and autosomal recessive hereditary spherocytosis in 23/111 patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrate that hemolytic anemia is underscored by complex molecular interactions of previously known and novel mutations in RBC cytoskeleton/enzyme genes, and therefore, NGS should be considered in all patients with clinically unexplained hemolytic anemia and in neonates with hyperbilirubinemia. Moreover, low expression alleles alpha-LELY and alpha-LEPRA should be included in all targeted HHA panels.

Effect of primary lesions in cytoskeleton proteins on red cell membrane stability in patients with hereditary spherocytosis

We investigated by targeted next generation sequencing the genetic bases of hereditary spherocytosis in 25 patients and compared the molecular results with the biochemical lesion of RBC membrane obtained by SDS-PAGE analysis. The HS diagnosis was based on available guidelines for diagnosis of congenital hemolytic anemia, and patients were selected because of atypical clinical presentation or intra-family variability, or because presented discrepancies between laboratory investigation and biochemical findings. In all patients but 5 we identified pathogenic variants in SPTA1, SPTB, ANK1, SLC4A1, EPB42 genes able to justify the clinical phenotype. Interestingly, a correspondence between the biochemical lesion and the molecular defect was identified in only 11/25 cases, mostly with band 3 deficiency due to SLC4A1 mutations. Most of the mutations in SPTB and ANK1 gene didn’t hesitate in abnormalities of RBC membrane protein; conversely, in two cases the molecular lesion didn’t correspond to the biochemical defect, suggesting that a mutation in a specific cytoskeleton protein may result in a more complex RBC membrane damage or suffering. Finally, in two cases the HS diagnosis was maintained despite absence of both protein defect and molecular lesion, basing on clinical and family history, and on presence of clear laboratory markers of HS. The study revealed complex relationships between the primary molecular lesion and the final effect in the RBC membrane cytoskeleton, and further underlines the concept that there is not a unique approach to the diagnosis of HS.

Recommendations for diagnosis and treatment of methemoglobinemia

Methemoglobinemia is a rare disorder associated with oxidization of divalent ferro‐iron of hemoglobin (Hb) to ferri‐iron of methemoglobin (MetHb). Methemoglobinemia can result from either inherited or acquired processes. Acquired forms are the most common, mainly due to the exposure to substances that cause oxidation of the Hb both directly or indirectly. Inherited forms are due either to autosomal recessive variants in the CYB5R3 gene or to autosomal dominant variants in the globin genes, collectively known as HbM disease. Our recommendations are based on a systematic literature search. A series of questions regarding the key signs and symptoms, the methods for diagnosis, the clinical management in neonatal/childhood/adulthood period, and the therapeutic approach of methemoglobinemia were formulated and the relative recommendations were produced. An agreement was obtained using a Delphi‐like approach and the experts panel reached a final consensus >75% of agreement for all the questions.

Facilitating EMA binding test performance using fluorescent beads combined with next‐generation sequencing

The eosin‐5′‐maleimide (EMA) binding test is widely used as diagnostic test for hereditary spherocytosis (HS), one of the most common haemolytic disorders in Caucasian populations. We recently described the advantages of replacing the use of healthy control blood samples with fluorescent beads in a modified EMA binding assay. In this study we further explore this novel approach. We performed targeted next‐generation sequencing, modified EMA binding test and osmotic gradient ektacytometry on consecutive individuals referred to our laboratory on the suspicion of HS. In total, 33 of 95 carried a (likely) pathogenic variant, and 24 had variants of uncertain significance (VUS). We identified a total 79 different (likely) pathogenic variants and VUS, including 43 novel mutations. Discarding VUS and recessive mutations in STPA1, we used the occurrence of (likely) pathogenic variants to generate a diagnostic threshold for our modified EMA binding test. Twenty‐one of 23 individuals with non‐SPTA1 (likely) pathogenic variants had EMA ≥ 43.6 AU, which was the optimal threshold in receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis. Accuracy was excellent at 93.4% and close to that of osmotic gradient ektacytometry (98.7%). In conclusion, we were able to simplify the EMA‐binding test by using rainbow beads as reference and (likely) pathogenic variants to define an accurate cut‐off value.

