Priority-setting for hospital funding of high-cost innovative drugs and therapeutics: A qualitative institutional case study

OBJECTIVES

Rising costs of innovative drugs and therapeutics (D&Ts) have led to resource allocation challenges for healthcare institutions. There is limited evidence to guide priority-setting for institutional funding of high-cost D&Ts. This study sought to identify and elaborate on the substantive principles and procedures that should inform institutional funding decisions for high-cost off-formulary D&Ts through a case study of a quaternary care paediatric hospital.

METHODS

Semi-structured, qualitative interviews, both virtual and in-person, were conducted with institutional stakeholders (i.e. staff clinicians, senior leadership, and pharmacists) (n = 23) and two focus groups at The Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto, Canada. Participants involved in, and impacted by, high-cost off-formulary drug funding decisions were recruited through stratified, purposive sampling. Participants were approached for study involvement between July 27, 2020 and June 7, 2022. Data was analysed through reflexive thematic analysis.

RESULTS

Institutional resource allocation for high-cost D&Ts was identified as ethically challenging but critical to sustainable access to novel therapies. Important substantive principles included: 1) clinical evidence of safety and efficacy, 2) economic considerations (direct costs, opportunity costs, value for money), 3) ethical principles (social justice, professional/organizational responsibility), and 4) disease-specific considerations. Multidisciplinary deliberation was identified as an essential procedural component of decision-making. Participants identified tension between innovation and the need for evidence-based decision-making; clinician and institutional responsibilities; and value for money and social justice. Participants emphasized the role of health system-level funding allocation in alleviating the financial and moral burden of decision-making by institutions.

CONCLUSIONS

This study identifies values and processes to aid in the development and implementation of institutional resource allocation frameworks for high-cost innovative D&Ts.

Institutional Priority-Setting for Novel Drugs and Therapeutics: A Qualitative Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

There is a lack of guidance on approaches to formulary management and funding for high-cost drugs and therapeutics by individual healthcare institutions. The objective of this review was to assess institutional approaches to resource allocation for such therapeutics, with a particular focus on paediatric and rare disease populations.

METHODS

A search of Embase and MEDLINE was conducted for studies relevant to decision-making for off-formulary, high-cost drugs and therapeutics. Abstracts were evaluated for inclusion based on the Simple Multiple-Attribute Rating Techniques (SMART) criteria. A framework of 30 topics across 4 categories was used to guide data extraction and was based on findings from the initial abstract review and previous health technology assessment (HTA) publications. Reflexive thematic analysis was conducted using QSR NVivo 12 software.

RESULTS

A total of 168 studies were included for analysis. Only 4 (2%) focused on paediatrics, while 21 (12%) centred on adults and the remainder (85%) did not specify. Thirty-two (19%) studies discussed the importance of high-cost therapeutics and 34 (23%) focused on rare/orphan drugs. Five themes were identified as being relevant to institutional decision-making for high-cost therapeutics: institutional strategy, substantive criteria, procedural considerations, guiding principles and frameworks, and operational activities. Each of these themes encompassed several sub-themes and was complemented by a sixth category specific to paediatrics and rare diseases.

CONCLUSION

The rising cost of novel drugs and therapeutics underscores the need for robust, evidence-based, and ethically defensible decision-making processes for health technology funding, particularly at the hospital level. Our study highlights practices and themes to aid decision-makers in thinking critically about institutional, substantive, procedural, and operational considerations in support of legitimate decisions about institutional funding of high-cost drugs and therapeutics, as well as opportunities and challenges that exist for paediatric and rare disease populations.

Age and sex-related comparison of referral-based telemedicine service utilization during the COVID-19 pandemic in Ontario: a retrospective analysis

BACKGROUND

The COVID-19 pandemic has led to increased utilization of telemedicine services.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of all referral-based ambulatory telemedicine services in Ontario from November 2019 to June 2021 was collected from the Ontario Health Insurance Plan (OHIP) billing database. Only fee-for-service billings were included in the present analysis. Coincident COVID-19 cases were obtained from Public Health Ontario. Comparisons were made based on age bracket, sex, telemedicine and in-person care.

RESULTS

Billings for telemedicine services in Ontario increased from $1.7 million CAD in November 2019 to $64 million CAD in April 2020 and the proportions reached a mean peak of 72% in April 2020 and declined to 46% in June 2021. A positive correlation was found between the use of telemedicine and COVID-19 cases (p = 0.05). The age group with the highest proportion of telemedicine use was the 10-20-year-olds, followed by the 20-50-year-olds (61 ± 9.0%, 55 ± 7.3%, p = 0.01). Both age groups remained above 50% telemedicine services at the end of the study period. There seemed to be higher utilization by females (females 54.2 ± 8.0%, males 47.9 ± 7.7%, ANCOVA p = 0.05) for all specialties, however, after adjusting for male to female ratio m:f of 0.952:1.0 according to the 2016 census, this was no longer significant.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of telemedicine services remained at a high level across groups, particularly the 10-50-year-olds. There were clear age preferences for using telemedicine. Studying these differences may provide insights into how the delivery of non-hospital-based medicine has changed during the COVID-19 pandemic.

