Self-care recommended by clinicians in patients with heart failure or type 2 diabetes: a Delphi study

Funding Acknowledgements

Type of funding sources: Public Institution(s). Main funding source(s): Australian Catholic University, Australia

Background

Patients with heart failure or type 2 diabetes often experience bothersome symptoms (e.g., swelling, dizziness) and need clinical support with symptom management to reduce the impact of these symptoms. Knowledge about recommended self-care management behaviors by experienced clinicians can help to guide the development of more effective self-care interventions.

Purpose

To develop a list of common bothersome symptoms of heart failure and type 2 diabetes and of self-care management behaviors that clinicians recommend to patients to reduce the impact of these symptoms.

Methods

A two-round Delphi study among a panel of 37 nurses and physicians (heart failure only n=14; type 2 diabetes only n=11 and both heart failure and type 2 diabetes n=12) from Italy, the Netherlands, Sweden and the US was performed. Online surveys were used to identify common and bothersome symptoms and related self-care management behaviors that they recommend to patients with heart failure or type 2 diabetes. Self-care management behaviors that received at least 75% agreement were retained and similar self-care management behaviors were discussed and merged to reduce redundancy.

Results

For heart failure, the final list included 12 common bothersome symptoms (e.g., fatigue/tiredness, shortness of breath) and 51 related self-care management behaviors (e.g., balance rest & activity, check body weight & swelling). For type 2 diabetes, 11 common bothersome symptoms (e.g., hypo- and hyperglycemia symptom clusters, foot wounds) and 25 related self-care management behaviors (e.g., check blood sugar, take insulin, contact podiatrist) were included in the final list. Consensus was reached on the vast majority (70%) of recommended behaviors.

Conclusion

The lists of common bothersome symptoms and self-care management behaviors reflect consensus but also discrepancies between clinicians’ recommendations and current guidelines. Efforts to enhance and align the use of proven effective self-care management behaviors to reduce symptom impact in routine care by clinicians should be considered.