German S3 guideline on the use of dental ceramic implants

PURPOSE

Based on the excellent long-term data, dental implants made of titanium are considered the international implantological standard for replacing missing teeth. However, ceramic implants made of zirconia (ZrO₂) have experienced a renaissance in the last 15 years due to constant innovations in materials and products, with material properties and soft tissue- and osseointegration behavior comparable to those of titanium. However, one limitation concerning ceramic implants is the lack of reliable long-term data, especially in the case of two-piece implant systems. As there is an increasing demand for ceramic implants from practitioners and patients, the German Society for Implantology (DGI) has decided to develop a guideline on the use of dental ceramic implants at the highest available evidence level with the involvement of experts in this field.

METHODS

Statements and recommendations were prepared after conducting a systematic literature search and an independent assessment process involving the relevant clinical literature from 2008 to 2021. The adopted recommendations and statements are summarized in this guideline.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

It confirms the feasible use of one-piece zirconia implants as an addendum/alternative to titanium implants. No final conclusion regarding the application of two-piece ceramic implant systems could be drawn on the basis of the existing data, thus its use can only be recommended after the patient has been informed in detail about the lack of long-term clinical data.

Structure and in vitro cytocompatibility of the gastropod shell of Helix pomatia

Distinguishing features of biological constructions are high stability and adaptation to their environment. Beside biocompatibility, nontoxicity and degradability these characteristics are demanded for new biomaterials in the field of tissue engineering. This study investigated the chemical composition, the organization and the in vitro osteoconductive potential of the terrestrial gastropod shell (Helix pomatia) on CAL72 and human osteoblast-like cells. Chemical composition of the biomaterial was examined by X-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was performed to analyze the architecture of the snail shell and the morphology of the seeded cells. A double staining procedure (FDA/PI) and a proliferation test (EZ4U) assessed the viability of the cells. Microscopical images showed the multilayered architecture of the aragonite shell with hexagonal crystals on the inner side. The cells spread well on the biomaterial and the highest proliferation rate could be measured with CAL72 cells on the inner shell surface. The osteoconductive effects of this natural biomaterial could encourage further experiments in the field of tissue engineering.

Effect of different crown contours on periodontal health in dogs. Microbiological results

OBJECTIVES

In some clinical circumstances, i.e. in cases when the upper anterior region has to be restored by prosthetic means, it is necessary to place the margins of crowns and fixed partial dentures subgingivally. In addition, in periodontally compromised patients the restoration sometimes has to be overcontoured in order to replace the lost interdental papilla. The overcontoured crown margin may influence the subgingival bacterial composition. Therefore, the aim of the present investigation was to evaluate the effect of three different subgingival crown contours in dogs on the composition of the subgingival microbiota.

METHODS

In four adult beagle dogs the second and third premolars were prepared in three quadrants and restored with single gold crowns. The unprepared second and third premolars in the last quadrant served as controls. The crowns had three different emergence profiles including a normal contour, a 30 degrees and a 50 degrees over-contour. During the entire study period, professional oral hygiene was performed seven times a week. Microbiological samples were harvested from four sites of test and control teeth (mesial, distal, buccal and lingual) at baseline, after 3 months, and after 5 months.

RESULTS

The microbiological analysis (DNA-DNA hybridization technique) of the subgingival microbial flora revealed a dominance of P. intermedia, T. denticola and C. showae in all test and control groups at baseline. At three months, the total amount of bacteria increased and a broader variety of bacterial species could be detected. The detection frequency of most bacterial species increased from baseline to the 5-month evaluation. The frequency of detection of some species was higher in the 30 degrees and 50 degrees overcontoured test groups compared to the normal contour group and to the natural teeth.

CONCLUSIONS

It can be concluded within the limits of this investigation that overcontoured gold crowns placed subgingivally have only slight effects on the microbiological composition in dogs when an intensive oral hygiene regimen was executed.

Effect of different crown contours on periodontal health in dogs. Clinical results

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study is to evaluate clinically the effect of different crown contours on the periodontium in beagle dogs.

