Structures of Pathological and Functional Amyloids and Prions, a Solid-State NMR Perspective

Analytical Framework to Understand the Origins of Methyl Side-Chain Dynamics in Protein Assemblies

Side-chain motions play an important role in understanding protein structure, dynamics, protein-protein, and protein-ligand interactions. However, our understanding of protein side-chain dynamics is currently limited by the lack of analytical tools. Here, we present a novel analytical framework employing experimental nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) relaxation measurements at atomic resolution combined with molecular dynamics (MD) simulation to characterize with a high level of detail the methyl side-chain dynamics in insoluble protein assemblies, using amyloid fibrils formed by the prion HET-s. We use MD simulation to interpret experimental results, where rotameric hops, including methyl group rotation and χ1/χ2 rotations, cannot be completely described with a single correlation time but rather sample a broad distribution of correlation times, resulting from continuously changing local structure in the fibril. Backbone motion similarly samples a broad range of correlation times, from ∼100 ps to μs, although resulting from mostly different dynamic processes; nonetheless, we find that the backbone is not fully decoupled from the side-chain motion, where changes in side-chain dynamics influence backbone motion and vice versa. While the complexity of side-chain motion in protein assemblies makes it very challenging to obtain perfect agreement between experiment and simulation, our analytical framework improves the interpretation of experimental dynamics measurements for complex protein assemblies.

Optimal-Control-Based Cβ Chemical Shift Encoding for Efficient Signal Assignment of Solid Proteins

Fast magic-angle spinning (MAS) solid-state NMR spectroscopy is a powerful tool for gaining structural and dynamic information on solid proteins. To access such information site-specifically, the signal assignment process is unavoidable. In the assignment process, Cα and Cβ chemical shifts are of paramount importance in identifying the type of amino acid residues. Conventionally, however, recording the Cβ chemical shift of solid proteins with relatively short transverse relaxation time is often limited by the long delay required for the magnetization transfer to Cβ spins and its evolution, that is, by the sensitivity drop. In this article, we propose a new method that encodes the Cβ chemical shifts onto the intensities of the scalar-coupled Cα signals by combining an optimal control-based spin manipulation pulse and a spin-state filter. This reduces the total required transverse evolution to less than half of that for the previously proposed method, opening up the concept of the Cβ-encoding nearest-neighbor NMR, for the first time, to solid proteins. Also, the total measurement time was shorter than that required for the explicit Cβ shift evolution. We demonstrate the sequential signal assignment for microcrystalline protein GB1, and then discuss the prospects for more challenging proteins.

Molecular characterization of the N-terminal half of TasA during amyloid-like assembly and its contribution to Bacillus subtilis biofilm formation

Biofilms are bacterial communities that result from a cell differentiation process leading to the secretion of an extracellular matrix (ECM) by part of the population. In Bacillus subtilis, the main protein component of the ECM is TasA, which forms a fiber-based scaffold that confers structure to the ECM. The N-terminal half of TasA is strongly conserved among Bacillus species and contains a protein domain, the rigid core (RcTasA), which is critical for the structural and functional properties of the recombinant protein. In this study, we demonstrate that recombinantly purified RcTasA in vitro retains biochemical properties previously observed for the entire protein. Further analysis of the RcTasA amino acid sequence revealed two aggregation-prone stretches and a region of imperfect amino acid repeats, which are known to contribute to functional amyloid assembly. Biochemical characterization of these stretches found in RcTasA revealed their amyloid-like capacity in vitro, contributing to the amyloid nature of RcTasA. Moreover, the study of the imperfect amino acid repeats revealed the critical role of residues D64, K68 and D69 in the structural function of TasA. Experiments with versions of TasA carrying the substitutions D64A and K68AD69A demonstrated a partial loss of function of the protein either in the assembly of the ECM or in the stability of the core and amyloid-like properties. Taken together, our findings allow us to better understand the polymerization process of TasA during biofilm formation and provide knowledge into the sequence determinants that promote the molecular behavior of protein filaments in bacteria.

