Phenotypic characterization of rabbit model for aortic valve stenosis: a novel medial calcification paradigm

Introduction

Calcific aortic valve stenosis (CAVS) is the result of subtle, chronic inflammation and osteoblastic differentiation. As we lack human specimens of the early stages, reliable and reproducible animal models are needed to facilitate research. We previously demonstrated the ability of a novel rabbit CAVS vitamin D2 toxicity protocol to produce calcification and valve stenosis (1). We sought to characterize the phenotype of the model at the final stage.

Methods

Twelve New Zealand Rabbits were randomized 1:1 to control (normal chaw) and experimental group (normal chaw+1% cholesterol+3.500 I.U.s Vitamin D2, in oil in a biscuit) for 7 weeks. Animals were sacrificed and aortic valve cusps were snap frozen or formalin-fixed paraffin embedded. Cusps were then mechanically homogenized in buffer optimized for protein extraction and total protein measured with Bradford method. Part of the extract was subjected to trypsinization, in-gel digestion and untargeted LC-MS/MS. The rest was used to quantitate BMP-2 with total protein-normalized sandwitch competitive ELISA. Thin tissue sections were stained with Masson's trichrome, Von Kossa and H&E. Osteopontin, Bone sialoprotein II (BSPII), tissue non-specific alkaline phosphatase (TNAP) and osteocalcin (OCN) were detected on tissue with immunohistochemistry. Femoral bones from the same animals served as positive controls.

Results

Aortic valve cusp demonstrate large areas of collagen degradation and calcification in the medial layer, almost sparing the intima. Osteopontin deposits were colocalized with the calcification area in the media, whereas BSPII, TNAP and OCN were not expressed in the lesion, although present in bones. Similarly, BMP-2 levels were not significantly different between groups (experimental = 43.45 vs controls = 62.75 pg/ml, Mann-Whitney U test p=0.496). Proteomic analysis revealed a set of 96 differentially expressed proteins between cases and controls, interestingly including sortilin, osteonectin, beta-crystallin A2, Matrix Gla protein, Na/H exchanger 3, V-type H ATPase subunit D, Y-box binding protein.

Conclusion

The novel rabbit vitamin D2 toxicity protocol leads to excessive medial calcification of the aortic valve, with overexpression of osteopontin but without other classic markers of CAVS. Proteomics analysis reveals novel pathways with pathophysiological implications for the model and medial calcification.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: Public grant(s) – National budget only. Main funding source(s): Hellenic Cardiology Society, Hellenic Heart Foundation

Modified New Zealand rabbit model produces severe aortic valve calcification and stenosis via extracellular membranous particles

Background/Purpose

In aortic valve stenosis calcification begins with nucleation on extracellular vesicles. In order to study early-stage disease, validated animal models are needed. The Drolet rabbit model is relevant due to tricuspid valve, but failed to consistently produce stenosis probably due to regimen administration. We compared a modified rabbit model and investigated the mechanisms and patterns of calcification.

Methods

New Zealand rabbits introduced to normal chaw+1% cholesterol+8750 IUs Vitamin D2/kg (Sigma) daily, in olive oil given in a bisquit vs control animals, for 8 weeks. Aortic valve area (AVA) and mean gradient (meanGr) was assessed with echocardiography (Vivid 7, M3S transducer, GE). At 8 weeks animals were sacrificed and valves were snap-frozen to −80°C. From each animal, one cusp was analyzed with Fourier-Transformed Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR, Nicolet 6700 spectrometer, OMNIC 7.3 software), another cusp was processed in alcoholic solution and the third was fixed 0.5 μm thin on 4% PFA; supernatant and tissue respectively examined with multispectral optical imaging. Valves from patients with severe stenosis were used for qualitative comparisons.

Results

At 8 weeks versus baseline, AVA reduced (0.5 cm2 to 0.3 cm2) and meanGr increased (1.1 to 2.95 mmHg, p<0.05), in control was unchanged. FT-IR vibrations in the region of 1800–800 cm–1 demonstrated changes in the protein structure and deposition of CaCO3 and non-hydroxyapatite Ca3(PO4)2 identical to patients' lesions. Multispectral optical imaging of supernatants revealed numerous membranous particles and conductivity analysis indicated calcium cations accumulation on the phospholipids of membrane. The tissue images confirmed the degradations and dendrimer-like depositions of calcium cations most likely on carbonates of amino acids.

Conclusions

The modified high-fat-vitamin D2 rabbit model produces aortic valve stenosis, with chemically identical mineralization to human lesion. Multispectral photonics demonstrate the presence of calcified membranous extracellular particles, a hallmark of cardiovascular calcification. Dendrimer-like depositions correspond to growing deposits. The model is suitable as a research platform purposed for aortic valve stenosis.

Figure 1. A: Image from alcoholic solution supernatant. The bright spots have high conductivity due to Ca 2+ deposition. B: ImageJ surface plot of circulated region confirms calcification. C: 3D-plot illustrates mineralization of membranes. D: 3D-plot of human aortic valve. E: Hypermicroscopic image of rabbit valve tissue: dendrimer-like and mineral cation deposits.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding source: Public Institution(s). Main funding source(s): National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Greece; Concordia University, Montreal, Canada