The prognosis of threatened abortion

Characteristics of vaginal bleeding during pregnancy

OBJECTIVE

To describe vaginal bleeding and associated pain in pregnancies terminated by childbirth.

DESIGN

A descriptive study based on information obtained by questionnaires administered during pregnancy.

SETTING

Antenatal care clinic at the Obstetrical Department, Aarhus University Hospital, Denmark.

SUBJECTS

Women (n = 8714) with singleton pregnancies attending routine antenatal care at the Department during a 2-year period from 1989 to 1991. Three questionnaires were administered during pregnancy and 5868 (67%) women completed all questionnaires.

MAIN MEASURES

Bleeding was characterized by frequency, gestational age at first occurrence, duration, and amount. Hemorrhage associated with abdominal pain and hospitalization was also described.

RESULTS

The overall frequency of bleeding was 19% (n = 1091). The median week of first occurrence was 8 gestational weeks. The median duration of bleeding was 2 days, and the median number of episodes was one. An association between the amount and duration of bleeding was found. Two thirds of the women had no abdominal pain associated with bleeding. Women with pain experienced heavier bleeding and bled for more days than women without pain. Bleeding resulted in hospitalization in one out of five women. In particular, women with second trimester bleeding, with heavy bleeding, long duration, and associated pain were hospitalized.

CONCLUSION

By the use of self-administered questionnaires a higher frequency of bleeding was found than in previous studies in which information has been based on medical records. Thus, the source of information in studies of pregnancy and bleeding-associated pregnancy complications must be carefully considered and described.

Vaginal bleeding and adverse reproductive outcomes: a meta-analysis

The objective of this paper is to characterise and quantify the association between vaginal bleeding and pregnancy outcome. A meta-analysis was performed in order to quantify the risk of adverse reproductive outcome by combining evidence from all previous studies of vaginal bleeding. The reproductive endpoints considered were low birthweight, preterm birth, stillbirth, perinatal death and congenital malformation. The meta-analysis confirms an association of vaginal bleeding with adverse pregnancy outcomes, but identified discrepancies in the reported risks of vaginal bleeding and magnitudes of association between bleeding and adverse reproductive outcomes, observed across studies. These discrepancies may be attributed to inconsistent definitions of the timing and severity of vaginal bleeding. The implications of such inconsistencies are discussed, suggesting a need for more standardised definitions of vaginal bleeding and reproductive endpoints in future studies.

Perinatal outcome of pregnancies complicated by vaginal bleeding

OBJECTIVE

To examine the effect of first and/or second trimester vaginal bleeding on pregnancy outcome.

DESIGN

A prospective one-year birth cohort.

SETTING

Two northernmost administrative districts of Finland.

PATIENTS

8718 singleton pregnancies, of whom 807 (9.3%) reported bleeding during the first (601) and/or second trimester (206); light bleeding in 595 cases and heavy bleeding in 212. The remaining 7911 women served as a reference group.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Low birth weight rate (LBW), preterm birth rate, congenital malformations and perinatal mortality rate.

RESULTS

Bleeding was most frequent in women of more advanced age (> or = 35 years old), with previous miscarriages, with infertility problems or using an IUCD prior to the pregnancy. Parity, smoking and social status were not associated with bleeding. Caesarean section rate and placental complications during the third trimester and at delivery were more common among the bleeders than in the reference group. The LBW rate was three-fold among the bleeders and the preterm birth rate two-fold. The risk (OR) of a LBW infant among second trimester bleeders was 4.1 (95% CI 2.6-6.4), that of preterm birth 2.9 (95% CI 1.9-4.6), and that of congenital malformations 2.9 (95% CI 1.7-4.7). No association existed between bleeding and perinatal mortality.

CONCLUSIONS

Bleeding during the second trimester indicates a poor pregnancy outcome and an increased risk of LBW, and preterm birth and/or congenital malformation.

First-trimester vaginal bleeding and the loss of chromosomally normal and abnormal conceptions

The frequency of first-trimester vaginal bleeding among 670 women with chromosomally normal fetal losses and 219 women with chromosomally abnormal losses was compared with that among 3089 women delivered at term. Vaginal bleeding early in gestation was predictive of pregnancy outcome in that moderate or heavy bleeding was associated with a fourfold risk of the loss of either chromosomally normal or abnormal conceptions. Spotting or slight bleeding was associated with a 2.7-fold risk of the loss of a chromosomally normal conception but was not associated with the loss of chromosomally abnormal conceptions when all abnormalities were categorized together.

