Thermodynamic criteria for high hit rate antisense oligonucleotide design

Antisense oligonucleotides are used for therapeutic applications and in functional genomic studies. In practice, however, many of the oligonucleotides complementary to an mRNA have little or no antisense activity. Theoretical strategies to improve the 'hit rate' in antisense screens will reduce the cost of discovery and may lead to identification of antisense oligonucleotides with increased potency. Statistical analysis performed on data collected from more than 1000 experiments with phosphorothioate-modified oligonucleotides revealed that the oligo-probes, which form stable duplexes with RNA (DeltaG(o)37 < or = -30 kcal/mol) and have small self-interaction potential, are more frequently efficient than molecules that form less stable oligonucleotide-RNA hybrids or more stable self-structures. To achieve optimal statistical preference, the values for self-interaction should be (DeltaG(o)37) > or = -8 kcal/mol for inter-oligonucleotide pairing and (DeltaG(o)37) > or = -1.1 kcal/mol for intra-molecular pairing. Selection of oligonucleotides with these thermodynamic values in the analyzed experiments would have increased the 'hit rate' by as much as 6-fold.

Thermodynamic calculations and statistical correlations for oligo-probes design

Optimization of probe design for array-based experiments requires improved predictability of oligonucleotide hybridization behavior. Currently, designing oligonucleotides capable of interacting efficiently and specifically with the relevant target is not a routine procedure. Multiple examples demonstrate that oligonucleotides targeting different regions of the same RNA differ in their hybridization ability. The present work shows how thermodynamic evaluations of oligo-target duplex or oligo self-structure stabilities can facilitate probe design. Statistical analysis of large sets of hybridization data reveals that thermodynamic evaluation of oligonucleotide properties can be used to avoid poor RNA binders. Thermodynamic criteria for the selection of 20 and 21mers, which, with high probability, interact efficiently and specifically with their targets, are suggested. The design of longer oligonucleotides can also be facilitated by the same calculations of DeltaG(o) (T) values for oligo-target duplex or oligo self-structure stabilities and similar selection schemes.

Cell culture analysis of the regulatory frameshift event required for the expression of mammalian antizymes

BACKGROUND

Antizyme is a critical regulator of cellular polyamine levels due to its effect on polyamine transport and its ability to target ornithine decarboxylase for degradation. Antizyme expression is autoregulatory, through dependence on an unusual +1 translational frameshift mechanism that responds to polyamine levels.

RESULTS

HEK293 cells were depleted of polyamines by treatment with an ornithine decarboxylase inhibitor, difluoromethylornithine (DFMO), and grown in the presence or absence of exogenous polyamines prior to the analysis of ribosomal frameshifting levels. Results obtained using an optimized dual luciferase assay system reveal a 10-fold dynamic range of frameshifting, which correlates positively with polyamine addition. Polyamine addition to cells, which have not been pre-treated with DFMO, also resulted in an increase in antizyme frameshifting but to a lesser degree (1.3 to 1.5-fold). In addition, the constructs with the 3' deletion were more responsive to stimulation by polyamine addition than those with the 5' deletion.

CONCLUSIONS

The observed regulation of antizyme frameshifting demonstrates the efficiency of a polyamine homeostatic mechanism, and illustrates the utility of a quantifiable cell-based assay for the analysis of polyamines or their analogues on translational frameshifting.

Drop-off during ribosome hopping

Ribosomes bypass a 50 nucleotide non-coding segment of mRNA between the two open reading frames of bacteriophage T4 gene 60 in order to synthesize a topoisomerase subunit. While nearly all ribosomes appear to initiate bypassing, only 50 % resume translation in the second open reading frame. Failure to bypass is shown here to be independent of the stop codon at the end of the first open reading frame and to be amplified by mutant variants of tRNA(Gly)(2) known to diminish bypassing efficiency. Unproductive bypassing may result from premature dissociation of peptidyl-tRNAs from ribosomes (drop-off) or resumption of translation at inappropriate sites. Assessment of the influence of factors known to induce drop-off reveals that ribosome recycling factor accounts for a small fraction of unproductive bypassing products, but none of the other known factors appear to play a significant role. Resumption of translation at inappropriate sites appears to be minimal, which suggests that spontaneous release of the peptidyl-tRNA may account for the remaining unproductive bypassing products and may be inherent to the gene 60 bypassing mechanism.

Analysis of the roles of tRNA structure, ribosomal protein L9, and the bacteriophage T4 gene 60 bypassing signals during ribosome slippage on mRNA

A 50-nucleotide coding gap divides bacteriophage T4 gene 60 into two open reading frames. In response to cis-acting stimulatory signals encrypted in the mRNA, the anticodon of the ribosome-bound peptidyl tRNA dissociates from a GGA codon at the end of the first open reading frame and pairs with a GGA codon 47 nucleotides downstream just before the second open reading frame. Mutations affecting ribosomal protein L9 or tRNA(Gly)(2), the tRNA that decodes GGA, alter the efficiency of bypassing. To understand the mechanism of ribosome slippage, this work analyzes the influence of these bypassing signals and mutant translational components on -1 frameshifting at G GGA and hopping over a stop codon immediately flanked by two GGA glycine codons (stop-hopping). Mutant variants of tRNA(Gly)(2) that impair bypassing mediate stop-hopping with unexpected landing specificities, suggesting that these variants are defective in ribosomal P-site codon-anticodon pairing. In a direct competition between -1 frameshifting and stop-hopping, the absence of L9 promotes stop-hopping at the expense of -1 frameshifting without substantially impairing the ability of mutant tRNA(Gly)(2) variants to re-pair with the mRNA by sub-optimal pairing. These observations suggest that L9 defects may stimulate ribosome slippage by enhancing mRNA movement through the ribosome rather than by inducing an extended pause in translation or by destabilizing P-site pairing. Two of the bypassing signals, a cis-acting nascent peptide encoded by the first open reading frame and a stemloop signal located in the 5' portion of the coding gap, stimulate peptidyl-tRNA slippage independently of the rest of the gene 60 context. Evidence is presented suggesting that the nascent peptide signal may stimulate bypassing by destabilizing P-site pairing.

