Omega-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids as a potential treatment for reducing dysmenorrhoea pain: Systematic literature review and meta-analysis

AIM

This systematic literature review with meta-analysis aimed to determine the effect of omega-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids on prostaglandin levels and pain severity in women with dysmenorrhoea and identify adverse side effects.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted in Embase, Scopus, Web of Science, MEDLINE complete, CINAHL and AMED databases (PROSPERO CRD42022340371). Included studies provided omega-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids compared to a control in women with dysmenorrhoea and reported pain and/or prostaglandin levels. A random effects meta-analysis with Cohen's d effect size (95% confidence interval) was performed in SPPS for studies that reported pain outcomes. Study quality was assessed using the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics Quality Criteria Checklist.

RESULTS

Twelve studies (n = 881 dysmenorrhoeal women) of predominantly neutral quality (83%) were included that provided daily supplementation of 300-1800 mg omega-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids over 2 or 3 months. Meta-analysis (n = 8 studies) showed a large effect of omega-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (d = -1.020, 95% confidence interval -1.53 to -0.51) at reducing dysmenorrhoea pain. No studies measured prostaglandin levels, 86% of studies measuring analgesic use showed a reduction with omega-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids and few studies reported mild adverse side effects in individual participants.

CONCLUSIONS

Findings suggest that daily supplementation of 300-1800 mg omega-3 long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids over 2-3 months are generally well tolerated and reduces pain and analgesic use in women with dysmenorrhoea. However, the neutral quality of research is limited by methodological issues and the mechanism of action remains to be determined.

Occupational exposure and radiobiological risk from thyroid radioiodine therapy in Saudi Arabia

Worldwide, thyroid cancer accounts for some 10% of total cancer incidence, most markedly for females. Thyroid cancer radiotherapy, typically using 131I (T1/2 8.02 days; β- max energy 606 keV, branching ratio 89.9%), is widely adopted as an adjunct to surgery or to treat inoperable cancer and hyperthyroidism. With staff potentially receiving significant doses during source preparation and administration, radiation protection and safety assessment are required in ensuring practice complies with international guidelines. The present study, concerning a total of 206 patient radioiodine therapies carried out at King Faisal Specialist Hospital and Research Center over a 6-month period, seeks to evaluate patient and occupational exposures during hospitalization, measuring ambient doses and estimating radiation risk. Using calibrated survey meters, patient exposure dose-rate estimates were obtained at a distance of 30-, 100- and 300 cm from the neck region of each patient. Occupational and ambient doses were measured using calibrated thermoluminescent dosimeters. The mean and range of administered activity (AA, in MBq) for the thyroid cancer and hyperthyroidism treatment groups were 4244 ± 2021 (1669-8066), 1507.9 ± 324.1 (977.9-1836.9), respectively. The mean annual occupational doses were 1.2 mSv, that for ambient doses outside of the isolation room corridors were found to be 0.2 mSv, while ambient doses at the nursing station were below the lower limit of detection. Exposures to staff from patients being treated for thyroid cancer were less compared to hyperthyroidism patients. With a well-defined protocol, also complying with international safety requirements, occupational exposures were found to be relatively high, greater than most reported in previous studies.

EXTREMELY LOW FREQUENCY ELECTROMAGNETIC EXPOSURE ASSESSMENT IN SCHOOLS: A STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF URBAN AND SEMI-URBAN AREAS

The aim of this research paper is to estimate the mean value of extremely low frequency (ELF) exposure in schools in Greece. Detailed ELF measurements were conducted and analyzed by the Weighted Peak Method (WPM), which estimates the overall contribution of electromagnetic waves from 1 Hz to 400 kHz, including their phases. A sample of 243 schools was sampled to calculate. The mean value of ELF magnetic fields (MFs) measured in these two groups comprising 243 schools was the principal focus of interest. ELF MF measurements taken in schools situated both far from and near ELF sources had mean and maximum values well below the current International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP) standard. The mean value of ELF MFs from all sources within the sampled schools in Greece was 0.21 μΤ. A statically significant difference between the mean MFs measured in the two groups of schools was found, but the MFs in both groups were much lower than the ICNIRP standard.

Urethrographic examinations: Patient and staff exposures and associated radiobiological risks

Medical exposure of the general population due to radiological investigations is the foremost source of all artificial ionising radiation. Here, we focus on a particular diagnostic radiological procedure, as only limited data are published with regard to radiation measurements during urethrograpic imaging. Specifically, this work seeks to estimate patient and occupational effective doses during urethrographic procedures at three radiology hospitals. Both staff and patient X-ray exposure levels were calculated in terms of entrance surface air kerma (ESAK), obtained by means of lithium fluoride thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLD-100(LiF:Mg:Cu.P)) for 243 urethrographic examinations. Patient radiation effective doses per procedure were estimated using conversion factors obtained from the use of Public Health England computer software. In units of mGy, the median and range of ESAK per examination were found to be 10.8 (3.6-26.2), 7.0 (0.2-32.3), and 24.3 (9.0-32.0) in Hospitals A, B, and C, respectively. The overall mean and range of staff doses (in µGy) were found to be 310 (4.0-1750) per procedure. With the exception of hospital C, the present evaluations of radiation dose have been found to be similar to those of previously published research. The wide range of patient and staff doses illustrate the need for radiation dose optimisation.

