Biomechanical comparison of headless compression screws versus independent locking screw for intra-articular fractures

PURPOSE

Headless compression screws (HCS) have a variable thread pitch and headless design enabling them to embed below the articular surface and generate compression force for fracture healing without restricting movement. Locking screws have greater variety of dimensions and a threaded pitch mirroring the design of the HCS. The objective of this study is to determine whether locking screws can generate compression force and compare the compressive forces generated by HCS versus locking screws.

METHOD

A comparison between 3.5-mm HCS versus 3.5-mm locking screws and 2.8-mm HCS versus 2.7-mm locking screws was performed using a synthetic foam bone model (Synbone) and FlexiForce sensors to record the compression forces (N). The mean peak compression force was calculated from a sample of 3 screws for each screw type. Statistical analysis was performed using the one-way ANOVA test and statistical significance was determined to be p =  < 0.05.

RESULTS

The 3.5-mm Synthes and Smith and Nephew locking screws generated similar peak compression forces to the 3.5-mm Acutrak 2 headless compression screws with no statistically significant difference between them. The smaller 2.7-mm Synthes and Smith and Nephew locking screws initially generated similar compressive forces up to 1.5 and 2 revolutions, respectively, but their peak compression force was less compared to the 2.8-mm Micro Acutrak 2 HCS.

CONCLUSION

Locking screws are able to generate compressive forces and may be a viable alternative to headless compressive screws supporting their use for intra-articular fractures.

Consensus on managing open ankle fractures in the frail patient

Aims

Ankle fractures are common injuries and the third most common fragility fracture. In all, 40% of ankle fractures in the frail are open and represent a complex clinical scenario, with morbidity and mortality rates similar to hip fracture patients. They have a higher risk of complications, such as wound infections, malunion, hospital-acquired infections, pressure sores, veno-thromboembolic events, and significant sarcopaenia from prolonged bed rest.

Methods

A modified Delphi method was used and a group of experts with a vested interest in best practice were invited from the British Foot and Ankle Society (BOFAS), British Orthopaedic Association (BOA), Orthopaedic Trauma Society (OTS), British Association of Plastic & Reconstructive Surgeons (BAPRAS), British Geriatric Society (BGS), and the British Limb Reconstruction Society (BLRS).

Results

In the first stage, there were 36 respondents to the survey, with over 70% stating their unit treats more than 20 such cases per year. There was a 50:50 split regarding if the timing of surgery should be within 36 hours, as per the hip fracture guidelines, or 72 hours, as per the open fracture guidelines. Overall, 75% would attempt primary wound closure and 25% would utilize a local flap. There was no orthopaedic agreement on fixation, and 75% would permit weightbearing immediately. In the second stage, performed at the BLRS meeting, experts discussed the survey results and agreed upon a consensus for the management of open elderly ankle fractures.

Conclusion

A mutually agreed consensus from the expert panel was reached to enable the best practice for the management of patients with frailty with an open ankle fracture: 1) all units managing lower limb fragility fractures should do so through a cohorted multidisciplinary pathway. This pathway should follow the standards laid down in the "care of the older or frail orthopaedic trauma patient" British Orthopaedic Association Standards for Trauma and Orthopaedics (BOAST) guideline. These patients have low bone density, and we should recommend full falls and bone health assessment; 2) all open lower limb fragility fractures should be treated in a single stage within 24 hours of injury if possible; 3) all patients with fragility fractures of the lower limb should be considered for mobilisation on the day following surgery; 4) all patients with lower limb open fragility fractures should be considered for tissue sparing, with judicious debridement as a default; 5) all patients with open lower limb fragility fractures should be managed by a consultant plastic surgeon with primary closure wherever possible; and 6) the method of fixation must allow for immediate unrestricted weightbearing.

Primary Ankle Fusion Using an Antegrade Nail Into the Talus for Early Treatment of OTA Type C3 Distal Tibial Plafond Fractures: A Preliminary Report

BACKGROUND

Type C3 distal tibial plafond fractures consistently show poor outcomes with high complication rates and significant risk of posttraumatic arthritis. We describe a minimally invasive technique of performing a primary ankle fusion using an anterograde tibial nail and compare our early results to traditional methods of fixation.