Intrinsic determinants of prion protein neurotoxicity in Drosophila: from sequence to (dys)function

Prion diseases are fatal brain disorders characterized by deposition of insoluble isoforms of the prion protein (PrP). The normal and pathogenic structures of PrP are relatively well known after decades of studies. Yet our current understanding of the intrinsic determinants regulating PrP misfolding are largely missing. A 3D subdomain of PrP comprising the β2-α2 loop and helix 3 contains high sequence and structural variability among animals and has been proposed as a key domain regulating PrP misfolding. We combined in vivo work in Drosophila with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, which provide additional insight to assess the impact of candidate substitutions in PrP from conformational dynamics. MD simulations revealed that in human PrP WT the β2-α2 loop explores multiple β-turn conformations, whereas the Y225A (rabbit PrP-like) substitution strongly favors a 310-turn conformation, a short right-handed helix. This shift in conformational diversity correlates with lower neurotoxicity in flies. We have identified additional conformational features and candidate amino acids regulating the high toxicity of human PrP and propose a new strategy for testing candidate modifiers first in MD simulations followed by functional experiments in flies. In this review we expand on these new results to provide additional insight into the structural and functional biology of PrP through the prism of the conformational dynamics of a 3D domain in the C-terminus. We propose that the conformational dynamics of this domain is a sensitive measure of the propensity of PrP to misfold and cause toxicity. This provides renewed opportunities to identify the intrinsic determinants of PrP misfolding through the contribution of key amino acids to different conformational states by MD simulations followed by experimental validation in transgenic flies.

Efficient 18.8 T MAS-DNP NMR reveals hidden side chains in amyloid fibrils

Amyloid fibrils are large and insoluble protein assemblies composed of a rigid core associated with a cross-β arrangement rich in β-sheet structural elements. It has been widely observed in solid-state NMR experiments that semi-rigid protein segments or side chains do not yield easily observable NMR signals at room temperature. The reasons for the missing peaks may be due to the presence of unfavorable dynamics that interfere with NMR experiments, which result in very weak or unobservable NMR signals. Therefore, for amyloid fibrils, semi-rigid and dynamically disordered segments flanking the amyloid core are very challenging to study. Here, we show that high-field dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP), an NMR hyperpolarization technique typically performed at low temperatures, can circumvent this issue because (i) the low-temperature environment (~ 100 K) slows down the protein dynamics to escape unfavorable detection regime, (ii) DNP improves the overall NMR sensitivity including those of flexible side chains, and (iii) efficient cross-effect DNP biradicals (SNAPol-1) optimized for high-field DNP (≥ 18.8 T) are employed to offer high sensitivity and resolution suitable for biomolecular NMR applications. By combining these factors, we have successfully established an impressive enhancement factor of ε ~ 50 on amyloid fibrils using an 18.8 T/ 800 MHz magnet. We have compared the DNP efficiencies of M-TinyPol, NATriPol-3, and SNAPol-1 biradicals on amyloid fibrils. We found that SNAPol-1 (with ε ~ 50) outperformed the other two radicals. The MAS DNP experiments revealed signals of flexible side chains previously inaccessible at conventional room-temperature experiments. These results demonstrate the potential of MAS-DNP NMR as a valuable tool for structural investigations of amyloid fibrils, particularly for side chains and dynamically disordered segments otherwise hidden at room temperature.

Functional Amyloids: Where Supramolecular Amyloid Assembly Controls Biological Activity or Generates New Functionality

Functional amyloids are a rapidly expanding class of fibrillar protein structures, with a core cross-β scaffold, where novel and advantageous biological function is generated by the assembly of the amyloid. The growing number of amyloid structures determined at high resolution reveal how this supramolecular template both accommodates a wide variety of amino acid sequences and also imposes selectivity on the assembly process. The amyloid fibril can no longer be considered a generic aggregate, even when associated with disease and loss of function. In functional amyloids the polymeric β-sheet rich structure provides multiple different examples of unique control mechanisms and structures that are finely tuned to deliver assembly or disassembly in response to physiological or environmental cues. Here we review the range of mechanisms at play in natural, functional amyloids, where tight control of amyloidogenicity is achieved by environmental triggers of conformational change, proteolytic generation of amyloidogenic fragments, or heteromeric seeding and amyloid fibril stability. In the amyloid fibril form, activity can be regulated by pH, ligand binding and higher order protofilament or fibril architectures that impact the arrangement of associated domains and amyloid stability. The growing understanding of the molecular basis for the control of structure and functionality delivered by natural amyloids in nearly all life forms should inform the development of therapies for amyloid-associated diseases and guide the design of innovative biomaterials.

Atomic-Resolution Structure of the Protein Encoded by Gene V of fd Bacteriophage in Complex with Viral ssDNA Determined by Magic-Angle Spinning Solid-State NMR

F-specific filamentous phages, elongated particles with circular single-stranded DNA encased in a symmetric protein capsid, undergo an intermediate step, where thousands of homodimers of a non-structural protein, gVp, bind to newly synthesized strands of DNA, preventing further DNA replication and preparing the circular genome in an elongated conformation for assembly of a new virion structure at the membrane. While the structure of the free homodimer is known, the ssDNA-bound conformation has yet to be determined. We report an atomic-resolution structure of the gVp monomer bound to ssDNA of fd phage in the nucleoprotein complex elucidated via magic-angle spinning solid-state NMR. The model presents significant conformational changes with respect to the free form. These modifications facilitate the binding mechanism and possibly promote cooperative binding in the assembly of the gVp-ssDNA complex.

