The potential radio-immunotherapeutic α-emitter 227Th - part I: Standardisation via primary liquid scintillation techniques and decay progeny ingrowth measurements

Thorium-227 is a potential therapeutic radionuclide for applications in targeted α-radioimmunotherapy for the treatment of various types of cancer. To provide nuclear medicine departments involved in Phase I clinical trials traceability to the SI unit of radioactivity (Bq), a standardisation of a radiochemically pure ²²⁷Th aqueous solution has been performed at the National Physical Laboratory. This was achieved via two primary liquid scintillation (LS) techniques -4π(LS)-γ digital coincidence counting (DCC) and 4π LS counting. These absolute techniques were supported by the indirect determination of the ²²⁷Th activity via the measurement of the ingrowth and decay rate of the decay progeny by both ionisations chambers and high purity germanium (HPGe) gamma-ray spectrometry. The results of the primary techniques were found to be consistent, both with each other (zeta score = 1.1) and to the decay progeny ingrowth measurements. An activity per unit mass of 20.726 (51) kBq g^-1 was determined for the solution. A procedure has been developed that provided an effective separation of the ²²⁷Th from its decay progeny, which was shown by the effective time zero of the ²²⁷Th-²²³Ra nuclear chronometer measured by HPGe gamma-ray spectrometry.

Evaluation of the separation and purification of 227Th from its decay progeny by anion exchange and extraction chromatography

Thorium-227 is currently undergoing evaluation as a potential radionuclide for targeted cancer therapy, and as such a high chemical purity of the material is required. To establish a reliable procedure for radiochemical isolation of ²²⁷Th from the parent ²²⁷Ac and decay progeny, which includes the radiotherapeutic ²²³Ra, the performance of three different separation schemes based on ion-exchange and extraction chromatography have been evaluated. The results suggest that both ion exchange and extraction chromatographic techniques can be successfully used for the separation of ²²⁷Th from its decay progeny, however extraction chromatographic resins demonstrate favourable performance in terms of Th recovery and purification from radionuclide impurities.

Fundamental uncertainty equations for nuclear dating applied to the 140Ba-140La and 227Th-223Ra chronometers

Basic equations for age dating through activity ratio measurements are presented and applied to nuclear chronometers based on parent-daughter decay. Uncertainty propagation formulae are derived which relate the relative uncertainty on the half-lives and measured activity ratios with the relative uncertainty on the calculated time of a nuclear event. Particular attention is paid to the case of relatively short-lived radionuclides for which the change in decay rate during the measurement is non-negligible. Mathematical solutions are presented to correct the perceived activity ratio and adapt the uncertainty propagation formulae to complete the uncertainty budget. The formulae have been applied to ¹⁴⁰Ba-¹⁴⁰La chronometry, which is particularly useful for dating a nuclear explosion through measurement of the produced activity ratio of ¹⁴⁰La and ¹⁴⁰Ba in a finite time interval. They were also applied to the ²²⁷Th-²²³Ra parent-daughter pair produced for therapeutic use. The impact of inaccuracies in the nuclear decay data on the performance of these nuclear chronometers is shown and discussed.

Development of the NPL gamma-ray spectrometer NANA for traceable nuclear decay and structure studies

We present a brief report on the progress towards the construction of the National Nuclear Array (NANA), a gamma-ray coincidence spectrometer for discrete-line nuclear structure and decay measurements. The proposed spectrometer will combine a gamma-ray energy resolution of approximately 3% at 1MeV with sub-nanosecond timing discrimination between successive gamma rays in mutually coincident decay cascades. We also review a number of recent measurements using coincidence fast-timing gamma-ray spectroscopy for nuclear structure studies, which have helped to inform the design criteria for the NANA spectrometer.

