The pH-dependent role of superoxide in riboflavin-catalyzed photooxidation of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanosine

[reaction: see text]. The riboflavin-catalyzed photooxidation of 2',3',5'-tri-O-acetyl-8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanosine generates a radical intermediate that is competitively trapped by H(2)O, O2(-)(*), or O(2). The products of H(2)O trapping have been previously described as the spiroiminodihydantoin (pH >or= 7) and iminoallantoin/guanidinohydantoin (pH < 7) nucleosides. Trapping by O2(-)(*) leads to the oxaluric acid (pH <or= 7) and imidazolone (pH >or= 8.6) pathways (R' ', R' ' = H or 2,3,5-tri-O-Ac-ribofuranosyl). The pH-dependent role of superoxide was probed using Mn-SOD and compared to guanosine and 8-methoxyguanosine photooxidation.

Characterization of hydantoin products from one-electron oxidation of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanosine in a nucleoside model

Use of one-electron oxidants such as Na(2)IrCl(6) to oxidize 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2'-deoxyguanosine (OG) residues in oligodeoxynucleotides was previously shown to lead to predominant formation of a base lesion of mass M - 10 compared to starting material [Duarte et al. (1999) Nucleic Acids Res. 27, 596-502]. To thoroughly characterize the structure of this lesion, the oxidation of the nucleoside 9-N-(2',3',5'-tri-O-acetyl-beta-D-erythro-pentanosyl)-8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine with one-electron oxidants at pH 2-4 was used as a model for duplex DNA oxidation of OG residues. (1)H NMR and H,H COSY NMR studies in CD(3)OD along with LC-ESI-MS/MS fragmentation analysis are consistent with the assignment of the M - 10 species as a mixture of two pH-dependent equilibrating isomers, a guanidinohydantoin (Gh) and an iminoallantoin (Ia) nucleoside, both present as mixtures of epimers at the C5 position of the hydantoin ring, i.e., four total isomers are formed. The Gh/Ia mixture is formed from hydration and decarboxylation of the initially formed intermediate 5-hydroxy-8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanosine, a species that is also produced by four-electron oxidation (e.g., singlet oxygen) of guanosine. The product mixture can be further oxidized to a species designated Ia(ox), a hydrolytically unstable material at pH 7 that has been characterized by ESI-MS and (1)H NMR. Competition studies with 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroadenosine placed the redox potential of Gh/Ia at about 1.0 V vs NHE. These studies provide important information concerning the structures of lesions obtained when OG, a "hot spot" for oxidative damage, serves as a "hole trap" in long-range electron-transfer studies.

Repair of hydantoins, one electron oxidation product of 8-oxoguanine, by DNA glycosylases of Escherichia coli

8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG), induced by reactive oxygen species and arguably one of the most important mutagenic DNA lesions, is prone to further oxidation. Its one-electron oxidation products include potentially mutagenic guanidinohydantoin (Gh) and spiroiminodihydantoin (Sp) because of their mispairing with A or G. All three oxidized base-specific DNA glycosylases of Escherichia coli, namely endonuclease III (Nth), 8-oxoG-DNA glycosylase (MutM) and endonuclease VIII (Nei), excise Gh and Sp, when paired with C or G in DNA, although Nth is less active than the other two. MutM prefers Sp and Gh paired with C (kcat/K(m) of 0.24-0.26 min(-1) x nM(-1)), while Nei prefers G over C as the complementary base (k(cat)/K(m) - 0.15-0.17 min(-1) x nM(-1)). However, only Nei efficiently excises these paired with A. MutY, a 8-oxoG.A(G)-specific A(G)-DNA glycosylase, is inactive with Gh(Sp).A/G-containing duplex oligonucleotide, in spite of specific affinity. It inhibits excision of lesions by MutM from the Gh.G or Sp.G pair, but not from Gh.C and Sp.C pairs. In contrast, MutY does not significantly inhibit Nei for any Gh(Sp) base pair. These results suggest a protective function for MutY in preventing mutation as a result of A (G) incorporation opposite Gh(Sp) during DNA replication.