Phylogenetic analysis of tmRNA genes within a bacterial subgroup reveals a specific structural signature

Bacterial tmRNA mediates a trans-translation reaction, which permits the recycling of stalled ribosomes and probably also contributes to the regulated expression of a subset of genes. Its action results in the addition of a small number of C-terminal amino acids to protein whose synthesis had stalled and these constitute a proteolytic recognition tag for the degradation of these incompletely synthesized proteins. Previous work has identified pseudoknots and stem-loops that are widely conserved in divergent bacteria. In the present work an alignment of tmRNA gene sequences within 13 beta-proteobacteria reveals an additional sub-structure specific for this bacterial group. This sub-structure is in pseudoknot Pk2, and consists of one to two additional stem-loop(s) capped by stable GNRA tetraloop(s). Three-dimensional models of tmRNA pseudoknot 2 (Pk2) containing various topological versions of the additional sub-structure suggest that the sub-structures likely point away from the core of the RNA, containing both the tRNA and the mRNA domains. A putative tertiary interaction has also been identified.

Coupling of open reading frames by translational bypassing

Translational bypassing joins the information found within two disparate open reading frames into a single polypeptide chain. The underlying mechanism centers on the decoding properties of peptidyl-transfer RNA (tRNA) and involves three stages: take-off, scanning, and landing. In take-off, the peptidyl-tRNA/messenger RNA (mRNA) complex in the P site of the ribosome dissociates, and the mRNA begins to move through the ribosome. In scanning, the peptidyl-tRNA probes the mRNA sliding through the decoding center. In landing, the peptidyl-tRNA re-pairs with a codon with which it can form a stable interaction. Although few examples of genes are known that rely on translational bypassing to couple open reading frames, ribosomes appear to have an innate capacity for bypassing. This suggests that the strategy of translational bypassing may be more common than presently appreciated. The best characterized example of this phenomenon is T4 gene 60, in which a complex set of signals stimulates bypassing of 50 nucleotides between the two open reading frames. In this review, we focus on the bypassing mechanism of gene 60 in terms of take-off, scanning, and landing.

RECODE: a database of frameshifting, bypassing and codon redefinition utilized for gene expression

The RECODE database is a compilation of 'programmed' translational recoding events taken from the scientific literature and personal communications. The database deals with programmed ribosomal frameshifting, codon redefinition and translational bypass occurring in a variety of organisms. The entries for each event include the sequences of the corresponding genes, their encoded proteins for both the normal and alternate decoding, the types of the recoding events involved, trans-factors and cis-elements that influence recoding. The database is freely available at http://recode.genetics. utah.edu/.

Decoding of tandem quadruplets by adjacent tRNAs with eight-base anticodon loops

To expand the genetic code for specification of multiple non-natural amino acids, unique codons for these novel amino acids are needed. As part of a study of the potential of quadruplets as codons, the decoding of tandem UAGA quadruplets by an engineered tRNA(Leu) with an eight-base anticodon loop, has been investigated. When GCC is the codon immediately 5' of the first UAGA quadruplet, and release factor 1 is partially inactivated, the tandem UAGAs specify two leucines with an overall efficiency of at least 10%. The presence of a purine at anticodon loop position 32 of the tRNA decoding the codon 5' to the first UAGA seems to influence translation of the following codon. Another finding is intraribosomal dissociation of anticodons from codons and their re-pairing to mRNA at overlapping or nearby codons. In one case where GCC is replaced by CGG, only a single Watson-Crick base pair can form upon re-pairing when decoding is resumed. This has implications for the mechanism of some cases of programmed frameshifting.

ODNBase--a web database for antisense oligonucleotide effectiveness studies. Oligodeoxynucleotides

SUMMARY

ODNBase is a database of antisense oligodeoxynucleotides targeted to mammalian mRNAs that were reported in the literature. It includes the oligo sequences tested, the measured effectiveness, the RNA that was targeted, the type of measurement assay used, the oligo concentration applied, and the reference for each oligo. It provides a searchable interface by motif content, activity level, applied concentration and RNA name. Oligo lists matching search criteria can be downloaded in a spreadsheet compatible format.

Antizyme expression: a subversion of triplet decoding, which is remarkably conserved by evolution, is a sensor for an autoregulatory circuit

The efficiency of programmed ribosomal frameshifting in decoding antizyme mRNA is the sensor for an autoregulatory circuit that controls cellular polyamine levels in organisms ranging from the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe to Drosophila to mammals. Comparison of the frameshift sites and flanking stimulatory signals in many organisms now permits a reconstruction of the likely evolutionary path of the remarkably conserved mRNA sequences involved in the frameshifting.