A qualitative study of what motivates and enables climate-engaged physicians in Canada to engage in health-care sustainability, advocacy, and action

Increasing numbers of health-care professionals are aware of the need to deliver low-carbon sustainable health systems. We aimed to explore how physicians can be motivated and supported to pursue this ambition by conducting an exploratory qualitative descriptive study that involved individual in-depth interviews with climate-engaged Canadian physicians participating in health-care sustainability advocacy and action. Interview transcripts were analysed to identify themes related to the actions that physicians can take to promote sustainable health care, and the motivators and enablers of physician engagement in sustainable health care. Participants (n=19) engaged in a spectrum of health-care sustainability initiatives ranging from reducing health-care waste to lobbying and political action. They were motivated to advance health-care sustainability by their concern about the health implications of climate change, frustration with health-care waste, and recognition of their locus of influence as physicians. Participants articulated that policy and system, organisational and team, and knowledge generation and translation supports are required to strengthen their capacity to advance health-care sustainability. These findings can provide inspiration for engagement opportunities in health-care sustainability, guide service delivery and educational innovations to promote health-care professionals' interest in becoming sustainability champions, and extend the capacity of health-care professionals to reduce the climate impact of health care.

Size matters - redefining sex differences among patients with transthyretin amyloid cardiomyopathy – have we been wrong all along?

Background

Transthyretin amyloid cardiomyopathy (ATTR-CM) is most often diagnosed in men (1–5). The few available studies suggest affected women have a more favourable cardiac phenotype (5–8), but remain unclear regarding differences in outcomes.

Objectives and methods

To characterise sex differences among consecutive patients with non-hereditary and two prevalent forms of hereditary ATTR-CM diagnosed over a 20-year period at our specialist centre through analysis of deep phenotyping at presentation, changes on serial echocardiography and overall prognosis.

Results

In total, 1732 patients were studied, comprising: 1095 with wild-type (wt)ATTR-CM; 206 with T60A-hATTR-CM; and 431 with V122I-hATTR-CM. Female prevalence was greater in T60A-hATTR-CM (29.6%) and V122I-hATTR-CM (27.8%) compared to wtATTR-CM (6%). At presentation, females were 3.3 years older than males (81.9 vs 77.8 years for wtATTR-CM; 68.7 vs 65.1 years for T60A-hATTR-CM; 77.1 vs 74.9 years for V122I-hATTR-CM). At diagnosis, non-indexed measures of wall thickness were significantly greater in males (interventricular septum in diastole (IVSd) of 17.13mm in males & 16.15mm in females; p<0.001). When indexed for body surface area (BSA), we observed that the mean indexed IVSd was fairly constant in males throughout the study period, but in females, had a tendency to decrease over the same study period. Furthermore, BSA significantly influenced measures of disease severity. When indexed for BSA, overall structural and functional phenotype was similar between sexes; the few observed significant differences including indexed IVSd (9.62mm/m2 in females & 8.88mm/m2 in males; p<0.001), indexed left ventricular (LV) end-diastolic volume (35.07ml/m2 in females & 41.05ml/m2 in males; p<0.001) and indexed LV end-systolic volume (17.95ml/m2 in females & 21.74ml/m2 in males; p<0.001) suggested a mildly worse phenotype in females. No significant differences were observed in disease progression on serial echocardiography and mortality across the overall population (p=0.459) and when divided by genotype (p=0.730 for wtATTR-CM; p=0.161 for T60A-hATTR-CM; p=0.056 for V122I-hATTR-CM).

Conclusion

This study of a well-characterized large cohort of ATTR-CM patients, contrary to previous dogmas, did not demonstrate overall differences between sexes in either clinical phenotype, when indexed, or with respect to disease progression and prognosis. The analysis highlighted the deficiencies in using non-indexed values which can not only lead to the inaccurate perception of a milder clinical phenotype in women compared to men, but has been shown to result in female patients presenting at an older age and with a worse phenotype compared to men. These findings indicate the need for revision of existing clinical guidelines regarding awareness and diagnosis of ATTR-CM in women, and modification of clinical trials which currently use single non-indexed threshold for wall thickness as key inclusion criterion.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: Foundation.

Prognostic implications of clinical phenotype and severity of cardiac involvement in patients presenting with immunoglobulin light chain amyloidosis

Background

Patients with systemic immunoglobulin light chain (AL) amyloidosis may present with a wide array of signs and symptoms due to the multi-systemic organ involved. The presence of cardiac involvement is the key determinant of survival. Cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) has the unique ability to measure the continuum of cardiac amyloidosis (CA) infiltration providing a deep characterisation from early CA involvement to severe degree of CA burden.

Purpose

The aim of this study was to characterise the clinical profiles and the severity of organ involvement in patients presenting with AL amyloidosis and to investigate implications for long-term outcome.

Methods

Patients newly diagnosed with AL amyloidosis at the National Amyloidosis Centre underwent comprehensive clinical, laboratory and instrumental work up, including CMR imaging with left ventricular (LV) mass, late gadolinium enhancement (LGE) and extracellular volume (ECV). The clinical phenotypes were classified in cardiac, renal and other according to the symptoms at presentation. The degree of CA was investigated by CMR: 0= no features of CA (normal LV mass, no LGE and normal ECV); 1=early cardiac amyloid infiltration (normal LV mass, raised ECV no LGE); 2= characteristic of CA with normal mass (diffuse subendocardial or transmural LGE, altered gadolinium kinetics and raised ECV); 3= characteristic of CA with elevated mass (diffuse subendocardial or transmural LGE and raised ECV). The study outcome was all-cause mortality.

