Procedure-specific simulation for vaginal surgery training: A randomized controlled trial

INTRODUCTION

Vaginal surgery has a superior outcome profile compared with other surgical routes, yet skills are declining because of low case volumes. Graduating residents' confidence and preparedness for vaginal surgery has plummeted in the past decade. The objective of the present study was to investigate whether procedure-specific simulation skills, versus usual training, result in improved operative competence.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We completed a randomized controlled trial of didactic and procedural training via low fidelity vaginal surgery models for anterior repair, posterior repair (PR), vaginal hysterectomy (VH), recruiting novice gynecology residents at three academic centers. We evaluated performance via global rating scale (GRS) in the real operating room and for corresponding procedures by attending surgeon blinded to group. Prespecified secondary outcomes included procedural steps knowledge, overall performance, satisfaction, self-confidence and intraoperative parameters. A priori sample size estimated 50 residents (20% absolute difference in GRS score, 25% SD, 80% power, alpha 0.05).

CLINICALTRIALS

gov: Registration no. NCT05887570.

RESULTS

We randomized 83 residents to intervention or control and 55 completed the trial (2011-23). Baseline characteristics were similar, except for more fourth-year control residents. After adjustment of confounders (age, level, baseline knowledge), GRS scores showed significant differences overall (mean difference 8.2; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.2-16.1; p = 0.044) and for VH (mean difference 12.0; 95% CI: 1.8-22.3; p = 0.02). The intervention group had significantly higher procedural steps knowledge and self-confidence for VH and/or PR (p < 0.05, adjusted analysis). Estimated blood loss, operative time and complications were similar between groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to usual training, procedure-specific didactic and low fidelity simulation modules for vaginal surgery resulted in significant improvements in operative performance and several other skill parameters.

Summative Evaluation of Vaginal Surgery Skills: Setting A Pass-Fail Score

INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS

We developed a summative assessment tool to evaluate competent performance on three procedure-specific low fidelity simulation models for vaginal surgery. Our purpose was to determine a pass-fail score for each model.

METHODS

We enrolled participants (2011-2023, three Canadian academic centers) and grouped them according to operative competency in vaginal procedures. Novice operators were medical students recruited through targeted advertisement to clerkship level medical students. Proficient operators consisted of gynecology residents from the intervention arm of a randomized controlled trial, trained to competence in the use of the models; urogynecology fellows and attending gynecologic surgeons recruited through departmental rounds. All participants were asked to perform the three procedures on the models, were videotaped, and their performance assessed by evaluators familiar with the procedure and the scoring system, blinded to operator identity. A total performance score (range 0-400) assessed timing and errors. Basic skill deductions were set a priori. We calculated sensitivity and specificity scores and obtained an optimal cutoff based on Youden's J statistic.

RESULTS

For anterior repair, we rated 46 novice and 16 proficient videos. The pass-fail score was 170/400. For posterior repair, we rated 54 novice and 14 proficient videos. The pass-fail score was 140/400. For vaginal hysterectomy, we rated 47 novice and 12 proficient videos. The pass-fail score was 180/400. Scores of proficient operators were significantly better than those of novice participants (p < 0.001 for all).

CONCLUSIONS

A pass-fail score can distinguish between novice and proficient operators and can be used for summative assessment of surgical skill.

Reducing urinary tract infection in female pelvic surgery: A retrospective cohort study

OBJECTIVE

To compare prebundle versus postbundle implementation urinary tract infection (UTI) rates among inpatients within 6 weeks of clean-contaminated pelvic reconstructive surgery.

METHODS

The authors conducted a retrospective cohort study from September 2019 to December 2021 at a tertiary hospital. The bundle strategy included the following: universal preoperative UTI check with treatment if positive, replacing prolonged postoperative voiding trials on the ward with earlier discharge and indwelling catheter removal by a nurse continence advisor the next day, and daily cranberry extract for 6 weeks postoperatively. UTI was defined as positive urine culture (≥100 000 colony-forming unit per mL) in a symptomatic patient. Data analysis involved hypothesis testing and logistic regression.