Sequence specificity of aminoglycoside-induced stop condon readthrough: potential implications for treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy

As a result of their ability to induce translational readthrough of stop codons, the aminoglycoside antibiotics are currently being tested for efficacy in the treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy patients carrying a nonsense mutation in the dystrophin gene. We have undertaken a systematic analysis of aminoglycoside-induced readthrough of each stop codon in human tissue culture cells using a dual luciferase reporter system. Significant differences in the efficiency of aminoglycoside-induced readthrough were observed, with UGA showing greater translational readthrough than UAG or UAA. Additionally, the nucleotide in the position immediately downstream from the stop codon had a significant impact on the efficiency of aminoglycoside-induced readthrough in the order C > U > A > or = G. Our studies show that the efficiency of stop codon readthrough in the presence of aminoglycosides is inversely proportional to the efficiency of translational termination in the absence of these compounds. Using the same assay, we analyzed a 33-base pair fragment of the mouse dystrophin gene containing the mdx premature stop codon mutation UAA (A), which is also the most efficient translational terminator. The additional flanking sequences from the dystrophin gene do not significantly change the relatively low-level aminoglycoside-induced stop codon readthrough of this stop codon. The implications of these results for drug efficacy in the treatment of individual patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy or other genetic diseases caused by nonsense mutations are discussed.

Identification of sequence motifs in oligonucleotides whose presence is correlated with antisense activity

Design of antisense oligonucleotides targeting any mRNA can be much more efficient when several activity-enhancing motifs are included and activity-decreasing motifs are avoided. This conclusion was made after statistical analysis of data collected from >1000 experiments with phosphorothioate-modified oligonucleotides. Highly significant positive correlation between the presence of motifs CCAC, TCCC, ACTC, GCCA and CTCT in the oligonucleotide and its antisense efficiency was demonstrated. In addition, negative correlation was revealed for the motifs GGGG, ACTG, AAA and TAA. It was found that the likelihood of activity of an oligonucleotide against a desired mRNA target is sequence motif content dependent.

One protein from two open reading frames: mechanism of a 50 nt translational bypass

Translating ribosomes bypass a 50 nt coding gap in order to fuse the information found in the two open reading frames (ORFs) of bacteriophage T4 gene 60. This study investigates the underlying mechanism by focusing on the competition between initiation of bypassing and termination at the end of the first ORF. While nearly all ribosomes initiate bypassing, no more than 50% resume translation in the second ORF. Two previously described cis-acting stimulatory signals are critical for favoring initiation of bypassing over termination. Genetic analysis of these signals supports a working model in which the first (a stem-loop structure at the junction between the first ORF and the coding gap) interferes with decoding in the A-site, and the second (a stretch of amino acids in the nascent peptide encoded by the first ORF) destabilizes peptidyl-tRNA-mRNA pairing.

Quadruplet codons: implications for code expansion and the specification of translation step size

One of the requirements for engineering expansion of the genetic code is a unique codon which is available for specifying the new amino acid. The potential of the quadruplet UAGA in Escherichia coli to specify a single amino acid residue in the presence of a mutant tRNA(Leu) molecule containing the extra nucleotide, U, at position 33.5 of its anticodon loop has been examined. With this mRNA-tRNA combination and at least partial inactivation of release factor 1, the UAGA quadruplet specifies a leucine residue with an efficiency of 13 to 26 %. The decoding properties of tRNA(Leu) with U at position 33.5 of its eight-membered anticodon loop, and a counterpart with A at position 33.5, strongly suggest that in both cases their anticodon loop bases stack in alternative conformations. The identity of the codon immediately 5' of the UAGA quadruplet influences the efficiency of quadruplet translation via the properties of its cognate tRNA. When there is the potential for the anticodon of this tRNA to dissociate from pairing with its codon and to re-pair to mRNA at a nearby 3' closely matched codon, the efficiency of quadruplet translation at UAGA is reduced. Evidence is presented which suggests that when there is a purine base at position 32 of this 5' flanking tRNA, it influences decoding of the UAGA quadruplet.

Discovery of a spermatogenesis stage-specific ornithine decarboxylase antizyme: antizyme 3

Previous studies with mice overproducing ornithine decarboxylase have demonstrated the importance of polyamine homeostasis for normal mammalian spermatogenesis. The present study introduces a likely key player in the maintenance of proper polyamine homeostasis during spermatogenesis. Antizyme 3 is a paralog of mammalian ornithine decarboxylase antizymes. Like its previously described counterparts, antizymes 1 and 2, it inhibits ornithine decarboxylase, which catalyzes the synthesis of putrescine. Earlier work has shown that the coding sequences for antizymes 1 and 2 are in two different, partially overlapping reading frames. Ribosomes translate the first reading frame, and just before the stop codon for that frame, they shift to the second reading frame to synthesize a trans-frame product. The efficiency of this frameshifting depends on polyamine concentration, creating an autoregulatory circuit. Antizyme 3 cDNA has the same arrangement of reading frames and a potential shift site with definite, although limited, homology to its evolutionarily distant antizyme 1 and 2 counterparts. In contrast to antizymes 1 and 2, which are widely expressed throughout the body, antizyme 3 transcription is restricted to testis germ cells. Expression starts early in spermiogenesis and finishes in the late spermatid phase. The potential significance of antizyme 3 expression during spermatogenesis is discussed in this paper.