METHODS

During the acute admission, the patient undergoes an arthroscopic preparation of the ankle joint and insertion of an anterograde nail into the talus. This technique is described in detail and presented alongside a retrospective 5-year review of all adult C3 distal tibial plafond fractures from our center.

RESULTS

Twenty-six patients (8 open fractures) had been fixed traditionally using open reduction internal fixation (24 patients) and circular frames (2 patients) with an average follow-up of 20 months. Those internally fixed had protected weightbearing for 3 months. Complications included deep infection (12%), nonunion (8%), malunion (4%), severe posttraumatic osteoarthritis (27%), and the secondary conversion to ankle replacement/fusion (12%) requiring an average of 3 reoperations.Six patients underwent primary fusion (3 open fractures) with an average follow-up of 18 months. Patients were allowed to immediately weightbear. There were no reported complications and the primary fusion group demonstrated shorter hospital stays, faster return to work, and higher mean self-reported foot and ankle score (SEFAS) compared to those treated with ORIF.

CONCLUSION

C3 distal tibial plafond fractures are difficult to manage and there has not been a satisfactory method of treating them that allows early return to work, has a low risk of complications, and reduces the risk of posttraumatic tibiotalar arthritis.We present our initial results with a method that uses traditional arthroscopic techniques to prepare the tibiotalar joint together with minimally invasive anterograde tibiotalar nailing. In this initial report of a small group of patients, we found that surgery can be performed once the swelling has subsided after injury and that allowing weightbearing as tolerated did not appear to have a negative effect on initial outcomes.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, retrospective comparative study.

Tibiotalocalcaneal nail and primary closure for the management of open ankle fractures in the elderly patient; results from a major trauma centre

INTRODUCTION

Open ankle fractures in elderly patients are challenging injuries to manage. The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of elderly patients with open ankle fractures treated with a tibiotalocalcaneal nail and primary wound closure.

METHODS

We identified all open ankle fractures in patients over 65 referred to our major trauma centre managed with a tibiotalocalcaneal nail and primary wound closure over 10 years. We recorded patient demographics, comorbidities, injury mechanism, length of stay, operation, weightbearing status, re-operations, infections and mortality.

RESULTS

We included 34 patients with an average age of 87 (73-99). We found 56 % of patients' mobility status declined post-operatively and 21 % of patients were discharged directly home. Four patients required further unplanned surgery including two deep infections requiring amputation. We had a 6 % three month mortality rate.

CONCLUSION

Use of a tibiotalocalcaneal nail with primary wound closure offers a reasonable treatment option for open fractures of the ankle in the elderly patient.

Strain reduction screws for nonunions following fixation around the elbow - A case series and review of the literature

Background

Nonunions following fracture fixation result in significant patient morbidity and financial burden. Traditional operative management around the elbow consists of removal of metalwork, debridement of the nonunion and re-fixation with compression, often with bone grafting. Recently, some authors in the lower limb literature have described a minimally invasive technique used for select nonunions where simply placing screws across the nonunion facilitates healing by reducing inter-fragmentary strain. To our knowledge, this has not been described around the elbow, where traditional more invasive techniques continue to be employed.

Aims

The aim of this study was to describe the application of strain reduction screws for management of select nonunions around the elbow.

Methods & Results

We describe 4 cases (two humeral shaft, one distal humerus and one proximal ulna) of established nonunion following previous internal fixation, where minimally invasive placement of strain reduction screws were used. In all cases, no existing metal work was removed, the nonunion site was not opened, and no bone grafting or biologic stimulation was used. Surgery was performed between 9 and 24 months after the original fixation. 2.7 mm or 3.5 standard cortical screws were placed across the nonunion without lagging. Three fractures went on to unite with no further intervention required. One fracture required revision fixation using traditional techniques. Failure of the technique in this case did not adversely affect the subsequent revision procedure and has allowed refinement of the indications.