RESULTS

The authors reviewed 132 postbundle inpatient charts and retained 93 for analyses. The results were compared with 204 prebundle inpatient charts. The rate of postoperative UTI decreased from 17.6% in the prebundle group to 6.5% after bundle implementation (P = 0.01). The adjusted odds ratio for postbundle versus prebundle likelihood of UTI was 0.35 (95% confidence interval, 0.13-0.98; P = 0.045). Significantly more postbundle patients compared with prebundle patients were discharged home on the first day postoperatively (76.3% vs. 37.7%, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

A clinical bundle can significantly decrease both UTI rates and hospital stay after pelvic reconstructive surgery.

Cannabis use preferences in women with myofascial pelvic pain: A cross-sectional study

Objective

Myofascial tenderness is present in most chronic pelvic pain conditions and causes significant distress to patients. Treatment is challenging and often not curative. Cannabis is often used for self-management of chronic pelvic pain. However, we do not know which concentrations and routes of administration are most acceptable to users. We aimed to investigate patterns and willingness of cannabis product use among both habitual users and non-users with myofascial pelvic pain (MPP), to inform therapeutic development.

Study design

We conducted a cross-sectional study of questionnaire responses from female patients with MPP from two tertiary pelvic pain centers. We aimed for a convenience sample of 100 responses with representation from both centers. Inclusion criteria were age over 18 with pelvic floor muscle tenderness on standard gynecologic examination. We collected information on demographics, pelvic pain history, cannabis use status, cannabis use preferences, validated opioid misuse risk assessment, and interest in using gynecologic cannabis products and used descriptive analyses.

Results

77/135 (57 %) questionnaire respondents were cannabis users and 58 (43 %) were non-users. Most users consume cannabis daily, (48.1 %) orally (66.2 %) or by smoking (60.7 %), and rated cannabis as effective at relieving pelvic pain. 37/58 (63.8 %) non-cannabis users responded that they would be willing to use cannabis for pelvic pain. Lack of information and potential adverse effects were the most common reasons for unwillingness to use. Approximately 3 of 4 respondents were willing to try vaginal or vulvar application of cannabis products for pelvic pain.

Conclusions

This cross-sectional study describes cannabis use patterns in MPP patients. Topical vulvar and vaginal cannabis products are of strong interest to both cannabis users and non-users and warrant further research.

Risk factors for urinary retention after urogynecologic surgery: A retrospective cohort study and prediction model

AIMS

Postoperative urinary retention (POUR) is a common complication of urogynecological surgery. Our study aimed to identify demographic and perioperative risk factors to construct a prediction model for POUR in urogynecology.

METHODS

Our retrospective cohort study reviewed all patients undergoing pelvic reconstructive surgeries at our tertiary care center (Jan 1, 2013-May 1, 2019). Demographic, pre-, intra- and postoperative variables were collected from medical records. The primary outcome, POUR, was defined as (1) early POUR (E-POUR), failing initial trial of void or; (2) late POUR (L-POUR), requiring an indwelling catheter or intermittent catheterization on discharge. Risk factors were identified through univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses. A clinical prediction model was constructed with the most significant and clinically relevant risk factors.

RESULTS

In 501 women, 182 (36.3%) had E-POUR and 61 of these women (12.2% of the entire cohort) had L-POUR. Multivariate logistic regression revealed preoperative postvoid residual (PVR) over 200 ml (odds ratio [OR]: 3.17; p = 0.026), voiding dysfunction symptoms extracted from validated questionnaires (OR: 3.00; p = 0.030), and number of concomitant procedures (OR: 1.30 per procedure; p = 0.021) as significant predictors of E-POUR; preoperative PVR more than 200 ml (OR: 4.07; p = 0.011) and antiincontinence procedure with (OR: 3.34; p = 0.023) and without (OR: 2.64; p = 0.019) concomitant prolapse repair as significant predictors of L-POUR. A prediction model (area under the curve: 0.70) was developed for E-POUR.

CONCLUSIONS

Elevated preoperative PVR is the most significant risk factor for POUR. Alongside other risk factors, our prediction model for POUR can be used for patient counseling and surgical planning in urogynecologic surgery.

Preoperative Depression and Anxiety Impact on Inpatient Surgery Outcomes: A Prospective Cohort Study

Objectives

To determine the association of preoperative mood symptoms and postoperative adverse outcomes; to explore sex-specific differences.

Background

Depression and anxiety can increase postoperative mortality. Psychological stress is associated with a chronic inflammatory response unfavorable to postsurgical healing.

