Consideration of image guidance in patterns of failure analyses of intensity-modulated radiotherapy for head and neck cancer: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) is considered standard of care for head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC). Improved conformity of IMRT and smaller margins, however, have led to concerns of increased rates of marginal failures. We hypothesize that while patterns of failure (PoF) after IMRT for HNSCC have been published before, the quality of patient positioning and image guided radiotherapy (IGRT) have rarely been taken into account, and their importance remains unclear. This work provides a systematic review of the consideration of IGRT in PoF studies after IMRT for HNSCC.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A systematic literature search according to PRISMA guidelines was performed on PubMed for HNSCC, IMRT and PoF terms and conference abstracts from ESTRO and ASTRO 2020 and 2021 were screened. Studies were included if they related PoF of HNSCC after IMRT to the treated volumes. Data on patient and treatment characteristics, IGRT, treatment adaptation, PoF and correlation of PoF to IGRT was extracted, categorized and analyzed.

RESULTS

One-hundred ten studies were included. The majority (70) did not report any information on IGRT. The remainder reported daily IGRT (18), daily on day 1-3 or 1-5, then weekly (7), at least weekly (12), or other schemes (3). Immobilization was performed with masks (78), non-invasive frames (4), or not reported (28). The most common PoF classification was "in-field/marginal/out-of-field", reported by 76 studies. Only one study correlated PoF in nasopharyngeal cancer patients to IGRT.

CONCLUSION

The impact of IGRT on PoF in HNSCC is severely underreported in existing literature. Only one study correlated PoF to IGRT measures and setup uncertainty. Further, most PoF studies relied on outdated terminology ("in/out-of-field"). A clearly defined and up-to-date PoF terminology is necessary to evaluate PoFs properly, as is systematic and preferably prospective data generation. PoF studies should consistently and comprehensively consider and report on IGRT.

Multi-camera optical tracking and fringe pattern analysis for eye surface profilometry in ocular proton therapy

Background and purpose

An optical tracking system for high-precision measurement of eye position and orientation during proton irradiation of intraocular tumors was designed. The system performed three-dimensional (3D) topography of the anterior eye segment using fringe pattern analysis based on Fourier Transform Method (FTM).

Materials and methods

The system consisted of four optical cameras and two projectors. The design and modifications to the FTM pipeline were optimized for the realization of a reliable measurement system. Of note, phase-to-physical coordinate mapping was achieved through the combination of stereo triangulation and fringe pattern analysis. A comprehensive pre-clinical validation was carried out. Then, the system was set to acquire the eye surface of patients undergoing proton therapy. Topographies of the eye were compared to manual contouring on MRI.

Results

Pre-clinical results demonstrated that 3D topography could achieve sub-millimetric accuracy (median:0.58 mm) and precision (RMSE:0.61 mm) in the clinical setup. The absolute median discrepancy between MRI and FTM-based anterior eye segment surface reconstruction was 0.43 mm (IQR:0.65 mm).

Conclusions

The system complied with the requirement of precision and accuracy for image guidance in ocular proton therapy radiation and is expected to be clinically tested soon to evaluate its performance against the current standard.