Conservation of polyamine regulation by translational frameshifting from yeast to mammals

Regulation of ornithine decarboxylase in vertebrates involves a negative feedback mechanism requiring the protein antizyme. Here we show that a similar mechanism exists in the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe. The expression of mammalian antizyme genes requires a specific +1 translational frameshift. The efficiency of the frameshift event reflects cellular polyamine levels creating the autoregulatory feedback loop. As shown here, the yeast antizyme gene and several newly identified antizyme genes from different nematodes also require a ribosomal frameshift event for their expression. Twelve nucleotides around the frameshift site are identical between S.pombe and the mammalian counterparts. The core element for this frameshifting is likely to have been present in the last common ancestor of yeast, nematodes and mammals.

The 23 S rRNA environment of ribosomal protein L9 in the 50 S ribosomal subunit

Ribosomal protein L9 consists of two globular alpha/beta domains separated by a nine-turn alpha-helix. We examined the rRNA environment of L9 by chemical footprinting and directed hydroxyl radical probing. We reconstituted L9, or individual domains of L9, with L9-deficient 50 S subunits, or with deproteinized 23 S rRNA. A footprint was identified in domain V of 23 S rRNA that was mainly attributable to N-domain binding. Fe(II) was tethered to L9 via cysteine residues introduced at positions along the alpha-helix and in the C-domain, and derivatized proteins were reconstituted with L9-deficient subunits. Directed hydroxyl radical probing targeted regions of domains I, III, IV, and V of 23 S rRNA, reinforcing the view that 50 S subunit architecture is typified by interwoven rRNA domains. There was a striking correlation between the cleavage patterns from the Fe(II) probes attached to the alpha-helix and their predicted orientations, constraining both the position and orientation of L9, as well as the arrangement of specific elements of 23 S rRNA, in the 50 S subunit.

Nonlinearity in genetic decoding: homologous DNA replicase genes use alternatives of transcriptional slippage or translational frameshifting

The tau and gamma subunits of DNA polymerase III are both encoded by a single gene in Escherichia coli and Thermus thermophilus. gamma is two-thirds the size of tau and shares virtually all its amino acid sequence with tau. E. coli and T. thermophilus have evolved very different mechanisms for setting the approximate 1:1 ratio between tau and gamma. Both mechanisms put ribosomes into alternate reading frames so that stop codons in the new frame serve to make the smaller gamma protein. In E. coli, approximately 50% of initiating ribosomes translate the dnaX mRNA conventionally to give tau, but the other 50% shift into the -1 reading frame at a specific site (A AAA AAG) in the mRNA to produce gamma. In T. thermophilus ribosomal frameshifting is not required: the dnaX mRNA is a heterogeneous population of molecules with different numbers of A residues arising from transcriptional slippage on a run of nine T residues in the DNA template. Translation of the subpopulation containing nine As (or +/- multiples of three As) yields tau. The rest of the population of mRNAs (containing nine +/- nonmultiples of three As) puts ribosomes into the alternate reading frames to produce the gamma protein(s). It is surprising that two rather similar dnaX sequences in E. coli and T. thermophilus lead to very different mechanisms of expression.

Eubacterial tmRNAs: everywhere except the alpha-proteobacteria?

Eubacterial tmRNAs mediate, at least in Escherichia coli, recycling of ribosomes stalled at the end of terminatorless mRNAs. A tmRNA-encoded peptide tag is added to abnormal protein products of truncated mRNAs. This tag is a specific signal for proteolysis of the aberrant protein. To obtain further sequence information, PCR was used to amplify more Eubacterial genes for tmRNA. Fifty-eight new tmDNA sequences including from members of nine additional phyla were determined. Remarkably, tmDNA sequences could be amplified from all species tested apart from those in the alpha-Proteobacteria, raising evolutionary implications.

Structure of human ornithine decarboxylase antizyme 2 gene

Ornithine decarboxylase antizyme 1, a negative regulator of polyamine levels, acts by destabilizing the first enzyme in the polyamine biosynthetic pathway (ODC) and by inhibiting uptake of polyamines. Recently, a second mammalian antizyme was discovered. Here, we report the genomic organization and chromosomal position of the new human gene, HuAZ2, and make a comparison with its antizyme 1 homologue. Fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH) localized the sequences from a bacterial artificial chromosomal (BAC) clone containing HuAZ2 at band 22 of the long arm of chromosome 15. This gene spans at least 15kb and contains five exons. No CAAT or TATA sequences could be identified within 800bp upstream of the translation initiation codon, but the 5'-flanking region contains several putative binding sites for other transcription factors. Transcription initiation of this gene appears to be heterogeneous.

Structural studies of the RNA pseudoknot required for readthrough of the gag-termination codon of murine leukemia virus

Retroviruses, such as murine leukemia virus (MuLV), whose gag and pol genes are in the same reading frame but separated by a UAG stop codon, require that 5-10 % of ribosomes decode the UAG as an amino acid and continue translation to synthesize the Gag-Pol fusion polyprotein. A specific pseudoknot located eight nucleotides 3' of the UAG is required for this redefinition of the UAG stop codon. The structural probing and mutagenic analyses presented here provide evidence that loop I of the pseudoknot is one nucleotide, stem II has seven base-pairs, and the nucleotides 3' of stem II are important for function. Stem II is more resistant to single-strand-specific probes than stem I. Sequences upstream of the UAG codon allow formation of two competing structures, a stem-loop and the pseudoknot.