PET Counting Response Variability Depending on Tumor Location, Activity, and Patient Obesity: A Feasibility Study of Solitary Pulmonary Nodule Using Monte Carlo

We aim to investigate the counting response variations of positron emission tomography (PET) scanners with different detector configurations in the presence of solitary pulmonary nodule (SPN). Using experimentally validated Monte Carlo simulations, the counting performance of four different scanner models with varying tumor activity, location, and patient obesity is represented using a noise equivalent count rate (NECR). NECR is a well-established quantitative metric which has positive correlation with clinically perceived image quality. The combined effect of tumor displacement and increased activity shows a linear ascending trend for NECR with slope ranges of (12.5-18.2)*10^-3 (kBq/cm³)^-1 for three-ring (3R) scanners and (15.3-21.5)*10^-3 (kBq/cm³)^-1 for four-ring (4R). The trend for the combined effect of tumor displacement and patient obesity is exponential decay with 3R configurations weakly dependent on the patient obesity if the tumor is located at the center of the field of view with exponent's range of (6.6-33.8)*10^-2cm^-1. The dependence is stronger for 4R scanners (9.6-38.5)*10^-2cm^-1. The analysis indicates that quantitative PET data from the same SPN patient possibly examined in different time points (e.g., during staging or for the evaluation of treatment response) are affected by the different detector configurations and need to be normalized with patient weight, activity, and tumor location to reduce unwanted bias of the diagnosis. This paper provides also with a proof of concept for the ability of properly tuned simulations to provide additional insights into the counting response variability especially in tumor types where often borderline decisions have to be made regarding their characterization.

Occupational exposure to electromagnetic fields. The situation in Greece

PURPOSE

The management of the occupational exposure to electromagnetic fields (EMF), an Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) issue of great scientific, social and economic significance, was under intense negotiations at European level over the last twenty years; the Directive 2013/35/EU is the new legislative tool. The presented study deals with the practical aspects of the Directive's implementation.

METHODS

The appropriate, extensive measurements and the overall EMF exposure assessments (i.e. exposure mapping, identification of hot spots, proposition of solutions) were conducted in specific workplaces, including power production, railway, broadcasting, clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) systems, industrial and research sites, as well as common office workplaces.

RESULTS

The vast majority of the performed EMF assessments did not reveal occupational overexposures; moreover in most of the cases, even the general public exposure limits (in the above occupational areas) were not exceeded. The very few localized overexposures detected, were manageable on the basis of the technical and organizational OHS principles. On the contrary, the maintenance procedures of the EMF emitting equipment, as recorded in this survey, presented overexposures revealing a challenging field.

CONCLUSIONS

This study lays a firm basis for the clarification of the occupational EMF environment, where potential exposures might be high. The proper risk assessment demands precise exposure identification and deep understanding of the EMF nature and hazards. Misconceptions range from the common exposure overestimation to the rarer case of the maintenance hazards underestimation, while attention is needed concerning the proper application of the complex limiting system of the Directive.

Estimation of effective dose and radiation risk in pediatric barium studies procedures

The objectives of this study are to assess pediatric radiation exposure in certain barium studies and to quantify the organ and effective doses and radiation risk resultant from patients' irradiation. A total of 69 pediatric barium studies for upper and lower gastrointestinal tract. Patients' radiation dose was quantified in terms of Entrance surface air kerma (ESAKs) using exposure parameters and DosCal software. Organ and effective doses (E) were extrapolated using national Radiological Protection Board software (NRPB-R279). The mean ± (SD) and the range of patient doses per procedure were 3.7 ± 0.4 (1.0-13.0)mGy, 7.4 ± 1.7(5.5-8.0)mGy and 1.4 ± 0.9 (0.5-3.6)mGy for barium meal, swallow and enema, respectively. The mean effective doses were 0.3 ± 0.03 (0.08-1.1)mSv, 0.2 ± 1.6 (0.44-0.7)mSv and 0.3 ± 0.9 (0.1-0.8)mSv at the same order. The radiation dose were higher compared to previous studies. Therefore, pediatrics are exposed to avoidable radiation exposure. Certain optimization measures are recommended along with establishing national diagnostic reference level (DRL) to reduce the radiation risk.

Artificial Optical Radiation photobiological hazards in arc welding

Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) is associated with crucial social, economic, cultural and technical issues. A highly specialized OHS sector deals with the photobiological hazards from artificial optical radiation (AOR), which is divided into visible light, UV and IR emitted during various activities and which is legally covered by European Directive 2006/25/EC. Among the enormous amount of sources emitting AOR, the most important non-coherent ones to consider for health effects to the whole optical range, are arcs created during metal welding. This survey presents the effort to assess the complicated exposure limits of the Directive in the controlled environment of a welding laboratory. Sensors covering the UV and blue light range were set to measure typical welding procedures reproduced in the laboratory. Initial results, apart from apparently justifying the use of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) due to even subsecond overexposures measured, also set the basis to evaluate PPE's properties and support an integrated risk assessment of the complex welding environment. These results can also improve workers' and employer's information and training about radiation hazards, which is a crucial OHS demand.

