Ockham's Razor: The Application of Parsimonious Medicine in Allergy/Immunology

The spectacular advances of modern medicine have distracted clinicians from applying the age-old principles of thorough history and examination followed by only ordering tests relevant to the patient's presentation. The most obvious diagnosis is the most likely and should be addressed first. Ockham's razor, or parsimonious medicine, should be applied because plurality of diagnoses is less likely than a single explanation. Component-resolved diagnostics and biological therapies for allergy/immune-mediated diseases have been highly effective when used by specialist allergy services. However, they are accessed too easily and frequently, either before diagnostically appropriate allergy skin testing and challenge have been employed or before the reasons for poor disease control have been investigated. The current fashion to test for vitamin D insufficiency in patients with poorly controlled allergic diseases has rarely achieved benefit but significantly increased costs. There are considerable health/economic benefits from following the proven value of a thorough clinical history, examination, focused allergy/immunology testing, and the judicious use of Ockham's razor.

Drug Allergy in Children: What is the Actual Frequency of Drug Allergies?

Objectives

Drug hypersensitivity reactions are immunologically mediated reactions resulting in the production of drug-specific antibodies and/or T-cells and constituting only <15% of all drug reactions. Based on the clinical observations, both patients and their parents refer to any undesirable drug reactions as drug allergy, regardless of whether the underlying mechanism is immunological or not. After allergy examinations, only a small percentage of the patients who were reported positive for drug reactions based on their clinical history are actually confirmed to have hypersensitivity. This study aims to determine the actual frequency of drug allergies in children, the drugs that cause the most common allergies in patients with a complaint of drug allergy and evaluate the accompanying demographic and clinical features.

Methods

The study evaluated data from a total of 266 patients (ages of 0-18) with suspected drug allergy during a 3-year period. Twenty-four patients with doctor-diagnosed drug-related anaphylaxis and 85 patients who did not accept diagnostic tests were excluded from the study and the study continued with a total of 157 patients. The allergy work-up consisted of in vivo and in vitro tests, in accordance with the recommendations of the ENDA/EAACI guidelines.

Results

Data from a group of 157 patients (M [54.6%]; F [45.4%]) were retrospectively analyzed. Beta-lactams (BLs) were the most common drugs involved in the reported clinical history followed by non-steroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). Allergic reactions occurred on the median 1st day (min: 1-max: 8) after drug intake and were most frequently observed as urticaria (55.3%). Immediate reactions (IRs) were observed in 53.5% and non-IRs in 46.5% of the patients.

Conclusion

Our data demonstrated that only 15.5% of patients confirmed to be positive to allergy during testing which is in line with the data in the literature. An allergy work-up is mandatory for excluding suspected hypersensitivity.

Epidemiology and drug allergy results in children investigated in allergy unit of a tertiary-care paediatric hospital setting

Background and objective

Drug Hypersensitivity Reactions (DHRs) are considered adverse effects of medications that resemble allergy symptoms. The reported positive clinical history of pediatric drug reactions is about 10%, however, after allergy investigations, only a small percent is confirmed as hypersensitivity.

The aim of this study was to analyze the clinical history, allergy work-up results and sensitization profile of children and adolescents referred to our Allergy Unit for suspected DHRs.

Methods

The study evaluated data related to a group of children with a positive history of drug reactions during a two-year period. The allergy work-up consisted of in vivo and in vitro tests, in accordance with the recommendations of the ENDA/EAACI guidelines.

Results

Data from a group of 637 patients [348 M (54.6%); 289 F (45.4%)] were retrospectively analyzed. Beta lactams (BLs) were the most common drugs involved in the reported clinical history, followed by non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). Severe cutaneous adverse reactions (SCARs) were most frequently observed during BL treatment. The confirmation of BL hypersensitivity was higher for immediate reactions (IRs) [9.4%; 5.1% through positive skin tests (STs) and 5.5% through drug provocation test (DPT)] compared to non-immediate reactions (non-IRs) (8.1%; 2.2% through STs and 6.2% through DPT). A higher number of positive results was obtained for BLs and macrolides when the tests were performed within 12 months after the index reaction (p < 0.05). During DPTs with amoxicillin-clavulanic acid, four hypersensitivity reactions (including one anaphylaxis) occurred despite negative STs.

Conclusion

Our data demonstrated that only 9.1% of patients resulted in being positive to allergy tests which is in line with the data in literature. An allergy work-up is mandatory for excluding suspected hypersensitivity.