Conclusion

Strain reduction screws are safe, simple and effective technique to treat select nonunions around the elbow. This technique has potential to be a paradigm shift in the management of these highly complex cases and is the first description in the upper limb to our knowledge.

Hindfoot Nail or Protibial Screw Fixation for Ankle Fracture: A Multi-Centre Study

Category:

Ankle; Trauma

Introduction/Purpose:

Multi-centre assessment of utilisation and outcomes of hindfoot intramedullary fixation (HFN) or fibula pro-tibial screw fixation (PTS) in complex ankle fractures.

Methods:

From January 2020 - June 2021, demographic data, co-morbidities, was collected on all patients undergoing HFN or PTS for an AO44 ankle fracture at three Major Trauma Centre's (MTC's) in the UK. Outcomes of interest included post-operative complications, Charlson-Co-morbidity-Index-Score (CCIS), weight-bearing status, peri-operative information, soft tissue management and post-operative complications were recorded, Radiographs were assessed for metalwork breakage and anatomical reduction (Pettrone Criteria).

Results:

77 patients were identified; 59 underwent HFN and 18 had PTS fixation. The mean age differed between techniques (80+-11.4 [HFN] vs. 66+-19.8 [PTS]) (p<0.001) and 10-year survival favoured patients undergoing PTS (30+-31.6% in the [HFN] and 55+-37.6%[PTS] (p<0.004). 17 (29%) HFN patients had diabetes compared with 7 (39%) PTS patients. 36 (61%) HFN's were open fractures, 7 (39%) PTS's were open fractures, differences in outcomes between primary closure/shortening/joint preparation and combined ortho-plastic management were noted in the HFN group.Time to full weight bearing was reduced in HFN vs. PTS (2.1+-3.1 vs. 8.0+-5.0) (p<0.001), only a minority of patients were allowed to WB immediately. 12 (27%) of patients with open fractures had post-operative complications compared with 5 (15%) of closed fractures. The mean Pettrone score for HFN was 1.3+-1.6 compared with 3.7+-0.6 for PTS, subgroup analysis showed Pettrone scores for open fractures treated with a HFN worsened(0.9 vs 2.3) (p=0.007).

Conclusion:

Comparing functional and outcome rates between the 2 techniques, PTS provides stable fixation, and a lower overall complication rates, with better radiological outcomes and expected survival. However, HFN is performed in frailer patients, with co-morbidities where early weight-bearing may be beneficial, accepting limited functionality and higher complication rate. Even though both techniques are designed for early mobility in the appropriate person this is not always realised, thus further studies are required to characterise which patients benefit most from each surgical technique.

Fibula Nail Outcomes in Soft Tissue Compromised Ankle Fractures

Category:

Trauma; Ankle

Introduction/Purpose:

Lower limb fractures account for a third of all orthopaedic injuries of which 22% are ankle fractures. With a gradual move toward minimally invasive surgery for ankle fractures, intramedullary implants have evolved over the years to dedicated fixation devices for fibula fractures. The aim of this study was to determine the clinical outcomes following fibula nail fixation and to identify the indication for the use of fibula nails in ankle fractures.

Methods:

A retrospective study of adult patients from 2 major trauma centers (MTCs) and 9 trauma units (TUs) who underwent fibula nail fixation for AO/OTA 44 fractures between January 1, 2018, and October 31, 2020 was conducted. Fracture were classified based on the Weber or AO/OTA classification. Operative fixation was performed using the Acumed Fibula Rod (Acumend Fibula Rod System, Hilsboro, OR, USA) and a minimally invasive direct approach to the lateral malleolsus with radiography-guided percutaneous screw insertion was used in all patients. The outcome measures included infection, metalwork complications, nonunion or malunion, time to union, and length of inpatient hospital stay.

Results:

Ninety-five patients were included, with a mean age of 66 years; 57.9% of patients were female. The average body mass index was 30. Sixty-nine patients (72.6%) sustained a Weber B and 24 (27.4%) sustained a Weber C fracture. In addition, 26.3% were open fractures and all patients had soft tissue compromise affecting the lateral malleolus. The calculated infection rate for fibula nail was 4.2% and metalwork complication rate was 5.2%. The nonunion and malunion rate was 8.4% and rate of removal of hardware was 2.1%. The average time to union was 12.5 weeks, and length of inpatient stay was 9.4 days (SD 10).