Results

The study population included 241 AL patients presenting with cardiac and renal (22.8%, n=55), cardiac (28.2%, n=68), renal (33.2%, n=80) and other (15.8% n=38) phenotypes. During a median follow up of 33 (IQR 7–52) months, cardiac phenotype either in isolation or in combination with renal phenotype was associated with a higher rate of all-cause mortality compared to the others (p<0.001) (Figure). On CMR imaging, 43.2% of patients without cardiac phenotype (49%, n=118/241) had characteristic scans of CA (CMR grade 2 and 3) whilst 13.8% of patients with cardiac phenotype (51%, n=123/241) had no features of CA on CMR images (CMR grade 0) in (p<0.001). With Kaplan Meier analysis, the risk of all-cause death increased in patients with characteristic features of CA on CMR scan (Figure 1) and in patients with cardiac phenotype and features of CA on CMR scans compared to the others (both p<0.001) (Figure). At multivariable analysis, age at diagnosis (hazard ratio [HR] 1.03, p=0.009), clinical phenotype at presentation (HR 1.35, p=0.014) and ECV measured by CMR (HR 56, p<0.001) emerged as independent prognostic parameters.

Conclusions

Patients with newly diagnosed AL amyloidosis present most frequently with renal and cardiac phenotypes. CMR detects CA in >40% of patients with non-cardiac phenotype. ECV is an independent predictor of all-cause mortality across the full clinical spectrum of AL amyloidosis.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: None.

Myocardial ischaemia in cardiac amyloidosis: a change of perspective

Introduction

Cardiac involvement is the main driver of clinical outcomes in systemic amyloidosis; however many clinical observations are not explained by the concept of replacement of the interstitium by amyloid material. Preliminary studies support the hypothesis that myocardial ischaemia contributes to cellular damage.

Purpose

This study assesses the presence and mechanisms of myocardial ischaemia using cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) with multiparametric mapping and histopathological assessment.

Methods

Ninety-two patients with cardiac amyloidosis (CA) (AL = 41, ATTR = 51) and 97 without CA (3-vessel coronary disease (3VD) = 47, unobstructed coronary arteries = 26, healthy volunteers (HV) = 24) underwent quantitative stress perfusion CMR with myocardial blood flow (MBF) mapping. Twenty-six myocardial biopsies and 3 explanted hearts with CA were analysed histopathologically.

Results

Stress MBF was severely reduced in patients with CA with lower values than patients with 3VD, unobstructed coronary arteries and HV (CA = 1.03±0.51 ml/min/g, 3VD = 1.35±0.50 ml/min/g, Unobstructed coronaries = 2.92±0.52 ml/min/g, HV = 3.14±0.69 ml/min/g; CA vs 3VD p=0.008, CA vs Unobstructed coronaries p<0.001, CA vs HV p<0.001). After adjustment for intracellular volume the MBF in patients with CA remained significantly lower than in HV (stress MBF/ICV: AL = 2.24±1.12, ATTR = 2.22±0.93, HV = 4.38±1.06; AL vs. ATTR p=1.000, AL vs HV p<0.001, ATTR vs. HV p<0.001). Myocardial perfusion reserve (MPR) was severely reduced in CA patients, compared to HV and patients with unobstructed coronary arteries, with the degree of reduction being comparable only to patients with 3VD (CA = 1.55±0.60, 3VD = 1.54±0.51, unobstructed coronaries = 2.78±0.70, HV = 4.08±0.86; CA vs 3VD p=1.000, CA vs unobstructed coronary arteries p<0.001, CA vs. HV p<0.001). Myocardial perfusion abnormalities correlated with amyloid burden, systolic and diastolic function, structural parameters and blood biomarkers (p<0.05). Biopsies demonstrated diffuse hypoxia with abnormal VEGF staining in cardiomyocytes and endothelial cells. Amyloid infiltration in intramural arteries was associated with severe lumen reduction in 20% of vessels, and severe reduction in capillary density.

Conclusion

CA is associated with severe myocardial ischaemia demonstrable by histology and CMR stress perfusion mapping. Histological evaluation indicates a complex pathophysiology, where systolic and diastolic dysfunction, amyloid infiltration of the epicardial arteries and disruption and rarefaction of the capillaries play a role in contributing to myocardial ischaemia.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: None.

Changes in referral pathway and phenotypic status of patients diagnosed with ATTR cardiac amyloidosis during the past 20 years

Background

Diagnostic and therapeutic advances have led to much increased awareness of transthyretin (ATTR) cardiac amyloidosis (CA).

Purpose

We sought to characterise the impact of this on referral practice, cardiac phenotype at diagnosis and specifically to determine whether patients are now being diagnosed at an earlier stage in their disease process.

Methods

We studied 1845 patients diagnosed with ATTR-CA at the National Amyloidosis Centre (NAC) from 2002–2021, all of whom underwent deep clinical phenotyping and follow-up.

Results

Analysis by 5-year quartiles revealed a substantial incremental increase in patients diagnosed with ATTR-CA (35 vs 260 vs 704 vs 846), which was associated with greater proportions of patients referred following advanced cardiac imaging (referrals following cardiac magnetic resonance and bone scintigraphy: 3% vs 44% vs 67% vs 76%; P<0.001). Over time, median duration of symptoms prior to diagnosis diminished from 36-months between 2002–2006 to 12-months between 2017–2021 (P<0.001) and a greater proportion of patients presented with milder disease across the 5-yearly quartiles (NAC stage 1: 40% vs 43% vs 44% vs 57%; P<0.001). The latter was associated with more favourable echocardiographic parameters of structure and function, including an incremental reduction in maximal left ventricular wall thickness (18.26mm vs 17.41mm vs 17.09mm vs 16.68mm; P=0.017). This was associated with improved survival in the overall population (2007–2011 vs 2012–2016: HR=1.65, 95% CI [1.33–2.06]; P<0.001 and 2012–2016 vs 2017–2021: HR =1.83, 95% CI [1.45–2.31]; P<0.001) and in each genotype (wtATTR, T60A and V122I). Despite a significant increase in the proportion of patients enrolled into clinical trials (0.0% vs 0.0% vs 2.6% vs 23.9%; P<0.001) and prescribed disease modifying therapy (5.7% vs 0.4% vs 4.8% vs 13.5%; P<0.001); the improved survival remained significant even after adjusting for clinical trials and disease modifying therapy (2012–2016 vs. 2017–2021: HR=1.65 95% CI [1.29–2.11], P<0.001).

