Clickable Dynamic Bioinks Enable Post-Printing Modifications of Construct Composition and Mechanical Properties Controlled over Time and Space

Bioprinting is a booming technology, with numerous applications in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine. However, most biomaterials designed for bioprinting depend on the use of sacrificial baths and/or non-physiological stimuli. Printable biomaterials also often lack tunability in terms of their composition and mechanical properties. To address these challenges, the authors introduce a new biomaterial concept that they have termed "clickable dynamic bioinks". These bioinks use dynamic hydrogels that can be printed, as well as chemically modified via click reactions to fine-tune the physical and biochemical properties of printed objects after printing. Specifically, using hyaluronic acid (HA) as a polymer of interest, the authors investigate the use of a boronate ester-based crosslinking reaction to produce dynamic hydrogels that are printable and cytocompatible, allowing for bioprinting. The resulting dynamic bioinks are chemically modified with bioorthogonal click moieties to allow for a variety of post-printing modifications with molecules carrying the complementary click function. As proofs of concept, the authors perform various post-printing modifications, including adjusting polymer composition (e.g., HA, chondroitin sulfate, and gelatin) and stiffness, and promoting cell adhesion via adhesive peptide immobilization (i.e., RGD peptide). The results also demonstrate that these modifications can be controlled over time and space, paving the way for 4D bioprinting applications.

Phosphoserine enhanced Cu-doped bioactive glass dynamic dual-network hydrogel for craniofacial bone defect repair

Flexible hydrogels containing various osteogenic inorganic constituents, which can accommodate complicated shape variations, are considered as ideal grafts for craniofacial bone defect reconstruction. However, in most hybrid hydrogels, poor interaction between the polymer network and particles has detrimental effects on hydrogel rheological and structural properties, clinical manipulation and repair efficacy. In this article, we designed and prepared a series of hyaluronic acid composite hydrogel containing Cu-doped bioactive glass (CuBG) and phosphoserine (PS), in which hyaluronic acid was modified by methacrylate groups and phenylboronic acid groups to form a double crosslinked network. PS acted as an interaction bridge of CuBG particles and HAMA-PBA network to improve the mechanical properties of the composite hydrogels. The CuBG/PS hydrogels exhibited suitable rheological properties (injectable, self-healing, shape-adaptable), bone tissue integrating ability and anti-bacterial property. Meanwhile, we found that CuBG and PS have synergistic effect on improving osteogenic efficiency both in vitro and in vivo, particularly when the ratio of CuBG to PS is lower than 3 (9CB/3PS). This work provided a versatile and scalable approach to enhanced the interaction within inorganic particles and polymer network in hydrogels without extra modification on components.

Dynamic Alginate Hydrogel as an Antioxidative Bioink for Bioprinting

3D bioprinting holds great potential for use in tissue engineering to treat degenerative joint disorders, such as osteoarthritis. However, there is a lack of multifunctional bioinks that can not only support cell growth and differentiation, but also offer protection to cells against injuries caused by the elevated oxidative stress; this conditions is a common characteristic of the microenvironment of the osteoarthritis disease. To mitigate oxidative stress-induced cellular phenotype change and malfunction, an anti-oxidative bioink derived from an alginate dynamic hydrogel was developed in this study. The alginate dynamic hydrogel gelated quickly via the dynamic covalent bond between the phenylboronic acid modified alginate (Alg-PBA) and poly (vinyl alcohol) (PVA). It presented good self-healing and shear-thinning abilities because of the dynamic feature. The dynamic hydrogel supported long-term growth of mouse fibroblasts after stabilization with a secondary ionic crosslinking between introduced calcium ions and the carboxylate group in the alginate backbone. In addition, the dynamic hydrogel showed good printability, resulting in the fabrication of scaffolds with cylindrical and grid structures with good structural fidelity. Encapsulated mouse chondrocytes maintained high viability for at least 7 days in the bioprinted hydrogel after ionic crosslinking. Most importantly, in vitro studies implied that the bioprinted scaffold could reduce the intracellular oxidative stress for embedded chondrocytes under H₂O₂ exposure; it could also protect the chondrocytes from H₂O₂-induced downregulation of extracellular matrix (ECM) relevant anabolic genes (ACAN and COL2) and upregulation of a catabolic gene (MMP13). In summary, the results suggest that the dynamic alginate hydrogel can be applied as a versatile bioink for the fabrication of 3D bioprinted scaffolds with an innate antioxidative ability; this technique is expected to improve the regenerative efficacy of cartilage tissues for the treatment of joint disorders.

