Giant fronto-ethmoidal osteoma - selection of an optimal surgical procedure

Introduction

Osteomas of the paranasal sinuses are benign bone tumours that produce clinical signs depending on their size and location. In most reported cases large tumours are excised by an external approach or in conjunction with an endoscopic technique. Endoscopic treatment of such tumours is a huge challenge for the operator.

Objective

Determine the optimal surgical approach by analysing giant osteomas of the frontal and ethmoidal sinuses in the literature.

Methods

Group of 37 osteomas obtained from the literature review. A group of osteomas removed only by endoscopy was compared with a group in which an external approach (lateral rhynotomy or craniotomy) or combined external and endoscopic approach was applied.

Results

The authors, based on the statistical analysis of the literature data, have found that the average size of osteomas excised endoscopically and those removed by external approaches does not differ statistically, when the osteomas are located in the ethmoidal cells (p = 0.2691) and the frontal sinuses (p = 0.5891).

Conclusion

The choice of surgical method appears to be independent of the osteoma size and the decision is likely to be taken based on the experience of the surgeon, available equipment and knowledge of different surgical techniques.

Characteristics of paranasal sinus osteoma and treatment outcomes

CONCLUSION

The incidence of paranasal sinus (PNS) osteoma was 6.4%. The most common site of PNS osteoma was the ethmoid sinus. All surgically treated patients underwent endoscopic surgery, and there was no recurrence in any patient. Technical improvements, including an image guidance system, extended the indications for endoscopic surgery for PNS osteomas, especially in the frontal sinus region.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the incidence and location of PNS osteomas detected by computed tomography (CT) scan at our hospital, and to describe our experience in the surgical treatment of PNS osteomas.

METHODS

This study was performed on 1724 patients undergoing CT scans because of suspected sinus disease between 2004 and 2013. Endoscopic surgery was performed in 34 symptomatic patients. Medical records of the patients were reviewed, and clinical findings and treatment outcomes were investigated.

RESULTS

PNS osteomas were detected in 110 patients (6.4%). Triple osteomas were detected in two patients. Double osteomas were detected in seven patients. In total, 121 lesions were identified as PNS osteomas. The ethmoid sinus was the most commonly affected site (57.0%), followed by the frontal sinus (25.6%), frontal recess (9.1%), maxillary sinus (5.0%), olfactory fissure (1.7%), and sphenoid sinus (1.7%) in descending order of frequency. Thirty-three patients were surgically treated for PNS osteomas through a purely endoscopic approach, and one patient with a frontal sinus osteoma underwent combined endoscopic surgery and frontal trephination. Image-guided surgery was performed in nine patients with involvement of the orbit and skull base, including the frontal sinus/recess. There were no major surgical complications and there was no tumor recurrence.