Spectroscopic evaluation of glioma grading at 3T: the combined role of short and long TE

Purpose. To evaluate the diagnostic value of 3T ¹H-MRS in grading cerebral gliomas using short and long echo times. Methods. 1H-MRS was performed on 71 patients with untreated cerebral gliomas. Metabolite ratios of NAA/Cr, Cho/Cr, Cho/NAA, and mI/Cr were calculated for short and long TE and compared between low and high grade gliomas. Lipids were qualitatively evaluated. ROC analysis was performed to obtain the cut-off values for the metabolic ratios presenting statistical difference between the two glioma grades. Results. Intratumoral Cho/Cr at both TEs and long TE Cho/NAA were significantly different between low and high grade gliomas. Peritumoral NAA/Cr of both TEs, as well as long TE Cho/Cr and Cho/NAA ratios, significantly differentiated the two tumor grades. Diagnostic sensitivity of peritumoral short TE NAA/Cr proved to be superior over the other metabolic ratios, whereas intratumoral short TE Cho/Cr reached the highest levels of specificity and accuracy. Overall, short TE 1H-MRS reached higher total sensitivity in predicting glioma grade, over long TE. Conclusion. An advantage was found in using short TE over long TE 1H-MRS in the discrimination of low versus high grade gliomas. Moreover, the results suggested that the peritumoral area of gliomas may be more valuable in predicting glioma grade than using only the intratumoral area.

Magnetic resonance spectroscopy of the breast at 3T: pre- and post-contrast evaluation for breast lesion characterization

PURPOSE

To determine whether in vivo proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy at 3T can provide accurate breast lesion characterization, and to determine the effect of gadolinium on the resonance of tCho.

METHODS

Twenty-four positive-mammogram patients were examined on a 3T MR scanner. 1H-MRS was performed before and after gadolinium administration. tCho peak was qualitatively evaluated before and after contrast injection.

RESULTS

Fourteen out of 27 lesions proved to be malignant after histopathological diagnosis. Using 1H-MRS, before contrast injection, 6/14 confirmed malignancies and 11/13 benign lesions were correctly classified; while, after contrast injection, 11/14 confirmed malignancies and 12/13 benign processes were correctly classified. Post gadolinium 1H-MRS proved useful in picking up tCho signal, improving the overall accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity by 35%, 83%, and 9%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

1H-MRS overall accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity in detecting breast lesion's malignancy were increased after gadolinium administration. It is prudent to perform 1H-MRS before contrast injection in large breast lesions to avoid choline underestimation. In cases of small or non-mass lesions, it is recommended to perform 1H-MRS after contrast injection for better voxel prescription to enable a reliable preoperative diagnosis.

Radiation doses to patients undergoing enteroclysis

Enteroclysis is a minimally invasive radiographic examination of the small intestine. During the procedure, considerable radiation dose is delivered to the patients. This study intends to: (a) evaluate the radiation dose to the patient using thermoluminescent dosemeters (TLDs, according to the protocol used at Radiology Department, University Hospital of Larissa, Greece; (b) estimate the thyroid surface dose (TSD) and doses to some radiosensitive organs located in the irradiation field. A total of 46 patients was examined. Patients were divided into two groups according to the digital X-ray machine used. The mean entrance surface dose (ESD) was 601.2 ± 96.2 mGy and the mean fluoroscopy time was 8.5 ± 3 min, while the mean TSD was 0.34 ± 0.6 mGy. The ESD for group A was lower by 20 % than group B due to fluoroscopic mode used. The dose values were higher than those in the literature. A local diagnostic reference level was introduced for further patient dose optimisation.

Radiation dose measurement in gastrointestinal studies

Barium studies investigations (barium swallow, barium meal and barium enema) are the basic routine radiological examination, where barium sulphate suspension is introduced to enhance image contrast of gastrointestinal tracts. The aim of this study was to quantify the patients' radiation doses during barium studies and to estimate the organ equivalent dose and effective dose with those procedures. A total of 33 investigations of barium studies were measured by using thermoluminescence dosemeters. The result showed that the patient entrance surface doses were 12.6 ± 10, 44.5 ± 49 and 35.7 ± 50 mGy for barium swallow, barium meal, follow through and enema, respectively. Effective doses were 0.2, 0.35 and 1.4 mSv per procedure for barium swallow, meal and enema respectively. Radiation doses were comparable with the previous studies. A written protocol for each procedure will reduce the inter-operator variations and will help to reduce unnecessary exposure.

A modification of flattening filter free linac for IMRT

PURPOSE

This study investigates the benefits of a modified flattening filter free (FFF) linac over the standard (STD) linac equipped with the flattening filter. Energy and angular spread of the electron beam of the FFF linac were modified. Modification of FFF beam parameters is explored to maximize the monitor unit efficiency and to minimize the head scatter in IMRT delivery for large target volumes or targets lying away from the central axis.

