A study concept of expeditious clinical enrollment for genetic modifier studies in Charcot-Marie-Tooth neuropathy 1A

BACKGROUND

Caused by duplications of the gene encoding peripheral myelin protein 22 (PMP22), Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 1A (CMT1A) is the most common hereditary neuropathy. Despite this shared genetic origin, there is considerable variability in clinical severity. It is hypothesized that genetic modifiers contribute to this heterogeneity, the identification of which may reveal novel therapeutic targets. In this study, we present a comprehensive analysis of clinical examination results from 1564 CMT1A patients sourced from a prospective natural history study conducted by the RDCRN-INC (Inherited Neuropathy Consortium). Our primary objective is to delineate extreme phenotype profiles (mild and severe) within this patient cohort, thereby enhancing our ability to detect genetic modifiers with large effects.

METHODS

We have conducted large-scale statistical analyses of the RDCRN-INC database to characterize CMT1A severity across multiple metrics.

RESULTS

We defined patients below the 10th (mild) and above the 90th (severe) percentiles of age-normalized disease severity based on the CMT Examination Score V2 and foot dorsiflexion strength (MRC scale). Based on extreme phenotype categories, we defined a statistically justified recruitment strategy, which we propose to use in future modifier studies.

INTERPRETATION

Leveraging whole genome sequencing with base pair resolution, a future genetic modifier evaluation will include single nucleotide association, gene burden tests, and structural variant analysis. The present work not only provides insight into the severity and course of CMT1A, but also elucidates the statistical foundation and practical considerations for a cost-efficient and straightforward patient enrollment strategy that we intend to conduct on additional patients recruited globally.

Rate of Changes in CMT Neuropathy and Examination Scores in Japanese Adult CMT1A Patients

Introduction: We aimed to clarify when adult patients with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 1A (CMT1A), especially those diagnosed at middle or advanced ages, first showed symptoms and whether the rate of disease progression is accelerated by aging.

Methods: Medical records of CMT1A outpatients between 2012 and 2019 were reviewed. The age at diagnosis, age when symptoms first appeared, and rate of disease progression, assessed based on clinical outcome measures including the CMT Neuropathy Score (CMTNS), Rasch-modified CMTNS (CMTNS-R), CMT Examination Score (CMTES), and Rasch-modified CMTES (CMTES-R) were analyzed.

Results: Among 45 adult CMT1A patients, 42% had been diagnosed after 50 years of age, whereas 91% of all patients had exhibited some CMT-related symptoms before 20 years of age. The annual increase of all clinical outcome measures did not differ between patients under and over 50 years. Even when limited to patients whose initial CMTES-R showed mild to moderate severity, the rate of change in CMTES-R did not differ between the two age groups (the annual mean ± standard deviation, under 50 years: 1.1 ± 1.0, and over 50 years: 0.9 ± 1.1, p = 0.68). To determine whether patients with disabilities at a young age have a higher deterioration rate, they were classified into three groups according to their current age and age at diagnosis: patients under 50 years of age, patients over 50 years of age but diagnosed before 50, and patients diagnosed after 50 years of age. The mean annual increase of all clinical outcome measures, however, did not differ among these groups (CMTES-R: 1.03 ± 1.01 vs. 0.94 ± 1.57 vs. 0.81 ± 0.88, respectively, p = 0.87).

Discussion: CMT1A patients develop symptoms in childhood and adolescence even if such symptoms are not noticeable until reaching an advanced age. Deterioration rates of clinical outcome measures are constant irrespective of the age in their adulthood, although we cannot rule out the limitation that the difference did not reach significance because of the small number of patients. Being aware of the existence of a considerable number of undiagnosed CMT patients will help promote the avoidance of inadequate medication.