Developing a core set of indicators for quality assessment of cancer genetic services

Background

One of the major challenges of personalized medicine is how to assess the quality of genetic services offered both in public and private sectors. Although the quality of genetic services can be assessed and compared with structure, process or outcome measures, a consensus on the appropriate quality assessment measures is lacking worldwide. The aim of the study is to develop a core set of indicators for the quality assessment of genetic services providing testing for breast and ovarian cancer (BRCA1/2 testing).

Methods

In the first phase, a literature review was performed to identify genetic services providing BRCA1/2 genetic testing in Europe. In the second phase, structural, process and outcome measures retrieved from the literature records will be rated, with a 5-point Likert grading scale, by members of multinational genetic associations in a three-round Delphi survey. The survey will also accommodate quality assessment measures proposed by the participants. In the last phase, the feasibility of using a core set of indicators will be assessed across European countries.

Results

The literature search yielded 92 relevant records published 2000-2019, in English or Italian. The records reported outcome measures (92/92) and, to a lesser extent, process (80/92) and structure measures (71/92). An ad hoc data extraction form has been developed and the evaluation of the literature records is ongoing. Highly rated measures obtained through consensus among genetics professionals will form the core set of indicators for quality assessment of genetic services providing BRCA1/2 genetic testing.

Conclusions

The development of a standardized set of indicators for the assessment of genetics services is an essential step forward in defining common quality standards of the services in Europe. It will also facilitate direct comparisons across countries, highlighting examples of good practices and points of improvement for currently implemented genetic services.

Key messages

A minimum set of indicators for the assessment of genetics services is required to guarantee quality standards of the services across European countries. A core set of indicators will facilitate direct comparisons across European countries, underlining good practices and points of improvement for currently implemented genetic services.

A systematic review of factors influencing pregnant women’s future vaccination choices

Background

Over the last years, vaccine hesitancy has been increasing globally, leading to a decrease in vaccination coverage in several Countries, mostly in Europe. Several systematic reviews were conducted to assess the determinants of hesitancy and of vaccination choices, but none of them focused on pregnant women, which would represent an ideal population to promote correct information on vaccines.

Methods

We conducted a systematic review of studies assessing knowledge and attitudes on paediatric vaccinations, vaccination choices and their determinants among pregnant women. We searched Medline, Scopus and Web of Science, adapting search terms to the different databases, following PRISMA Statement criteria. No time limits were set.

Results

A total of 5,309 records were retrieved. After duplicates removal and title/abstract selection, 15 full texts were included in the narrative synthesis. Most studies (14/15) were quantitative surveys, 2 focused only on specific vaccines (rotavirus and HPV), 4 studies were conducted in European countries (Germany and Italy). The main factors associated with vaccine hesitancy or refusal were the fear of side effects, in particular for the most recent vaccines, the perception of a greater importance of natural immunity and a low perception of utility of vaccines, the lack of trust in health professionals, having obtained information on vaccines not from a doctor, primiparity and a low level of education (for these two last factors, with inconsistent results between studies).

Conclusions

Available evidence shows that the perceived risks and importance of vaccinations and the information received during pregnancy can influence vaccination choices of future mothers, and that the determinants of hesitancy may vary in different contexts. Pregnant women represent a key population for the implementation of interventions aimed at increasing knowledge and acceptance of vaccinations, which should be based on an analysis of the specific context.

Key messages

The perceived risks and importance of vaccinations and the information received during pregnancy can influence vaccination choices of future mothers. Interventions aimed at increasing knowledge and acceptance of vaccinations should be based on an analysis of the specific context.

Knowledge and attitudes on pediatric vaccinations and intention to vaccinate in a sample of pregnant women from the City of Rome

BACKGROUND

In recent years, pediatric immunization rates in Italy have decreased well below the recommended thresholds, largely due to an increase in scepticism about the efficacy and safety of vaccines. We aimed to identify the degree of such scepticism, and the factors driving it, among a sample of pregnant women in the City of Rome.

METHODS

We conducted a cross-sectional survey on a sample of pregnant women attending antenatal classes (CANs) in Rome through distribution of a self-administered questionnaire. Multiple logistic regression models were built to analyze the determinants of knowledge, attitudes and intention to vaccinate in this population.

