Teachers' and students' perceptions of a sense of community in blended education

Universities have renewed interest in blended learning in preparation for post-COVID education. However, unsatisfactory social interactions hinder the quality of blended learning, despite its potential for flexible and personalized learning. In this situation, a sense of community would provide essential academic and social benefits. To develop a sense of community among students, we need to further understand students' and teachers' perceptions concerning this subject by exploring their experiences in blended learning. Therefore, we investigated this for three blended courses using a qualitative case study approach. We conducted: (1) classroom observation; (2) document analysis of course content, assignments, and assessments; and (3) individual interviews with teachers (n = 3) and group interviews with students (n = 18). The results showed the main factors that appeared to contribute to sense of community: group learning activities within courses, non-academic and extracurricular activities across courses, and the campus as a physical place integrating academic and social life after COVID. Further, we identified two obstacles: students valued group learning but struggled to manage group dynamics, and despite teachers' efforts to encourage learning autonomy, students viewed teachers as the ultimate authority in the learning process, which strained the student-teacher relationship. Additionally, this study revealed the limitations that digital tools have for promoting sense of community, as students questioned whether these tools have added value for supporting intricate and in-depth conversations. Finally, based on these findings, we provided practical recommendations for the future development of sense of community in blended learning.

Modelling the role of learner presence within the community of inquiry framework to determine online course satisfaction in distance education

This study sought to investigate the nuances in predictive relationships existing among teaching presence, cognitive presence and social presence as well as learner presence in the Community of Inquiry (CoI) framework towards online course satisfaction. The study is necessitated by the deficiency of current literature in providing information on the nuances in interaction among the three original presences and learner presence, prior to the final determination of online course satisfaction. Thus, the study adopted a survey design and collected data via a questionnaire from 347 postgraduate students on an online database course. Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modelling was used to validate a definite model on the predictive relationships existing among teaching presence, cognitive presence, social presence, learner presence and online course satisfaction. Results from the structural model analysis proved a statistically significant predictive relationship between learner presence and the three other presences (i.e. cognitive presence, social presence and teaching presence). Other relationships established include social presence and cognitive presence; social presence and teaching presence. Finally, online course satisfaction was predicted by social presence and teaching presence. Based on the findings it was recommended that institutions that offer online courses should device concrete strategies that promote social presence and teaching presence since these variables are precursors to online course satisfaction. Finally, the design of online courses should be effective and learner-centred to attract the learner since learner presence determines all the other three 'presences' in online learning environment.

Investigating relationships among regulated learning, teaching presence and student engagement in blended learning: An experience sampling analysis

This study explored the relationships among regulated learning, teaching presence and student engagement in blended learning. A two-level model was designed based on contextual factors (teaching presence) and individual factors (regulated learning), and experience sampling method was employed to collect intensive longitudinal data on 139 participants across three universities over 13 weeks in a blended course. Furthermore, multilevel regression analysis were conducted to examine the effects of teaching presence, self-regulated learning (SRL), co-regulated learning (CoRL) on intra- and interindividual variance in student engagement. The findings were as follows. 1) Perceived teacher support and instructional design fit had a significant positive effect on cognitive and emotional engagement and were crucial contextual factors that influenced intraindividual variance in learning engagement. 2) SRL and CoRL were copredictors of student engagement in blended learning. CoRL was more related to emotional engagement, while SRL was more related to cognitive engagement. 3) Modality had a significant effect on cognitive engagement but not on emotional engagement. 4) SRL and CoRL positively moderated the relationship between perceived teaching presence and cognitive engagement, while they negatively moderated the relationship between teacher support and emotional engagement, i.e., the relation between teacher support and emotional engagement was stronger in situations of low SRL or CoRL. Implications for teaching practice on blended learning were also discussed.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10639-023-11717-5.

Examinations of the relationships between self-efficacy, self-regulation, teaching, cognitive presences, and learning engagement during COVID-19

This study investigated the relationships between self-efficacy, self-regulation, and teaching presence, cognitive presence, and learning engagement during the pandemic. A total of 1435 undergraduate students in Korea completed an online survey on their learning experiences during COVID-19. The findings indicate that self-efficacy had a positive relationship with teaching presence and cognitive presence as well as self-regulation. No direct relationship between self-efficacy on learning engagement was found; however, the relationship between self-efficacy and learning engagement was fully mediated by self-regulation, teaching presence, and cognitive presence. Self-regulation had a positive relationship with both cognitive presence and learning engagement. Teaching presence had a positive impact on cognitive presence, but not on learning engagement. However, cognitive presence fully mediated the relationship between teaching presence and learning engagement. In effect, this study lends support to the significance of the role of cognitive presence in online learning.

Ecological aspects of online learning in higher education: a qualitative multi-level exploration in a developing country

Using 22 undergraduate business students' online learning experiences during the COVID-19 lockdown in Pakistan (as the pandemic was the only time these students were enrolled as online students in Pakistan), this study demonstrates that online learning is a multi-level phenomenon and a practice situated within the environment. Despite online learning being a heavily researched area, research has under-examined the interaction of the Community of Inquiry (CoI) framework with the context. By adopting an ecological perspective, and by examining the interaction of micro, meso, and macro levels, this qualitative research provides useful insights into the interaction of the individual (micro-level) captured through the CoI framework, with the broader environment in which learners are located (meso and macro levels). It contributes to research on online learning broadly, and the CoI framework specifically, by revealing that each element of the CoI framework (micro-level), is influenced by macro (developing country), as well as meso (institutional policies and institutional preparedness) levels. It also spotlights the negotiated relationship between the individual and the systemic forces. The findings of this study are particularly relevant given that online education has the potential to become a norm in higher education in developing countries.