Probing nucleic acid structure with nickel- and cobalt-based reagents

The use of nickel and cobalt reagents is presented for characterizing the solvent exposure of guanine residues in DNA and RNA. These reagents promote guanine oxidation in the presence of a peracid such as monopersulfate, and the extent of reaction indicates the steric and electronic environment surrounding the N7 and aromatic face of this residue. Since oxidation does not itself perturb target structure or induce strand scission, it is coupled with fragmentation by treatment with piperidine (for smaller polynucleotides) or termination of primer extension (for larger polynucleotides).

Guanine versus deoxyribose damage in DNA oxidation mediated by vanadium(IV) and vanadium(V) complexes

Vanadyl sulfate reacts with the peroxy acid oxidant KHSO5 to produce guanine-selective oxidation of a 167-bp restriction fragment of DNA. The oxidized lesions result in strand scission after hot piperidine treatment. Although several reactive intermediates are possible, quenching studies with ethanol and tert-butyl alcohol suggest that a monoperoxysulfate radical or a caged sulfate radical are the likely species responsible for oxidation of guanine. Several oxidants and various vanadium complexes (including insulin mimetic compounds) were studied with DNA for comparison. None of the other vanadium complexes showed modification of the double-stranded 167-bp fragment of DNA in the presence of KHSO5. The reactivity of VOSO4 may be due to its irreversible oxidation potential of 0.77 V (vs. Ag+/AgCl, pH 7.0, 10 mM phosphate), making it an appropriate catalyst for decomposition of monoperoxysulfate.

Mechanisms of DNA cleavage by copper complexes of 3-clip-phen and of its conjugate with a distamycin analogue

Mechanisms of DNA oxidation by copper complexes of 3-Clip-Phen and its conjugate with a distamycin analogue, in the presence of a reductant and air, were studied. Characterisation of the production of 5-methylenefuranone (5-MF) and furfural, associated with the release of nucleobases, indicated that these copper complexes oxidised the C1' and C5' positions of 2-deoxyribose, respectively, which are accessible from the DNA minor groove. Oxidation at C1' was the major degradation route. Digestion of DNA oxidation products by P1 nuclease and bacterial alkaline phosphatase allowed characterisation of glycolic acid residues, indicating that these copper complexes also induced C4' oxidation. However, this pathway was not associated with base propenal release. The ability of the copper complex of the 3-Clip-Phen conjugate with the distamycin analogue to produce sequence-selective DNA cleavage allowed confirmation of these mechanisms of DNA oxidation by PAGE. Comparison of DNA cleavage activity showed that conjugation of 3-Clip-Phen with a DNA minor groove binder, like the distamycin analogue, decreased both its ability to perform C1' oxidation as well as the initial rate of the reaction, but this conjugate is still active after 5 h at 37 degrees C, making it an efficient DNA cleaver.

Removal of hydantoin products of 8-oxoguanine oxidation by the Escherichia coli DNA repair enzyme, FPG

An intriguing feature of 7,8-dihydro-8-oxo-2'-deoxyguanosine (OG) is that it is highly reactive toward further oxidation. Indeed, OG has been shown to be a "hot spot" for oxidative damage and susceptible to oxidation by a variety of cellular oxidants. Recent work has identified two new DNA lesions, guanidinohydantoin (Gh) and spiroiminodihydantoin (Sp), resulting from one-electron oxidation of OG. The presence of Gh and Sp lesions in DNA templates has been shown to result in misinsertion of G and A by DNA polymerases, and therefore, both are potentially mutagenic DNA lesions. The base excision repair (BER) glycosylases Fpg and MutY serve to prevent mutations associated with OG in Escherichia coli, and therefore, we have investigated the ability of these two enzymes to process DNA duplex substrates containing the further oxidized OG lesions, Gh and Sp. The Fpg protein, which removes OG and a variety of other oxidized purine base lesions, was found to remove Gh and Sp efficiently opposite all four of the natural DNA bases. The intrinsic rate of damaged base excision by Fpg was measured under single-turnover conditions and was found to be highly dependent upon the identity of the base opposite the OG, Gh, or Sp lesion; as expected, OG is removed more readily from an OG:C- than an OG:A-containing substrate. However, when adenine is paired with Gh or Sp, the rate of removal of these damaged lesions by Fpg was significantly increased relative to the rate of removal of OG from an OG:A mismatch. The adenine glycosylase MutY, which removes misincorporated A residues from OG:A mismatches, is unable to remove A paired with Gh or Sp. Thus, the activity of Fpg on Gh and Sp lesions may dramatically influence their mutagenic potential. This work suggests that, in addition to OG, oxidative products resulting from further oxidation of OG should be considered when evaluating oxidative DNA damage and its associated effects on DNA mutagenesis.