Mutations which alter the elbow region of tRNA2Gly reduce T4 gene 60 translational bypassing efficiency

Translating ribosomes bypass a 50 nucleotide coding gap in bacteriophage T4 gene 60 mRNA between codons 46 and 47 in order to synthesize the full-length protein. Bypassing of the coding gap requires peptidyl-tRNA2Gly detachment from a GGA codon (codon 46) followed by re-pairing at a matching GGA codon just before codon 47. Using negative selection, based on the sacB gene from Bacillus subtilis, Escherichia coli mutants were isolated which reduce bypassing efficiency. All of the mutations are in the gene for tRNA2Gly. Most of the mutations disrupt the hydrogen bonding interactions between the D- and T-loops (G18*psi55 and G19*C56) which stabilize the elbow region in nearly all tRNAs. The lone mutation not in the elbow region destabilizes the anticodon stem at position 40. Previously described Salmonella typhimurium mutants of tRNA2Gly, which reduce the stability of the T-loop, were also tested and found to decrease bypassing efficiency. Each tRNA2Gly mutant is functional in translation (tRNA2Gly is essential), but has a decoding efficiency 10- to 20-fold lower than wild-type. This suggests that rigidity of the elbow region and the anticodon stem is critical for both codon-anticodon stability and bypassing.

A three-way junction and constituent stem-loops as the stimulator for programmed -1 frameshifting in bacterial insertion sequence IS911

Several signals are required for the programmed frameshifting in translation of IS911 mRNA. These include a Shine Dalgarno (SD)-like sequence, a slippery sequence of six adenine residues and a guanine residue (A6G) and a 3' secondary structure. The structure of the mRNA containing these elements was investigated using chemical and enzymatic probing. The probing data show that the 3' structure is a three-way junction of stems. The function of the three-way junction was investigated by mutagenesis. Disrupting the stability of the structure greatly affects frameshifting and transposition levels as tested by separate in vivo assays. Structural probing and thermal melting profiles indicate that the disrupted three-way junctions have altered structures.

Functional and structural analysis of a pseudoknot upstream of the tag-encoded sequence in E. coli tmRNA

Escherichia coli tmRNA (transfer-messenger RNA) facilitates a trans-translation reaction in which a stalled ribosome on a terminatorless mRNA switches to an internal coding sequence in tmRNA, resulting in the addition of an 11 amino acid residue tag to the truncated protein that is a signal for degradation and in recycling of the stalled ribosome. A tmRNA secondary structure model with a partial tRNA-like structure and several pseudoknots was recently proposed. This report describes an extensive mutational analysis of one predicted pseudoknot (PK1) located upstream of the E. coli tmRNA tag-encoded sequence. Both the extent of aminoacylation and the alanine incorporation into the tag sequence, reflecting the two functions of tmRNA, were measured in vitro for all the engineered RNA variants. To characterize structure-function relationships for the tmRNA mutants, their solution conformations were investigated by using structural probes and by measuring the temperature dependence of their UV absorbance. This analysis strongly supports the presence of a pseudoknot in E. coli tmRNA, and its involvement in trans-translation. Mutations disrupting the first stem of the pseudoknot inactivate function and promote stable alternative conformations. Mutations of the second stem of the pseudoknot also effect both functions. The nucleotide stretch between the two stems (loop 2) is required for efficient trans-translation, and nucleotides at positions 61 and 62 must be guanine residues. The probing data suggest the presence of magnesium ion(s) interacting with loop 2. The loops crossing the minor and major grooves can be mutated without significant effects on tmRNA function. Nucleotide insertion or deletion between the pseudoknot and the coding sequence do not change the mRNA frame of the tag-peptide sequence, suggesting that the pseudoknot structure is not a determinant for the resumption of translation.

Intricacies of ribosomal frameshifting

Folded structures in mRNAs can stimulate reprogramming of ribosomes to make one protein from two different reading frames. The first crystal structure of a frameshift stimulatory RNA pseudoknot reveals remarkable features.

Programmed frameshifting in the synthesis of mammalian antizyme is +1 in mammals, predominantly +1 in fission yeast, but -2 in budding yeast

The coding sequence for mammalian ornithine decarboxylase antizyme is in two different partially overlapping reading frames with no independent ribosome entry to the second ORF. Immediately before the stop codon of the first ORF, a proportion of ribosomes undergo a quadruplet translocation event to shift to the +1 reading frame of the second and main ORF. The proportion that frameshifts is dependent on the polyamine level and, because the product antizyme is a negative regulator of intracellular polyamine levels, the frameshifting acts to complete an autoregulatory circuit by sensing polyamine levels. An mRNA element just 5' of the shift site and a 3' pseudoknot are important for efficient frameshifting. Previous work has shown that a cassette with the mammalian shift site and associated signals directs efficient shifting in the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae at the same codon to the correct frame, but that the shift is -2 instead of +1. The product contains an extra amino acid corresponding to the shift site. The present work shows efficient frameshifting also occurs in the fission yeast, Schizosaccharomyces pombe. This frameshifting is 80% +1 and 20% -2. The response of S. pombe translation apparatus to the mammalian antizyme recoding signals is more similar to that of the mammalian system than to that of S. cerevisiae. S. pombe provides a good model system for genetic studies on the mechanism of at least this type of programmed mammalian frameshifting.