Evaluating online learning engagement of nursing students

BACKGROUND

Previous studies suggest that increased learning satisfaction may encourage learning engagement in an online learning environment.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the level of learning engagement and its relationship with students' perceived learning satisfaction in an online clinical nursing elective course.

DESIGN

A prospective interventional study.

SETTINGS

A nursing course was converted to an online format because of the coronavirus disease COVID pandemic.

PARTICIPANTS

Part-time post-registration nursing undergraduates enrolled in an elective online clinical course.

METHODS

Related teaching and learning strategies were deployed in the course using the Community of Inquiry framework. All students who completed the course were invited to complete an online survey that included a validated Online Student Engagement questionnaire (OSE). Pearson's correlations were used to determine the association between perceived learning satisfaction and learning engagement. A logistic regression model was used to explore the associations of gender, age, working experience and perceived learning satisfaction with higher learning engagement.

RESULTS

The questionnaires were completed by 56 of 68 students (82%). The Pearson's correlation coefficient between the mean perceived learning satisfaction and OSE scores was 0.75 (p < .001). Twenty-five students (45%) were identified as highly engaged, using a cut-off of ≥3.5 for the mean OSE score. The mean perceived learning satisfaction (SD) score differed significantly between highly engaged and not highly engaged students [4.02 (0.49) vs. 3.27 (0.62), p < .001]. The logistic regression model showed that a greater perceived learning satisfaction [adjusted odds ratio (OR): 17.2, 95% C.I.: 3.46-86.0, p = .001] was associated with an increased likelihood of higher learning engagement, and >1 year of working experience (adjusted OR: 0.11, 95% C.I.: 0.01-0.89, p = .0039) was associated with a decreased likelihood of higher learning engagement.

CONCLUSIONS

The study findings suggest that perceived learning satisfaction predicts learning engagement among nursing students in this online learning course.

Mindful Medical Education Online

The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted medical education. In-person classes and clinical rotations were urgently canceled, followed by a historic and unprecedented migration to online teaching. Most medical school courses were not designed to be fully online, and faculty and students are novices in the process. The purpose of this article is to provide recommendations for educators to optimize their approach to online curricular transformation. Mindful teaching online creates presences that set climate and support discourse, establish routines that build practice, model professional expectations, and challenge but support learners.

Integrating students' perspectives about online learning: a hierarchy of factors

This article reports on a large-scale (n = 987), exploratory factor analysis study incorporating various concepts identified in the literature as critical success factors for online learning from the students' perspective, and then determines their hierarchical significance. Seven factors--Basic Online Modality, Instructional Support, Teaching Presence, Cognitive Presence, Online Social Comfort, Online Interactive Modality, and Social Presence--were identified as significant and reliable. Regression analysis indicates the minimal factors for enrollment in future classes-when students consider convenience and scheduling-were Basic Online Modality, Cognitive Presence, and Online Social Comfort. Students who accepted or embraced online courses on their own merits wanted a minimum of Basic Online Modality, Teaching Presence, Cognitive Presence, Online Social Comfort, and Social Presence. Students, who preferred face-to-face classes and demanded a comparable experience, valued Online Interactive Modality and Instructional Support more highly. Recommendations for online course design, policy, and future research are provided.

Using summary videos in online classes for nursing students: A mixed methods study

Online courses need strategies to engage students, especially after a learning module is over. We made a series of summary videos for students' assignments and investigated their impact on students' learning. This study investigated whether, from the students' perspective, summary videos made by teachers for each learning module in asynchronized online courses led to students' engagement and feeling of being helped. We used exploratory sequential mixed methods research design, which started with a qualitative phase. After collecting students' feedback from an open-ended question administered to 47 nursing students from 3 online courses, we conducted qualitative data analysis. The analysis identified 2 themes: engagement and helpfulness. We used these themes to find 2 validated surveys from the literature to quantitatively measure students' engagement levels and perceived helpfulness of the summary videos. In the quantitative phase, we surveyed 78 nursing students from 4 online courses 3 times. The results indicated that there was no statistically significant difference in students' perceived engagement level among the 3 time points, and that students did not believe the helpful impact of the summary videos on their learning increased significantly. In the mixed methods phase, we compared and contrasted the teaching strategies, quotes from the qualitative strand, and results from the statistical analyses of survey data. The results indicated that the summary videos were helpful in facilitating students' achievement of learning new knowledge and reinforcing previous knowledge; engaging students cognitively, emotionally, and socially; and motivating students intrinsically. However, the videos did not help with students' behavioral engagement and did not help students have a fun learning experience. We concluded that the teaching presence in the summary videos created the positive and supportive learning environment necessary for giving students the opportunity to engage with learning contents.