Conclusion

Increased awareness and advances in cardiac imaging have been associated with a substantial increase in the diagnosis of ATTR-CA and at a progressively earlier stage of the disease, which has contributed to improved survival in recent years. These changes may have important implications for initiation and outcome of therapy. Given that ATTR-CA is now being diagnosed earlier, more data are needed to guide decisions on in whom and when to initiate treatment, and which treatments should be used at each disease stage. Furthermore, the changes in ATTR-CA phenotype at diagnosis urgently need to be factored into clinical trial design, given that pre-determined end-points based on trials performed in the past may no longer be appropriate, or at least sufficiently powered, or of adequate duration to evaluate efficacy of novel agents.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: None.

Cardiac transplantation in transthyretin amyloid cardiomyopathy: outcomes from three decades of tertiary centre experience

Background

Transthyretin cardiac amyloidosis (ATTR-CM) is a progressive and fatal cardiomyopathy. Treatment options in patients with advanced heart failure are limited to cardiac transplantation (CT). Despite small case series demonstrating comparable outcomes with CT between patients with ATTR-CM and non-amyloid cardiomyopathies, ATTR-CM is considered to be an absolute contraindication to CT in some centres. This is in part due to a perceived risk of amyloid recurrence in the cardiac allograft. We report outcomes of patients with ATTR-CM assessed at our centre whom underwent CT over the past thirty years.

Methods

We retrospectively evaluated all ATTR-CM patients assessed at the UK National Amyloidosis Centre between 1990 and 2020 who underwent CT. Pre-transplantation disease and patient characteristics were determined and outcomes were compared with our large cohort of non-transplanted ATTR-CM patients. Censor date was 11th January 2022.

Results

Eleven (9 male, 2 female) patients with ATTR-CM underwent CT including 8 with wild-type ATTR-CM and 3 with variant ATTR-CM (ATTRv). Median age at CT was 60.3 years and median follow up post-CT was 65.7 months. Median (range) NT-proBNP concentration pre-transplant was 4478ng/L (1057–8778ng/L), median (range) left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) was 39% (27–56%) and mean (IQR) interventricular septal (IVSD) was 18 mm (15.9–20.1 mm). 8 patients were NYHA functional class III, the 3 remaining patients were class II.

One, three, and five-year survival was 100%, 89% and 86%, respectively and the longest surviving patient was censored >19 years post CT. Survival is at least comparable to UK and US CT outcome registry data for all non-amyloid patients undergoing CT. No patients had recurrence of amyloid in the cardiac allograft as assessed by endomyocardial biopsy and/or Tc-DPD scintigraphy. Two patients were commenced on Patisiran for amyloid polyneuropathy at 211 and 5 months post-CT. Graft rejection requiring treatment was observed in 2 patients, and successfully treated with intravenous steroids. Renal impairment was common, with 6 patients being left with chronic kidney disease.

Three patients died, including one with ATTRv-CM from complications of leptomeningeal amyloidosis. Survival among the cohort of patients who underwent CT was significantly longer than UK patients with ATTR-CM generally (P≤0.006), regardless of NAC ATTR disease stage and including those diagnosed under 65 years of age (P=0.028). (Figure 1) All surviving patients were NYHA functional class I at time of censor.

Conclusion

Our data indicates that cardiac transplantation is well tolerated, restores functional capacity, and prolongs survival in ATTR-CM with little risk of recurrence of amyloid in the cardiac allograft. We believe that our data argues strongly for ATTR-CM to be routinely included in the list of indications for cardiac transplantation.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: None.

A multi-modality, multi-parametric phenotyping study of transthyretin amyloid cardiomyopathy associated with the p.V142I TTR variant

Introduction

Transthyretin amyloid cardiomyopathy (ATTR-CM) is an increasingly recognised cause of heart failure. 3–4% of individuals of African descent carry a transthyretin gene mutation encoding the p.V142I variant, a powerful risk factor for development of variant ATTR-CM. This equates to 1.6 million potential carriers in the USA alone. We report findings from a multi-parametric, multi-modality phenotyping study of p.V142I ATTR-CM.

Hypothesis

The phenotype of p.V142I variant ATTR-CM is an aggressive form of ATTR CM.

Methods

A retrospective phenotyping study of 395 patients with p.V142I-ATTR-CM at our national referral centre was conducted. Patients underwent evaluation at the centre at time of diagnosis, including clinical and functional assessment, echocardiography, biomarker analysis; a subgroup had cardiac magnetic resonance imaging. 395 wild type ATTR-CM patients matched for independent predictors of prognosis (NAC Disease Stage, age, decade of first presentation) were used as a comparator group.

Results

Average age of pV142I ATTR-CM patients was 75.8 years. There was significant functional impairment (38.2% of cases NHYA ≥ III, mean 6 minute walk test distance 272m). Significant impairment of echocardiographic parameters was seen; mean LVEF 43%, global longitudinal strain −9.1%, TAPSE 14.2mm, E/E prime 17.4, E/A ratio 2.47 with high frequency of at least moderate mitral (44%) and tricuspid regurgitation (51%). Median NT-proBNP was 3165 ng/L (IQR 4224). Arrhythmias were common with 17.4% of patients having a bradyarrhythmia, 26.1% having atrial fibrillation/flutter, and 5.6% having a pacemaker at presentation. Uni and multivariate cox regression analysis identified serum troponin, tricuspid regurgitation, LVEF, TAPSE and lower systolic blood pressure as independent predictors of prognosis. Prognostic parameters were statistically significantly worse and five year survival by Kaplan Meier analysis was significantly reduced when compared to matched WT ATTR-CM patients (p<0.05) (Figure 1).