METHODS

One month after commencing oral hygiene procedures the second and third premolars in three quadrants of four adult beagle dogs were prepared for receiving crowns. The unprepared second and third premolars in one quadrant served as controls. Crowns with three different emergence profiles (normal (=tooth) contour, 30 degrees and 50 degrees over-contour) were cemented where one quadrant received the same treatment. Clinical parameters were recorded on all four sites (mesial, buccal, distal and lingual) of test and control teeth at baseline, after 3 and 5 months. During the entire study period, professional oral hygiene was performed seven times a week.

RESULTS

The Plaque Index increased for the 30 degrees and 50 degrees over-contour groups, although no statistically significant differences could be observed. For the normal contour and control group minor changes occurred. Similar results could be depicted for the Gingival Index. The changes regarding the variables Plaque and Gingival Index were correlated to the Gingival Crevicular Fluid Flow. Here, significant differences for the Gingival Crevicular Flow were observed between the treatment groups and over the treatment period for the 30 and 50 degrees over-contour groups. Only slight differences for this parameter were observed in and between the control and normal contour groups. In the control group, the Pocket Probing depth remained stable during the entire study but increased in the crowned treatment groups over time. At 3 and 5 months the probing depth was significant greater in the 30 degrees and 50 degrees over-contour groups compared to the control group. There was a higher loss of clinical attachment levels for the test groups than for the control group. There were statistically significant differences at each timepoint between groups and also within groups except for the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

Within the limits of this study it can be concluded that over-contoured subgingival crowns seem to affect clinical periodontal health only slightly in dogs over 5 months when an intensive oral hygiene regimen is executed.

[Guided bone regeneration around dental implants using a bioabsorbable membrane. A pilot investigation in experimental animals]

The aim of this experimental investigation was to evaluate the effect of guided bone regeneration around immediately placed implants using different barrier membranes. Five adult fox hounds were used in this investigation. After extraction of all premolars in the lower jaw, implant osteotomies in the regions of the former premolars and additional buccal bone defects (5 mm x 5 mm) were created. Subsequently, the implants were placed. The defects were treated with one of the following three modalities: (a) guided bone regeneration, using a bioinert expanded polytetrafluoroethylene membrane, (b) no membrane application and (c) guided bone regeneration, using a bioabsorbable membrane made from a synthetic copolymer of lactide and glycolide. After a healing period of six months, the animals were sacrificed and the implants with the surrounding tissues processed for histologic evaluation. The clinical pretreatment defects between the different treatment groups were not statistically different (bioinert membrane group: 4.8 mm; control group: 4.3 mm; bioabsorbable membrane group: 4.9 mm). The remaining histological defects after a healing period of 6 months amounted to 3.2 mm for the nonresorbable group, to 5.6 mm for the control and to 6.3 mm for the bioabsorbable group. A significant difference was observed between the bioinert membrane group and the other two groups. The mineralized bone-to-implant contact in the bioinert membrane group was 52%, in the control group 47% and in the bioabsorbable membrane group 43.3%. The values were not statistically significant different. The results of this study indicate that a partial bone regeneration with bioinert e-PTFE membranes around immediately placed implants is possible. The utilized bioabsorbable polylactide/polyglycolide membrane did not show any bone regenerative effect, and the results did not differ from the control group without membrane application.

Clinical and histologic evaluation of submerged and nonsubmerged hydroxyapatite-coated implants: a preliminary study in dogs

