Notchplasty is associated with decreased risk of anterior cruciate ligament graft revision

PURPOSE

Despite influencing knee biomechanics and outcomes, the use of notchplasty at time of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) has not been evaluated with regards to risk of secondary injury and revision. This study evaluates this association.

METHODS

42 patients (21.7-years, IQR = 19.0-27.5) that underwent primary then revision ACLR at a single institution were contrasted with a case matched control group of patients with grafts that did not fail. Patients were propensity score matched in a 1:2 ratio by age, gender, and date of index procedure. Post-hoc statistical correction was made for post-index procedure sports participation level.

RESULTS

Notchplasty was performed in 2 of 42 cases that went on to revision, and in 31 of 84 cases in the control group (p < 0.001). This was associated with reduced rates of revision ACLR (OR = 0.085, 95%CI = 0.019-0.378). A significant difference was seen in the post-ACLR activity level between groups (p = 0.028), with post-hoc testing highlighting those returning to competitive sport to be more likely to require subsequent revision (OR = 9.647, 95%CI = 1.947-47.795). Notchplasty remained significantly associated with (reduced) risk of revision surgery, despite the observed variation in post-ACLR activity (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Individuals whose graft failed following ACLR were significantly less likely to have had notchplasty performed as part of their surgery than a control group who did not suffer graft reinjury. We propose that this may be due to decreased tensioning of the graft as the knee enters dynamic valgus, which may be of great relevance to athletes undergoing ACLR to enable return to sport.

Quantifying graft impingement in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BACKGROUND

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions (ACLR) fail at a rate of 10-15%, with graft impingement often a cause. In this study we investigate the prevalence and causes of impingement seen during ACLR surgery.

METHODS

We reviewed consecutive primary ACLR from 2012-2018. Graft impingement was estimated intraoperatively by placing the arthroscope through the tibial tunnel and passively extending the knee, observing how much was obscured by the lateral femoral condyle from an anterior and lateral direction. Preoperative MRI scans were used to measure the intercondylar notch; Notch Width Index (NWI) and Notch Depth Index (NDI). Positioning of the tunnels was determined on postoperative radiographs.

RESULTS

There were 283 ACLRs performed with 33 failures diagnosed on MRI (11.7%). 257 patients had complete imaging and follow up (91%). The mean age was 28 (±9) years and mean follow-up 5.3 (±1.8) years. The mean NWI was 0.26(±0.03), and NDI was 0.49(±0.06). The tibial tunnel aperture was located 42(±6) % of the way from anterior-posterior and 39(±6) % from medial-lateral. Impingement requiring a notchplasty was observed in 80% of cases, with lateral impingement more prominent.

CONCLUSIONS

The amount of impingement did not correlate with tunnel position, which was located within the recommended area. There was a weak negative correlation between NWI and lateral impingement (r_s = -0.16, p = 0.01), and NDI and anterior impingement (r_s = -0.12, p = 0.04), therefore a smaller notch is associated with greater impingement. Despite optimal tunnel positioning, impingement still occurs in a significant number of cases therefore notchplasty should always be considered to keep revision rates low.

Flexion contracture can be relieved by concurrent notchplasty in medial open wedge high tibial osteotomy

BACKGROUND

Given that medial open wedge high tibial osteotomy (OWHTO) not only delays the progression of osteoarthritis but also alleviates the resulting pain, surgical outcomes would be improved if limited ROM can also be managed. In this regard, the effect of concurrent notchplasty on flexion contracture has not been evaluated.

HYPOTHESIS

(1) Concurrent notchplasty in OWHTO would relieve flexion contracture regardless of the severity of osteoarthritis and this effect would be maintained over time, and (2) concurrent notchplasty would not cause any added complications compared to the same procedure without notchplasty.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In total, 107 patients who underwent OWHTO between 2011 and 2017 with a mean follow-up period of 46.6months (range: 24-102months) were reviewed. ROM was measured at three time points as follows: before surgery, at 6-12months postoperatively, and at the latest follow-up. The measurements were analyzed using a linear mixed model in terms of notchplasty and other factors, including age, sex, body mass index, preoperative hip-knee-ankle angle, lateral distal femoral angle, medial proximal tibial angle, correction angle, concurrent meniscectomy, postoperative posterior slope, and Kellgren-Lawrence grade. Then, ROMs at the three time points were compared between the notchplasty and non-notchplasty groups.

RESULTS

Of the 107 patients, 47 underwent concurrent notchplasty. The linear mixed model regarding flexion contracture showed a significant notchplasty-by-time interaction (p<0.001). When comparing preoperative flexion contractures between the two groups, a significant difference was found (p<0.001). At 6-12months postoperatively, flexion contractures were relieved regardless of notchplasty; however, the difference between the groups was decreased (p=0.026). At the latest follow-up, flexion contractures were partly aggravated in both groups, but no significant difference was found between the groups (p=0.461). Comparison of flexion contracture between before surgery and at the latest follow-up in each group revealed a significant difference only in the notchplasty group (p<0.001, with notchplasty; p=0.197, without notchplasty). The linear mixed model regarding maximal flexion did not show any factor having a significant interaction with time. There were no surgical complications such as infection, thromboembolic events, and hemarthrosis, in both notchplasty and non-notchplasty groups.