Conclusion:

This is the largest multicenter to date which demonstrates that use of a fibula nail appears to be a safe approach to treating patients who have a physiologically higher risk of surgery, poor skin condition, and a complex fracture pattern. The risks of wound and metalwork complicatons appear relatively low following fibula nail fixation in comparison to ankle ORIF's.

Fibula Nail Outcomes in Soft Tissue Compromised Ankle Fractures

BACKGROUND

To determine the clinical outcomes following fibula nail fixation and to identify the indication for the use of fibula nails in lower limb fractures.

METHODS

Retrospective study of adult patients from 2 major trauma centers (MTCs) and 9 trauma units (TUs) who underwent fibula nail fixation for AO/OTA 44 fractures between January 1, 2018, and October 31, 2020. Outcome measures included infection, metalwork complications, nonunion or malunion, time to union, and length of inpatient hospital stay.

RESULTS

Ninety-five patients were included, with a mean age of 66 years; 57.9% of patients were female. The average body mass index was 30. Sixty-nine patients (72.6%) sustained a Weber B and 24 (27.4%) sustained a Weber C fracture. In addition, 26.3% were open fractures and all patients had soft tissue compromise affecting the lateral malleolus. The calculated infection rate for fibula nail was 4.2% and metalwork complication rate was 5.2%. The nonunion and malunion rate was 8.4% and rate of removal of hardware was 2.1%. The average time to union was 12.5 weeks, and length of inpatient stay was 9.4 days (SD 10).

CONCLUSION

This multicenter study demonstrates that use of a fibula nail appears to be a safe approach to treating patients who have a physiologically higher risk of surgery, poor skin condition, and a complex fracture pattern.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, case-control study.

Coronal shear fractures of the distal humerus managed according to the Modified Dubberley Classification System

BACKGROUND

Coronal shear fractures of the capitellum and trochlea are relatively uncommon and can be challenging to treat because of variable articular comminution and poor bone stock. Classification is valuable to help guide surgical decision making and prognosis. The aim of this study was to present a large series of coronal shear fractures treated according to the Modified Dubberley Classification System (MDCS).

METHODS

Forty-five patients with a coronal shear fracture were followed up (12-93 months, mean: 28 months) after surgical intervention. Fractures were classified according to the MDCS by 3 observers, and outcome data collected included Oxford elbow score (OES), visual analog pain score (VAS), range of motion, complications, and radiographic findings.

RESULTS

There were 10 type 1, 12 type 2, 8 type 3, and 15 type 4 fractures. There were 26 subtype B fractures (posterior comminution). A total of 37 patients underwent open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) and 8 primary arthroplasty. The median OES and VAS were 43(16-48) and 2 (0-9), respectively. Median flexion extension arc was 125° (range, 70°-140°). There was no significant difference in OES, VAS, or range of motion according to fracture type (types 1-4), subtype (type a or b), or treatment method (arthroplasty vs. ORIF). The overall complication and reoperation rates were 31% and 33%, respectively. A total of 75% of complications occurred in type 3 and 4 fractures, and there was a nonsignificant trend toward higher complication rate in type B fractures than type A fractures (34% vs. 16%, P = .19). Patients with a type B fracture who underwent screw-only fixation had a significantly lower OES and higher complication rate compared with when they had combined plating with screws (OES, P = .03; complications P = .04) and compared with when an arthroplasty was performed (OES, P = .05; complications P = .04).

CONCLUSION

Consistently good outcomes can be achieved by classification and management according to the MDCS. It is recommended that type B fractures undergo combined plate and screw fixation and that type 4 fractures should be considered for arthroplasty because of the higher risk of complications with ORIF.

56 Antibiotic Prescribing for Open Fractures - A Quality Improvement Project to Enhance BOAST 4 Attainment

Introduction

Open fractures are associated with increased infection rates and the evidence shows timely administration of prophylactic antibiotics within one hour of injury improves the outcomes.