RESULTS

A total of 458 pregnant women attending CANs in 36 family health centers and two hospitals in Rome answered the survey. Mean age was 32.9 (±5.0) years, and over 90% of women were in their first pregnancy. More than 26% of respondents showed a good level of knowledge of the safety and efficacy of vaccines, but there were high rates of uncertainty or agreement with some of the most common anti-vaccination sentiments. Only 75% of women were sure about vaccinating their children with the hexavalent vaccine, and 64.3% with MMR. A good level of knowledge was the strongest predictor of positive attitudes towards vaccination (OR 11.61, 95% CI 6.43-20.96), which, in turn, influenced the intention to vaccinate for most vaccines with the perception of the benefit of immunization for protection against disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Scepticism about the safety, efficacy and importance of vaccines is associated to pregnant women's hesitancy to vaccinate their children, suggesting the need to develop strategies to increase vaccine acceptance in the antenatal period. The capacity of health care professionals, particularly midwives, to correctly deliver information to future parents should be strengthened in order to reduce the spread of misinformation and fear of vaccine safety.

Patient experience and utility of genetic information: a cross-sectional study among patients tested for cancer susceptibility and thrombophilia

We evaluated whether genetic tests with evidence of clinical and personal utility (i.e. APC and BRCA1/2 tests) are associated with higher satisfaction and a more positive perception of care experience than those with undefined utility (i.e. tests for thrombophilia). A cross-sectional survey was performed through telephone interviews to patients tested for deleterious variants in APC or BRCA1/2 genes, or for inherited thrombophilia (FV Leiden and/or FIIG20210A) during a 5-year period (2008-2012). Three aspects of patient experience were assessed: effective communication through pre- and post-test genetic counselling; collaboration between caregivers on the management of patient care; and impact of genetic testing on quality of life. Overall 237 patients had telephone interviews. Multivariate logistic regression analyses showed that patients tested for APC or BRCA1/2 variants were more likely to be satisfied with both pre- and post-test counselling than those tested for inherited thrombophilia (APC vs. thrombophilia, p = 0.039 and 0.005; BRCA1/2 vs. thrombophilia, p = 0.030 and <0.001). Patients tested for APC were more likely to report an improvement in quality of life than those for thrombophilia (OR = 2.97, 95%CI 1.14, 7.72; p = 0.025). A positive association was observed between patients who underwent BRCA1/2 testing, and self-perceived improvement in quality of life (OR = 1.41, 95%CI 0.74, 2.69; p = 0.294). Tests of undefined clinical and personal utility are associated with a lower degree of patient satisfaction with genetic counselling and no clear opinions on changes in quality of life compared with those with well-defined utility.

Identification of Delivery Models for the Provision of Predictive Genetic Testing in Europe: Protocol for a Multicentre Qualitative Study and a Systematic Review of the Literature

INTRODUCTION

The appropriate application of genomic technologies in healthcare is surrounded by many concerns. In particular, there is a lack of evidence on what constitutes an optimal genetic service delivery model, which depends on the type of genetic test and healthcare context considered. The present project aims to identify, classify, and evaluate delivery models for the provision of predictive genetic testing in Europe and in selected Anglophone extra-European countries (the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand). It also sets out to survey the European public health community's readiness to incorporate public health genomics into their practice.

MATERIALS AND EQUIPMENT

The project consists of (i) a systematic review of published literature and selected country websites, (ii) structured interviews with health experts on the genetic service delivery models in their respective countries, and (iii) a survey of European Public Health Association (EUPHA) members' knowledge and attitudes toward genomics applications in clinical practice. The inclusion criteria for the systematic review are that articles be published in the period 2000-2015; be in English or Italian; and be from European countries or from Canada, the USA, Australia, or New Zealand. Additional policy documents will be retrieved from represented countries' government-affiliated websites. The results of the research will be disseminated through the EUPHA network, the Italian Network for Genomics in Public Health (GENISAP), and seminars and workshops.

EXPECTED IMPACT OF THE STUDY ON PUBLIC HEALTH

The transfer of genomic technologies from research to clinical application is influenced not only by several factors inherent to research goals and delivery of healthcare but also by external and commercial interests that may cause the premature introduction of genetic tests in the public and private sectors. Furthermore, current genetic services are delivered without a standardized set of process and outcome measures, which makes the evaluation of healthcare services difficult. The present study will identify and classify delivery models and, subsequently, establish which are appropriate for the provision of predictive genetic testing in Europe by comparing sets of process and outcome measures. In this way, the study will provide a basis for future recommendations to decision makers involved in the financing, delivery, and consumption of genetic services.

Quality and relevance of master degree education for the professional development of nurses and midwives

BACKGROUND

Advanced education in nursing is essential to provide safe, high quality and efficient health services in line with population needs. However, there is an almost complete lack of studies on how nurses view the usefulness of post-graduate education for their current employment and for professional advancement.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate how nurse graduates view the quality, relevance and applicability of the knowledge and skills acquired during the Master of Science in Nursing (MSN) degree.

DESIGN

Multicentre cross-sectional study.

METHODS

A multicenter cross-sectional study was carried out through an online questionnaire mailed (July 2014-June 2015) to 560 nurses who obtained the MSN degree from 23 Italian universities in the academic year 2010-2011.

