Breaking Bad Proteins-Discovery Approaches and the Road to Clinic for Degraders

Proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs) describe compounds that bind to and induce degradation of a target by simultaneously binding to a ubiquitin ligase. More generally referred to as bifunctional degraders, PROTACs have led the way in the field of targeted protein degradation (TPD), with several compounds currently undergoing clinical testing. Alongside bifunctional degraders, single-moiety compounds, or molecular glue degraders (MGDs), are increasingly being considered as a viable approach for development of therapeutics, driven by advances in rational discovery approaches. This review focuses on drug discovery with respect to bifunctional and molecular glue degraders within the ubiquitin proteasome system, including analysis of mechanistic concepts and discovery approaches, with an overview of current clinical and pre-clinical degrader status in oncology, neurodegenerative and inflammatory disease.

Cryo-EM reveals important regulatory mechanism of the workhorses of targeted protein degradation

Most methods for targeted protein degradation (TPD) deliver targets to E3 ubiquitin ligases, leading to proteasomal degradation. In this issue of Molecular Cell, Shaaban et al.¹ illuminate cullin-RING ubiquitin ligase (CRL) modulation by CAND1, which can be utilized for TPD.

Abstract 3429: Beyond cereblon IMIDs - biophysics-based discovery of novel molecular glue chemotypes

Molecular glue degraders are compact, low molecular weight molecules that can efficiently induce specific and potent degradation of a target protein. This class of degraders function by inducing interactions between a target of interest and a ubiquitin-ligase, either by stabilization of weak pre-existing interactions, or by generation of entirely novel interactions. These molecules offer significant opportunity beyond heterobifunctional degraders such as PROTACs, not least in terms of improved molecular properties.

However, beyond the IMID molecular glues, typified by thalidomide, pomalidomide and lenalidomide, novel molecular glue chemotypes remain scarce.

To address this need, we have developed biophysics-based molecular glue screening platform, exploiting our internal, high quality fragment library and proximity-based screening platforms to rapidly identify promising new molecular glues for further optimization. A potential advantage of utilizing cell-free biophysical systems is the opportunity to select both the target and the desired ligase, opening up for development of degraders that capitalize upon differential expression of ligases in different tissues.

As proof of concept, we have applied this platform to find new molecular glues to degrade CK1α. This Ser/Thr kinase has been found to be over-expressed in metastatic colorectal cancer, and this over-expression correlates with poor overall survival. The kinase has also been implicated as an oncogenic driver in tumors such as B-Cell lymphomas and non-Hodgkin lymphomas, suggesting a potential therapeutic application for novel CK1α molecular glues.

Utilizing known IMID-derived molecular glues between CK1α and CRBN as benchmark controls, we identified several non-IMID derived chemotypes as tentative stabilizers of the CRBN/CK1α interaction. Further studies on these novel candidate degrader templates are now underway.

Citation Format: Yujia Zhang, Jessica Bates, Benoit Gourdet, Louise Birch, Philip Addis, Roland Hjerpe, Allan M. Jordan. Beyond cereblon IMIDs - biophysics-based discovery of novel molecular glue chemotypes [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2023; Part 1 (Regular and Invited Abstracts); 2023 Apr 14-19; Orlando, FL. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2023;83(7_Suppl):Abstract nr 3429.

U1A is a positive regulator of the expression of heterologous and cellular genes involved in cell proliferation and migration

Here, we show that direct recruitment of U1A to target transcripts can increase gene expression. This is a new regulatory role, in addition to previous knowledge showing that U1A decreases the levels of U1A mRNA and other specific targets. In fact, genome-wide, U1A more often increases rather than represses gene expression and many U1A-upregulated transcripts are directly bound by U1A according to individual nucleotide resolution crosslinking and immunoprecipitation (iCLIP) studies. Interestingly, U1A-mediated positive regulation can be transferred to a heterologous system for biotechnological purposes. Finally, U1A-bound genes are enriched for those involved in cell cycle and adhesion. In agreement with this, higher U1A mRNA expression associates with lower disease-free survival and overall survival in many cancer types, and U1A mRNA levels positively correlate with those of some oncogenes involved in cell proliferation. Accordingly, U1A depletion leads to decreased expression of these genes and the migration-related gene CCN2/CTGF, which shows the strongest regulation by U1A. A decrease in U1A causes a strong drop in CCN2 expression and CTGF secretion and defects in the expression of CTGF EMT targets, cell migration, and proliferation. These results support U1A as a putative therapeutic target for cancer treatment. In addition, U1A-binding sequences should be considered in biotechnological applications.