Method

A multi-cycle audit was carried out retrospectively for patients presenting to Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust (BSUH) with an open limb fracture in 2018-2020. Targeted teaching was carried out for orthopaedic trainees, prompt posters created and alterations to the trauma clerking proforma were implemented.

Results

In first cycle, 48 (92.3%) out of total 52 patients were prescribed antibiotics prior to definitive surgical management, with a mean time to administration of 271 minutes. Of these, 41 (78.8%) received prescriptions according to BSUH guidelines. The use of STAT ‘once-only’ prescriptions was found to significantly reduce the mean time to administration for 154 minutes. In second cycle, all of 29 patients (100%) were prescribed antibiotics prior to definitive surgical management, with a reduced mean time to administration (233 minutes). Of these, 26 (89.7%) received prescriptions according to BSUH guidelines, and a significantly greater proportion received initial STAT prescriptions (51.7% vs. 15.4%).

Conclusions

This quality improvement project has demonstrated the successful implementation of targeted changes to improve the attainment of BOAST 4 guidelines.

Lengthening Nails for Distraction Osteogenesis: A Review of Current Practice and Presentation of Extended Indications

Purpose

Circular frames have been the gold standard of treatment for complex deformity corrections and bone loss. However, despite the success of frames, patient satisfaction has been low, and complications are frequent. Most recently, lengthening nails have been used to correct leg length discrepancies. In this article, we review the current trends in deformity correction with emphasis on bone lengthening and present our case examples on the use of lengthening nails for management of complex malunions, non-unions, and a novel use in bone transport.

Materials and methods

A nonsystematic literature review on the topic was performed. Four case examples from our institute, Brighton and Sussex University Hospitals, East Sussex, England, UK, were included.

Results

New techniques based on intramedullary bone lengthening and deformity correction are replacing the conventional external frames. Introduction of lengthening and then nailing and lengthening over a nail techniques paved the way for popularization of the more recent lengthening nails. Lengthening nails have gone through evolution from the first mechanical nails to motorized nails and more recently the magnetic lengthening nails. Two case examples demonstrate successful use of lengthening nails for management of malunion, and two case examples describe novel use in management of non-unions, including the first report in the literature of plate-assisted bone segment transport for the longest defect successfully treated using this novel technique.

Conclusion

With the significant advancement of intramedullary lengthening devices with lower complications rates and higher patient satisfaction, the era of the circular frame may be over.

How to cite this article

Barakat AH, Sayani J, O'Dowd-Booth C, et al. Lengthening Nails for Distraction Osteogenesis: A Review of Current Practice and Presentation of Extended Indications. Strategies Trauma Limb Reconstr 2020;15(1):54–61.

Standardised virtual fracture clinic management of Achilles tendon ruptures is safe and reproducible

BACKGROUND

Traditional fracture clinics are some of the busiest clinics in a hospital, often with significant patient waiting times and delays. The use of virtual fracture clinic (VFC) for the management of certain injuries to reduce the workload on the traditional fracture clinic, in addition to reducing costs is growing in popularity. The tendoachilles is the most frequently ruptured tendon in the body but despite this, management remains a keenly debated topic.

METHODS

All adult patients referred to the VFC with an actual or suspected Achilles tendon rupture were identified between January 2015 to October 2017.

RESULTS

This study found that patient with and acute achilles tendon ruptures managed according to a standardised VFC protocol had a re-rupture rate of 3.82%.

CONCLUSIONS

One of the advantages of a VFC model that is standardised, initiated in the ED, is that it has no variation in outcome seen in our patient group.

‘Modern’ distal femoral locking plates allow safe, early weight-bearing with a high rate of union and low rate of failure

Aims

Fractures of the distal femur can be challenging to manage and are on the increase in the elderly osteoporotic population. Management with casting or bracing can unacceptably limit a patient’s ability to bear weight, but historically, operative fixation has been associated with a high rate of re-operation. In this study, we describe the outcomes of fixation using modern implants within a strategy of early return to function.

Patients and Methods

All patients treated at our centre with lateral distal femoral locking plates (LDFLP) between 2009 and 2014 were identified. Fracture classification and operative information including weight-bearing status, rates of union, re-operation, failure of implants and mortality rate, were recorded.

