Agraz JL, Grenko CM, Chen AA, Viaene AN, Nasrallah MD, Pati S, Kurc T, Saltz J, Feldman MD, Akbari H, Sharma P, Shinohara RT, Bakas S. Robust Image Population Based Stain Color Normalization: How Many Reference Slides Are Enough?
IEEE Open J Eng Med Biol 2022;
3:218-226. [PMID:
36860498 PMCID:
PMC9970045 DOI:
10.1109/ojemb.2023.3234443]
[Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0] [Reference Citation Analysis] [What about the content of this article? (0)] [Affiliation(s)] [Abstract] [Key Words] [Track Full Text] [Figures] [Journal Information] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Received: 07/25/2022] [Revised: 11/08/2022] [Accepted: 01/01/2023] [Indexed: 01/06/2023] Open
Abstract
Histopathologic evaluation of Hematoxylin & Eosin (H&E) stained slides is essential for disease diagnosis, revealing tissue morphology, structure, and cellular composition. Variations in staining protocols and equipment result in images with color nonconformity. Although pathologists compensate for color variations, these disparities introduce inaccuracies in computational whole slide image (WSI) analysis, accentuating data domain shift and degrading generalization. Current state-of-the-art normalization methods employ a single WSI as reference, but selecting a single WSI representative of a complete WSI-cohort is infeasible, inadvertently introducing normalization bias. We seek the optimal number of slides to construct a more representative reference based on composite/aggregate of multiple H&E density histograms and stain-vectors, obtained from a randomly selected WSI population (WSI-Cohort-Subset). We utilized 1,864 IvyGAP WSIs as a WSI-cohort, and built 200 WSI-Cohort-Subsets varying in size (from 1 to 200 WSI-pairs) using randomly selected WSIs. The WSI-pairs' mean Wasserstein Distances and WSI-Cohort-Subsets' standard deviations were calculated. The Pareto Principle defined the optimal WSI-Cohort-Subset size. The WSI-cohort underwent structure-preserving color normalization using the optimal WSI-Cohort-Subset histogram and stain-vector aggregates. Numerous normalization permutations support WSI-Cohort-Subset aggregates as representative of a WSI-cohort through WSI-cohort CIELAB color space swift convergence, as a result of the law of large numbers and shown as a power law distribution. We show normalization at the optimal (Pareto Principle) WSI-Cohort-Subset size and corresponding CIELAB convergence: a) Quantitatively, using 500 WSI-cohorts; b) Quantitatively, using 8,100 WSI-regions; c) Qualitatively, using 30 cellular tumor normalization permutations. Aggregate-based stain normalization may contribute in increasing computational pathology robustness, reproducibility, and integrity.
Collapse