Crystal and electronic structures of magnesium(II), copper(II), and mixed magnesium(II)-copper(II) complexes of the quinoline half of styrylquinoline-type HIV-1 integrase inhibitors

A new target in AIDS therapy development is HIV-1 integrase (IN). It was proven that HIV-1 IN required divalent metal cations to achieve phosphodiester bond cleavage of DNA. Accordingly, all newly investigated potent IN inhibitors contain chemical fragments possessing a high ability to chelate metal cations. One of the promising leads in the polyhydroxylated styrylquinolines (SQLs) series is (E)-8-hydroxy-2-[2-(4,5-dihydroxy-3-methoxyphenyl)-ethenyl]-7-quinoline carboxylic acid (1). The present study focuses on the quinoline-based progenitor (2), which is actually the most probable chelating part of SQLs. Conventional and synchrotron low-temperature X-ray crystallographic studies were used to investigate the chelating power of progenitor 2. Mg2+ and Cu2+ cations were selected for this purpose, and three types of metal complexes of 2 were obtained: Mg(II) complex (4), Cu(II) complex (5) and mixed Mg(II)-Cu(II) complexes (6 and 7). The analysis of the crystal structure of complex 4 indicates that two tridentate ligands coordinate two Mg2+ cations, both in octahedral geometry. The Mg-Mg distance was found equal to 3.221(1) A, in agreement with the metal-metal distance of 3.9 A encountered in the crystal structure of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I. In 5, the complex is formed by two bidentate ligands coordinating one copper ion in tetrahedral geometry. Both mixed Mg(II)-Cu(II) complexes, 6 and 7 exhibit an original arrangement of four ligands linked to a central heterometallic cluster consisting of three octahedrally coordinated magnesium ions and one tetrahedrally coordinated copper ion. Quantum mechanics calculations were also carried out in order to display the electrostatic potential generated by the dianionic ligand 2 and complex 4 and to quantify the binding energy (BE) during the formation of the magnesium complex of progenitor 2. A comparison of the binding energies of two hypothetical monometallic Mg(II) complexes with that found in the bimetallic magnesium complex 4 was made.

Tautomers of styrylquinoline derivatives containing a methoxy substituent: computation of their population in aqueous solution and their interaction with RSV integrase catalytic core

8-Hydroxy-2-[2-(3-hydroxy-4-methoxyphenyl)ethenyl]-7-quinoline carboxylic acid and 8-hydroxy-2-[2-(3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenyl)ethenyl]-7-quinoline carboxylic acid inhibit the processing and strand transfer reactions catalyzed by HIV-1 integrase with an IC50 of 2 microM. Some of their spectral properties are briefly reported. Their fluorescence is so weak that it is of no use in an experimental determination of the binding to the protein and we resorted to computer simulation. Both styrylquinoline derivatives, in their monoanionic form, have several dozens of tautomers and each of these forms has four planar rotamers. In this work computer simulations have been performed to determine which tautomer is the most abundant in aqueous solution and which binds to the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) integrase catalytic core. As the substituents on the quinoline moiety are the same as on salicylic acid, the energies of hydroxy benzoic acid tautomers were also computed both in vacuo and embedded in a continuous medium which had the dielectric constant of bulk water, using the recent CPCM technique. The CPCM method was then applied to the two integrase inhibitors to estimate the tautomer population in water. The binding site of the compounds on the RSV integrase catalytic core was determined through a docking protocol, consisting of coupling a grid search method with full energy minimization. The designed method is a way leading to identification of potent integrase inhibitors using in silico experiments.

HIV-1 integrase: the next target for AIDS therapy?

HIV-1 is the aetiological agent of AIDS. Present treatment of AIDS uses a combination therapy with reverse transcriptase and protease inhibitors. Recently, the integrase (IN), the third enzyme of HIV-1 which is necessary for the integration process of proviral DNA into the host genome, has reached as a legitimate new drug target. Several families of inhibitors of the catalytic core domain of HIV-1 IN exhibiting submicromolar activities have now been identified. Our contribution in this field was related to the development of new polyhydroxylated styrylquinolines. The latter compounds have proved to be potent HIV-1 IN inhibitors, that block the replication of HIV-1 in cell culture, and are devoid of cytotoxicity. The crystal structure of the catalytically active core domain of a HIV-1 IN mutant has been determined. The active site region is identified by the position of two of the conserved carboxylate residues essential for catalysis, Asp64 and Asp116, which coordinate a Mg2+ ion, whereas the third catalytic residue, Glu152 does not participate in metal binding. However, a recent molecular dynamics simulation of the HIV-1 IN catalytic domain provides support to the hypothesis that a second metal ion is likely to be carried into the HIV-1 IN active site by the DNA substrate. The structure of a complex of the HIV-1 IN core domain with the inhibitor 5-CITEP has been recently reported. The inhibitor binds centrally in the active site of the IN and makes a number of close contacts with the protein, particularly with Lys156, Lys159 and Gln148, amino acids which were identified to be near the active site of the enzyme, through site-directed mutagenis and photo-crosslinking experiments. The exact mechanism by which HIV-1 IN inhibitors block the catalytic activity of the protein remains unknown. However, several putative pharmacophore components have been characterized. All these groups lie in a possible coordination to a divalent ion, supporting thus the hypothesis that the interaction causing the inhibition is mediated by one or two cations. Finally, among the HIV-1 IN inhibitors, three classes have proved to exhibit significant antiviral activities. Thus, it seems likely that the efficient use of HIV-1 IN as a target for rational design will become possible in the next future, possibly through the use of combination regimens including IN inhibitors.