A clinical and histologic study was performed to evaluate the differences in the healing of submerged and nonsubmerged hydroxyapatite-coated 2-piece implants. Three foxhounds were used for this evaluation. Mandibular premolars 1, 2, 3, and 4 were extracted. Three months later, 2 submerged implants were placed on one side of the mandible, and 2 nonsubmerged implants were placed on the other side of the mandible. After 3 months of healing, the submerged implants were exposed, and a third implant was placed on each side of the mandible in a nonsubmerged procedure. Clinical parameters were recorded, the animals were sacrificed 6 months after placement of the first implants, and histologic and histometric analyses were performed. Results of the evaluation of the clinical parameters showed only minor differences among the different treatment groups. Regarding the percentage of bone-to-implant contact of the different treatment groups, the submerged implants showed a bone-to-implant contact of 63.4%, the nonsubmerged implants showed 70.3% contact, and the late nonsubmerged implants demonstrated a bone-to-implant contact of 58.7%. The average distance from the implant neck to the first bone-to-implant contact (fBIC) for submerged implants was 0.58 mm, for nonsubmerged implants it was 1.09 mm, and it was 1.13 mm for late nonsubmerged implants. The vertical distance between the gingival margin and the apical extent of the junctional epithelium (aJE) varied from 1.14 mm to 1.28 mm in the different groups. The distance from the aJE to fBIC was 1.00 mm for the submerged group, 1.08 mm for the nonsubmerged group, and 1.00 mm for the late nonsubmerged group. Generally, it can be concluded that the clinical and the histologic behavior of submerged or nonsubmerged 2-piece implants utilized in this experiment do not differ.

Comparison of bioabsorbable and bioinert membranes for guided bone regeneration around non-submerged implants. An experimental study in the mongrel dog

The aim of this clinical investigation was to evaluate the effect of guided bone regeneration around non-submerged implants using different barrier membranes. Five adult mongrel dogs were used in this investigation. After having all premolars extracted and implant osteotomies performed in the regions of the former premolars, buccal bone defects were created. Subsequently, 3 implants were placed and the defects treated with 1 of the following 3 modalities: a) guided bone regeneration using an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene membrane, b) guided bone regeneration using a bioabsorbable membrane made from a synthetic copolymer of glycolide and lactide and c) no membrane application. Following implant and membrane placement, the mucoperiosteal flaps were repositioned and tightly sutured around the neck of the implants allowing for a non-submerged healing. After a healing period of 6 months, the animals were sacrificed and the specimens processed for histologic evaluation. The clinical pre-treatment defects between the different treatment groups were not statistically different (bioinert membrane group: 4.9 mm; control group: 4.8 mm; bioabsorbable membrane group: 4.5 mm). The remaining histological defects after 6 months of healing amounted to approximately 2.5 mm in the bioinert membrane group, 5.7 mm in the control group and 6.0 mm in the bioabsorbable membrane group. A significant difference was observed between the bioinert membrane group and the other 2 groups. The mineralized bone-to-implant contact in the bioinert membrane group was 51.5%, in the control group 46.3% and in the bioabsorbable membrane group 37.5%. The values between the bioinert membrane group and the bioabsorbable membrane group were statistically different. The results of this study indicate that bone regeneration with bioinert e-PTFE membranes around non-submerged implants is possible. The utilized absorbable polyglycolic/polylactid membrane did not show any bone regenerative effect and the results did not differ from the control group without membrane application.

Evaluation of a new bioresorbable barrier to facilitate guided bone regeneration around exposed implant threads. An experimental study in the monkey

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of a new bioresorbable barrier alone or in combination with BioOss for guided bone regeneration around dental implants with exposed implant threads. Five adult Macaca fascicularis monkeys were used in this investigation. After extraction of all premolars and first molars, two endosteal oral implants were installed in each quadrant and the bony defects were randomly treated with either: 1) placement of the new bioresorbable device alone (group 1); 2) placement of the new bioresorbable barrier in combination with BioOss (group 2); 3) placement of an ePTFE barrier in combination with BioOss (group 3); or (4) control (group 4). After a period of six months the animals were killed and the histological processing was performed. There was a significant difference in the amount of new bone regeneration around the implants between the four groups (i.e. groups 1, 2, 3 and 4) (P=0.0122). There was no difference, however, between group 2 and group 3. It can be concluded that the new bioresorbable barrier in combination with BioOss appears to obtain the same results in this type of bony defects as the grafting material in combination with an ePTFE barrier.

