Direct and indirect costs associated with nonoperative treatment for shoulder instability: an observational study in 132 patients

BACKGROUND

Shoulder instability is associated with decreased functioning. The associated costs could be substantial and interesting to clinicians, researchers, and policy makers. This prospective observational study aims to (1) estimate productivity losses and healthcare expenses following the nonoperative treatment of shoulder instability and (2) identify patient characteristics that influence societal costs.

METHODS

One hundred and thirty-two patients completed a questionnaire regarding production losses and healthcare utilization following consecutive episodes of shoulder instability. Productivity losses were calculated using the friction cost approach. Healthcare utilization was evaluated using standard costs. analysis of variance test was used to assess which patient characteristics are related to productivity losses and healthcare expenses. Societal costs were assessed using multilevel analyses. Bootstrapping was used to estimate statistical uncertainty.

RESULTS

Mean productivity losses are €1469, €881, and €728 and mean healthcare expenses are €3759, €3267, and €2424 per patient per dislocation for the first, second, and third dislocation. Productivity losses decrease significantly after the second (mean difference €-1969, 95%CI= -3680 to -939) and third (mean difference €-2298, 95%CI= -4092 to -1288) compared to the first dislocation.

CONCLUSIONS

Nonoperative treatment of shoulder instability has substantial societal costs.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III, economic analysis.

What Is the Radiographic Prevalence of Incidental Kienböck Disease?

BACKGROUND

Kienböck disease is characterized by osteonecrosis of the lunate. Not all patients with radiographic evidence of the disease experience symptoms bothersome enough to consult a doctor. Little research has been performed on the prevalence of Kienböck disease, and the prevalence in the asymptomatic population is unclear. Knowledge of the natural course of the disease and how often patients are not bothered by the symptoms is important, because it might influence the decision as to whether disease-modifying treatment would be beneficial.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

(1) What is the prevalence of incidental and symptomatic Kienböck disease? (2) What are the factors associated with incidental and symptomatic Kienböck disease? (3) Are there differences in Lichtman stage distribution between incidentally discovered and symptomatic Kienböck disease?

METHODS

We retrospectively searched radiology reports of all MRI scans, CT scans, and radiographs that included the wrists of 51,071 patients obtained over an 11-year period at one institution to screen for Kienböck disease and avascular necrosis of the lunate. Corresponding MR images, CT scans, or radiographs were reviewed by an orthopaedic hand surgeon to confirm the presence of Kienböck disease when the report was inconclusive. The medical record was reviewed to determine whether the radiographic Kienböck disease was incidental. Prevalences were calculated for both symptomatic and incidental Kienböck disease. Additionally, we assessed the association of age, sex, and race with incidental and symptomatic Kienböck disease as well as the radiographic severity according to the Lichtman classification and calculated odds ratios.

RESULTS

We identified 51 cases (0.10%) of incidental Kienböck disease and 87 cases (0.17%) of symptomatic Kienböck disease out of 51,071 patients. Patients with incidental Kienböck were older (mean, 54 years; SD, 17; mean difference, -6.1; 95% confidence interval [CI], -11 to -0.96; p = 0.020) and patients with symptomatic Kienböck disease were younger (mean, 43 years; SD, 14; mean difference, 5.1; 95% CI, 1.2-9.0; p = 0.010) compared with the group of patients without Kienböck disease (mean, 48 years; SD, 19). Lunate collapse (Lichtman Stages III and IV) was seen in nine of 51 patients (18%) with incidental Kienböck disease and in 44 of 87 patients (51%) with symptomatic Kienböck disease (odds ratio, 0.21; 95% CI, 0.086-0.51; p < 0.001). Our study did not identify any other factors associated with Kienböck disease.

CONCLUSIONS

We found that Kienböck disease is diagnosed on radiographs in a notable number of asymptomatic patients and that asymptomatic patients are more likely to have precollapse stages of the disease. This suggests that symptoms and disability do not correlate with pathophysiology, progression, or activity. Patients and surgeons benefit from awareness that symptoms are not a good indicator of the severity or prognosis of pathophysiology and that lunate osteonecrosis can exist with no or insufficient symptoms. This is important when considering treatment, because we cannot distinguish active disease at risk of collapse that could merit disease-modifying treatment from disease that will not progress.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, prognostic study.