DISCUSSION

A total of 426 nurses completed the survey (response rate 76.1%), 80% of whom believed they had acquired knowledge and skills useful in their professional life after graduation. A multiple logistic regression model highlighted the characteristics of nurse graduates who judged the master's course relevant for their present role. In brief, they are expert nurses (OR=3.41, 95% CI=1.54-7.54) who achieved professional growth after the course (OR=5.25, 95% CI=2.67-10.33) and who judged the course very good or excellent (OR=2.16, 95% CI=1.04-4.52). Only 8% of the respondents achieved a full professional growth after the course.

CONCLUSION

In Italy, MSN courses are able to provide a high level of skills and competencies. However, given the low rate of professional growth after the course, specific policies should increase the employment rates of new master's graduate nurses.

Which BRCA genetic testing programs are ready for implementation in health care? A systematic review of economic evaluations

PURPOSE

There is considerable evidence regarding the efficacy and effectiveness of BRCA genetic testing programs, but whether they represent good use of financial resources is not clear. Therefore, we aimed to identify the main health-care programs for BRCA testing and to evaluate their cost-effectiveness.

METHODS

We performed a systematic review of full economic evaluations of health-care programs involving BRCA testing.

RESULTS

Nine economic evaluations were included, and four main categories of BRCA testing programs were identified: (i) population-based genetic screening of individuals without cancer, either comprehensive or targeted based on ancestry; (ii) family history (FH)-based genetic screening, i.e., testing individuals without cancer but with FH suggestive of BRCA mutation; (iii) familial mutation (FM)-based genetic screening, i.e., testing individuals without cancer but with known familial BRCA mutation; and (iv) cancer-based genetic screening, i.e., testing individuals with BRCA-related cancers.

CONCLUSIONS

Currently BRCA1/2 population-based screening represents good value for the money among Ashkenazi Jews only. FH-based screening is potentially very cost-effective, although further studies that include costs of identifying high-risk women are needed. There is no evidence of cost-effectiveness for BRCA screening of all newly diagnosed cases of breast/ovarian cancers followed by cascade testing of relatives, but programs that include tools for identifying affected women at higher risk for inherited forms are promising. Cost-effectiveness is highly sensitive to the cost of BRCA1/2 testing.Genet Med 18 12, 1171-1180.

Low level of attention to health inequalities in prevention planning activities of the Italian Regions

Background

Health promotion and prevention activities should tackle health inequalities to reduce disparities in health among disadvantaged populations. This study aimed to assess the extent to which the Italian Regions considered health inequalities during the planning of prevention activities, to detect geographical differences and to identify the possible determinants of differences in attention to health inequalities.

Methods

The 19 Regional Prevention Plans (RPPs) developed by Italian Regions within the National Prevention Plan (NPP) 2010–2013 were assessed using a specific tool to address the level of attention to health inequalities. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to identify regional characteristics associated with a higher level of attention to health inequalities.

Results

Of the 702 projects included in the 19 RPPs, only 56 (8.0 %) specifically addressed issues related to health inequalities. The results of the multivariate analysis showed that a higher level of attention was associated with the macroarea of intervention ‘prevention in high-risk groups’, with the higher quality of the Strategic Plan Section of the RPP and with the higher percentage of migrants in the Region in 2010. Moreover, projects that addressed the topic of health inequalities were more likely to be developed in the Northern Regions, in Regions with a lower level of ‘linking social capital’ and with a Higher Regional Health Care Expenditure (RHCE) as a percentage of Regional Gross Domestic Product (RGDP) in 2010.

Conclusions

The level of attention to health inequalities in the regional planning process of prevention activities 2010–2013 in Italy is low. The results of this study supported the new round of prevention planning in Italy, and highlight the urgent need to increase the number of policies and interventions able to reduce health inequalities.

[Online communication regarding health promotion and protection: the public health perspective]

Currently web health portals are moving away from providing institutional and administrative types of information towards a more interactive type of communication focused on providing citizens and health care professionals various services associated with health promotion and on facilitating access to healthcare services. The aim of this study was to provide guidance in the planning and conduction of online health promotion and protection communication activities that will contribute to the process of community empowerment repeatedly called upon by the WHO. For this purpose, the authors conducted an analysis of the epidemiology of the determinants of health and disease in Italy as well as two systematic revisions of the literature regarding web-based health information needs of citizens and the efficacy of health promotion and preventative interventions administered via the internet. Although current scientific evidence suggests that some interventions (e.g. expert systems or tailored interventions) are more effective with respect to others (e.g. online support groups or other types of interventions), common sense suggests that public health computer platforms such as the " citizens' channel" of the Ministry of Health web portal should implement hybrid models, i.e. models that contain various types of interventions, and should provide access to both general information and to interactive and personalized programs.