Unanchored tri-NEDD8 inhibits PARP-1 to protect from oxidative stress-induced cell death

NEDD8 is a ubiquitin‐like protein that activates cullin‐RING E3 ubiquitin ligases (CRLs). Here, we identify a novel role for NEDD8 in regulating the activity of poly(ADP‐ribose) polymerase 1 (PARP‐1) in response to oxidative stress. We show that treatment of cells with H₂O₂ results in the accumulation of NEDD8 chains, likely by directly inhibiting the deneddylase NEDP1. One chain type, an unanchored NEDD8 trimer, specifically bound to the second zinc finger domain of PARP‐1 and attenuated its activation. In cells in which Nedp1 is deleted, large amounts of tri‐NEDD8 constitutively form, resulting in inhibition of PARP‐1 and protection from PARP‐1‐dependent cell death. Surprisingly, these NEDD8 trimers are additionally acetylated, as shown by mass spectrometry analysis, and their binding to PARP‐1 is reduced by the overexpression of histone de‐acetylases, which rescues PARP‐1 activation. Our data suggest that trimeric, acetylated NEDD8 attenuates PARP‐1 activation after oxidative stress, likely to delay the initiation of PARP‐1‐dependent cell death.

UBQLN2 Mediates Autophagy-Independent Protein Aggregate Clearance by the Proteasome

Clearance of misfolded and aggregated proteins is central to cell survival. Here, we describe a new pathway for maintaining protein homeostasis mediated by the proteasome shuttle factor UBQLN2. The 26S proteasome degrades polyubiquitylated substrates by recognizing them through stoichiometrically bound ubiquitin receptors, but substrates are also delivered by reversibly bound shuttles. We aimed to determine why these parallel delivery mechanisms exist and found that UBQLN2 acts with the HSP70-HSP110 disaggregase machinery to clear protein aggregates via the 26S proteasome. UBQLN2 recognizes client-bound HSP70 and links it to the proteasome to allow for the degradation of aggregated and misfolded proteins. We further show that this process is active in the cell nucleus, where another system for aggregate clearance, autophagy, does not act. Finally, we found that mutations in UBQLN2, which lead to neurodegeneration in humans, are defective in chaperone binding, impair aggregate clearance, and cause cognitive deficits in mice.

•

UBQLN2 clears aggregates independent of autophagy via HSP70 and the proteasome

•

A disease mutation in UBQLN2 prevents its binding to HSP70

•

Mutant UBQLN2 is defective in clearance of aggregates in vivo

•

UBQLN2 knockin mice develop cognitive impairment and brain pathology

Tetramerization-defects of p53 result in aberrant ubiquitylation and transcriptional activity

The tumor suppressor p53 regulates the expression of genes involved in cell cycle progression, senescence and apoptosis. Here, we investigated the effect of single point mutations in the oligomerization domain (OD) on tetramerization, transcription, ubiquitylation and stability of p53. As predicted by docking and molecular dynamics simulations, p53 OD mutants show functional defects on transcription, Mdm2-dependent ubiquitylation and 26S proteasome-mediated degradation. However, mutants unable to form tetramers are well degraded by the 20S proteasome. Unexpectedly, despite the lower structural stability compared to WT p53, p53 OD mutants form heterotetramers with WT p53 when expressed transiently or stably in cells wild type or null for p53. In consequence, p53 OD mutants interfere with the capacity of WT p53 tetramers to be properly ubiquitylated and result in changes of p53-dependent protein expression patterns, including the pro-apoptotic proteins Bax and PUMA under basal and adriamycin-induced conditions. Importantly, the patient derived p53 OD mutant L330R (OD1) showed the more severe changes in p53-dependent gene expression. Thus, in addition to the well-known effects on p53 stability, ubiquitylation defects promote changes in p53-dependent gene expression with implications on some of its functions.

Heterologous SUMO-2/3-ubiquitin chains optimize IκBα degradation and NF-κB activity

The NF-κB pathway is regulated by SUMOylation at least at three levels: the inhibitory molecule IκBα, the IKK subunit γ/NEMO and the p52 precursor p100. Here we investigate the role of SUMO-2/3 in the degradation of IκBα and activation of NF-κB mediated by TNFα. We found that under conditions of deficient SUMOylation, an important delay in both TNFα-mediated proteolysis of IκBα and NF-κB dependent transcription occurs. In vitro and ex vivo approaches, including the use of ubiquitin-traps (TUBEs), revealed the formation of chains on IκBα containing SUMO-2/3 and ubiquitin after TNFα stimulation. The integration of SUMO-2/3 appears to promote the formation of ubiquitin chains on IκBα after activation of the TNFα signalling pathway. Furthermore, heterologous chains of SUMO-2/3 and ubiquitin promote a more efficient degradation of IκBα by the 26S proteasome in vitro compared to chains of either SUMO-2/3 or ubiquitin alone. Consistently, Ubc9 silencing reduced the capture of IκBα modified with SUMO-ubiquitin hybrid chains that display a defective proteasome-mediated degradation. Thus, hybrid SUMO-2/3-ubiquitin chains increase the susceptibility of modified IκBα to the action of 26S proteasome, contributing to the optimal control of NF-κB activity after TNFα-stimulation.