Mean serum high sensitivity troponin T and extracellular volume (ECV) by cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) was higher in p.V142I ATTR-CM than WT ATTR-CM cases (94 ng/L vs 74.2 ng/L, p<0.05, 58% vs 55%, p<0.05). Interventricular wall thickness however was lower in p.V142I ATTR-CM than matched WT cases (17.2 mm vs 16.8 mm).

Conclusion

p.V142I ATTR-CM is an aggressive phenotype, with significant functional impairment, burden of regurgitant valvular disease and systolic impairment resulting in poor survival.

Patients with p.V142I ATTR-CM had a higher burden of amyloid infiltration as measured as shown by ECV measurements on CMR, higher serum troponin and lower wall thickness when compared to a matched cohort of WT ATTR-CM patients. This novel observation suggests a unique disease mechanism that is more cardiotoxic which results in myocyte loss and myocardial thinning as opposed to myocyte hypertrophy.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: None.

Progression, regression and redefining the treatment response – cardiac magnetic resonance with T1 and extracellular volume mapping in cardiac light-chain amyloidosis

Background

The presence and severity of cardiac involvement in AL amyloidosis is the main driver of prognosis [1]; patients with symptomatic heart failure frequently die within 6 months [1] but median survival has nearly doubled over the past decade, mainly due to significant improvements in chemotherapy. The haematological response to chemotherapy is principally evaluated with serial measurements of serum-free light-chains (FLC) [2]. The cardiac response to chemotherapy is assessed through changes in serum concentrations of brain natriuretic peptides (including NT-proBNP) and echocardiographic parameters [3–5]. Neither are able to directly measure cardiac amyloid burden. Cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) with extra-cellular volume (ECV) mapping can measure the extent cardiac amyloid infiltration [6].

Aims

We investigated the ability of CMR to: 1) measure changes in response to chemotherapy; 2) assess the correlation between haematological response (HMR) and changes in cardiac amyloid; 3) assess the association between changes in cardiac amyloid and prognosis over and above existing predictors.

Methods

In total, 176 patients with cardiac light-chain amyloidosis treated with chemotherapy were assessed with FLC, NT-proBNP and CMR with ECV mapping at baseline (before chemotherapy), 6-months, 12-months & 24-months after commencing chemotherapy. Haematological response was categorized by reductions in FLC as: complete response (CR), very good partial response (VGPR), partial response (PR) or no response (NR). CMR response was categorized by changes in ECV as: progression (≥0.05 increase), stable (<0.05 change) or regression (≥0.05 decrease).

Results

A progressive increase in patients achieving either CR or VGPR was observed at each time point (61% of patients at 6-months, 71% at 12-months and 80% at 24-months). At 6-months, CMR regression was observed in 3% (all had either CR or VGPR) and progression in 32% (61% had either PR or NR; 39% had either CR or VGPR). At 1-year, CMR regression was observed in 22% (all had either CR or VGPR); progression in 22% (63% had either PR or NR; 37% had either CR or VGPR). At 2-years, CMR regression was observed in 38% (all had CR/VGPR); progression in 14% (80% had either PR or NR; 20% had either CR or VGPR). During follow-up (40±15 months), 36 (25%) patients died. CMR response at 6-months predicted death (progression HR 3.821; 95% CI 1.950–7.487; p<0.001) and remained independently associated with prognosis after adjusting for haematological response, NT-proBNP and longitudinal strain on echocardiography (p<0.01).

Conclusions

CMR demonstrates that cardiac amyloid deposits frequently regress following chemotherapy, but only in patients who achieve CR or VGPR, highlighting the need for deep haematological response. Changes in amyloid burden (ECV) predict outcomes after adjusting for known predictors, showing the crucial role of CMR in redefining treatment response.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: Foundation.

Multi-imaging characterisation of cardiac phenotype in different types of amyloidosis

Background

Bone scintigraphy is extremely valuable when assessing patients with suspected cardiac amyloidosis (CA), but the clinical significance and associated phenotype of different degrees of myocardial tracer uptake across different types of amyloidosis is yet to be defined.

Purpose

We sought to define the phenotypes of patients with varying degrees of cardiac uptake on bone scintigraphy, across multiple types of systemic amyloidosis using extensive characterisation comprising of biomarkers, echocardiographic and cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) imaging.

Methods

A total of 296 patients (117 immunoglobulin light-chain [AL] amyloidosis, 165 transthyretin [ATTR] amyloidosis, 7 apolipoprotein-A1-amyloidosis [AApoAI],and 7 apolipoprotein-A4-amyloidosis [AApoA4]) underwent deep characterisation of their cardiac phenotype.