A second mammalian antizyme: conservation of programmed ribosomal frameshifting

A second mammalian ornithine decarboxylase antizyme was discovered. The deduced protein sequence of the human antizyme2 is 54% identical and 67% similar to human antizyme1 but 99.5% identical to mouse antizyme2. Polyamine-regulated programmed ribosomal frameshifting is used in decoding antizyme2 mRNA as it is for antizyme1 mRNA. The mRNA signals for the programmed frameshifting are similar in the mRNAs for the two antizymes. However, in the stimulatory pseudoknot 3' of the shift site, while the sequences of the stems are highly conserved, the sequences of the loops are divergent. Functional distinctions between antizymes seem likely, but no distinction in the tissue distribution of human antizyme1 and 2 mRNAs was distinguished, though antizyme2 mRNA is 16-fold less abundant than its antizyme1 counterpart. In addition to the previously characterized human antizyme1 mRNA, a second antizyme1 mRNA with an additional 160 nucleotides at its 3' end was identified, and it has a tissue distribution different from that of the shorter antizyme1 mRNA.

Flexibility of the nascent polypeptide chain within the ribosome--contacts from the peptide N-terminus to a specific region of the 30S subunit

The ribosomal environment of the N-terminus of the nascent polypeptide chain has been investigated using peptides of different lengths, synthesized in situ on Escherichia coli ribosomes; the peptides each carry a photoreactive diazirine moiety at their N-terminus, so as to generate cross-links to neighbouring ribosomal components. Our previous studies [Choi, K. M. & Brimacombe, R. (1998) Nucleic Acids Res. 26, 887-895] with three independent families of peptides, derived from the E. coli ompA protein gene, the tetracycline-resistance gene and the bacteriophage T4 gene 60, identified a series of sites within the 23S rRNA to which the peptides became cross-linked. The distribution of these cross-links indicated that the nascent peptide is very flexible within the 50S subunit. Here, we demonstrate that the N-termini of the ompA and gene-60 peptides can, in addition, even become concomitantly cross-linked to the 30S subunit. The cross-linking is predominantly to 30S ribosomal proteins S1, S2, S4 and (to a lesser extent) S3, which form a cluster near to the decoding region. This result is discussed in terms of the flexibility of the nascent peptide during the co-translational folding process, and in terms of the 'ribosomal bypass' phenomenon which is known to occur during translation of the gene 60 mRNA.

A nickel complex cleaves uridine in folded RNA structures: application to E. coli tmRNA and related engineered molecules

To gain more insight about Escherichia coli tmRNA structure, NiCR, a square planar macrocyclic nickel (II) complex, was used to probe guanine N7 exposure. On the basis of this additional structural information, a refined secondary structure of the molecule is proposed. In addition to its known specificity for guanine N7, we show here that the chemical probe can also cleave at specific uridine residues. In contrast to the alkaline-labile modification of guanine, the reactivity of NiCR at these uridine residues results in direct strand scission. To better characterize the uridine cleavage sites and assess the importance of the RNA structure for the reaction to occur, smaller RNA molecules derived from one pseudoknot (PK4) of E. coli tmRNA containing two uridine cleavage sites were engineered and probed. It is shown that this pseudoknot can fold by itself in solution and that the expected uridine residues are also cleaved by the nickel complex, suggesting that only a local sequence and/or structural context is required for cleavage. In E. coli tmRNA, the five uridine cleavage sites are located in double-stranded regions. These sites contain a G-U wobble base-pair and a downstream uridine which is cleaved. Using smaller RNAs derived from one stem of PK4, systematic changes in the proposed recognition motif indicate that the G-U pair is required for cleavage. Furthermore, there is no cleavage if the G-U pair is reversed. If the recognition motif is moved within the stem, the cleavage site moves accordingly. Additionally, if the recognition motif is changed such that the G-U pair is flanked by two uridine residues, the reactivity occurs only at the 3' uridine. Radical quenching studies have indicated that sulfate radical, as in the case of guanine oxidation, is involved in uridine oxidation. Although additional studies are required to better characterize the reaction, this paper reports a novel specificity for a chemical probe which may be useful for investigating structural motifs involving G-U pairs in folded RNAs.

Presence and location of modified nucleotides in Escherichia coli tmRNA: structural mimicry with tRNA acceptor branches

Escherichia coli tmRNA functions uniquely as both tRNA and mRNA and possesses structural elements similar to canonical tRNAs. To test whether this mimicry extends to post-transcriptional modification, the technique of combined liquid chromatography/ electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (LC/ESIMS) and sequence data were used to determine the molecular masses of all oligonucleotides produced by RNase T1 hydrolysis with a mean error of 0.1 Da. Thus, this allowed for the detection, chemical characterization and sequence placement of modified nucleotides which produced a change in mass. Also, chemical modifications were used to locate mass-silent modifications. The native E.coli tmRNA contains two modified nucleosides, 5-methyluridine and pseudouridine. Both modifications are located within the proposed tRNA-like domain, in a seven-nucleotide loop mimicking the conserved sequence of T loops in canonical tRNAs. Although tmRNA acceptor branches (acceptor stem and T stem-loop) utilize different architectural rules than those of canonical tRNAs, their conformations in solution may be very similar. A comparative structural and functional analysis of unmodified tmRNA made by in vitro transcription and native E.coli tmRNA suggests that one or both of these post-transcriptional modifications may be required for optimal stability of the acceptor branch which is needed for efficient aminoacylation.

A dual-luciferase reporter system for studying recoding signals

A new reporter system has been developed for measuring translation coupling efficiency of recoding mechanisms such as frameshifting or readthrough. A recoding test sequence is cloned in between the renilla and firefly luciferase reporter genes and the two luciferase activities are subsequently measured in the same tube. The normalized ratio of the two activities is proportional to the efficiency with which the ribosome "reads" the recoding signal making the transition from one open reading frame to the next. The internal control from measuring both activities provides a convenient and reliable assay of efficiency. This is the first enzymatic dual reporter assay suitable for in vitro translation. Translation signals can be tested in vivo and in vitro from a single construct, which allows an intimate comparison between the two systems. The assay is applicable for high throughput screening procedures. The dual-luciferase reporter system has been applied to in vivo and in vitro recoding of HIV-1 gag-pol, MMTV gag-pro, MuLV gag-pol, and human antizyme.