Targeting the DNA cleavage activity of copper phenanthroline and clip-phen to A.T tracts via linkage to a poly-N-methylpyrrole

To target DNA A.T tracts, a three-ring polyamide containing an N-methylpyrrole amino acid has been linked, on solid support, to carboxylic derivatives of phenanthroline and dimers of phenanthroline: 2-Clip-Phen, 3-Clip-Phen, or 2-Clip-Phen containing a long tether. After metalation by CuCl(2), the DNA cleavage activities of the different conjugates were compared on a restriction fragment. Cleavage patterns showed that the polyamide moiety of conjugates directs the cleavage activity in the vicinity of A.T tracts but the precise cleavage selectivity of these conjugates was dependent on the type of phenanthroline residue linked to the poly-N-methylpyrrole entity.

Characterization of spiroiminodihydantoin as a product of one-electron oxidation of 8-Oxo-7,8-dihydroguanosine

[reaction: see text] Further oxidation of the common DNA lesion 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanosine by one-electron oxidants such as IrCl6(2-), Fe(CN)6(3-), or SO4-* leads to two major products, depending upon reaction conditions. In nucleosides at pH 7, 22 degrees C, the principal product is shown herein to be a spiroiminodihydantoin nucleoside, as a diastereomeric mixture, that can be characterized by NMR, ESI-MS/MS, and independent synthesis.

Nickel and cobalt reagents promote selective oxidation of Z-DNA

The structural characteristics of Z-DNA were used to challenge the selectivity of guanine oxidation promoted by nickel and cobalt reagents. Base pairing and stacking within all helical structures studied previously had hindered access to guanine and limited its reaction. However, the Z-helix uniquely retains high exposure of guanine N7. This exposure was sufficient to direct oxidation specifically to a plasmid insert -(CG)(13)AATT(CG)(13)- that adopted a Z-conformation under native supercoiling. An alternative insert -(CG)(7)- retained its B-conformation and demonstrated the expected lack of reactivity. For a nickel salen complex made from a particularly bulky ligand, preferential reaction shifted to the junctions within the Z-DNA insert as is common for large reagents. Inactivation of the nickel reagents by high-salt concentrations prevented parallel investigations of Z-DNA, formed by oligonucleotides. However, the activity of Co(2+) was minimally affected by salt and consequently confirmed the high reactivity of 5'-p(CG)(4) in its Z-conformation. These reagents may now be applied to a broad array of targets, since their structural specificity remains predictable for both complex and helical assemblies of nucleic acids.

Selective association between a macrocyclic nickel complex and extrahelical guanine residues

Nickel-dependent recognition and oxidation of guanine have been linked in part through the paramagnetic effects of nickel on the NMR of model oligonucleotide duplexes. Direct interaction between nickel and guanine N7 had originally been postulated from correlations between the efficiency of guanine oxidation and the environment surrounding its N7 position. (1)H and (31)P NMR spectra of DNA containing a single, isolated extrahelical guanine are consistent with selective binding of nickel to the N7 of this unique base over a background of nonspecific association to the phosphate backbone. The presence of a macrocyclic complex or simple salt of nickel did not detectably alter the structure of the duplex or extrahelical residue. Accordingly, nickel appeared to bind the extrahelical guanine N7 within the major groove as indicated by paramagnetic effects on the proton signals of nucleotides on the 5' but not 3' side of the nickel binding site. Similar (1)H NMR analysis of DNA containing a dynamic equilibrium of extrahelical guanine residues also suggested that the nickel complex did not affect the native distribution of structures. Oxidation of these sites by a nickel-mediated pathway consequently reflected their solvent accessibility in a general and metal-independent manner. The close proximity of the extrahelical guanines produced a composite of paramagnetic effects on each adjacent nucleotide resulting from both direct and proximal coordination of nickel.