NEDD8 overexpression results in neddylation of ubiquitin substrates by the ubiquitin pathway

Ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like proteins use unique E1, E2, and E3 enzymes for conjugation to their substrates. We and others have recently reported that increases in the relative concentration of the ubiquitin-like protein NEDD8 over ubiquitin lead to activation of NEDD8 by the ubiquitin E1 enzyme. We now show that this results in erroneous conjugation of NEDD8 to ubiquitin substrates, such as p53, Caspase 7, and Hif1α, demonstrating that overexpression of NEDD8 is not appropriate for identification of substrates of the NEDD8 pathway.

Isolation of ubiquitylated proteins using tandem ubiquitin-binding entities

Studying postubiquitylation events has always been a difficult task due to the labile nature of these posttranslational modifications. When utilized in tandem, ubiquitin-binding entities (TUBEs) not only increase up to thousand times the affinity for poly-ubiquitin chains but also protect ubiquitylated proteins from the action of the proteasome and de-ubiquitylating enzymes.

Sumoylation modulates the activity of Spalt-like proteins during wing development in Drosophila

The Spalt-like family of zinc finger transcription factors is conserved throughout evolution and is involved in fundamental processes during development and during embryonic stem cell maintenance. Although human SALL1 is modified by SUMO-1 in vitro, it is not known whether this post-translational modification plays a role in regulating the activity of this family of transcription factors. Here, we show that the Drosophila Spalt transcription factors are modified by sumoylation. This modification influences their nuclear localization and capacity to induce vein formation through the regulation of target genes during wing development. Furthermore, spalt genes interact genetically with the sumoylation machinery to repress vein formation in intervein regions and to attain the wing final size. Our results suggest a new level of regulation of Sall activity in vivo during animal development through post-translational modification by sumoylation. The evolutionary conservation of this family of transcription factors suggests a functional role for sumoylation in vertebrate Sall members.

Oligomerization conditions Mdm2-mediated efficient p53 polyubiquitylation but not its proteasomal degradation

In normal cells p53 is maintained at low level through the action of the ubiquitin-proteasome system. As a consequence of p53 transcriptional activity, various regulators of this tumor suppressor are produced, forming a negative feedback loop tightly controlling p53 stability. One of the most prominent is the ubiquitin-ligase Mdm2. Here, we have used a transfer of signals strategy to study the p53 degradation process promoted by Mdm2 in the absence of p53 transcriptional activity. Our results show that in a p53 null background, transcriptionally silent p53-fusions require multiple N- and C-terminal signals to be optimally targeted to proteasomal degradation. As for WT p53, p53-fusions able to form tetramers are polyubiquitylated and optimally degraded by the proteasome. However, p53 molecules unable to oligomerize, show Mdm2-mediated polyubiquitylation deficiency but are still targeted to proteasome degradation in vitro and ex vivo. In the presence of Mdm2, nuclear shuttling of p53 monomeric fusions favours proteasome-dependent degradability but not its polyubiquitylation. In vitro, 26S proteasome fails to drive degradation of OD mutants in the presence of Mdm2, suggesting the contribution of additional cellular factors in this process. All together, our results indicate that Mdm2-mediated proteasome-dependent degradation of polyubiquitylation deficient p53 monomers is mechanistically possible, taking alternative pathways to better achieve their proteolysis. These results support the existence of additional levels to regulate p53 stability and activity acting on individual subunits of the functional tetramer.

Alternative UPS drug targets upstream the 26S proteasome

The successful use of proteasome inhibitors in anti-cancer therapy encouraged the development of new drugs targeting the activity of the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS) at various levels. The UPS comprises a complex set of protein adaptors whose coordinated function modulates the interaction of ubiquitin-modified proteins with protein effectors. In addition, UPS crosstalk with other post-translational modifications, complicates a sophisticated set of conjugation and de-conjugation pathways, providing a large variety of potential targets for the development of specific inhibitors. Traditionally associated with the proteasome, ubiquitin-conjugation does not always result in protein degradation. The major signal that targets proteins for degradation is the formation of ubiquitin-chains on lysine 48 (K48). Other ubiquitin features such as K63 chains or mono-ubiquitylation appear to regulate the transient formation of functional macromolecular complexes or relocate modified proteins inside the cell. The emerging idea that UPS-mediated degradation participates not only in the initiation but also in the termination step of certain functions, highlights new potential drug targets upstream the 26S proteasome. This review underlines some of these, in particular, possibilities for intervention before the recognition of substrates by the ubiquitin-conjugating enzymes and after the conjugation of target proteins with ubiquitin. To illustrate possible therapeutic targets at the level of transcription, subcellular distribution and signal transduction pathways, NF-kappaB and p53 have been used as main examples in this review.