CONCLUSION

The preoperative difference in flexion contracture was overcome by adding notchplasty to OWHTO, and this improvement was maintained over time. No added complications were noted in the notchplasty group. The results should be interpreted with caution, considering measurement error of ROM. However, concurrent notchplasty in OWHTO deserves further study to validate its efficacy.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III, retrospective cohort study.

IRB INFORMATION

Project No. S2020-0081, AMC IRB SOP.

Anterior cruciate ligament femoral-tunnel drilling through an anteromedial portal: 3-dimensional plane drilling angle affects tunnel length relative to notchplasty

Background

Notchplasty is a surgical technique often performed during anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) with widening of the intercondylar notch of the lateral distal femur to avoid graft impingement. The purpose of this study was to correlate femoral-tunnel length with 3-dimensional (3D) drilling angle through the anteromedial (AM) portal with and without notchplasty.

Materials and methods

Computer data were collected from an anatomical study using 16 cadaveric knees. The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) femoral insertion was dissected and outlined for gross anatomical observation. The dissected cadaveric knees were scanned by computed tomography (CT). Three-dimensional measurements were calculated using software (Geomagic, Inc., Research Triangle Park, NC, USA) and included the center of the ACL footprint and the size of the ACL femoral footprint. The femoral-tunnel aperture centers were measured in the anatomical posterior-to-anterior and proximal-to-distal directions using Bernard’s quadrant method. The ACL tunnel was created 3-demensionally in the anatomical center of femoral foot print of ACL using software (SolidWorks®, Corp., Waltham, MA, USA). The 8-mm cylinder shaped ACL tunnel was rested upon the anatomical center of the ACL footprint and placed in three different positions: the coronal plane, the sagittal plane, and the axial plane. Finally, the effect of notchplasty on the femoral-tunnel length and center of the ACL footprint were measured. All the above-mentioned studies performed ACLR using the AM portal.

Results

The length of the femoral tunnels produced using the low coronal and high axial angles with 5-mm notchplasty became significantly shorter as the femoral starting position became more horizontal. The result was 30.38 ± 2.11 mm on average at 20° in the coronal plane/70° in the axial plane/45° in the sagittal plane and 31.26 ± 2.08 mm at 30° in the coronal plane/60° in the axial plane/45° in the sagittal plane, respectively, comparing the standard technique of 45° in the coronal/45° in the axial/45° in the sagittal plane of 32.98 ± 3.04 mm (P < 0.001). The tunnels made using the high coronal and low axial angles with notchplasty became longer than those made using the standard technique: 40.31 ± 3.36 mm at 60° in the coronal plane/30° in the axial plane/45° in the sagittal plane and 50.46 ± 3.13 mm at 75° in the coronal plane/15° in the axial plane/45° in the sagittal plane (P < 0.001).

Conclusions

Our results show that excessive notchplasty causes the femoral tunnel to be located in the non-anatomical center of the ACL footprint and reduces the femoral-tunnel length. Therefore, care should be taken to avoid excessive notchplasty when performing this operation.

Notchplasty alters knee biomechanics after anatomic ACL reconstruction

PURPOSE

The aims of this study were (1) to study the biomechanics of single-bundle anatomic ACL reconstructed knees with and without notchplasty using a robotic testing system and (2) to determine if there would be a difference between performing a small or large notchplasty.

METHODS

Fifteen fresh-frozen specimens were used in this study. The ACL reconstruction (ACL-R) was performed using an anatomic single-bundle technique with the 8 mm soft tissue graft fixed at 30° with suspensory fixation on the femoral side and a screw and washer on the tibial side. The notchplasty was then created with a burr. The following knee states were compared: (1) ACL-R, (2) ACL-R with a small (3 mm) notchplasty, and (3) ACL-R with a large (6 mm) notchplasty. Four loading conditions were applied: (1) an anterior drawer with an 89 N anterior tibial load, (2) simulated pivot-shift loading, (3) a 5 Nm internal rotational moment, and (4) a 5 Nm external rotational moment.

RESULTS

Under anterior tibial loading, anterior tibial translation increased, and graft force decreased significantly after ACL-R + 3 mm notchplasty and ACLR + 6 mm notchplasty compared to ACL-R alone at FE, 15° and 30° of knee flexion. There were no changes in either anterior tibial translation or graft force under simulated pivot-shift loading, internal rotational moment, or external rotational moment.