Insertion of dGMP and dAMP during in vitro DNA synthesis opposite an oxidized form of 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine

Oxidative damage to DNA bases commonly resultsin the formation of oxidized purines, particularly 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG) and 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoadenine (8-oxoA), the former being a well-known mutagenic lesion. Since 8-oxoG is readily subject to further oxidation compared with normal bases, the insertion of a base during DNA synthesis opposite an oxidized form of 8-oxoG was investigated in vitro. A synthetic template containing a single 8-oxoG lesion was first treated with different one-electron oxidants or under singlet oxygen conditions and then subjected to primer extension catalyzed by Klenow fragment exo- (Kf exo-), calf thymus DNA polymerase alpha (pol alpha) or human DNA polymerase beta (pol beta). Consistent with previous reports, dAMP and dCMP are inserted selectively opposite 8-oxoG with all three DNA polymerases. Interestingly, oxidation of 8-oxoG was found to induce dAMP and dGMP insertion opposite the lesion by Kf exo- with transient inhibition of primer extension occurring at the site of the modified base. Furthermore, the lesion constitutes a block during DNA synthesis by pol alpha and pol beta. Experiments with an 8-oxoA-modified template oligonucleotide show that both 8-oxoA and an oxidized form of 8-oxoA direct insertion of dTMP by Kf exo-. Mass spectrometric analysis of 8-oxoG-containing oligonucleotides before and after oxidation with IrCl62-are consistent with oxidation of primarily the 8-oxoG site, resulting in formation of a guanidinohydantoin moiety as the major product. No evidence for formation of abasic sites was obtained. These results demonstrate that an oxidized form of 8-oxoG, possibly guanidinohydantoin, may direct misreading and misinsertion of dNTPs during DNA synthesis. If such a process occurred in vivo, it would represent a point mutagenic lesion leading to G-->T and G-->C transversions. However, the corresponding oxidized form of 8-oxoA primarily shows correct insertion of T during DNA synthesis with Kf exo-.

A nickel complex cleaves uridine in folded RNA structures: application to E. coli tmRNA and related engineered molecules

To gain more insight about Escherichia coli tmRNA structure, NiCR, a square planar macrocyclic nickel (II) complex, was used to probe guanine N7 exposure. On the basis of this additional structural information, a refined secondary structure of the molecule is proposed. In addition to its known specificity for guanine N7, we show here that the chemical probe can also cleave at specific uridine residues. In contrast to the alkaline-labile modification of guanine, the reactivity of NiCR at these uridine residues results in direct strand scission. To better characterize the uridine cleavage sites and assess the importance of the RNA structure for the reaction to occur, smaller RNA molecules derived from one pseudoknot (PK4) of E. coli tmRNA containing two uridine cleavage sites were engineered and probed. It is shown that this pseudoknot can fold by itself in solution and that the expected uridine residues are also cleaved by the nickel complex, suggesting that only a local sequence and/or structural context is required for cleavage. In E. coli tmRNA, the five uridine cleavage sites are located in double-stranded regions. These sites contain a G-U wobble base-pair and a downstream uridine which is cleaved. Using smaller RNAs derived from one stem of PK4, systematic changes in the proposed recognition motif indicate that the G-U pair is required for cleavage. Furthermore, there is no cleavage if the G-U pair is reversed. If the recognition motif is moved within the stem, the cleavage site moves accordingly. Additionally, if the recognition motif is changed such that the G-U pair is flanked by two uridine residues, the reactivity occurs only at the 3' uridine. Radical quenching studies have indicated that sulfate radical, as in the case of guanine oxidation, is involved in uridine oxidation. Although additional studies are required to better characterize the reaction, this paper reports a novel specificity for a chemical probe which may be useful for investigating structural motifs involving G-U pairs in folded RNAs.

Gel electrophoretic detection of 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine and 7, 8-dihydro-8-oxoadenine via oxidation by Ir (IV)

Two gel electrophoretic methods are described for detection of 7, 8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine and 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoadenine based on their further oxidation with one-electron oxidants including IrCl62-and IrBr62-. The products of nucleobase oxidation lead to enhanced piperidine-sensitive cleavage and to highly visible stop points in a primer extension assay. 8-oxoG and 8-oxoA lesions may be distinguished by the latter's inability to be oxidized by IrBr62-compared to IrCl62-Comparison is also made to oxidation by MnO4-.