Dynamic and Wearable Electro-responsive Hydrogel with Robust Mechanical Properties for Drug Release

Electro-responsive dynamic hydrogels, which possess robust mechanical properties and precise spatiotemporal resolution, have a wide range of applications in biomedicine and energy science. However, it is still challenging to design and prepare electro-responsive hydrogels (ERHs) which have all of these properties. Here, we report one such class of ERHs with these features, based on the direct current voltage (DCV)-induced rearrangement of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles, where the rearrangement can tune the hydrogel networks that are originally maintained by the SDS micelle-assisted hydrophobic interactions. An enlarged mesh size is demonstrated for these ERHs after DCV treatment. Given the unique structure and properties of these ERHs, hydrophobic cargo (thiostrepton) has been incorporated into the hydrogels and is released upon DCV loading. Additionally, these hydrogels are highly stretchable (>6000%) and tough (507 J/m²), showing robust mechanical properties. Moreover, these hydrogels have a high spatiotemporal resolution. As the cross-links within our ERHs are enabled by the non-covalent (i.e., hydrophobic) interactions, these hydrogels are self-healing and malleable. Considering the robust mechanical properties, precise spatiotemporal resolution, dynamic nature (e.g., injectable and self-healing), and on-demand drug delivery ability, this class of ERHs will be of great interest in the fields of wearable bioelectronics and smart drug delivery systems.

Multifunctional Microgel-Based Cream Hydrogels for Postoperative Abdominal Adhesion Prevention

Postoperative abdominal adhesions are a common problem after surgery and can produce serious complications. Current antiadhesive strategies focus mostly on physical barriers and are unsatisfactory and inefficient. In this study, we designed and synthesized advanced injectable cream-like hydrogels with multiple functionalities, including rapid gelation, self-healing, antioxidation, anti-inflammation, and anti-cell adhesion. The multifunctional hydrogels were facilely formed by the conjugation reaction of epigallocatechin-3-gallate (EGCG) and hyaluronic acid (HA)-based microgels and poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) based on the dynamic boronic ester bond. The physicochemical properties of the hydrogels including antioxidative and anti-inflammatory activities were systematically characterized. A mouse cecum-abdominal wall adhesion model was implemented to investigate the efficacy of our microgel-based hydrogels in preventing postoperative abdominal adhesions. The hydrogels, with a high molecular weight HA, significantly decreased the inflammation, oxidative stress, and fibrosis and reduced the abdominal adhesion formation, compared to the commercial Seprafilm group or Injury-only group. Label-free quantitative proteomics analysis demonstrated that S100A8 and S100A9 expressions were associated with adhesion formation; the microgel-containing hydrogels inhibited these expressions. The microgel-containing hydrogels with multifunctionality decreased the formation of postoperative intra-abdominal adhesions in a murine model, demonstrating promise for clinical applications.

3D Printable Dynamic Hydrogel: As Simple as it Gets!

3D Printing technology offers a vast range of applications for tissue engineering applications. Over the past decade a vast range of new equipment has been developed; while, 3D printable biomaterials, especially hydrogels, are investigated to fit the printability requirements. The current candidates for bioprinting often requires post-printing cross-linking to maintain their shape. On the other hand, dynamic hydrogels are considered as the most promising candidate for this application with their extrudability and self-healing properties. However, it proves to be very difficult to match the required rheological in a simple material. Here, we present for the first time the simplest formulation of a dynamic hydrogel based on thiol-functionalized hyaluronic acid formulated with gold ions that fulfill all the requirements to be printed without the use of external stimuli, as judged by the rheological studies. The printability was also demonstrated with a 3D printer allowing to print the dynamic hydrogel as it is, achieving 3D construct with a relatively good precision and up to 24 layers, corresponding to 10 mm high. This material is the simplest 3D printable hydrogel and its mixture with cells and biological compounds is expected to open a new era in 3D bioprinting. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Regulating Bacterial Behavior within Hydrogels of Tunable Viscoelasticity

Engineered living materials (ELMs) are a new class of materials in which living organism incorporated into diffusive matrices uptake a fundamental role in material's composition and function. Understanding how the spatial confinement in 3D can regulate the behavior of the embedded cells is crucial to design and predict ELM's function, minimize their environmental impact and facilitate their translation into applied materials. This study investigates the growth and metabolic activity of bacteria within an associative hydrogel network (Pluronic-based) with mechanical properties that can be tuned by introducing a variable degree of acrylate crosslinks. Individual bacteria distributed in the hydrogel matrix at low density form functional colonies whose size is controlled by the extent of permanent crosslinks. With increasing stiffness and elastic response to deformation of the matrix, a decrease in colony volumes and an increase in their sphericity are observed. Protein production follows a different pattern with higher production yields occurring in networks with intermediate permanent crosslinking degrees. These results demonstrate that matrix design can be used to control and regulate the composition and function of ELMs containing microorganisms. Interestingly, design parameters for matrices to regulate bacteria behavior show similarities to those elucidated for 3D culture of mammalian cells.