The production of Neptunium-236g

Radiochemical analysis of (237)Np is important in a number of fields, such as nuclear forensics, environmental analysis and measurements throughout the nuclear fuel cycle. However analysis is complicated by the lack of a stable isotope of neptunium. Although various tracers have been used, including (235)Np, (239)Np and even (236)Pu, none are entirely satisfactory. However, (236g)Np would be a better candidate for a neptunium yield tracer, as its long half-life means that it is useable as both a radiometric and mass spectrometric measurements. This radionuclide is notoriously difficult to prepare, and limited in scope. In this paper, we examine the options for the production of (236g)Np, based on work carried out at NPL since 2011. However, this work was primarily aimed at the production of (236)Pu, and not (236g)Np and therefore the rate of production are based on the levels of (236)Pu generated in the irradiation of (i) (238)U with protons, (ii) (235)U with deuterons, (iii) (236)U with protons and (iv) (236)U with deuterons. The derivation of a well-defined cross section is complicated by the relevant paucity of information on the variation of the (236m)Np:(236g)Np production ratio with incident particle energy. Furthermore, information on the purity of (236g)Np so produced is similarly sparse. Accordingly, the existing data is assessed and a plan for future work is presented.

On the integrated decay and ingrowth equations used in the measurement of radioactive decay families: the general solution

In the measurement of radioactivity, a finite measurement time is employed to collect data. Usually, this time is small with respect to the half-life of the nuclide being measured and the 'usual' decay equations can be used to decay measured activities to a given reference time. In some applications, such as neutron activation, an integrated form of the decay equation needs to be employed as the measurement time is comparable to the half-life and using the non-integrated form introduces a significant error. This correction is well known and is used widely. For radionuclide families, such as the natural decay series of uranium and thorium or simple parent--daughter systems, no such integrated form of the decay and ingrowth series appears to have been published in the open literature. This paper sets out the general solution for integrated decay and ingrowth of sequential decay and illustrates the validity of this theoretical solution by applying it to real examples.

Development of an organically bound tritium standard

High-concentration factors between seawater and marine organisms have been observed for organically bound tritium (OBT). The absence of an available OBT standard impedes the validation of an analytical method for environmental samples. This paper describes the secondary standardisation of tritiated thymidine, which was chosen to act as an OBT standard, using liquid scintillation counting. Traceability was provided by using internal standards of tritiated water (HTO). The assumption that the counting efficiencies for tritiated thymidine and HTO were identical was tested with separate quench curves. The rate of self-decomposition for tritiated thymidine, which resulted in an activity concentration of tritiated thymidine lower than the total tritium activity concentration, was determined.

Secondary standardisation of 95mTc

The radionuclide 95mTc, which has a half-life of 61(2)days and emits a number of gamma-rays, may be used in radiochemical analysis as a yield tracer for the long-lived fission product 99Tc. In this work, we present (i) the production of 95mTc via an (alpha, 2n) reaction with stable 93Nb (a method which does not result in the production of any 97mTc, 98Tc or 99Tc), (ii) the chemical separation of 95mTc from niobium via coprecipitation, liquid-liquid extraction and liquid chromatography, and (iii) the secondary standardisation of 95mTc with high-resolution gamma-ray spectrometry and an ionisation chamber system.

Standardization and decay data of 237Np

This paper reports contributions from participants in the EUROMET project (No. 416) which was entitled "237Np research into problems relating to purification, characterization and standardization". Primary standardizations were made by the defined low solid angle, coincidence, 4pi alpha, 2pi alpha and liquid scintillation counting methods. Secondary standardizations were made with calibrated gamma-ray spectrometers. Absolute X-ray, gamma-ray and alpha-particle emission probabilities were also determined. The results for the successful conclusion of both primary and secondary standardization are presented together with the values for alpha-particle and gamma-ray emission probabilities determined in this exercise. Several significant inconsistencies remain with the gamma-ray emission probabilities, and these are highlighted.

Thorium in the workplace: results from a European-based measurement comparison project

A Series of comparisons were conducted to test the capabilities of a range of metrological techniques and analytical laboratories engaged in the assay of thorium in the workplace. The results of these exercises are presented together with the decision criteria used to determine whether results are significantly different from the true value. The discussion highlights those aspects which warrant closer and further attention.

Thorium in the workplace: the preparation and validation of comparison samples for a European-based measurement comparison project

The quality of any comparison exercise depends critically on the quality. accuracy and fitness for purpose of the comparison samples. The comparisons were designed to move progressively from the testing of the analysis capabilities for relatively simple. aqueous solutions through to the more complex natural matrix materials encountered in the workplace. In each case, it was imperative that the comparison samples were prepared and validated in such a way as to ensure traceability of their activity values to national and international standards of radioactivity, to enable a reasonable estimate to be made of the uncertainty on those values and to ensure homogencity both within and between samples. The processes involved are discussed.