METHODS

The EGSnrc code is used to model FFF and STD linacs and study basic beam properties for both linac types in various beam configurations. Increasing energy of FFF linac results in similar beam attenuation properties and maximized dose rate compared to STD linac. Matching beam attenuation properties allows a more direct exploration of beam flatness of FFF linac in regard to IMRT delivery, especially away from the central axis where the effective dose rate is considerably smaller than the one at the central axis. Flatness of open beam dose profile of FFF linac is improved by increasing the angular spread of the electron beam. The resulting dose rate within the treatment field and outside of the field (peripheral dose) are characterized and compared to the unmodified FFF and STD linacs,

RESULTS

In order to match beam penetration properties, the energy of FFF is adjusted from 6.5 to 8.0 MeV for small to medium field sizes and from 6.5 to 8.5 MeV for larger ones. Dose rate of FFF vs STD linac increased by a factor of 1.9 (6.5 MeV) and 3.4-4.1 (8.0-8.5 MeV). Adjusting the mean angular spread of the electron beam from 0 degrees to 5 degrees-10 degrees resulted in complete flattening of photon beam for field sizes between 10 x 10 cm2 and 15 x 15 cm2 and partial flattening for field sizes from 15 x 15 cm2 to 30 x 30 cm2. Values of angular spread > or =14 degrees are not recommended as they exceed the opening of the primary collimator, affecting the area at the edges of the field. FFF fields of sizes smaller than 6 x 6 cm2 are already flat and beam flattening is not necessary. Overall, the angular spread of 5 degrees-10 degrees is sufficient and can satisfactorily flatten open beam dose profiles even for larger field sizes. Increasing the electron beam angular spread amounts to a slight decrease of dose rate of FFF linac. However, for angular spread, 5 degrees-10 degrees dose rate factor of FFF vs STD is still about 1.6-2.6, depending on the field size (and the adjusted energy). Similarly, in case of peripheral dose, a moderate increase in dose can be observed for angular spread of 5 degrees-10 degrees and for field sizes 10 x 10 cm2 to 30 x 30 cm2. Lastly, beam flatness of not modified FFF linac can be conveniently described by an analytical function representing a ratio of STD vs FFF doses: 1 + b|r|(n).

CONCLUSIONS

A modified FFF beamline with increased energy and electron beam angular spread results in satisfactory flattened beam and high dose rate within the field. Peripheral dose remaining at similar (or smaller) level than that of STD linac for the same delivered dose within the treatment field.

Radiation dose optimisation and risk estimation to patients and staff during hysterosalpingography

Hysterosalpingography (HSG) is an efficient radiological examination for the evaluation of the female reproductive tract. However, it involves unavoidable irradiation to the ovaries of women in childbearing age. Therefore, radiation dose optimisation is required in order to reduce the probability of the associated risks. This study attempts to: measure patient and staff doses, estimate the effective dose and radiation risk for HSG using digital fluoroscopic images. Thirty-seven patients with infertility were examined using two digital X-ray machines. Thermoluminescence dosimeters (TLD) were used to measure entrance surface dose (ESD) for patients and staff during the procedure. The mean ESD and thyroid surface dose of the patient were 3.60 and 0.17 mGy, respectively, while the mean ESD for the staff was 0.18 mGy per procedure. The patient overall risk for cancer and hereditary effects is 24 x 10(-6), while the risk for the staff is negligible. HSG with fluoroscopic technique demonstrate improved dose characteristics, compared to the conventional radiographic-based technique, reducing the surface dose by a factor of 3, without compromising the diagnostic findings.

Radiation dose measurement and risk estimation for paediatric patients undergoing micturating cystourethrography

Micturating cystourethrography (MCU) is considered to be the gold-standard method used to detect and grade vesicoureteric reflux (VUR) and show urethral and bladder abnormalities. It accounts for 30-50% of all fluoroscopic examinations in children. Therefore, it is crucial to define and optimize the radiation dose received by a child during MCU examination, taking into account that children have a higher risk of developing radiation-induced cancer than adults. This study aims to quantify and evaluate, by means of thermoluminescence dosimetry (TLD), the radiation dose to the newborn and paediatric populations undergoing MCU using fluoroscopic imaging. Evaluation of entrance surface dose (ESD), organ and surface dose to specific radiosensitive organs was carried out. Furthermore, the surface dose to the co-patient, i.e. individuals helping in the support, care and comfort of the children during the examination, was evaluated in order to estimate the level of risk. 52 patients with mean age of 0.36 years who had undergone MCU using digital fluoroscopy were studied. ESD, surface doses to thyroid, testes/ovaries and co-patients were measured with TLDs. MCU with digital equipment and fluoroscopy-captured image technique can reduce the radiation dose by approximately 50% while still obtaining the necessary diagnostic information. Radiographic exposures were made in cases of the presence of reflux or of the difficulty in evaluating a finding. The radiation surface doses to the thyroid and testes are relatively low, whereas the radiation dose to the co-patient is negligible. The risks associated with MCU for patients and co-patients are negligible. The results of this study provide baseline data to establish reference dose levels for MCU examination in very young patients.

Assessing the Difference between Planned and Delivered Intensity-modulated Radiotherapy Dose Distributions based on Radiobiological Measures

AIMS

Because of the highly conformal distributions that can be obtained with intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT), any discrepancy between the intended and delivered distributions would probably affect the clinical outcome. Consequently, there is a need for a measure that would quantify those differences in terms of a change in the expected clinical outcome.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

To evaluate such a measure, cancer of the cervix was used, where the bladder and rectum are proximal and partially overlapping with the internal target volume. A solid phantom simulating the pelvic anatomy was fabricated and a treatment plan was developed to deliver the prescribed dose to the phantom. The phantom was then irradiated with films positioned in several transverse planes. The racetrack microtron at 50 MV was used in the treatment planning and delivery processes. The dose distribution delivered was analysed based on the film measurements and compared against the treatment plan. The differences in the measurements were evaluated using both physical and biological criteria. Whereas the physical comparison of dose distributions can assess the geometric accuracy of delivery, it does not reflect the clinical effect of any measured dose discrepancies.