Methodological advances and strategies for high resolution structure determination of cellular protein aggregates

Aggregation of proteins is at the nexus of molecular processes crucial to aging, disease, and employing proteins for biotechnology and medical applications. There has been much recent progress in determining the structural features of protein aggregates that form in cells; yet, owing to prevalent heterogeneity in aggregation, many aspects remain obscure and often experimentally intractable to define. Here we review recent results of structural studies for cell-derived aggregates of normally globular proteins, with a focus on high resolution methods for their analysis and prediction. Complementary results obtained by solid-state NMR spectroscopy, Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy and microspectroscopy, cryo-electron microscopy, and amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange measured by NMR and mass spectrometry (MS), applied to bacterial inclusion bodies and disease inclusions, are uncovering novel information on in-cell aggregation patterns as well as great diversity in the structural features of useful and aberrant protein aggregates. Using these advances as a guide, this review aims to advise the reader on which combination of approaches may be the most appropriate to apply to their unique system.

Functional amyloids from bacterial biofilms - structural properties and interaction partners

Protein aggregation and amyloid formation have historically been linked with various diseases such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease, but recently functional amyloids have gained a great deal of interest in not causing a disease and having a distinct function in vivo. Functional bacterial amyloids form the structural scaffold in bacterial biofilms and provide a survival strategy for the bacteria along with antibiotic resistance. The formation of functional amyloids happens extracellularly which differs from most disease related amyloids. Studies of functional amyloids have revealed several distinctions compared to disease related amyloids including primary structures designed to optimize amyloid formation while still retaining a controlled assembly of the individual subunits into classical cross-β-sheet structures, along with a unique cross-α-sheet amyloid fold. Studies have revealed that functional amyloids interact with components found in the extracellular matrix space such as lipids from membranes and polymers from the biofilm. Intriguingly, a level of complexity is added as functional amyloids also interact with several disease related amyloids and a causative link has even been established between functional amyloids and neurodegenerative diseases. It is hence becoming increasingly clear that functional amyloids are not inert protein structures found in bacterial biofilms but interact with many different components including human proteins related to pathology. Gaining a clear understanding of the factors governing the interactions will lead to improved strategies to combat biofilm associated infections and the correlated antibiotic resistance. In the current review we summarize the current state of the art knowledge on this exciting and fast growing research field of biofilm forming bacterial functional amyloids, their structural features and interaction partners.

Pulse induced resonance with angular dependent total enhancement of multi-dimensional solid-state NMR correlation spectra

We demonstrate a new resonance condition that obeys the relation Δδ=nν_R/2, where Δδ is the chemical shift difference between two homonuclear-coupled spins, ν_R is the magic-angle spinning speed and n is an integer. This modulation on the rotational resonance recoupling condition is obtained by the application of rotor-synchronous ¹H pulses when at least one proton is dipolar-coupled to one of the homonuclear spins. We suggest a new experimental scheme entitled 'pulse induced resonance with angular dependent total enhancement' (PIRATE) that can enhance proton-driven spin diffusion by the application of a single ¹H pulse every rotor period. Experimental evidence is demonstrated on the two carbon spins of glycine and on the Y21M mutant of fd bacteriophage virus. Numerical simulations reveal the existence of the resonances and report on the important interactions governing these phenomena.

The amyloid state of proteins: A boon or bane?

Proteins and their aggregation is significant field of research due to their association with various conformational maladies including well-known neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer's (AD), Parkinson's (PD), and Huntington's (HD) diseases. Amyloids despite being given negative role for decades are also believed to play a functional role in bacteria to humans. In this review, we discuss both facets of amyloid. We have shed light on AD, which is one of the most common age-related neurodegenerative disease caused by accumulation of Aβ fibrils as extracellular senile plagues. We also discuss PD caused by the aggregation and deposition of α-synuclein in form of Lewy bodies and neurites. Other amyloid-associated diseases such as HD and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) are also discussed. We have also reviewed functional amyloids that have various biological roles in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes that includes formation of biofilm and cell attachment in bacteria to hormone storage in humans, We discuss in detail the role of Curli fibrils' in biofilm formation, chaplins in cell attachment to peptide hormones, and Pre-Melansomal Protein (PMEL) roles. The disease-related and functional amyloids are compared with regard to their structural integrity, variation in regulation, and speed of forming aggregates and elucidate how amyloids have turned from foe to friend.