Thorium in the workplace measurement intercomparison

The monitoring of radionuclides in the nuclear industry has been recognized as the most straightforward way of assessing health and safety issues associated with the exposure of the workforce to potentially harmful radiation doses. Much of this is achieved by measurements in the workplace itself and by the bioassay and monitoring of workers in the industry. However, there also exists a significant 'non-nuclear' industry where workers are exposed to radioactive materials, for example where this involves thorium, which is made wide use of in the aerospace and other high technology industries. As such work involves the processing of thorium bearing materials, the workforce is potentially exposed to 232Th and its daughter nuclides. Thus, to monitor the workforce effectively, it is important to be able to measure both 232Th and the decay products of 232Th where they are in an unknown state of radioactive equilibrium and this is where monitoring laboratories may experience some difficulty. Accordingly, the Health and Safety Laboratory in the UK has organized a EC wide project on the monitoring of thorium in the 'non-nuclear' workplace; this project is currently ongoing. We report the results of the first intercomparison of this project involving two solutions of 232Th, one in radioactive equilibrium and one not in equilibrium with its daughters. The results are presented with some comments on how this intercomparison has progressed and how these first results will inform the rest of the project.

The standardisation of 229Th for an environmental yield tracer

The naturally occurring long-lived nuclides of thorium (228Th, 230Th and 232Th) are all alpha-emitters that are of interest both to the nuclear and non-nuclear industries and levels of these nuclides need to be monitored in both the working and natural environment. In order to do this in a manner where the results of radiochemical analysis are traceable to national standards, a chemical yield tracer has to be employed. 229Th has been identified as a suitable tracer for such purposes and has been used in the past. This paper describes the absolute standardisation of 225Th by 47pi alpha-gamma coincidence counting. The results of this work are presented together with an analysis of the standardisation uncertainties that were achieved in practice.

Standardisation of 210Pb

The standardisation of 210Pb is complicated by the presence of the daughters, 210Bi and 210Po. In addition, the low energies of the beta emissions from 210Pb make it difficult to obtain high detection efficiencies in an atmospheric proportional counter and hence produce the need for large extrapolations with consequential large uncertainties when extrapolating to unit efficiency with the conventional 4pi(PC)-gamma-coincidence technique. In order to produce a reliable standardisation, it is necessary to remove the daughter products. A solution of 210Pb was therefore chemically separated from its daughters and then standardised using the conventional 4pi(LS)-gamma-coincidence technique. The low energy (46 keV) and low emission probability (4%) of the associated photon emissions effectively rules out the possibility of using ionisation chambers as secondary standard transfer instruments for this nuclide. A germanium spectrometer therefore was calibrated for this purpose using 241Am as a normalising agent. The results of this work are presented together with an analysis of the standardisation uncertainties that can be achieved in practice.

Production of a spiked milk reference material

A spiked milk reference material containing 134Cs and 137Cs has been successfully produced. The material has been characterised in a manner directly traceable to national standards of radioactivity. This work is part of a EUROMET project to produce spiked reference materials at a range of densities from 0.1 to 2.0 g/cm3.

Environmental radioactivity measurement intercomparisons in the UK

The results of two recent (1989 and 1990) nationwide radioactivity-measurement intercomparisons covering a range of pure beta- and beta/gamma-emitting radionuclides are presented. Over fifty laboratories took part in the first exercise and, in general, the results were satisfactory although most laboratories confined themselves to gamma-ray measurements only. There were some areas of concern, notably decay-scheme data, statements of uncertainty and cascade-summing effects. A follow-up meeting was held to discuss these points with the participants. As a result of this meeting, a second exercise was held, covering a different range of nuclides at lower-activity levels and seeking to discover how participants had improved their procedures in the light of the results from the first exercise. The overall results of the two exercises are reviewed in the light of i) UK radioactivity-monitoring arrangements and ii) the National Measurement Accreditation Scheme (NAMAS).

The effect of additives on the setting properties of a glass-ionomer cement

Studies of the setting behavior of glass ionomer cements formed from either glass powders and polyacid solutions or from glass-dry polyacid blends mixed with water have been carried out using an oscillating rheometer. Certain acids accelerate the setting rate, but none is as effective as D-tartaric acid. Bases added to the cements slow the setting reactions by partially neutralizing the acid.