Results

AL-amyloidosis patients with grade 0 myocardial radiotracer uptake spanned the spectrum of CMR findings from no evidence of CA to characteristic features of CA, while AL-amyloidosis patients with grade 1–3 always produced characteristic CMR features. In ATTR-amyloidosis the CA burden strongly correlated with myocardial tracer uptake (correlation between bone scintigraphy cardiac uptake and CMR derived extracellular volume: R=0.88, 95% CI [0.84–0.91], P<0.001), except in patients with the Ser77Tyr variant. AApoAI-amyloidosis presented with grade 0–1 myocardial tracer uptake, and unique features of disproportionate right sided involvement such as disproportionate right ventricular (RV) and right atrial uptake on bone scintigraphy, RV free wall thickening, and tricuspid valve thickening and dysfunction. Within our cohort, AApoAIV-amyloidosis always presented with grade 0 myocardial tracer uptake, and characteristic features of CA on CMR. All AL-amyloidosis patients with grade 1 myocardial tracer uptake had characteristic CMR features of CA (n=48, 100%), while only ATTR-amyloidosis grade 1 patients with the Ser77Tyr variant had characteristic features of CA on CMR (n=5, 11.4%). Following the exclusion of Ser77Tyr and AApoAI, a CMR showing characteristic features of CA or an extracellular volume >0.40 in a patient with grade 1 myocardial tracer uptake had a sensitivity and specificity of 100% for diagnosing AL-amyloidosis.

Conclusion

Deep characterisation of the cardiac phenotype in different types of amyloidosis, across a range of bone scintigraphy cardiac uptake grades has identified clear differences between each amyloidosis type. The distinctive characteristics in each cohort has allowed the development of a diagnostic pathway to help define the diagnostic differentials and the clinical phenotype in each individual patient, following comprehensive assessment with bone scintigraphy and CMR.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: None.

Symptom Burden Associated With Radiation Dermatitis in Breast Cancer Patients Undergoing Radiotherapy

PURPOSE

Radiation dermatitis (RD) is a side effect experienced by many patients undergoing radiotherapy (RT) for breast cancer. In the present study, the Edmonton Symptom Assessment System (ESAS), a validated patient-reported symptom screening tool, was used to determine the impacts of RT-induced skin outcomes on ESAS items. Patient- and treatment-related factors and skin treatments to manage RD symptoms, were assessed for association with ESAS scores.

METHODS

Patient and treatment characteristics were collected retrospectively for breast cancer patients treated with adjuvant RT between December 2013 and November 2015. Prospective data was collected through clinician-reported surveys. Linear regression analyses were performed to detect the relationship between patient-reported ESAS scores and clinician-reported RD symptoms.

RESULTS

A total of 857 patients were included in the analysis. Moderate to severe scores were commonly reported for fatigue (n = 412, 48%), wellbeing (n = 386, 45%) and anxiety (n = 266, 31%). Oral analgesic use was associated with ESAS fatigue, drowsiness, pain, nausea, lack of appetite, shortness of breath, and wellbeing (P < .05), while dressings were only associated with anxiety (P = .02). No RD symptoms were found to be significantly associated with any ESAS items.

CONCLUSIONS

The ESAS accurately reflects symptoms of fatigue, anxiety, and wellbeing for breast cancer patients undergoing RT. Our study, however, found no association between ESAS scores and RD severity, which may reflect the shortcomings of the ESAS in assessing symptom burden. Further research is necessary to warrant the development of a new site-specific symptom screening tool for use in RT for breast cancer.

Dosimetry and outcomes in patients receiving radiotherapy for synchronous bilateral breast cancers

BACKGROUND

Synchronous bilateral breast cancer (SBBC) is rare and there is little evidence describing organs at risk (OAR) and limits to the heart and lungs caused by radiotherapy (RT). Quantifying mean heart dose (MHD) and mean lung dose (MLD) from RT in this patient cohort may lead to better understanding of doses to OAR and resultant effects on clinical outcomes. The primary objective was to assess median MHD and MLD in SBBC, while secondary aims included analyses of 1) factors associated with MHD and MLD, 2) V5 and V20 values and 3) factors associated with clinical outcomes.

METHODS

Patients planned for adjuvant bilateral whole breast/chest wall (WB) RT from a single institution treated in 2011-2018 were included. Median MHD and MLD (Gy) were stratified by hypofractionated (42.56 Gy/16 fractions, HFRT) and conventional fractionation (50 Gy/ 25 fractions, CFRT) and summarized separately based on the following treatments: 1) locoregional RT, WB tangential RT either 2) no boost 3) sequential boost or 4) simultaneous integrated boost. MHD, MLD, lung V5 and V20 values, and demographics were collected. Linear regression analyses identified factors associated with MHD and MLD and factors associated with clinical outcomes.

RESULTS

A total of 88 patients were included. The median MHD for HFRT and CFRT was 1.99 Gy and 2.94 Gy, respectively. The median MLD for HFRT and CFRT was 6.00 Gy and 10.08 Gy, respectively. MHD and MLD were significantly associated with the occurrence of a cardiac or pulmonary event post-radiation. Patients who had a mastectomy or tumoral muscle involvement were more likely to develop a local recurrence, metastasis or new primary while patients who had a lumpectomy or tumor with a positive estrogen receptor status were less likely to experience these events.

CONCLUSIONS

Further investigation should be conducted to identify SBBC RT techniques that mitigate dose to OARs to improve clinical outcomes in bilateral breast patients.

Impact of adjuvant breast radiotherapy on patient-reported fatigue

PURPOSE

Breast cancer patients receiving adjuvant radiotherapy (RT) benefit from local control. However, RT can give rise to increased fatigue, lowering quality of life. The aim of this study was to prospectively identify trends and risk factors in patient-reported fatigue associated with breast RT.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Patients were assessed using the Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale (ESAS) before, once per week during RT, up to 6 weeks after RT completion, and 1-3 months post RT. Patients were included in the analysis if the ESAS was completed before, at least once during, and at least once after RT.