Reported management of threatened miscarriage by general practitioners in Wessex

Questionnaires were sent to all 1432 general practitioners in the Wessex region to obtain information about their current management of bleeding in early pregnancy. A total of 1290 (90%) returned completed questionnaires. These showed widely varying views about the prognostic importance of particular symptoms and physical signs and about elements of management. Although 96% of the respondents prescribed bed rest more or less routinely for heavy bleeding in early pregnancy, only 17% felt it was mandatory, and 32% admitted that they did not believe it affected the outcome. Of the 13% of respondents who prescribed progestogens for threatened miscarriage, most did so on the advice of their local obstetrician. Seventeen per cent of the doctors always admitted women with apparently complete miscarriages to hospital. Twenty nine per cent of the respondents never gave anti-D immunoglobulin to rhesus negative women after a complete miscarriage. Bleeding in early pregnancy is a common problem and more research is required to improve management, particularly the assessment of fetal viability.

Abnormal vaginal bleeding in adolescents

The evaluation and management of abnormal vaginal bleeding should be tailored to the individual case. Pediatricians caring for adolescents need to be skilled in the evaluation and management of this common adolescent problem. Physicians who do not feel comfortable with their skills in the performance of a pelvic exam should obtain consultation from an adolescent specialist or a gynecologist who has experience with adolescents.

Cardiac malformations in spontaneous abortions

A detailed examination of 247 spontaneously aborted foetuses, under the age of 24 weeks gestation, showed 38 instances of cardiac malformation (15.4%). Very early specimens were not included. There was a bimodal relationship with maternal age and parity and a higher incidence in summer conceptions, but there was no apparent association with maternal blood groups. There were more male foetuses and they had proportionately more malformed hearts than the females. There was a marked inverse relationship with foetal age; in early foetuses, less than 25 mm, cardiac malformations were present in 68%. A wide variety of morphological abnormalities was encountered; these are listed. No cardiac malformations occurred in 72 threatened abortions which went to full-term delivery.

Evaluation of threatened abortion by human chorionic gonadotropin levels and ultrasonography

To determine the prognostic value of human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) concentrations in maternal plasma and urine, we studied 104 women with threatened abortion (cases) and 108 women with normal pregnancies and normal serum levels of HCG (controls). Of the 104 cases, 48 were also examined ultrasonically. We concluded that measurements of serum levels of HCG are of more accurate prognostic value than those of urine levels. Low serum levels of HCG indicate a poor prognosis for the pregnancy, as do steady decreases, in repeated measurements, of initially high HCG level. The combination of normal serum levels of HCG and signs of fetal life during ultrasonic examination indicates a very good prognosis for the pregnancy.

Corpus luteum dysfunction: serum progesterone levels in diagnosis and assessment of therapy for recurrent and threatened abortion

These studies were designed to show that properly timed measurements of serum progesterone (P) can be conveniently used in the diagnosis and treatment of patients with recurrent and threatened abortion. Luteal phase serum P levels between 2 and 10 ng/ml and serum P levels below 15 ng/ml in the first 10 weeks of gestation were considered diagnostic of corpus luteum (CL) dysfunction. Patients were treated with clomiphene, gonadotropins, and/or progesterone suppositories in order to correct serum P levels, thus elevating the serum P into the normal range. When treatment of patients with subnormal P levels resulted in normalization of serum P, successful pregnancies occurred. CL dysfunctions, either before or after conception, were found in eight of the nine patients with histories of recurrent spontaneous abortions. Correction of serum P was associated with successful pregnancy in these eight patients. Twelve patients with threatened abortion were also found to have subnormal serum P levels. Progesterone suppositories corrected the serum P levels in nine of the eleven patients treated, and none of these patients aborted. Serum P measurements provide a means for evaluation of CL function during early gestation. Management of patients with CL dysfunction can also be monitored with serial serum P measurements, provided that progesterone is the therapeutic agent rather than synthetic progestins.

Plasma HCG levels in patients with bleeding in the first and second trimesters of pregnancy

The prognostic value of maternal plasma human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) determinations, measured by a specific beta-subunit radioimmunoassay, was studied in 188 patients with bleeding between 6 and 20 weeks gestation. The patients were arranged into different subgroups according to ultrasound findings as well as clinical and histopathological evidence. In threatened abortion with successful outcome (50 per cent of all patients studied), the weekly mean hCG values were normal or even slightly elevated. In patients with a blighted ovum, the first hCG level measured was in the normal range in 34 per cent of the patients. In patients who aborted embryo with former life signs hCG values were generally normal before the abortion. The hCG levels were usually low in patients with incomplete abortion and ectopic pregnancy. An initially subnormal level of hCG was associated with a poor outcome of pregnancy in 92 per cent of patients. If the first hCG level was within the normal range the outcome of pregnancy was favourable in 79 per cent of patients.