Results

A total of 127 fractures were identified in 122 patients. The mean age was 72.8 years (16 to 101) and 92 of the patients (75%) were female. A consultant performed the operation in 85 of the cases, (67%) with the remainder performed under direct consultant supervision. In total 107 patients (84%) were allowed to bear full weight immediately. The rate of clinical and radiological union was 81/85 (95%) and only four fractures of 127 (3%) fractures required re-operation for failure of surgery. The 30-day, three- and 12-month mortality rates were 6 (5%), 17 (15%) and 25 (22%), respectively.

Conclusion

Our study suggests an exponential increase in the incidence of a fracture of the distal femur with age, analogous to the population suffering from a proximal femoral fracture. Allowing immediate unrestricted weight-bearing after LDFLP fixation in these elderly patients was not associated with failure of fixation. There was a high rate of union and low rate of re-operation. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2017;99-B:951–7.

Thrombo-prophylaxis in pelvic and acetabular trauma patients: a UK consensus?

AIMS

The incidence of deep vein thrombosis, non-fatal pulmonary embolism and fatal pulmonary embolism may be as high as 61%, 10% and 2%, respectively, in patients with pelvic and acetabular injuries. A survey of the pelvic and acetabular units across the United Kingdom was performed to ascertain the thrombo-prophylaxis policy for these patients. In particular, questions were asked about different regimes on post-operative patients, conservatively managed patients and those simply discussed over the telephone. We enquired about their known rates of DVT and PE and their methods of data collection.

METHODS

Postal questionnaires were sent to 22 pelvic and acetabular trauma centres around the United Kingdom.

RESULTS

Replies from 18 units were received in which a total of 837 operations are performed per year. Forty-five percent of pelvic and acetabular units do not routinely prescribe chemical prophylaxis for post-operative patients and 56% do not prescribe prophylaxis for conservatively managed patients. The policy of the remaining units showed no consistency in duration or agent. Fifty-three percent of units use a database to collect information related to the numbers of patients operated up on. Forty-seven percent have no defined method for collecting DVT and PE numbers. For this reason, reported rates of proximal DVT, non-fatal PE and fatal PE were below that expected at 2.5%, 0.8% and 0.1%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite high rates of thrombo-embolic complications in patients with pelvic and acetabular injuries there is no UK consensus on prescribing prophylaxis.

Displaced intracapsular fracture complicating transient osteopoenia of the hip in pregnancy: timing of surgery

A patient who presented with a displaced subcapital fracture of the proximal femur in her third trimester of pregnancy is reported. Following delivery of the baby with an emergency caesarean section, the fracture was immediately reduced and fixed using cannulated screws. The outcome of her fracture management for this rare condition is discussed. Only seven cases have been reported in the literature and we review the possibility that this condition may be a systemic rather than a purely localised problem as previously believed.

Auditing orthopaedic audit

INTRODUCTION

Clinical audit plays an important role in the drive to improve the quality of patient care and thus forms a cornerstone of clinical governance. Assurance that the quality of patient care has improved requires completion of the audit cycle. A considerable sum of money and time has been spent establishing audit activity in the UK. Failure to close the loop undermines the effectiveness of the audit process and wastes resources.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We analysed the effectiveness of audit in trauma and orthopaedics at a local hospital by comparing audit projects completed over a 6-year period to criteria set out in the NHS National Audit and Governance report.

RESULTS

Of the 25 audits performed since 1999, half were presented to the relevant parties and only 20% completed the audit cycle. Only two of these were audits against national standards and 28% were not based on any standards at all. Only a third of the audits led by junior doctors resulted in implementation of their action plan compared to 75% implementation for consultant-led and 67% for nurse-led audits.

CONCLUSIONS

A remarkably large proportion of audits included in this analysis failed to meet accepted criteria for effective audit. Audits completed by junior doctors were found to be the least likely to complete the cycle. This may relate to the lack of continuity in modern medical training and little incentive to complete the cycle. Supervision by permanent medical staff, principally consultants, and involvement of the audit department may play the biggest role in improving implementation of change.