RESULTS

It is shown how small inaccuracies in delivered dose can affect the treatment outcome in terms of complication-free tumour cure.

CONCLUSIONS

With highly conformal IMRT, the accuracy of the patient set-up and treatment delivery are critical for the success of the treatment. A method is proposed to evaluate the precision of the delivered plan based on changes in complication and control rates as they relate to uncertainties in dose delivery.

A comparison of Monte Carlo simulation with experimental dosimetric techniques for a 6 MV stereotactic radiotherapy unit

PURPOSE

To compare Monte Carlo simulation with conventional dosimetry techniques for stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT), since accurate dosimetry of narrow photon beams is very complicated and has often been questioned, mainly due to the lack of lateral electronic equilibrium and uncertainty in beam energy in terms of steep dose gradients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this work a Monte Carlo (MC, EGS4) simulation for dosimerty study was performed for the 6MV home made SRT unit of the University Hospital of Patras (Hellas). The results were compared with conventional small field dosimetry techniques such as ionization chamber, TLD's, and films (conventional and radiochromic). Hence, a comparison of many of the dosimetric techniques currently being used in small field dosimetry was attempted.

RESULTS

It was shown that all techniques are in reasonable agreement (within -/+ 2%) and that Monte Carlo can be used as a reliable reference for the dosimetry of the SRT beams, especially where lateral electronic equilibrium does not exist, as long as accurate simulation can be achieved.

CONCLUSION

This study is only limited by the insurance of accurate simulation of the linear accelerator, which can be a difficult task since it is limited by the availability of the manufacturer's designs and the availability of computers and computer time for adequate runs, but it could become a useful tool for Monte Carlo simulations, as it contains detailed analysis of the run parameters and component modules selection.

Field flatness and symmetry of photon beams: review of the current recommendations

Flatness and symmetry are main parameters determining the quality of a photon beam produced by linear accelerators. The quality assurance in routine clinical practice of radiotherapy and consequently the treatment-outcome depend definitely on the physical parameters of treatment-delivery. Several recommendations from national and international associations are reported. By reviewing the current literature and mainly according to the World Health Organization (WHO) report of quality assurance in radiotherapy, we may suggest that for flatness and symmetry, the optimal level of deviation should be within +/- 3%. Flatness and symmetry should be checked monthly or once a year in accordance to the guidelines of national societies.

A monte carlo approach to electron contamination sources in the Saturne-25 and -41

The various components of the accelerator treatment head act as sources of contaminating electrons. The presence of contamination electrons increases the surface dose, which deteriorates the skin-sparing effect. The present study examines the sources of this 'contamination', the influence on the surface dose and the shape of the build-up curve. The Monte Carlo simulation of two linear accelerators, Saturne-25 and -41, allowed us to study the influence of electron contamination in various therapeutic energies and in different geometries. The Saturne-25 and -41 cover a wide range of therapeutic energies with nominal energies 12/23 MV and 6/15 MV, respectively. The analysis of the results shows that at a source-to-surface distance of 100 cm and a wide opening of the collimators, the main sources of contaminating electrons are the flattening filter and the air below it. The contribution of the secondary contamination electrons on the surface dose is 16% for 6 MV and 12 MV, 6% for 15 MV and 17% for 23 MV. The energy spectra of electrons coming from the flattening filter and the air below it are completely different. The air produces electrons of low energies. The mean energies of these spectra vary from 1 MeV to 2 MeV depending on the nominal energy of the photon beam. The secondary electrons generated by the flattening filter produce a wide energy spectrum with mean energies of the same order of the bremsstrahlung spectrum. The flattening filter absorbs the secondary electrons generated in the target, the primary collimator and the air inside the head.

A multiobjective gradient-based dose optimization algorithm for external beam conformal radiotherapy

A multiobjective gradient-based algorithm has been developed for the purpose of dose distribution optimization in external beam conformal radiotherapy. This algorithm is based on the concept of gathering the values of all objectives into a single value. The weighting factors of the composite objective values are varied in different steps, allowing the reconstruction of the trade-off surfaces (three or more objectives) or curves (two objectives) which define the boundary between the feasible and non-feasible domain regions. The analysis of these curves allows the decision-maker to select the solution that best fits the clinical goals. In contrast to all the other algorithms, our method provides not a single solution but a sample of solutions representing all possible clinical importance factors (weights) for the objectives used. The application of this algorithm to two test cases shows that a correct selection for the importance factors to multiply the individual objectives in the global objective value is not trivial and that the location and shape of the boundary region between the feasible and non-feasible solution regions are case dependent. Provided that the individual objective functions are analytically differentiable and that the number of objectives is the range of two to three, the computation times are acceptable for clinical use. Furthermore, the optimization for a unique combination of importance factors within the aggregate objective function is performed in less than 1 min.

Graphical treatment simulation and automated collision detection for conformal and stereotactic radiotherapy treatment planning

The purpose of this work is to develop a "room's eye view" graphical simulation program with an automated collision detection option, to assist a treatment planning user to visualize the treatment setup checking at the same time the feasibility of his plan. The program simulates the treatment process using accurate three-dimensional graphical models of the gantry, table, and that of an average patient. This allows the use of any mechanical movement concerning the radiotherapy unit. The simulation of the mechanical movements and their limitations are according to IEC standards and thus compatible with any radiotherapy machine. Graphical methods for collision detection between the models guarantee speed and accuracy. The module simulates the treatment setup with accuracy better than 2 degrees for any tested case. When a collision takes place a warning message is displayed. In this paper a software tool is developed that can be used as a stand-alone program or embedded in any treatment planning system. The visualization of the treatment fields prior to treatment permits the geometric feasibility of the plan, thus adding one more step toward the automation of the treatment process.