The effects of guided bone regeneration and grafting on implants placed into immediate extraction sockets. An experimental study in dogs

Guided bone regeneration (gbr) for the treatment of insufficient bone volume around implants can be performed using membranes with or without grafting materials (i.e., autogenous, allogenous, xenogenous, or alloplastic grafts). A possible way to evaluate the quality of implant osseointegration is the torque necessary to remove implants from their bony housing. The aim of this study was to compare the torques necessary to remove dental implants from implant beds reconstructed with different bone substitutes and GBR or GBR alone in 6 adult mongrel dogs. All mandibular premolars were extracted and 3 extraction sockets on each side were enlarged using a trephine bur. A 13 mm titanium screw-type dental implant (3.75 mm diameter) was placed in each enlarged extraction socket so that only the apical 3 to 4 mm were engaged in bone. The 3 defects were then randomly treated with either 1) canine demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA) plus GBR using an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene membrane (DFDBA+GTAM); 2) bioabsorbable hydroxyapatite and GBR (HA+GTAM); or 3) GBR (GTAM alone). After 6 months, the torque to remove the implants was measured in 4 animals and analyzed using ANOVA. There were no statistically significant differences between the 3 groups (GTAM alone: 46.37+/-16.41 Ncm; HA+GTAM: 46.00+/-16.59 Ncm; DFDBA+ GTAM: 52.15+/-29.24 Ncm). In addition, the influence of early removal of barriers on the torque values was evaluated with the t-test. Comparing exposed versus retained membranes by treatment modality, the only statistically significant difference was found in the DFDBA+GTAM group. When the torque values of all implants with exposed and retrieved membranes were compared to all those with retained membranes a significant difference could be detected. Histologic sections were prepared from the 2 dogs not included in the removal torque testing. In the histometric analysis the GTAM alone group showed a mean mineralized bone-to-implant-contact of 27.1%, the DFDBA+GTAM group of 34.6%, and the HA+GTAM of 39.3%. The mineralized bone-to-implant-contact of the HA+GTAM group was significantly higher than that of the GTAM alone group. In addition, the mineralized bone-to-implant-contact was divided into an apical and coronal part using the apical seventh thread as the dividing landmark. In the apical region, there was no significant difference between the groups regarding mineralized bone-to-implant-contact. In the coronal part the mineralized bone-to-implant-contact of the GTAM alone group was significantly lower compared to the other 2 groups. Within the limits of this investigation, it can be concluded that the type of grafting material will not influence torque removal values, but that early membrane exposure and removal will negatively influence the torque measurements. The combination of GBR with a bone substitute increased the mineralized bone-to-implant contact.

Changes in peri-implant tissues subjected to orthodontic forces and ligature breakdown in monkeys