Methods

Prospective cohort study. Patients were recruited from surgical preadmission clinics at a university hospital. Preoperative depression and anxiety were measured via the Beck Depression and Beck Anxiety Inventories (BDI-II and BAI). Our primary outcome was a composite of postoperative complications, extended length of stay (ELOS) and early readmission. Associated variables included demographics, preoperative pain, pain tolerance/catastrophizing, coping mechanisms, postoperative pain, and opioid use. We adjusted for age, comorbidities, and surgical specialty.

Results

Of 1061 recruited patients (ten surgical specialties, 2015-2020), 455 males and 486 females had preoperative and postoperative data available. Mean age was 62.9 (range 20.2-96.2). At baseline, 9.3% of patients had moderate or severe depression; 7.4% had moderate or severe anxiety. Females were more likely to be moderately or severely depressed (11% vs 7%, P = 0.036) and moderately or severely anxious (9% vs 6%, P = 0.034). Females had significantly fewer reported comorbidities and lower American Society of Anesthesiologists category (P < 0.001). Increasing BDI-II and BAI scores significantly increased likelihood of postoperative complications, ELOS, and/or hospital readmission in females (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] = 2.57 for BDI-II 1-19 vs 0, P = 0.041; aOR = 4.48 for BDI-II > 19 vs 0, P = 0.008; aOR = 1.54 for BAI ≤ 6 vs >6, P = 0.038) but not in males. Mood symptoms did not influence postoperative pain or opioid use.

Conclusion

Preoperative depression and anxiety negatively impact surgical outcomes in female patients undergoing major surgery.

Urinary tract infection after clean-contaminated pelvic surgery: a retrospective cohort study and prediction model

INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS

Postoperative urinary tract infection (UTI) leads to increased patient morbidity and health care costs. A prediction model may identify patients at highest risk for UTI development. Our primary objective was to determine the rate of UTI in the first 6 weeks after benign gynecologic surgery. Our secondary objective was to identify risk factors and build a predictive model for postoperative UTI.

METHODS

We reviewed 310 patient records, which represent all patients who underwent clean-contaminated surgery at a tertiary center (2016-2017). UTI was defined as positive urine culture (> 100,000,000 CFU/l) in a symptomatic patient. Pre-, intra- and postoperative variables were collected. The relation between these variables and UTI was assessed through logistic regression. A clinical prediction model was built.

RESULTS

Patients' mean age was 58.5 years and mean body mass index was 27.5 kg/m². Most were inpatients (65.8%) and 269 had urogynecologic procedures, with the remainder undergoing pelvic surgery for other indications. The most common operation was vaginal reconstruction for prolapse (59.7%), associated with concomitant synthetic midurethral sling in 1/3 cases. Forty patients (12.9%) developed UTI. Multivariate prediction modeling showed increasing age (OR 1.33, CI 1.01-1.75), increasing number of procedures (OR 1.42, CI 1.14-1.78) and prolonged voiding dysfunction (OR 3.78, CI 1.66-8.60) to be significant UTI predictors.

CONCLUSIONS

Urinary tract infection in the first 6 weeks after complex pelvic surgery is common. Our prediction model identifies that patients who are older women, have prolonged voiding dysfunction and have a greater number of concomitant pelvic floor surgeries have higher risk of postoperative UTI.

Pregnancy-Associated Pelvic Floor Health Knowledge and Reduction of Symptoms: The PREPARED Randomized Controlled Trial

OBJECTIVES

Pregnancy and childbirth can lead to pelvic floor disorders, yet this topic is not routine in antenatal education. We aimed to determine the impact of a pregnancy workshop on women's postpartum pelvic floor health knowledge, performance of pelvic floor muscle exercises (PFME), symptoms, condition-specific quality of life, mode of delivery, and satisfaction.

METHODS

This was a RCT. Pregnant primiparous women in a tertiary care centre received a pelvic floor health workshop intervention versus routine prenatal care. Thirty-six participants/group were needed to detect a significant knowledge difference (power = 0.80, α = 0.05). Participants completed questionnaires at recruitment and six weeks postpartum. Main outcome measures were: difference between groups in knowledge scores; PFME-specific knowledge and practice; pelvic symptoms and condition-specific quality of life; and mode of and satisfaction with delivery.