Comparison of conformal radiation therapy techniques within the dynamic radiotherapy project 'Dynarad'

The objective of the dynamic radiotherapy project 'Dynarad' within the European Community has been to compare and grade treatment techniques that are currently applied or being developed at the participating institutions. Cervical cancer was selected as the tumour site on the grounds that the involved organs at risk, mainly the rectum and the bladder, are very close to the tumour and partly located inside the internal target volume. In this work, a solid phantom simulating the pelvic anatomy was used by institutions in Belgium, France, Greece, Holland, Italy, Sweden and the United Kingdom. The results were evaluated using both biological and physical criteria. The main purpose of this parallel evaluation is to test the value of biological and physical evaluations in comparing treatment techniques. It is demonstrated that the biological objective functions allow a much higher conformality and a more clinically relevant scoring of the outcome. Often external beam treatment techniques have to be combined with intracavitary therapy to give clinically acceptable results. However, recent developments can reduce or even eliminate this need by delivering more conformal dose distributions using intensity modulated external dose delivery. In these cases the reliability of the patient set-up procedure becomes critical for the effectiveness of the treatment.

Intensity modulated arc therapy (IMAT) with centrally blocked rotational fields

A new technique for intensity-modulated beam (IMB) delivery that combines the features of intensity modulated arc therapy (IMAT) with the use of 'classical blocks' is proposed. The role of the blocks is to realize the high-gradient modulation of the intensity profile corresponding to the region to be protected within the body contour, while the MLC leaves or the secondary collimator defines the rest of the field and delivers intensity-modulated multiple rotational segments. The centrally blocked radiation fields are applied sequentially, in several rotations. Each rotation of the gantry is responsible for delivering one segment of the optimal intensity profile. The new IMAT technique is applied for a treatment geometry represented by an annular target volume centrally located within a circular body contour. The annulus encompasses a circular critical structure, which is to be protected. The beam opening and corresponding weight of each segment are determined in two ways. The first method applies a linear optimization algorithm to precalculated centrally blocked radial dose profiles. These radial profiles are calculated for a set of beam openings, ranging from the largest field that covers the whole planning target volume (PTV) to the smallest, which is 1 cm larger than the width of the central block. The optimization is subjected to dose homogeneity constraints imposed on a linear combination of these profiles and finally delivers the dimensions and weights of the rotational beams to be used in combination. The second method decomposes into several subfields the fluence profile of a rotational beam known to deliver a constant dose level to PTV. This fluence profile is determined by using the analytical method proposed by Brahme for the case of the annular PTV and the concentric organ at risk (OAR). The proper segmentation of this intensity profile provides the field sizes and corresponding weights of the subfields to be used in combination. Both methods show that for this particular treatment geometry, three to seven segments are sufficient to cover the PTV with the 95% dose level and to keep the dose level to the central critical structure under 30% of the maximum dose. These results were verified by experimentally delivering the calculated segments to radiotherapy verification films sandwiched between two cylindrical pieces of a pressed-wood phantom. The total beam time for a three-field irradiation was 77 s. The predicted and experimental dose profiles along the radius of the phantom agreed to within 5%. Generalization of this technique to real-patient treatment geometry and advantages over other conformal radiotherapy techniques are also discussed.

Dose-volume analysis of different stereotactic radiotherapy mono-isocentric techniques

Several stereotactic irradiation techniques, using Linacs with the patient in lying and sitting position and a Gamma Knife Unit, were compared with regard to mono-isocentric three-dimensional dose distributions. Three types of target volumes, a sphere and two ellipsoids, were used for the comparisons. All three targets were centered on a real head, reconstructed from transversal CT scans. The ARTEMIS 3D Treatment Planning System, developed by the Tenon Hospital, Paris, was used for the dosimetry and the dose-volume histogram (DVH) calculation. For the comparative study, several quantitative parameters were used, derived from the dose-volume histogram calculation. Differential DVHs were plotted for each target volume and beam arrangement. Irradiation techniques were compared by deriving quantitative parameters from the DVHs such as mean and integral dose delivered to the target and normal tissue irradiated, as well as by the relative volume of the examined areas. All techniques used in this study produced very similar dose distributions. The small differences confirm the capability of the studied techniques to produce the same irradiation effects. By changing from the spherical target shape to a more elliptical shape, more of the normal tissue was irradiated with higher doses. For elliptical cases we therefore identified a need for more conformal stereotactic planning.

A phantom for dosimetric characterization of small radiation fields: design and use

An acrylic phantom was designed and constructed for the acquisition and verification of basic dosimetric data of narrow fields in stereotactic radiotherapy/radiosurgery (SRT/SRS) using thermoluminescent (TL) dosimetry. An array of holes to accommodate up to 426 dosimeters was used to allow the assessment of dose distribution in circular fields with a 1-mm spatial dose resolution with minimal field perturbation. It was found experimentally that there must be a minimum gap of 1 mm between neighboring dosimeters in 6-MV photon fields. Most of the dosimetric characteristics of a 6-MV x-ray SRS/SRT unit assessed using TL dosimetry and ion chamber dosimetry were in good agreement when the longitudinal axis of the chamber was parallel to the central beam axis. TL dosimetry showed that the penumbra width increased with increasing collimator aperture. The low cost of the phantom and the widespread use and familiarity of TL dosimetry in radiotherapy departments offer a significant advantage in the use of the proposed methodology.