The Drosophila gene for antizyme requires ribosomal frameshifting for expression and contains an intronic gene for snRNP Sm D3 on the opposite strand

Previously, a Drosophila melanogaster sequence with high homology to the sequence for mammalian antizyme (ornithine decarboxylase antizyme) was reported. The present study shows that homology of this coding sequence to its mammalian antizyme counterpart also extends to a 5' open reading frame (ORF) which encodes the amino-terminal part of antizyme and overlaps the +1 frame (ORF2) that encodes the carboxy-terminal three-quarters of the protein. Ribosomes shift frame from the 5' ORF to ORF2 with an efficiency regulated by polyamines. At least in mammals, this is part of an autoregulatory circuit. The shift site and 23 of 25 of the flanking nucleotides which are likely important for efficient frameshifting are identical to their mammalian homologs. In the reverse orientation, within one of the introns of the Drosophila antizyme gene, the gene for snRNP Sm D3 is located. Previously, it was shown that two closely linked P-element transposon insertions caused the gutfeeling phenotype of embryonic lethality and aberrant neuronal and muscle cell differentiation. The present work shows that defects in either snRNP Sm D3 or antizyme, or both, are likely causes of the phenotype.

Folding of an mRNA pseudoknot required for stop codon readthrough: effects of mono- and divalent ions on stability

Unfolding of an mRNA pseudoknot that induces ribosome suppression of the gag gene stop codon in Moloney murine leukemia virus has been studied by UV hyperchromicity and calorimetry. The pseudoknot melts in two steps, corresponding to its two helical stems. The total enthalpy of denaturation is approximately 170 kcal/mol, approximately the value expected for the secondary structure. At low salt concentrations (<50 mM KCl) the unfolding transitions are not two-state, but they approach two-state behavior at higher salt concentrations. The structure is preferentially stabilized by smaller alkali metal ions (Li+ > Na+ > K+ > Rb+ > Cs+) and by NH4+; the same preferences are exhibited by one of the stems in the context of a hairpin. Divalent metal ions are not required to fold the pseudoknot but do stabilize it further. To examine divalent ion effects over a wide concentration range, urea was used to lower the RNA unfolding temperature and was shown not to affect characteristics of the pseudoknot unfolding in other respects. The pseudoknot binds divalent ions somewhat more tightly than a hairpin but shows only weak selectivity for different size ions. It is suggested that a region of "intermediate" divalent ion binding affinity, in between highly ligated specific sites and purely delocalized ion binding in character, is created by the pseudoknot fold but that nonspecific, delocalized ion binding contributes at least half the free energy of pseudoknot stabilization by Mg2+.

A rapid in vitro method for obtaining RNA accessibility patterns for complementary DNA probes: correlation with an intracellular pattern and known RNA structures

A technique is described to identify the rare sequences within an RNA molecule that are available for efficient interaction with complementary DNA probes: the target RNA is digested by RNase H in the presence of a random pool of complementary DNA fragments generated from the same DNA preparation that was used for target RNA synthesis. The DNA region was amplified by PCR, partially digested with DNase and denatured prior to RNA binding. In the presence of single-stranded DNA fragments the RNA was digested with RNase H such that, on average, each molecule was cut once. Cleavage sites were detected by gel electrophoresis either directly with end-labeled RNA or by primer extension. The pattern of accessible sites on c- raf mRNA was determined and compared with the known profile of activity of oligonucleotides found in cells, showing the merit of the method for predicting oligonucleotides which are efficient for in vivo antisense targeting. New susceptible sites in the 3'-untranslated region of c- raf mRNA were identified. Also, four RNAs were probed to ascertain to what extent structure predicts accessibility: the P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena group I intron, yeast tRNAAsp, Escherichia coli tmRNA and a part of rat 18S rRNA.

Reported translational bypass in a trpR'-lacZ' fusion is accounted for by unusual initiation and +1 frameshifting

I. Benhar and H. Engelberg-Kulka reported that a 55 nucleotide translational bypass occurs in decoding a fusion of the Escherichia coli tryptophan repressor, trpR, and lacZ genes. The start of the bypass occurred in the trpR gene and coding resumed in the lacZ gene. It was considered that bypassing likely occurred in expression of trpR itself to produce an additional 10 kDa product which may be biologically important. We report here that bypass is undetectable in the same and related trpR'-lacZ' fusions. The beta-galactosidase activity derived from the fusions is accounted for by unusual internal initiation and +1 frameshifting, both of which occur in the lacZ part of the fusion. The 10 kDa product reportedly encoded by the trpR gene was not detectable to a level of 1% of the full-length 12 kDa tryptophan repressor product, at least when expressed from a T7 promoter.