Quantitative three-dimensional computed tomography analysis of glenoid fracture patterns according to the AO/OTA classification

HYPOTHESIS/BACKGROUND

This study measures the characteristics of glenoid fractures to determine if the AO Foundation and Orthopaedic Trauma Association (AO/OTA) classification captures the most common fracture patterns. The primary null hypothesis was that surface area and degree of fragmentation do not differ among the different fracture types. Secondarily, we tested if there was a relationship between high- vs. low-energy trauma and fracture classification.

METHODS

Three-dimensional models were created for a consecutive series of 53 fractures. The fracture classifications, the number of fragments, and the fragmented articular surface area were related to the type of injury. The difference of articular surface size and number of fragments among classification groups was analyzed with the Kruskal-Wallis test.

RESULTS

There is a significant difference in fractured articular surface area among classification groups. Compared with transverse and multifragmented fractures, both anterior and posterior fractures involved significantly less of the articular surface area. High-energy trauma is associated with transverse and multifragmented fractures in 93% of the cases. It is associated with a greater number of fracture fragments and fracture of a larger percentage of the glenoid surface area, with a mean fractured surface of 60% for high-energy fractures and 25% for low-energy injuries.

DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION

Quantitative 3-dimensional CT analysis confirms that the current AO/OTA classification adequately characterizes and discriminates glenoid fracture patterns. The classification groups are related to the fragmented articular surface area and the number of fragments. Also, the mechanism of injury is related to the classification group, which supports the clinical relevance of the classification.

Quantitative 3-dimensional CT analyses of fractures of the middle phalanx base

BACKGROUND

Quantitative 3-dimensional computed tomography (3DCT) analyses can provide a more detailed understanding of fracture morphology. For fracture-dislocation of the proximal interphalangeal joint, the extent of fragmentation of the volar lip of the middle phalanx-a factor that might influence treatment-is not always apparent from radiographs. We hypothesized that there is no correlation between number of fracture fragments and the percentage of articular surface area involved in intra-articular fractures of the base of the middle phalanx using quantitative 3DCT analyses.

METHODS

We used 13 computed tomography scans with a slice thickness of 1.25 mm or less to create 3-dimensional models of 15 intra-articular fractures of the base of the middle phalanx in 13 patients. We resized 3-dimensional models of a non-fractured middle phalanx of the same hand to fit the fractured middle phalanx in order to approximate the size and shape of the fractured middle phalanx in its pre-injury state. We created a heatmap to demonstrate the location of the fractured articular surface.

RESULTS

With the number of scans available, we did not find a significant correlation between the percentage of articular surface area involved and the number of fracture fragments. The median percentage of articular surface area involved was 46 % (range, 21-90 %). The heatmap demonstrated that the radio-volar side of the articular surface seems to be more involved than the ulnar-volar side in intra-articular fractures of the base of the middle phalanx.

CONCLUSION

Quantitative 3DCT analysis of fracture fragments provides useful information that could facilitate surgery and analysis of complex fractures of the base of the middle phalanx.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, Basic Science Study, Anatomic Study, Imaging.

[Scapula alata following a gunshot injury]

BACKGROUND

The clinical condition "winged scapula" (scapula alata) is frequently not recognized as such. The accompanying symptoms are often attributed to more frequently occurring shoulder disorders, which can lead to unnecessary surgical procedures.

CASE DESCRIPTION

A 41-year-old man was shot during a robbery 3 years ago, resulting in a complete paraplegia from the fourth thoracic vertebra downwards. Within a year of the attack, during rehabilitation towards wheelchair use, he developed pain around his right shoulder. He also had diminished strength when extending his right arm and problems with trunk balance. These symptoms were long thought to be caused by shoulder overuse during wheelchair use, but turned out to be a consequence of injury to the long thoracic nerve.

CONCLUSION

Shoulder symptoms due to scapula alata can be caused be a penetrating wound leading to nerve injury. The treatment of patients with a scapula alata calls for a multidisciplinary approach.