Focal femoral osteolysis after revision hip replacement with a cannulated, hydroxyapatite-coated long-stemmed femoral component

We describe a case of symptomatic focal femoral osteolysis around a screw hole distal to the hydroxyapatite-coated portion of a cannulated femoral component in a revision hip replacement. No locking screw had been inserted into this, the most proximal of the three distal holes for locking screws. The presence of polyethylene wear debris in the tissue excised from the lesion suggested that it had passed through the cannulated portion of the stem and out of the proximal unfilled distal locking hole, initiating an osteolytic reaction in an otherwise well-fixed stem. This case highlights an important design characteristic of such cannulated, uncemented femoral components. We recommend that the proximal aperture of these cannulated stems be occluded at implantation.

From presentation to publication: the natural history of orthopaedic abstracts in the United Kingdom

BACKGROUND

Up to 63% of the chapters in major orthopaedic textbooks use the results from abstracts that have been presented at international orthopaedic meetings.

METHODS

Orthopaedic abstracts were reviewed that were presented at the 1997 and 1998 meetings of the British Orthopaedic Association and other specialist orthopaedic meetings. The number of abstracts that had gone on to a full text publication was assessed and changes in study design or outcome were determined.

RESULTS

Of the 415 abstracts 137 (33.0%) went on to full text publication. Abstracts presented at the British Orthopaedic Association were significantly more likely to go on to full text publication than abstracts from the other meetings studied. The mean time to publication was 15.6 months. Sample sizes in unpublished studies were smaller (mean 129.8 subjects compared with a mean of 191.4 subjects for published studies). Of full text papers, 19.0% differed regarding study design from the abstract presented at the initial meeting and 10.9% had published different results. Randomised controlled trials had the highest rate of later full text publication (53.6%) followed by observational studies (32.8%), basic science studies (31.4%), and case reports (6.7%).

CONCLUSIONS

In comparison with a study from North America, similar numbers of abstracts presented at meetings finally became published as full text articles, the abstracts had fewer authors, more often included randomised controlled trials and follow up data, and had fewer changes to the results. It is questionable whether the inclusion of such results from abstracts presented at international meetings by major orthopaedic textbooks should be undertaken before full text publication.

Balancing priorities in the management of hip fractures: guidelines versus resources

BACKGROUND

About 60,000 patients are treated for hip fractures each year in the UK and the incidence is increasing. The majority of these patients are elderly and sick, and delay to operation may be fatal. The National Confidential Enquiry into Peri-Operative Deaths (NCEPOD) guidelines aim to improve quality of care for such patients. However, we present an audit highlighting the importance of balancing the implementation of such guidelines with available local resources to ensure that established priorities in the care of these patients remain paramount.

METHODS

The 2001 NCEPOD report recommends that pre-operative transthoracic echocardiography be performed in patients who have evidence of aortic stenosis in order to identify those requiring invasive monitoring and high dependency unit care postoperatively.

RESULTS

We have assessed the impact of the implementation of these guidelines on surgery for fractured neck of femur at our hospital, auditing both delay to surgery and the effect of the investigation on subsequent management. In the period studied prior to the introduction of the NCEPOD guidelines, no patients underwent pre-operative echocardiography. Subsequent to their introduction, 10% of patients underwent the investigation, which in the current study did not alter management but did delay surgery by 4-8 days in all cases.

CONCLUSIONS

For such guidelines to be implemented, adequate resources should first be provided. In the absence of these resources, clinicians must balance the need for adequate pre-operative assessment with the need for urgent surgery.

Unusual presentation of a giant cell tumor of the tendon sheath in the foot

Giant cell tumor of the tendon sheath has frequently been described in the hand, but it is much less common in the foot. The case report presents an apparent cystic bony lesion of the proximal phalanx of the second toe of the foot. The operative findings and histological examination revealed a giant cell tumor of the tendon sheath that had eroded the phalanx. The case demonstrates that in the differential diagnosis of a cystic lesion of bone, extrinsic soft-tissue lesions should be considered.