Confounding factors in the diagnosis and clinical course of rare congenital hemolytic anemias

Congenital hemolytic anemias (CHAs) comprise defects of the erythrocyte membrane proteins and of red blood cell enzymes metabolism, along with alterations of erythropoiesis. These rare and heterogeneous conditions may generate several difficulties from the diagnostic point of view. Membrane defects include hereditary spherocytosis and elliptocytosis, and the group of hereditary stomatocytosis; glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase and pyruvate kinase, are the most common enzyme deficiencies. Among ultra-rare forms, it is worth reminding other enzyme defects (glucosephosphate isomerase, phosphofructokinase, adenylate kinase, triosephosphate isomerase, phosphoglycerate kinase, hexokinase, and pyrimidine 5′-nucleotidase), and congenital dyserythropoietic anemias. Family history, clinical findings (anemia, hemolysis, splenomegaly, gallstones, and iron overload), red cells morphology, and biochemical tests are well recognized diagnostic tools. Molecular findings are increasingly used, particularly in recessive and de novo cases, and may be fundamental in unraveling the diagnosis. Notably, several confounders may further challenge the diagnostic workup, including concomitant blood loss, nutrients deficiency, alterations of hemolytic markers due to other causes (alloimmunization, infectious agents, rare metabolic disorders), coexistence of other hemolytic disorders (autoimmune hemolytic anemia, paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria, etc.). Additional factors to be considered are the possible association with bone marrow, renal or hepatic diseases, other causes of iron overload (hereditary hemochromatosis, hemoglobinopathies, metabolic diseases), and the presence of extra-hematological signs/symptoms. In this review we provide some instructive clinical vignettes that highlight the difficulties and confounders encountered in the diagnosis and clinical management of CHAs.

Targeted Next Generation Sequencing and Diagnosis of Congenital Hemolytic Anemias: A Three Years Experience Monocentric Study

Congenital hemolytic anemias (CHAs) are heterogeneous and rare disorders caused by alterations in structure, membrane transport, metabolism, or red blood cell production. The pathophysiology of these diseases, in particular the rarest, is often poorly understood, and easy-to-apply tools for diagnosis, clinical management, and patient stratification are still lacking. We report the 3-years monocentric experience with a 43 genes targeted Next Generation Sequencing (t-NGS) panel in diagnosis of CHAs; 122 patients from 105 unrelated families were investigated and the results compared with conventional laboratory pathway. Patients were divided in two groups: 1) cases diagnosed with hematologic investigations to be confirmed at molecular level, and 2) patients with unexplained anemia after extensive hematologic investigation. The overall sensitivity of t-NGS was 74 and 35% for families of groups 1 and 2, respectively. Inside this cohort of patients we identified 26 new pathogenic variants confirmed by functional evidence. The implementation of laboratory work-up with t-NGS increased the number of diagnoses in cases with unexplained anemia; cytoskeleton defects are well detected by conventional tools, deserving t-NGS to atypical cases; the diagnosis of Gardos channelopathy, some enzyme deficiencies, familial siterosterolemia, X-linked defects in females and other rare and ultra-rare diseases definitely benefits of t-NGS approaches.

Characterization of hereditary red blood cell membranopathies using combined targeted next-generation sequencing and osmotic gradient ektacytometry

Hereditary red blood cell (RBC) membranopathies are characterized by mutations in genes encoding skeletal proteins that alter the membrane complex structure. Hereditary spherocytosis (HS) is the most common inherited RBC membranopathy leading to hereditary hemolytic anemia with a worldwide distribution and an estimated prevalence, in Europe, of about 1:2000 individuals. The recent availability of targeted next generation sequencing (t-NGS) and its combination with RBC deformability measured with a laser-assisted optical rotational ektacytometer (LoRRca) has demonstrated to be the most powerful contribution to lower the percentage of hereditary hemolytic anemia undiagnosed cases. In order to know the kind and frequency of RBC membrane mutations in our geographical area (Catalonia) and to better understand their pathophysiology, 42 unrelated, non-transfusion-dependent (NTD) patients with hereditary hemolytic anemia have been studied by combining t-NGS and LoRRca. The osmoscan module of LoRRca provides three rheological profiles that reflect the maximal deformability (EImax), osmotic fragility (Omin), and hydration state (Ohyper) of RBCs and contribute to a better understanding of the contribution RBC rheology to the severity of anemia. From the 42 patients studied, 37 were suspected to be a RBC membrane defect due to phenotypic characteristics and abnormal RBC morphology and, from these, in 31 patients (83.8% of cases) the mutation was identified by t-NGS. No definite diagnosis was achieved in 11 patients (26.2% of cases), including 6 out of 37 cases, with suspected membranopathy, and 5 with unclassifiable HHA. In all these undiagnosed patients, the existence of hemoglobinopathy and/or enzymopathy was ruled out by conventional methods.