Modeling of the inhibition of retroviral integrases by styrylquinoline derivatives

Styrylquinoline derivatives, known to be potent inhibitors of HIV-1 integrase, have been experimentally tested for their inhibitory effect on the disintegration reaction catalyzed by catalytic cores of HIV-1 and Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) integrases. A modified docking protocol, consisting of coupling a grid search method with full energy minimization, has been specially designed to study the interaction between the inhibitors and the integrases. The inhibitors consist of two moieties that have hydroxyl and/or carboxyl substituents: the first moiety is either benzene, phenol, catechol, resorcinol, or salicycilic acid; the hydroxyl substituents on the second (quinoline) moiety may be in the keto or in the enol forms. Several tautomeric forms of the drugs have been docked to the crystallographic structure of the RSV catalytic core. The computed binding energy of the keto forms correlates best with the measured inhibitory effect. The docking procedure shows that the inhibitors bind closely to the crystallographic catalytic Mg(2+) dication. Additional quantum chemistry computations show that there is no direct correlation between the binding energy of the drugs with the Mg(2+) dication and their in vitro inhibitory effect. The designed method is a leading way for identification of potent integrase inhibitors using in silico experiments.

Structure-activity relationships and binding mode of styrylquinolines as potent inhibitors of HIV-1 integrase and replication of HIV-1 in cell culture

Our prior studies showed that polyhydroxylated styrylquinolines are potent HIV-1 integrase (IN) inhibitors that block the replication of HIV-1 in cell culture at nontoxic concentrations. To explore the mechanism of action of these inhibitors, various novel styrylquinoline derivatives were synthesized and tested against HIV-1 IN and in cell-based assays. Regarding the in vitro experiments, the structural requirements for biological activity are a carboxyl group at C-7, a hydroxyl group at C-8 in the quinoline subunit, and an ancillary phenyl ring. However the in vitro inhibitory profile tolerates deep alterations of this ring, e.g. by the introduction of various substituents or its replacement by heteroatomic nuclei. Regarding the ex vivo assays, the structural requirements for activity are more stringent than for in vitro inhibition. Thus, in addition to an o-hydroxy acid group in the quinoline, the presence of one ortho pair of substituents at C-3' and C-4', particularly two hydroxyl groups, in the ancillary phenyl ring is imperatively required for inhibitory potency. Starting from literature data and the SARs developed in this work, a putative binding mode of styrylquinoline inhibitors to HIV-1 IN was derived.

Tautomers of styrylquinoline derivatives containing a methoxy substituent: computation of their population in aqueous solution and their interaction with RSV integrase catalytic core

8-Hydroxy-2-[2-(3-hydroxy-4-methoxyphenyl)ethenyl]-7-quinoline carboxylic acid and 8-hydroxy-2-[2-(3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenyl)ethenyl]-7-quinoline carboxylic acid inhibit the processing and strand transfer reactions catalyzed by HIV-1 integrase with an IC50 of 2 microM. Some of their spectral properties are briefly reported. Their fluorescence is so weak that it is of no use in an experimental determination of the binding to the protein and we resorted to computer simulation. Both styrylquinoline derivatives, in their monoanionic form, have several dozens of tautomers and each of these forms has four planar rotamers. In this work computer simulations have been performed to determine which tautomer is the most abundant in aqueous solution and which binds to the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) integrase catalytic core. As the substituents on the quinoline moiety are the same as on salicylic acid, the energies of hydroxy benzoic acid tautomers were also computed both in vacuo and embedded in a continuous medium which had the dielectric constant of bulk water, using the recent CPCM technique. The CPCM method was then applied to the two integrase inhibitors to estimate the tautomer population in water. The binding site of the compounds on the RSV integrase catalytic core was determined through a docking protocol, consisting of coupling a grid search method with full energy minimization. The designed method is a way leading to identification of potent integrase inhibitors using in silico experiments.