RESULTS

Fifty women were recruited per group; 40 attended the workshop. Women were Caucasian (72%), college educated (96%), mean age 33.2. Mean demographics did not differ. Postpartum data were available for 37 women per group. The intervention group scored higher on a pelvic floor knowledge questionnaire (mean score 31.2/39 vs. 29.3/39, P = 0.02, 95% CI 0.3, 3.6). 58.3% of intervention participants reported daily performance of PFME compared with 22.9% of controls (P = 0.002) and rated higher confidence in correct performance (P = 0.004). The intervention group reported fewer bowel symptoms (P = 0.046). There were no differences in urinary or prolapse symptoms, mode of delivery, complications, or satisfaction.

CONCLUSION

A pelvic floor health workshop improves postpartum knowledge, performance of PFME, and bowel-specific quality of life.

Study of Prolapse-Induced Cervical Elongation

OBJECTIVE

The cervix often appears to be elongated in women with pelvic organ prolapse (POP). This can pose surgical challenges. MRI evidence has suggested that prolapsed cervices are significantly longer than those in normal controls. Our objective was to compare cervical length in surgical hysterectomy specimens from women with symptomatic POP with the length in specimens from women with other benign gynaecological conditions.

METHODS

In this pilot, prospective, case-control study, hysterectomy specimens were collected at St. Paul's Hospital, Vancouver, BC, between 2013 and 2015. Recorded patient demographics were age at the time of hysterectomy, any prior history of cervical dysplasia, and reason for hysterectomy. Specimens from women in whom the indication for hysterectomy was POP were compared with the specimens from women with other benign gynaecological conditions. Specimens were excluded if there was a history of cervical dysplasia because we could not verify whether women had undergone previous procedures resulting in cervical shortening. After bivalving each uterus, cervical and total uterine lengths were measured by staff pathologists, and the ratios of cervical length to total uterine length were calculated. Measurements in the two hysterectomy groups were compared using linear regression.

RESULTS

Seventy-seven specimens were collected, 52 from women with POP and 25 from women without POP. The most common indication for hysterectomy in women without POP was uterine fibroids. Women with POP were on average older than women without POP (mean 58.5 years vs. 47.8 years, P < 0.001). The ratio of cervical length to total uterine length in women with POP was 0.10 higher (95% CI 0.03, 0.16; P = 0.005) than in women without POP.

CONCLUSION

Women with symptomatic POP have significantly higher ratios of cervical length to total uterine length than women without POP.

Teaching Vaginal Surgery to Junior Residents: Initial Validation of 3 Novel Procedure-Specific Low-Fidelity Models

OBJECTIVE

Competency-based surgical education relies on operative models to teach surgical skills within a curriculum. Low fidelity simulation has been shown to improve surgical performance. Our objectives were: to develop procedure-specific models to teach anterior repair (AR), posterior repair (PR), and vaginal hysterectomy (VH) to junior residents; to establish model reliability and validity.

DESIGN

Residents were randomized to control (no training) and intervention (model training) groups. They were filmed while performing a series of tasks. Experts were also filmed. Each video was scored by 2 blinded raters.

SETTING

Multicenter collaboration within the Western Society of Pelvic Medicine (Vancouver, Calgary, and Edmonton). Face and content validity were evaluated. A standard scoring tool was developed for performance evaluation. Interrater reliability was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficient. Cronbach α was calculated for internal consistency. Jonckheere-Terpstra test verified whether the scores increased with operator skill level.

PARTICIPANTS

A total of 14 junior gynecology residents, 2 urogynecology fellows, and 3 staff urogynecologists were rated by a total of 6 gynecologic surgeons who scored 42 videos each.

RESULTS

Experienced pelvic surgeons from 3 participating sites agreed the models captured essential elements of real surgical skills (face validity) and of the true procedures (content validity). Intraclass correlation coefficient was adequate (AR = 0.86, PR = 0.90, and VH = 0.87). Cronbach α for the total scores was adequate (AR = 0.85, PR = 0.8, and VH = 0.71). Performance score increased with operator skill level for all 3 procedures (AR, p = <0.001; PR, p = 0.008; and VH, p = 0.007).

CONCLUSIONS

Our low fidelity procedure-specific vaginal surgery models had adequate initial validity. Future research will investigate transferability of acquired skills to the operating room.