Dynamic hyaluronic acid hydrogel with covalent linked gelatin as an anti-oxidative bioink for cartilage tissue engineering

In the past decade, cartilage tissue engineering has arisen as a promising therapeutic option for degenerative joint diseases, such as osteoarthritis, in the hope of restoring the structure and physiological functions. Hydrogels are promising biomaterials for developing engineered scaffolds for cartilage regeneration. However, hydrogel-delivered mesenchymal stem cells or chondrocytes could be exposed to elevated levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in the inflammatory microenvironment after being implanted into injured joints, which may affect their phenotype and normal functions and thereby hinder the regeneration efficacy. To attenuate ROS induced side effects, a multifunctional hydrogel with an innate anti-oxidative ability was produced in this study. The hydrogel was rapidly formed through a dynamic covalent bond between phenylboronic acid grafted hyaluronic acid (HA-PBA) and poly(vinyl alcohol) and was further stabilized through a secondary crosslinking between the acrylate moiety on HA-PBA and the free thiol group from thiolated gelatin. The hydrogel is cyto-compatible and injectable and can be used as a bioink for 3D bioprinting. The viscoelastic properties of the hydrogels could be modulated through the hydrogel precursor concentration. The presence of dynamic covalent linkages contributed to its shear-thinning property and thus good printability of the hydrogel, resulting in the fabrication of a porous grid construct and a meniscus like scaffold at high structural fidelity. The bioprinted hydrogel promoted cell adhesion and chondrogenic differentiation of encapsulated rabbit adipose derived mesenchymal stem cells. Meanwhile, the hydrogel supported robust deposition of extracellular matrix components, including glycosaminoglycans and type II collagen, by embedded mouse chondrocytesin vitro. Most importantly, the hydrogel could protect encapsulated chondrocytes from ROS induced downregulation of cartilage-specific anabolic genes (ACAN and COL2) and upregulation of a catabolic gene (MMP13) after incubation with H₂O₂. Furthermore, intra-articular injection of the hydrogel in mice revealed adequate stability and good biocompatibilityin vivo. These results demonstrate that this hydrogel can be used as a novel bioink for the generation of 3D bioprinted constructs with anti-ROS ability to potentially enhance cartilage tissue regeneration in a chronic inflammatory and elevated ROS microenvironment.

Temperature-Responsive, Manipulable Cavitary Hydrogel Containers by Macroscopic Spatial Surface-Interior Separation

Synthetic macroscopic materials transforming from bulk solid or semisolid to a closed structure with inner cavities and distinct outer and inner microstructures are rarely reported. Here, we report an in situ method for directing spatial surface-interior separation from bulk dynamic hydrogels to closed three-dimensional (3D) hydrogel containers with inner cavities via constructing a competitively cross-linking gradient within dynamic hydrogels. The initial cross-linking of phenylboronic acid/catechol complexes is disrupted by stronger ferric ions/catechol associations, generating gradually weakened cross-linking from the outside to the inside. Both stronger cross-linking in the outer shells and sequentially weaker cross-linked interior generated during swelling closed the hydrogel container with a tunable dense outer shell, fluffy inner layer, and cavities in the core. Cellulose nanocrystals could be used to significantly improve the spatial distinction of gradient cross-linking within hydrogels, leading to an even denser outer shell with tunable shell thickness. Moreover, cavitary hydrogel containers with diverse shapes can be programmed by designing the initial shapes of dynamic hydrogels and macroscopic assembly of individual dynamic hydrogels based on their self-healing capability after subsequent surface-interior separation. These cavitary hydrogel containers demonstrate thermal-responsive gate systems with unique sustained release at higher temperature and potential reaction containers for oxygen generation on demand. This facile spatial surface-interior separation strategy for fabricating closed cavity systems has great potential for various applications.