Nickel- and cobalt-dependent reagents identify structural features of RNA that are not detected by dimethyl sulfate or RNase T1

Ribosomal 5S RNA presents a particular challenge to structural investigations since this polynucleotide is too large for complete NMR characterization but lacks significant tertiary structure to modulate, for example, diagnostic alkylation of guanine N7 by dimethyl sulfate. Nickel- and cobalt-dependent reagents that are sensitive to the N7 and aromatic face of guanine have now been applied to 5S rRNA (Xenopus lavis) and provide structural information that was not previously available from traditional chemical or enzymatic probes. Although G75 had repeatedly demonstrated an average reactivity with dimethyl sulfate and minimal reactivity with RNase T1, this residue was the major target of both metal-dependent reagents. Such reactivity provides crucial support for a structural model of loop E identified by prior physical, but not chemical, methods. Similarly, the tetraloop structure of loop D was more accurately reflected by the reactivity of G87 and G89 in the presence of the nickel reagent rather than in the presence of RNase T1. In addition, nickel-dependent modification of guanine residues surrounding the three-helix junction of loop A suggests an organization that is less compact than previously considered.

Nickel-dependent oxidative cross-linking of a protein

A model protein, ribonuclease A (bovine pancreas), was examined for its ability to coordinate Ni2+ and promote selective oxidation. In the presence of a peracid such as monopersulfate, HSO5-, nickel induced the monomeric RNase A to form dimers, trimers, tetramers, and higher oligomers without producing fragmentation of the polypeptide backbone. Co2+ and to a lesser extent Cu2+ exhibited similar activity. The nickel-dependent reaction appeared to result from a specific association between the protein and Ni2+ that allowed for transient and in situ oxidation of the bound nickel to yield intermolecular tyrosine-tyrosine cross-links. Macrocylic nickel complexes that had previously been shown to promote guanine oxidation were unable to mimic the activity of the free metal salt. Amino acid analysis of the protein dimer confirmed the expected consumption of one tyrosine per polypeptide and formation of dityrosine. The presence of excess tyrosine efficiently inhibited formation of the protein dimer and produced instead a ribonuclease-tyrosine cross-link. In contrast, high concentrations of the hydroxyl radical quenching agent mannitol only partially inhibited ribonuclease dimerization. The polypeptide-mediated activation of nickel and its subsequent reactivity mimic a process that could contribute to the adverse effects of nickel in vivo.

Cytosine-specific chemical probing of DNA using bromide and monoperoxysulfate

Bromination of cytosine and formation of a piperidine-labile site are observed when two simple salts, KBr and KHSO5, are allowed to react with single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides. Selectivity for C compared with T, G or A is typically a factor of 4 or more; selectivity for Cs in a single-stranded region such as a C-bulge is nearly a factor of 10 compared with duplex Cs. Low reactivity and little base selectivity are observed using duplex DNA, although increased concentrations of reagents lead to complete degradation of the DNA. The results suggest that these conditions for in situ generation of Br2 constitute a useful tool for examination of the exposure of a non-duplex cytosine base in folded DNA structures.

Nickel-catalyzed oxidations: from hydrocarbons to DNA

Nickel(II) complexes of tetradentate ligands such as cyclam and salen are catalysts for olefin epoxidation using PhIO and NaOCl, respectively. In order to understand the lack of enantioselectivity observed with chiral cyclam and salen complexes, studies of DNA and RNA oxidation were carried out in which evidence for diffusible oxidants might be found. A variety of square-planar, tetradentate nickel(II) complexes were observed to mediate guanine-specific modification in the presence of KHSO5 or magnesium monoperphthalate. In particular, the cationic complex, [(2,12-dimethyl-3,7,11,17-tetraazabicyclo [11.3.1]heptadeca-1(17),2,11,13,15-pentaenato)nickel]2+, [NiCR]2+, has been studied as a probe of nucleic acid folding. The extent of guanine reaction depends upon the exposure of N7, a good transition metal binding site, thus implicating nickel-guanine binding during DNA oxidation. If this is the case, related systems should be able to confer enantioselectivity during the use of chiral nickel complexes and achiral substrates for oxidation. Mechanistic studies, including radical quenching and DNA enantioselectivity, are described and their mechanistic implications discussed.