RESULTS

A total of 651 patients were included. Fatigue scores increased significantly during weeks 1-3 (p < 0.001) and weeks 5-6 (p < 0.0001) during RT compared to baseline. After RT completion, fatigue scores did not change significantly compared to baseline. Mastectomy patients who received previous chemotherapy experienced significantly more fatigue compared to mastectomy patients without previous chemotherapy (p = 0.0002). Patients less than 50 (p = 0.002), 50-59 (p = 0.007), or 60-69 (p = 0.048) years of age at RT start were more likely to have higher proportions of moderate or severe fatigue compared to patients ≥ 70 years of age.

CONCLUSIONS

Fatigue associated with breast irradiation increased up to 6 weeks during RT and returned to near baseline scores at 1-3 months post treatment. Given that fatigue was significant in mastectomy patients, further research is needed to reduce fatigue among this cohort, especially those who have received previous chemotherapy and younger patients who are receiving breast RT.

Myocardial perfusion after COVID-19 infection: No persisting impaired myocardial blood flow in surviving patients

Funding Acknowledgements

Type of funding sources: None.

Background

 Acute myocardial damage is common in hospitalized patients with severe COVID-19, with evidence of myocardial infarction and myocarditis demonstrated on cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR). Post-mortem studies have also implicated microvascular thrombosis, which may cause persistent microvascular disease. 

Purpose

 To determine the long-term coronary sequelae in recovered COVID-19 using multiparametric CMR including state-of-the-art inline quantitative stress myocardial blood flow (sMBF) mapping to assess global and regional sMBF.

Methods

 Prospective, multicentre observational study of recovered COVID-19 patients scanned at three London CMR units. Results were compared to a propensity-matched, pre-COVID chest pain cohort (104 patients referred for perfusion CMR, with subsequently demonstrated unobstructed coronary arteries) and 27 healthy volunteers (HV). Perfusion image analysis was performed using a novel artificial intelligence approach deriving global and regional stress and rest MBF with a cut-off of >2.25mL/g/min signifying normal sMBF and <1.82mL/g/min abnormal sMBF (Kotecha JCVI 2019). 

Results

 104 recovered, post-COVID patients (median age 62 years, 76% male; 89[87%] hospitalised, 41/89[46%] requiring ICU) underwent adenosine-stress perfusion CMR at a median 131(IQR 43-179) days from COVID-19 diagnosis. Median LVEF was 67% (IQR 60-71%; 12 (11.5%) with impaired LVEF), 51 patients (49%) had late gadolinium enhancement (LGE); 18% infarct-pattern and 33% non-ischaemic LGE.  Global stress MBF in post-COVID patients was no different to age-, sex- and co-morbidities-matched controls (2.57 ± 0.77 vs. 2.40 ± 0.75 ml/g/min, p = 0.11, Figure 1), though lower than HV (3.00 ± 0.76 ml/g/min, p = 0.001). Post-COVID, multivariate predictors of low sMBF were male sex (OR 0.57, 95%CI 0.41-0.80, p = 0.001) and hypertension (OR 0.67, 95%CI 0.51-0.88, p = 0.004), but not COVID-19 disease severity (ICU admission) or presence of scar (ischemic/non-ischemic).  21/42 with reduced sMBF (<2.25mL/g/min) had regional perfusion defects consistent with epicardial coronary disease.

Conclusions

  COVID-19 survivors do not demonstrate evidence of reduced global MBF by CMR compared to risk factor matched controls. Stress perfusion CMR identifies etiology of acute myocardial damage (infarction/myocarditis) and presence of occult coronary ischemia.

A retrospective review of the real-world experience of the Pegfilgrastim biosimilar (Lapelga®) to the reference biologic (Neulasta®)

Introduction

Cancer patients receiving myelosuppressive chemotherapy are vulnerable to febrile neutropenia (FN) which contributes to poor treatment outcomes. The use of granulocyte colony-stimulating factors is administered to prevent chemotherapy-induced neutropenia. The introduction of biosimilars has allowed for greater cost-savings while maintaining safety and efficacy. This retrospective study assessed the incidence of FN and related treatment outcomes and the cost minimization of a pegfilgrastim biosimilar and its reference.

Methods

A retrospective chart review of breast cancer patients receiving (neo) adjuvant chemotherapy from February 2017 to May 2020 was conducted. The endpoints included the incidence of FN, the occurrence of dose reduction (DR), dose delay (DD) and pain. A cost minimization analysis was performed from a third-party payer perspective.

Results

One hundred Neulasta® and 74 Lapelga® patients were included in the first-cycle analysis. The rate of FN in cycle 1 for Neulasta® and Lapelga® was 2/100 and 4/74, respectively; risk difference (RD)  =  3.4%; 95% CI: –2.4 to 9.2%. Eighty-three Neulasta® and 59 Lapelga® patients were included in the all-cycle analyses, where DR was reported in 76 (15%) Neulasta® cycles vs 33 (10%) Lapelga® cycles (RD = –3.6, 95% CI: –10.2 to 2.9). DD was reported in 20 (4%) Neulasta® cycles vs. 11 (3.5%) Lapelga® cycles (RD = –0.3; 95% CI: –2.7 to 2.0). Adverse events were similar between groups. Cost minimization using a cohort of 20,000 patients translated into an incremental savings of $21,606,800 CAD for each cycle.

Conclusion

The biosimilar pegfilgrastim was non-inferior to the reference biologic based on FN incidence in addition to related outcomes including DR and DD.

Prediction of breast cancer-related outcomes with the Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale: A literature review

PURPOSE

The Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale (ESAS) is a validated tool used in patients with varied cancer diagnoses to measure patient symptoms. The present manuscript will review the literature assessing the ability of the ESAS to predict patient-related outcomes in breast cancer patients.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted of Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials databases, Ovid MEDLINE, and Embase for English articles that investigated the use of predictive modelling with the ESAS in the breast cancer population. Study type, publication year, sample size, patient demographics, predicted outcomes, and strongest predictive factors/symptoms were summarized for each study.