Computational methods to predict protein aggregation

In most cases, protein aggregation stems from the establishment of non-native intermolecular contacts. The formation of insoluble protein aggregates is associated with many human diseases and is a major bottleneck for the industrial production of protein-based therapeutics. Strikingly, fibrillar aggregates are naturally exploited for structural scaffolding or to generate molecular switches and can be artificially engineered to build up multi-functional nanomaterials. Thus, there is a high interest in rationalizing and forecasting protein aggregation. Here, we review the available computational toolbox to predict protein aggregation propensities, identify sequential or structural aggregation-prone regions, evaluate the impact of mutations on aggregation or recognize prion-like domains. We discuss the strengths and limitations of these algorithms and how they can evolve in the next future.

The protein disorder cycle

This mini-review represents a brief, disorder-centric consideration of the interplay between order and disorder in proteins. The goal here is to show that inside the cell, folding, non-folding, and misfolding of proteins are interlinked on multiple levels. This is evidenced by the highly heterogeneous spatio-temporal structural organization of a protein molecule, where one can find differently (dis)ordered components that can undergo local or global order-to-disorder and disorder-to-order transitions needed for functionality. This is further illustrated by the fact that at particular moments of their life, most notably during their synthesis and degradation, all proteins are at least partially disordered. In addition to these intrinsic forms of disorder, proteins are constantly facing extrinsic disorder, which is intrinsic disorder in their functional partners. All this comprises the multileveled protein disorder cycle.

Dynamic protein structures in normal function and pathologic misfolding in systemic amyloidosis

Dynamic and disordered regions in native proteins are often critical for their function, particularly in ligand binding and signaling. In certain proteins, however, such regions can contribute to misfolding and pathologic deposition as amyloid fibrils in vivo. For example, dynamic and disordered regions can promote amyloid formation by destabilizing the native structure, by directly triggering the aggregation, by promoting protein condensation, or by acting as sites of early proteolytic cleavage that favor a release of aggregation-prone fragments or facilitate fibril maturation. At the same time, enhanced dynamics in the native protein state accelerates proteolytic degradation that counteracts amyloid accumulation in vivo. Therefore, the functional need for dynamic protein regions must be balanced against their inherently labile nature. How exactly this balance is achieved and how is it shifted upon amyloidogenic mutations or post-translational modifications? To illustrate possible scenarios, here we review the beneficial and pathologic roles of dynamic and disordered regions in the native states of three families of human plasma proteins that form amyloid precursors in systemic amyloidoses: immunoglobulin light chain, apolipoproteins, and serum amyloid A. Analysis of structure, stability and local dynamics of these diverse proteins and their amyloidogenic variants exemplifies how disordered/dynamic regions can provide a functional advantage as well as an Achilles heel in pathologic amyloid formation.

Aggregation-Prone Structural Ensembles of Transthyretin Collected With Regression Analysis for NMR Chemical Shift

Monomer dissociation and subsequent misfolding of the transthyretin (TTR) is one of the most critical causative factors of TTR amyloidosis. TTR amyloidosis causes several human diseases, such as senile systemic amyloidosis and familial amyloid cardiomyopathy/polyneuropathy; therefore, it is important to understand the molecular details of the structural deformation and aggregation mechanisms of TTR. However, such molecular characteristics are still elusive because of the complicated structural heterogeneity of TTR and its highly sensitive nature to various environmental factors. Several nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and molecular dynamics (MD) studies of TTR variants have recently reported evidence of transient aggregation-prone structural states of TTR. According to these studies, the stability of the DAGH β-sheet, one of the two main β-sheets in TTR, is a crucial determinant of the TTR amyloidosis mechanism. In addition, its conformational perturbation and possible involvement of nearby structural motifs facilitates TTR aggregation. This study proposes aggregation-prone structural ensembles of TTR obtained by MD simulation with enhanced sampling and a multiple linear regression approach. This method provides plausible structural models that are composed of ensemble structures consistent with NMR chemical shift data. This study validated the ensemble models with experimental data obtained from circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy and NMR order parameter analysis. In addition, our results suggest that the structural deformation of the DAGH β-sheet and the AB loop regions may correlate with the manifestation of the aggregation-prone conformational states of TTR. In summary, our method employing MD techniques to extend the structural ensembles from NMR experimental data analysis may provide new opportunities to investigate various transient yet important structural states of amyloidogenic proteins.