Hydrophobic vs coulombic interactions in the binding of steroidal polyamines to DNA

Seven new steroidal polyamines derived from bile acids, either lithocholic or deoxycholic acid, have been studied as DNA-binding agents using four complimentary methods: an ethidium displacement assay, observed changes in the thermal denaturation of poly[d(AT)], effects on hyperchromicity of DNA, and circular dichroism. In addition, modelling studies were conducted to examine the electrostatic surface potential of the polycations. The results point to a key role for a large hydrophobic surface area on the steroid in addition to the Coulombic attraction by ammonium and guanidinium groups on the steroid interacting with the polyphosphate backbone.

Phase-retrieval analysis of pre- and post-repair Hubble Space Telescope images

Phase-retrieval measurements of point-spread functions from the pre- and post-repair Hubble Space Telescope are presented. The primary goal was to determine the aberrations present in the second wide-field and planetary camera (WFPC2) to align and validate its corrective optics. With both parametric model-fitting techniques and iterative (Gerchberg-Saxton) methods, accurate measurements have been obtained of the WFPC2 and Hubble Space Telescope optics, including improved maps of the zonal errors in the mirrors. Additional phase-retrieval results were obtained for the aberrated, prerepair cameras and the corrected faint-object camera. The information has been used to improve models produced by point-spread-function simulation programs. On the basis of the measurements a conic constant for the primary mirror of κ = -1.0144 has been derived.

Synthesis and DNA binding properties of C3-, C12-, and C24-substituted amino-steroids derived from bile acids

Seven new amino- and guanidino-substituted steroids have been synthesized from bile acid precursors, either deoxycholic acid or lithocholic acid. Their DNA binding properties have been examined using an ethidium displacement assay, through studies of hyperchromicity and thermal denaturation, and by circular dichroism. Comparison is made to simple aliphatic polyamines such as putrescine, 1,12-diaminododecane, spermidine, and spermine.

DNA modification promoted by water-soluble nickel(II) salen complexes: a switch to DNA alkylation

Reaction of a 17-base hairpin-forming oligonucleotide with [N,N'-bis(salicylaldehyde)-meso-1,2-bis(4- trimethylaminophenyl)ethylenediimino]nickel(II) perchlorate, 2, and KHSO5 produced two types of high molecular weight products, an alkaline-labile species and a nonalkaline-labile species, which co-migrated on gel electrophoresis. Upon treatment with piperidine, the base-labile derivative led to strand scission products only at accessible guanine residues that were not part of a Watson-Crick duplex. The formation of higher molecular weight species is proposed to occur via a highly reactive ligand-centered radical acting as a DNA alkylating agent.

Hepatic subcapsular steatosis in a patient with insulin dependent diabetes receiving dialysis

Fatty change confined to the subcapsular region of the liver is rare and has always been associated with continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis in insulin dependent diabetes. The case of a 41 year old man who died from the complications of his diabetes is reported.

A primer extension assay for modification of guanine by Ni(II) complexes

Images

A highly sensitive probe for guanine N7 in folded structures of RNA: application to tRNA(Phe) and Tetrahymena group I intron

A nickel complex has been shown to promote conformation-specific oxidation of guanosine in polynucleotide RNA. In all cases, reaction was strictly dependent on the solvent exposure and surface properties of guanine N7. Modification of native tRNA(Phe) (yeast) was detected at G18, G19, G20, and Gm34 and concurred with predictions based on its crystal structure. Additional guanine derivatives became exposed to oxidation only after the tRNA unfolded in the absence of Mg2+. Reaction of the Tetrahymena group I intron RNA (L-21 ScaI) also compared favorably to its three-dimensional model by appropriately identifying guanosine residues in hairpin loops, duplex termini, and the essential cofactor binding site. These results complemented prior data generated by hydroxyl radical, and in combination they served to distinguish the solvent accessibility of sugar backbone and base positions in guanosine residues. Most importantly, this nickel complex exhibited greater selectivity than either dimethyl sulfate or RNase T1 for characterizing tRNA(Phe) and intron RNA.