Structural probing and mutagenic analysis of the stem-loop required for Escherichia coli dnaX ribosomal frameshifting: programmed efficiency of 50%

Three elements are crucial for the programmed frameshifting in translation of dnaX mRNA: a Shine-Dalgarno (SD)-like sequence, a double-shift site, and a 3' structure. The conformation of the mRNA containing these three elements was investigated using chemical and enzymatic probes. The probing data show that the structure is a specific stem-loop. The bottom half of the stem is more stable than the top half of the stem. The function of the stem-loop was further investigated by mutagenic analysis. Reducing the stability of the bottom half of the stem strongly effects frameshifting levels, whereas similar changes in the top half are not as effective. Stabilizing the top half of the stem gives increased frameshifting beyond the WT efficiency. The identity of the primary RNA sequence in the stem-loop is unimportant, provided that the overall structure is maintained. The calculated stabilities of the variant stem-loop structures correlate with frameshifting efficiency. The SD-interaction and the stem-loop element act independently to increase frameshifting in dnaX.

Probing the structure of the Escherichia coli 10Sa RNA (tmRNA)

The conformation of the Escherichia coli 10Sa RNA (tmRNA) in solution was investigated using chemical and enzymatic probes. Single- and double-stranded domains were identified by hydrolysis of tmRNA in imidazole buffer and by lead(II)-induced cleavages. Ribonucleases T1 and S1 were used to map unpaired nucleotides and ribonuclease V1 was used to identify paired bases or stacked nucleotides. Specific atomic positions of bases were probed with dimethylsulfate, a carbodiimide, and diethylpyrocarbonate. Covariations, identified by sequence alignment with nine other tmRNA sequences, suggest the presence of several tertiary interactions, including pseudoknots. Temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis experiments showed structural transitions of tmRNA starting around 40 degrees C, and enzymatic probing performed at selected temperatures revealed the progressive melting of several predicted interactions. Based on these data, a secondary structure is proposed, containing two stems, four stem-loops, four pseudoknots, and an unstable structural domain, some connected by single-stranded A-rich sequence stretches. A tRNA-like domain, including an already reported acceptor branch, is supported by the probing data. A second structural domain encompasses the coding sequence, which extends from the top of one stem-loop to the top of another, with a 7-nt single-stranded stretch between. A third structural module containing pseudoknots connects and probably orients the tRNA-like domain and the coding sequence. Several discrepancies between the probing data and the phylogeny suggest that E. coli tmRNA undergoes a conformational change.

Ribosomal protein L9 interactions with 23 S rRNA: the use of a translational bypass assay to study the effect of amino acid substitutions

During translation of bacteriophage T4 gene 60 mRNA, ribosomes bypass 50 nucleotides with high efficiency. One of the mRNA signals for bypass is a stem-loop in the first part of the coding gap. When the length of this stem-loop is extended by 36 nucleotides, bypass is reduced to 0.35% of the wild-type level. Bypass is partially restored by a mutation in the C-terminal domain of Escherichia coli large ribosomal subunit protein L9. Previous work has shown that L9 is an elongated protein with an alpha-helix that connects and orients the N and C-terminal domains that both contain a predicted RNA binding site. We have determined two binding sites of L9 on 23 S rRNA. A 778 nucleotide RNA fragment encompassing domain V (nucleotides 1999 to 2776) of the 23 S rRNA is retained on filters by L9 and contains both sites. The N and C-terminal domains of L9 were shown to interact with nucleotides just 5' to nucleotide 2231 and 2179 of the 23 S rRNA, respectively, using the toeprint assay. These L9 binding sites on 23 S rRNA suggest that L9 functions as a brace across helix 76 to position helices 77 and 78 relative to the peptidyl transferase center. In this study, bypass on a mutant gene 60 mRNA has been used as an assay to probe the importance of particular L9 amino acids for function. Amino acid substitutions in the C-terminal domain are shown to partially restore bypass. These mutant L9 proteins have reduced binding to a 23 S rRNA fragment (nucleotides 1999 to 2274) containing domain V, to which L9 binds. They partially retain both the N and C-terminal domain interactions. On the other hand, substitutions of amino acids in the N-terminal domain, which greatly reduce RNA binding, do not restore bypass. The latter mutants have completely lost the N-terminal domain interaction. Addition of an amino acid to the alpha-helix also restores gene 60 bypass. RNA binding by this mutant is similar to that observed for the C-terminal domain mutants that partially restore bypass.

Recoding: dynamic reprogramming of translation

A minority of genes in probably all organisms rely on "recoding" for translation of their mRNAs. In these cases, the rules for decoding are temporarily altered through the action of specific signals built into the mRNA sequences. Three classes are described. 1. Frameshifting at a particular site allows expression of a protein from an mRNA with overlapping open reading frames, often giving two protein products from one mRNA. 2. The meanings of code words are altered: specific stop codons can be redirected to encode selenocysteine, tryptophan, or glutamine. 3. Ribosomes can translate over coding gaps in mRNA. These novel mechanisms expand the repertoire of the genetic code and are at the heart of several regulatory schemes.

Reading two bases twice: mammalian antizyme frameshifting in yeast

Programmed translational frameshifting is essential for the expression of mammalian ornithine decarboxylase antizyme, a protein involved in the regulation of intracellular polyamines. A cassette containing antizyme frameshift signals is found to direct high-level (16%) frameshifting in yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In contrast to +1 frameshifting in the mammalian system, in yeast the same frame is reached by -2 frameshifting. Two bases are read twice. The -2 frameshifting is likely to be mediated by slippage of mRNA and re-pairing with the tRNA in the P-site. The downstream pseudoknot stimulates frameshifting by 30-fold compared with 2.5-fold in reticulocyte lysates. When the length of the spacer between the shift site and the pseudoknot is extended by three nucleotides, +1 and -2 frameshifting become equal.