AVS/express for the PC implementation of a 3D visualization module for radiotherapy

Treatment planning systems (TPS) are nowadays of great help in cancer radiotherapy. Basically, they allow the pair physician/physicist to simulate the beams' irradiation effects on tumors as well as healthy tissues in terms of delivered radiation doses and finally to assess the validity of a beam setup. The state of the art in TPS leads to the following evidence concerning the future of such softwares: an access to a 3D visualization at each step of the design and verification of a plan has become necessary. Moreover, the fast increasing performances of personal computers (PC) will make possible in a near future the implementation at a lower cost of a complete 3D TPS. One of the keys of such an ambition is the compatibility between the implementation tools and the needs for power and flexibility. A first implementation on Open VMS of a simple 3D visualization for Institut Curie's TPS ISIS using Advanced Visual Systems' AVS 5 has been achieved. Their next generation tool, AVS/Express, seemed to meet the needs of a wide scale development. The use of AVS/Express working together with Microsoft Visual C++ in the implementation on Windows NT of a 3D visualization module is exposed.

A simple method for the correction of distorted digital angiographic images for stereotactic target localization

The most commonly used imaging modality for the diagnosis and localization of arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) treated with stereotactic radiotherapy is traditional angiography, but it would be desirable to also use digital subtraction angiography (DSA). However, DSA images are distorted due to the electron-optical characteristics of the X-ray image intensifier. For that reason, we have developed a method for the correction of the image distortion. The ISIS II Treatment Planning System (ISIS II TPS), developed at the Curie Institute, has been used for image acquisition and stereotactic localization. A grid phantom has been constructed for determining the distortion of the DSA images. The software developed for the correction has been implemented into the TPS and is based on a correction vector produced by matching the distorted and corrected grid points. The method has been tested for its ability to correct the position of all grid points as well as its effectiveness in real cases as compared to traditional angiography. The maximum displacement of the corrected grid points compared with their original position is measured to be 0.1 mm. The accuracy of the target localization using the corrected DSA images is comparable with traditional angiography localization and falls inside acceptable accuracy limits. In conclusion, this method offers the possibility of using DSA images for stereotactic localization without limiting the requested accuracy.

Optimization of the dose level for a given treatment plan to maximize the complication-free tumor cure

During the past decade, tumor and normal tissue reactions after radiotherapy have been increasingly quantified in radiobiological terms. For this purpose, response models describing the dependence of tumor and normal tissue reactions on the irradiated volume, heterogeneity of the delivered dose distribution and cell sensitivity variations can be taken into account. The probability of achieving a good treatment outcome can be increased by using an objective function such as P+, the probability of complication-free tumor control. A new procedure is presented, which quantifies P+ from the dose delivery on 2D surfaces and 3D volumes and helps the user of any treatment planning system (TPS) to select the best beam orientations, the best beam modalities and the most suitable beam energies. The final step of selecting the prescribed dose level is made by a renormalization of the entire dose plan until the value of P+ is maximized. The index P+ makes use of clinically established dose-response parameters, for tumors and normal tissues of interest, in order to improve its clinical relevance. The results, using P+, are compared against the assessments of experienced medical physicists and radiation oncologists for two clinical cases. It is observed that when the absorbed dose level for a given treatment plan is increased, the treatment outcome first improves rapidly. As the dose approaches the tolerance of normal tissues the complication-free cure begins to drop. The optimal dose level is often just below this point and it depends on the geometry of each patient and target volume. Furthermore, a more conformal dose delivery to the target results in a higher control rate for the same complication level. This effect can be quantified by the increased value of the P+ parameter.

Multimedia educational services in stereotactic radiotherapy

The computer-based learning methods in medicine have been well established as stand-alone learning systems. Recently, these systems were enriched with the use of telematics technology to provide distance learning capabilities. Stereotactic radiotherapy is one of the most representative advanced radiotherapy techniques. Due to the multidisciplinary character of the technique and the rapid evolution of technology implemented, the demands in training have increased. The potential of interactive multimedia and Internet technologies for the achievement of distance learning capabilities in this domain are investigated. The realization of a computer-based educational program in stereotactic radiotherapy in a multimedia format is a new application in the computer-aided distance learning field. The system is built according to a client and server architecture, based on the Internet infrastructure, and composed of server nodes. The impact of the system may be described in terms of: time and transportation costs saving, flexibility in training (scheduling, rate and subject selection), online communication and interaction with experts, cost effective access to material (delivery or access by a large number of users and revision of the material by avoiding high costs of computer-based training systems and database development).

Calculating shielding requirements in diagnostic X-ray departments

Structural radiation protection for diagnostic X-ray facilities is most commonly performed following the recommendations of the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements Report No. 49. A number of analytical methods have already been developed to improve the design of these facilities. Specifically, these methods reassess shielding calculations in X-ray areas with respect to the methodology of the calculation of the barrier thickness and the number of sources considered in the area. Thus, they generate an overall solution for the cases met at the medical radiation structural design. This paper presents an extension of an existing method for calculating shielding requirements, for multiple X-ray tubes in a room operated at various beam qualities. The methodology computes the required shielding thickness such that the exposure behind it stays below a desired value. The presented method eliminates the overestimation of added shielding thickness which may occur using the other methods already mentioned. A user-friendly windows-based program has also been developed to assist shielding computations.