Liquid-Behaviors-Assisted Fabrication of Multidimensional Birefringent Materials from Dynamic Hybrid Hydrogels

Liquid-solid transition is a widely used strategy to shape polymeric materials and encode their microstructures. However, it is still challenging to fully exploit liquid behaviors of material precursors. In particular, the dynamic and static liquid behaviors naturally conflict with each other, which makes it difficult to integrate their advantages in the same materials. Here, by utilizing a shear-thinning phenomenon in the dynamic hybrid hydrogels, we achieve a hydrodynamic alignment of cellulose nanocrystals (CNC) and preserve it in the relaxed hydrogel networks due to the much faster relaxation of polymer networks (within 500 s) than CNC after the unloading of external force. During the following drying process, the surface tension of hydrogels further enhances the orientation index of CNC up to 0.872 in confined geometry, and these anisotropic microstructures demonstrate highly tunable birefringence (up to 0.004 14). Due to the presence of the boundaries of dynamic hydrogels, diverse xerogels including fibers, films, and even complex three-dimensional structures with variable anisotropic microstructures can be fabricated without any external molds.

A Diffusion-Reaction Model for Predicting Enzyme-Mediated Dynamic Hydrogel Stiffening

Hydrogels with spatiotemporally tunable mechanical properties have been increasingly employed for studying the impact of tissue mechanics on cell fate processes. These dynamic hydrogels are particularly suitable for recapitulating the temporal stiffening of a tumor microenvironment. To this end, we have reported an enzyme-mediated stiffening hydrogel system where tyrosinase (Tyr_ase) was used to stiffen orthogonally crosslinked cell-laden hydrogels. Herein, a mathematical model was proposed to describe enzyme diffusion and reaction within a highly swollen gel network, and to elucidate the critical factors affecting the degree of gel stiffening. Briefly, Fick’s second law of diffusion was used to predict enzyme diffusion in a swollen poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-peptide hydrogel, whereas the Michaelis–Menten model was employed for estimating the extent of enzyme-mediated secondary crosslinking. To experimentally validate model predictions, we designed a hydrogel system composed of 8-arm PEG-norbornene (PEG8NB) and bis-cysteine containing peptide crosslinker. Hydrogel was crosslinked in a channel slide that permitted one-dimensional diffusion of Tyr_ase. Model predictions and experimental results suggested that an increasing network crosslinking during stiffening process did not significantly affect enzyme diffusion. Rather, diffusion path length and the time of enzyme incubation were more critical in determining the distribution of Tyr_ase and the formation of additional crosslinks in the hydrogel network. Finally, we demonstrated that the enzyme-stiffened hydrogels exhibited elastic properties similar to other chemically crosslinked hydrogels. This study provides a better mechanistic understanding regarding the process of enzyme-mediated dynamic stiffening of hydrogels.

Viscoelastic Oxidized Alginates with Reversible Imine Type Crosslinks: Self-Healing, Injectable, and Bioprintable Hydrogels

Bioprinting techniques allow for the recreation of 3D tissue-like structures. By deposition of hydrogels combined with cells (bioinks) in a spatially controlled way, one can create complex and multiscale structures. Despite this promise, the ability to deposit customizable cell-laden structures for soft tissues is still limited. Traditionally, bioprinting relies on hydrogels comprised of covalent or mostly static crosslinks. Yet, soft tissues and the extracellular matrix (ECM) possess viscoelastic properties, which can be more appropriately mimicked with hydrogels containing reversible crosslinks. In this study, we have investigated aldehyde containing oxidized alginate (ox-alg), combined with different cross-linkers, to develop a small library of viscoelastic, self-healing, and bioprintable hydrogels. By using distinctly different imine-type dynamic covalent chemistries (DCvC), (oxime, semicarbazone, and hydrazone), rational tuning of rheological and mechanical properties was possible. While all materials showed biocompatibility, we observed that the nature of imine type crosslink had a marked influence on hydrogel stiffness, viscoelasticity, self-healing, cell morphology, and printability. The semicarbazone and hydrazone crosslinks were found to be viscoelastic, self-healing, and printable-without the need for additional Ca2+ crosslinking-while also promoting the adhesion and spreading of fibroblasts. In contrast, the oxime cross-linked gels were found to be mostly elastic and showed neither self-healing, suitable printability, nor fibroblast spreading. The semicarbazone and hydrazone gels hold great potential as dynamic 3D cell culture systems, for therapeutics and cell delivery, and a newer generation of smart bioinks.