RESULTS

A total of nine articles were included in this review. Five articles used the ESAS in predictive models to determine patient time to death. ESAS was also used to predict emergency department visits, determine symptoms associated with decreased quality of life, and generate a Health Utility Score. Lack of appetite was the most common ESAS symptom, as it was reported in five studies to be associated with decreased survival. In four of the nine articles, an additional survey investigating physical functioning was used in combination with ESAS to strengthen the predictive models.

CONCLUSIONS

Included studies support the use of ESAS in predictive models, particularly for predicting survival. Using the ESAS as a predictive tool allows for more accurate time to death predictions, potentially improving symptom management and preventing overtreatment of palliative patients near the end of life.

Use of Adjuvant Breast Hypofractionation Radiation Treatment at a Cancer Center in Ontario From 2011 to 2018

BACKGROUND

The adoption of hypofractionated radiotherapy (HFRT) into clinical practice varies widely despite randomized trials and guidelines supporting its equivalence to conventional fractionated radiotherapy (CFRT) for certain patient populations. We assessed the use of HFRT at a single institution from 2011 to 2018, as well as time-savings calculations.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was conducted for patients with breast cancer receiving adjuvant radiotherapy by HFRT or CFRT. Trends in HFRT use (≤ 16 fractions) were stratified according to 4 subgroups: tangential breast RT, locoregional breast RT, tangential chest wall RT, and locoregional chest wall RT. Treatment time savings were approximated using the institutional median treatment time.

RESULTS

A total of 5190 patients were included. HFRT use in all subgroups increased from 2011 to 2018. Tangential breast HFRT alone increased from 62.2% in 2011 to 96.9% in 2018. Locoregional breast HFRT and tangential chest wall HFRT use increased from less than 10% in 2011 to 76.2% and 76.9% in 2018. In locoregional chest wall RT, HFRT use of 44.9% was observed in 2018. Increased use of locoregional HFRT was mainly due to institutional policy changes. Time-savings calculations showed that 4002 hours of treatment or an additional 1402 HFRT courses could have been administered if all patients received HFRT.

CONCLUSION

The use of HFRT at our center increased in all patient subgroups. More evidence and guidelines for patients receiving chest wall or locoregional HFRT are required because the use of HFRT remains low in these patient cohorts.

Re-analysis of symptom clusters in advanced cancer patients attending a palliative outpatient radiotherapy clinic

BACKGROUND

Cancer patients often present with several concurrent symptoms. There is evidence to suggest that related symptoms can cluster together in stable groups. The present study sought to identify symptom clusters in advanced cancer patients using the Edmonton Symptom Assessment System (ESAS) in a palliative outpatient radiotherapy clinic.

METHODS

Principal component analysis (PCA), exploratory factor analysis (EFA), and hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) were used to identify symptom clusters among the 9 ESAS items using ESAS scores from each patient's first visit.

RESULTS

PCA identified three symptom clusters (cluster 1: depression, anxiety; cluster 2: nausea, dyspnea, loss of appetite; cluster 3: pain, well-being, tiredness, drowsiness). EFA identified two clusters (cluster 1: tiredness, drowsiness, loss of appetite, well-being, pain, nausea, dyspnea; cluster 2: depression, anxiety). HCA identified three symptom clusters (cluster 1: depression, anxiety, pain, well-being; cluster 2: tiredness, drowsiness, dyspnea; cluster 3: nausea, loss of appetite).

CONCLUSIONS

Symptom clusters were identified using three analytical methods. The following items were always in the same cluster: depression and anxiety; nausea and appetite loss; well-being and pain; tiredness and drowsiness. Further research in symptom clusters is necessary to advance our understanding of the complex symptom interactions in advanced cancer patients and to determine the most clinically relevant symptom clusters.

Are we better a decade later in the accuracy of survival prediction by palliative radiation oncologists?

BACKGROUND

Clinician predicted survival (CPS) plays a crucial role in palliative care, informing physicians of appropriate treatment best suited to the patient. The primary objective of this study was to assess the accuracy of CPS of cancer patients referred for palliative radiotherapy. Secondary objectives included an analysis of factors predictive of accurate CPS, comparisons of the accuracy of survival predictions over subsequent clinic visits, and comparisons to the previous study in the Rapid Response Radiotherapy Program (RRRP) in 2005.

METHODS

CPS was provided by one of four radiation oncologists from August 2014 to March 2017. Karnofsky Performance Status (KPS), primary cancer site, and sites of metastases were recorded. Date of death was retrieved from the Patient Care System (PCS) and Excelicare. Mean difference between actual survival (AS) and CPS was used to determine the accuracy of survival predictions.

RESULTS

One-hundred seventy-two patients were included in the final analysis. Survival was largely overestimated (n=135, 78.5%), with CPS being overestimated by 19.0 weeks on average. KPS (P=0.2), primary cancer site (P=0.08), and various sites of metastases were not significantly related to CPS accuracy. Gender was significantly related to CPS accuracy after multivariable analysis (P=0.04), but was no longer significant after excluding prostate and breast cancer patients in multivariable analysis (P=0.2). The mean difference between AS and CPS did not significantly change over subsequent visits (P=0.5) and CPS accuracy decreased significantly compared to the previous RRRP study (P=0.04).

CONCLUSIONS

The survival estimates provided by radiation oncologists are inaccurately overestimated. Further research should aim to increase the accuracy of CPS in order to improve patient outcomes.