Quality control of dose volume histogram computation characteristics of 3D treatment planning systems

Detailed quality control (QC) protocols are a necessity for modern radiotherapy departments. The established QC protocols for treatment planning systems (TPS) do not include recommendations on the advanced features of three-dimensional (3D) treatment planning, like the dose volume histograms (DVH). In this study, a test protocol for DVH characteristics was developed. The protocol assesses the consistency of the DVH computation to the dose distribution calculated by the same TPS by comparing DVH parameters with values obtained by the isodose distributions. The computation parameters (such as the dimension of the computation grid) that are applied to the TPS during the tests are not fixed but set by the user as if the test represents a typical clinical case. Six commercial TPS were examined with this protocol within the frame of the EC project Dynarad (Biomed I). The results of the intercomparison prove the consistency of the DVH results to the isodose values for most of the examined TPS. However, special attention should be paid when working with cases of adverse conditions such as high dose gradient regions. In these cases, higher errors are derived, especially when an insufficient number of dose calculation points are used for the DVH computation.

Developing a dose-volume histogram computation program for brachytherapy

A dose-volume histogram (DVH) computation program was developed for brachytherapy treatment planning in an attempt to benefit from the DVH's ability to present graphically information on 3D dose distributions. The program is incorporated into a planning system that utilizes a pair of orthogonal radiographs to localize the radiation sources. DVHs are calculated for the volume of tissue enclosed by an isodose surface (e.g. half the value of the reference isodose). The calculation algorithm is based on a non-uniform random sampling that gives a denser point distribution at the centre of the implants. Our program was tested and proved to be fast enough for clinical use and sufficiently accurate (i.e. computation time of 20 s and less than 2% relative error for one point source, for 100,000 calculation points). The accuracy improves when a larger calculation point number is used, but the computation time also increases proportionally. The DVH is presented in the form of a simple graph or table, or as Anderson's 'natural' DVH graph. The cumulative DVH tables can be used to extract a series of indexes characterizing the homogeneity and the dose levels of the distribution in the treatment volume and the surrounding tissues. If a reference plan is available, the DVH results can be assessed relative to the reference plan's DVH.

A new non-invasive and relocatable immobilization frame for fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy

PURPOSE

A newly developed non-invasive immobilization frame for stereotactic radiotherapy is presented, which is intended to be used for both imaging (computed tomography (CT) and angiography) and radiotherapeutic procedures.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The frame is made of duraluminium so as to be stable and light and it has an elliptical shape. The immobilization is achieved using three stable locations on the patient's head, i.e. the upper dentition, the nose and the back of the neck. The fixation on the three locations ensures complete immobilization in all directions.

RESULTS

The immobilization frame can be fitted as many times as is needed to most heads. In order to assess the accuracy of relocation, repeated fittings on two volunteers and on 22 patients undergoing stereotactic treatment were performed (more than 200 mountings in total), which showed maximum anterior-posterior, inferior-superior and lateral reproducibility in positioning of less than 1 mm in all cases.

CONCLUSIONS AND DISCUSSION

The in-house-constructed stereotactic frame is simple to use, easily made, non-invasive, relocatable and well tolerated by the patients, providing the possibility of multiple fractions. The major advantage of using such a non-invasive stereotactic frame is the flexibility in timing the different diagnostic procedures (CT and angiography) as well as providing the possibility to extend the use to large brain lesions (treatment without an additional collimator) where a high precision is also required. It also offers significant labour and cost saving over the invasive frames and the majority of the non-invasive frames. To date, 22 patients with ages varying between 12 and 70 years have been treated using this method.

Development in a Windows environment of a radiation treatment planning system for personal computers

A new personal computer (PC) radiotherapy treatment planning system (RTPS) is presented. The PC-based RTPS is designed to run in the Microsoft Windows 3.11 environment (and later versions), for computers equipped with 486 or Pentium processors. The algorithm used by the new PC-based program for dose calculation belongs to the 'radiological pathlength' category and it was previously implemented on VAX 711 computers at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC) in New York, NY, within EXTREP-III RTPS. The EXTREP-III program is a two-dimensional RTPS (with restricted three-dimensional capabilities), developed and used in clinical practice at MSKCC during the 1980s. The PC-based program is implemented in the Visual Basic (version 3.0) language and supports features commonly available in most photon-mode RTPSs: dose calculation for fixed, isocentric and rotational irradiation techniques, dose corrections for both internal inhomogeneities and external inhomogeneities (boluses and compensators), association of machine-specific beams with various wedges and blocks, etc. The graphic interface of the PC-based RTPS is completely new and is designed to meet the requirements of fast and accurate planning. The user interface consists of an event-oriented button-based console which allows users to perform planning and to have isodose charts overlaid on patient computed tomography images initially loaded in the program. The PC-based RTPS tests, performed in order to assess its accuracy and speed of computation, show good results. The acceptable computation times obtained, the good accuracy in dose computation and the user-friendly interface of the program are sufficient reasons to consider the PC-based RTPS a good quality-price ratio tool for radiation treatment planning in cancer therapy.