Chagas' disease diagnosis: comparative analysis of parasitologic, molecular, and serologic methods

During the course of chronic chagasic infection, low parasitemia levels prevent parasite detection by current techniques such as hemoculture and xenodiagnosis. Since serologic tests have sensitivity but lack specificity, molecular assays based on the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) have been proposed as alternative tools for parasite detection in individuals with chronic Chagas' disease. A variable degree of PCR efficiency has been reported in the literature and illustrates the need for further evaluation of large numbers of chagasic patients. In this study, we compared an optimized PCR technique with hemoculture and complement-mediated lysis (CoML) in 113 individuals from or living in endemic areas of Brazil who had conventional serologic results that were either positive, negative, or inconclusive. The PCR amplification yielded positive results in 83.5% (66 of 79) of individuals with positive serology, 47.6% (10 of 21) with negative serology, and 46.2% (6 of 13) with inconclusive serology. Of 10 patients with negative serology and positive PCR result, eight (80%) had positive CoML, indicating that they could have been chagasic but were not mounting immune responses. The PCR results were also positive for all individuals who had positive hemoculture, for 37 individuals with negative hemoculture and positive serology, and for two of six individuals with inconclusive serology and negative hemoculture. Thirteen individuals living in nonendemic areas who had negative serology were used as a negative control group: 100% had negative PCR results. Our results show that the optimized PCR protocol used here was very sensitive in detecting the presence of Trypanosoma cruzi in chronic chagasic patients. The PCR and CoML results were well correlated in all of the groups studied, which suggests that our PCR protocol may be effective in the evaluation of cure in patients who receive anti-parasite treatment.

Use of Trypanosoma cruzi purified glycoprotein (GP57/51) or trypomastigote-shed antigens to assess cure for human Chagas' disease

With the exception of assays for the detection of antibodies promoting complement-mediated lysis of Trypanosoma cruzi, serologic tests have generally failed to assess the effectiveness of chemotherapy for Chagas' disease. Conventional serology, although useful for the diagnosis of infection, is not capable of determining which patients have been cured. Here we demonstrate that a high proportion of antibodies detected by conventional serology (using fixed epimastigotes or trypomastigotes or crude extracts obtained therefrom) are directed against the carbohydrate residue galactosyl alpha 1- > 3 galactose (Gal alpha 1- > 3 Gal), a determinant also recognized by antibodies from noninfected healthy volunteers. In a study of 14 cured patients with long-term followup, we found that the persistently positive reactions detected using conventional serology were largely eliminated following immunoadsorption with melibiose. Because of their wide distribution among microorganisms of intestinal and pulmonary microflora, these carbohydrate determinants may keep stimulating lymphocytes previously primed by T. cruzi Gal alpha 1- > 3 Gal epitopes, thereby accounting for false-positive results in cured patients. Consistent with this proposition, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays performed with two distinct T. cruzi antigen preparations that lack the Gal alpha 1- > 3 Gal epitope, namely purified GP57/51 and trypomastigote-shed antigens, were indeed capable of determining a cure after chemotherapy, albeit to a different degree. Collectively, the data indicate that conventional immunoassays prepared with highly specific T. cruzi antigens can be useful in the assessment of a cure after chemotherapy.

Lytic antibody titre as a means of assessing cure after treatment of Chagas disease: a 10 years follow-up study

A complement-mediated lysis test (CoML) using living trypomastigotes was compared with conventional serological methods and with haemoculture. Over a 10 years follow-up period evidence was obtained which supported the view that chagasic patients, treated with nitroheterocyclic drugs, in whom CoML had reverted to negative, might be considered cured despite conventional serology remaining positive.