Quantifying the Importance of Abiotic and Biotic Factors Governing the Succession of Gut Microbiota Over Shrimp Ontogeny

The assembly of gut microbiota implicates shrimp acute hepatopancreas necrosis disease progression

Ample evidence shows dysbiosis in the gut microbiota when comparing healthy shrimp with those affected by severe acute hepatopancreatic necrosis disease (AHPND). However, the static comparison used in available studies leads to the uncertainties regarding how and to what extent the gut microbiota responds to the progressive severity of AHPND. In addition, shrimp AHPND is featured by rapid and massive mortality, thus the initiation of AHPND must be diagnosed for preemptive therapy. For these reasons, we explored the ecological assembly of gut microbiota over shrimp AHPND progression. Increasing AHPND severity was associated with linear increase in the copies of pirAB genes, relative abundance of gut Vibrio and potentially pathogenic, and reduction in the gut bacterial diversity, stability, and relative abundance of Bdellovibrio. Negative and significant association between gut Vibrio and Bdellovibrio were noted, indicating that compromised predation exerts a role in AHPND progression. Notably, the extents of departure to the healthy shrimp gut microbiota were positively coupled with the increasing severity of AHPND. After controlling the temporal variation in the gut microbiota as healthy shrimp age, we constructed a diagnosis model that accurately diagnosed the initial, progressed or moribund stages of AHPND, with an overall accuracy of 86.5%. Shrimp AHPND induced more stochastic gut microbiotas as a consequence of the attenuated ability of diseased shrimp to select their commensals, resulting in convergent bacterial communities between gut and rearing water over AHPND progression. Collectively, our findings provide important step toward the ecological assembly of gut microbiota implicating in AHPND etiology and in diagnosing AHPND stages. KEY POINTS: • The departure of shrimp gut microbiota positively linked with AHPND severity. • The diagnosis model accurately diagnosed the stages of AHPND. • Shrimp AHPND induced more stochastic gut microbiota.

In silico prediction of potential indigenous microbial biomarkers in Penaeus vannamei identified through meta-analysis and genome-scale metabolic modelling

BACKGROUND

Understanding the microbiome is crucial as it contributes to the metabolic health of the host and, upon dysbiosis, may influence disease development. With the recent surge in high-throughput sequencing technology, the availability of microbial genomic data has increased dramatically. Amplicon sequence-based analyses majorly profile microbial abundance and determine taxonomic markers. Furthermore, the availability of genome sequences for various microbial organisms has prompted the integration of genome-scale metabolic modelling that provides insights into the metabolic interactions influencing host health. However, the analysis from a single study may not be consistent, necessitating a meta-analysis.

RESULTS

We conducted a meta-analysis and integrated with constraint-based metabolic modelling approach, focusing on the microbiome of pacific white shrimp Penaeus vannamei, an extensively cultured marine candidate species. Meta-analysis revealed that Acinetobacter and Alteromonas are significant indicators of "health" and "disease" specific taxonomic biomarkers, respectively. Further, we enumerated metabolic interactions among the taxonomic biomarkers by applying a constraint-based approach to the community metabolic models (4416 pairs). Under different nutrient environments, a constraint-based flux simulation identified five beneficial species: Acinetobacter spWCHA55, Acinetobacter tandoii SE63, Bifidobacterium pseudolongum 49 D6, Brevundimonas pondensis LVF1, and Lutibacter profundi LP1 mediating parasitic interactions majorly under sucrose environment in the pairwise community. The study also reports the healthy biomarkers that can co-exist and have functionally dependent relationships to maintain a healthy state in the host.

CONCLUSIONS

Toward this, we collected and re-analysed the amplicon sequence data of P. vannamei (encompassing 117 healthy and 142 disease datasets). By capturing the taxonomic biomarkers and modelling the metabolic interaction between them, our study provides a valuable resource, a first-of-its-kind analysis in aquaculture scenario toward a sustainable shrimp farming.

A meta-analysis study of the robustness and universality of gut microbiota-shrimp diseases relationship

Intensive case study has shown dysbiosis in the gut microbiota-shrimp disease relationship, however, variability in experimental design and the diversity of diseases arise the question whether some gut indicators are robust and universal in response to shrimp health status, irrespective of causal agents. Through an unbiased subject-level meta-analysis framework, we re-analyzed 10 studies including 261 samples, 4 lifestages, 6 different diseases (the causal agents are virus, bacterial, eukaryotic pathogens, or unknown). Results showed that shrimp diseases reproducibly altered the structure of gut bacterial community, but not diversity. After ruling out the lifestage- and disease specific- discriminatory taxa (different diseases dependent indicators), we identify 18 common disease-discriminatory taxa (indicative of health status, irrespective of causal agents) that accurately diagnosed (90.0% accuracy) shrimp health status, regardless of different diseases. These optimizations substantially improved the performance (62.6% vs. 90.0%) diagnosing model. The robustness and universality of model was validated for effectiveness via leave-one-dataset-out validation and independent cohorts. Interspecies interaction and stability of the gut microbiotas were consistently compromised in diseased shrimp compared with corresponding healthy cohorts, while stochasticity and beta-dispersion exhibited the opposite trend. Collectively, our findings exemplify the utility of microbiome meta-analyses in identifying robust and reproducible features for quantitatively diagnosing disease incidence, and the downstream consequences for shrimp pathogenesis from an ecological prospective. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Shrimp AHPND Causing Vibrio anguillarum Infection: Quantitative Diagnosis and Identifying Antagonistic Bacteria

Acute hepatopancreatic necrosis disease (AHPND) is one of the most common and serious diseases in shrimp aquaculture. Relevant works have focused on the gut microbiota-disease relationship when serious AHPND occurs. In contrast, little is known about how the gut microbiota responds to pathogen infection over AHPND progression, whereas this knowledge is fundamental to uncover the etiology of AHPND. Here, we explored the temporal succession of shrimp gut microbiota during Vibrio anguillarum (a causal pathogen of AHPND) challenge. The successful infection of V. anguillarum was confirmed by linearly increased abundance of the pathogen in the shrimp gut over AHPND progression. V. anguillarum infection caused an irreversible disruption in the shrimp gut microbiota, of which infection and hours post infection (hpi) respectively constrained 6.2% and 10.2% of variation in the data. Furthermore, the predicted functional pathways involved in immunity and metabolism significantly decreased, while those facilitating infectious diseases significantly enriched in the infected shrimp. Intriguingly, after ruling out the effect of background changes in gut microbiota, we identified 20 infection-discriminatory taxa that could be served as independent variables for accurately (89.4%) diagnosing V. anguillarum infection, even at the early infection stage, i.e., 24 hpi. Using a consensus network, we identified several Vibrio and Pseudoalteromonas taxa that directly antagonized V. anguillarum, following the Darwin's niche theory. This is one of the few attempts to identify gut bioindicators for diagnosing pathogen infection. In addition, the antagonistic commensals of V. anguillarum might be the candidate probiotics for preventing AHPND.