CONCLUSION

When added to anatomic ACL reconstruction, notchplasty increased anterior tibial translation and decreased graft forces during low knee flexion angles. There was no difference between a small and large notchplasty. The findings of this study are clinically relevant as the purpose of anatomic ACL reconstruction is to restore normal knee laxity, and while notchplasty may be helpful in avoiding graft impingement and improving visualization, removing even 3 mm of bone leads to biomechanical changes.

The effects of graft size and insertion site location during anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction on intercondylar notch impingement

BACKGROUND

Intercondylar notch impingement is detrimental to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). Notchplasty is a preventative remodeling procedure performed on the intercondylar notch during ACL reconstruction (ACLR). This study investigates how ACL graft geometry and both tibial and femoral insertion site location may affect ACL-intercondylar notch interactions post ACLR. A range of ACL graft sizes are reported during ACLR, from six millimeters to 11mm in diameter. Variability of three millimeters in ACL insertion site location is reported during ACLR. This study aims to determine the post-operative effects of minor variations in graft size and insertion location on intercondylar notch impingement.

METHODS

Several 3D finite element knee joint models were constructed using three ACL graft sizes and polar arrays of tibial and femoral insertion locations. Each model was subjected to flexion, tibial external rotation, and valgus motion. Impingement force and contact area between the ACL and intercondylar notch compared well with experimental cadaver data from literature.

RESULTS

A three millimeter anterior-lateral tibial insertion site shift of the maximum size ACL increased impingement force by 242.9%. A three millimeter anterior-proximal femoral insertion site shift of the maximum size ACL increased impingement by 346.2%. Simulated notchplasty of five millimeters eliminated all impingement for the simulation with the greatest impingement. For the kinematics applied, small differences in graft size and insertion site location led to large increases in impingement force and contact area.

CONCLUSIONS

Minor surgical variations may increase ACL impingement. The results indicate that notchplasty reduces impingement during ACLR. Notchplasty may help to improve ACLR success rates.

Impingement following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: comparing the direct versus indirect femoral tunnel position

PURPOSE

During anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, authors have suggested inserting the femoral tunnel at the biomechanically relevant direct fibres, but this higher position can cause more impingement. Therefore, we aimed to assess ACL graft impingement at the femoral notch for ACL reconstruction at both the direct and indirect tunnel positions.

METHODS

A virtual model was created for twelve cadaveric knees with computed tomography scanning in which a virtual graft was placed at direct and indirect tunnel positions of the anteromedial bundle (AM), posterolateral bundle (PL) or centre of the both bundles (C). In these six tunnel positions, the volume (mm³) and mid-point location of impingement (°) were measured at different flexion angles.

RESULTS

Generally, more impingement was seen with the indirect position compared with the direct position although this was only significant at 90° of flexion for the AM position (97 ± 28 vs. 76 ± 20 mm³, respectively; p = 0.046). The direct tunnel position impinged higher at the notch, whereas the indirect position impinged more towards the lateral wall, but this was only significant at 90° of flexion for the AM (24 ± 5° vs. 34 ± 4°, respectively; p < 0.001) and C position (34 ± 5° vs. 42 ± 5°, respectively; p = 0.003).

CONCLUSION

In this cadaveric study, the direct tunnel position did not cause more impingement than the indirect tunnel position. Based on these results, graft impingement is not a limitation to reconstruct the femoral tunnel at the insertion of the biomechanically more relevant direct fibres.

Notchplasty in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in the setting of passive anterior tibial subluxation

PURPOSE

In an effort to minimize graft impingement among various ACL deficient states, we sought to quantitatively determine requirements for bone resection during notchplasty with respect to both volumetric amount and location.

METHODS

A validated method was used to evaluate Magnetic Resonance Imaging scans. We measured the ATT of the medial and lateral compartments in the following four states: intact ACL (27 patients), acute ACL disruption; <2 months post-injury (76 patients), chronic ACL disruption; 12 months post-injury (42 patients) and failed ACL reconstruction (75 patients). Subsequently, 11 cadaveric knees underwent Computed Tomography (CT) scanning. Specialized software allowed virtual anterior translation of the tibia according to the average ATT measured on MRI. Impingement volume was analyzed by performing virtual ACLRs onto the various associated CT scans. Location was analyzed by overlaying an on-screen protractor. The center of the notch was defined as 0°.

RESULTS

Average impingement volume changed significantly in the various groups compared to the intact ACL group (acute 577 ± 200 mm(3), chronic 615 ± 199 mm(3), failed ACLR 678 ± 210 mm(3), p=0.0001). The location of the required notchplasty of the distal femoral wall border did not change significantly. The proximal femoral border moved significantly towards the center of the notch (acute 8.6° ± 4.8°, chronic 7.8° ± 4.2° (p=0.013), failed ACLR 5.1° ± 5.9° (p=0.002)).

CONCLUSION

Our data suggests that attention should be paid peri-operatively to the required volume and location of notchplasty among the various ACL deficient states to minimize graft impingement.