The aims of this investigation were to histologically evaluate in monkeys the effect of a repetitive mechanical trauma alone on the peri-implant tissues, and the effect of a repetitive mechanical trauma in combination with ligature-induced peri-implantitis on the peri-implant tissues. The study used 5 male cynomolgus monkeys. Prior to the start of the study, all premolars and the first and second molars in the mandible were extracted. After a healing period of 12 weeks, following tooth extraction, split/full thickness flaps were elevated on both sides of the mandible in order to expose the bony ridge. Four implants, of 3.75 mm in diameter and 7 mm in length, were then inserted on each side and the flaps were readapted and sutured in place. Following a healing period of 16 weeks, the second stage procedure was performed, impressions were taken, and custom-made crowns using a non-precious metal alloy were fabricated and inserted on all implants 4 weeks after abutment connection. At the same time peri-implantitis was induced on one side of the mandible by placing plaque-retentive ligatures around the implants. On the other side, an oral hygiene program consisting of thrice weekly brushing with a toothbrush and flour of pumice mixed with 2% chlorhexidine was initiated. Four months later, a repetitive mechanical trauma was initiated on implants 1 and 2 on both sides in the mandible. Consequently, a split mouth design was obtained: 1) test 1=ligature-induced peri-implantitis alone (LPNO); 2) test 2=ligature-induced peri-implantitits with a repetitive mechanical trauma (LPMT); 3) test 3=healthy peri-implant tissues with a repetitive mechanical trauma (MT); and 4) control (NO)=healthy peri-implant tissues with no repetitive mechanical trauma. Following 16 weeks of repetitive mechanical trauma the animals were sacrificed. Histologic observations and computed-assisted histometric and histomorphometric analyses were performed to determine the amount of peri-implant bone loss and the percentage of direct mineralized bone-to-implant contact around each endosseous oral implant. Histologically, all implants yielded osseointegration at the light microscopic level. There was a significant difference regarding the mean direct mineralized bone-to-implant contact length as a fraction of the total implant length between the healthy (i.e., MT and NO) and diseased sites (i.e., LPNO and LPMT) (P < 0.05). When comparing the percent of direct mineralized bone-to-implant contact for the 2 best threads of each implant and group, no significant difference (P=0.675) could be detected. Under the conditions of this study, the repetitive mechanical trauma showed no histologic effect on the peri-implant bone loss neither in healthy nor in diseased implant sites. The effects of excessive loading on osseointegration are presently not clearly understood. The key problem seems to be the determination when loading on implants exceeds the physiological range of bone adaptation which may then cause implant failure. Further research to elucidate this problem is essential.

Custom-made root analogue titanium implants placed into extraction sockets. An experimental study in monkeys

The aim of this investigation was to evaluate clinically and histologically a new custom-made, root analogue titanium implant placed into extraction sockets in monkeys (Macaca fascicularis). Three adult monkeys were used in this investigation. After raising full thickness flaps on the buccal and lingual side, the upper central and lateral incisors were extracted. Each tooth root was machine copied to 1 titanium analogue using a new CAD/CAM-system. The implants were installed in the respective extraction sockets and the flaps sutured back. After 6 months of healing biopsies were taken and processed according to the cutting-grinding technique. The percentage of mineralized bone-to-implant contact was measured as a fraction of the rough implant surface using computer-assisted analysis. The main clinical problem that occurred during implant placement was the fracture of the buccal alveolar wall. The histometric evaluation showed a mean mineralized bone-to-implant contact of 41.2 +/- 20.6%. In this investigation it could be shown that implants fabricated by laser copying will osseointegrate. The presented data encourage the performance of clinical and experimental trials evaluating the new system utilizing improved second generation CAD/CAM equipment. Such studies are currently underway.

The effect of a calcium hydroxide paste on wound healing and osseointegration of dental implants. A pilot study in beagle dogs

The aim of this investigation was to evaluate the effect of a new calcium hydroxide suspension (Osteoinductal) on the healing process of endosseous dental implants after placement. The material, composed of 25% calcium hydroxide, 25% Oleum pedum tauri and 50% vaselinum album, was developed with the intention to accelerate and to increase the mineralized bone to implant contact during the healing phase. Eight adult beagle dogs were used in this study. Prior to the beginning of the study the dogs had all mandibular premolars extracted. After the extraction sites had healed for 3 months, implant osteotomies were performed. On one side of the mandibular premolars extracted. After the extraction sites had healed for 3 months, implant osteotomies were performed. On one side of the mandible Osteoinductal was applied into the osteotomies before placement of the implants, whereas the other side did not receive Osteoinductal. A total of 48 implants were placed with two losses during the entire study period. Two dogs were sacrificed 1 week, 2 weeks, 4 weeks and 3 months after implant placement. The specimens were evaluated histologically and histomorphometrically. In the histological evaluation an intense inflammatory reaction towards the calcium hydroxide suspension was found leading to a destruction of the bone surrounding the implants after 1 and 2 weeks. A giant cell reaction against the test material was visible at 4 weeks. At 3 months no inflammatory and no giant cell reaction could be depicted in the test group. The mean direct bone to implant contact or inflammatory tissue to implant contact showed no differences between test and control group for 1 and 2 weeks. Although statistically not significant, there was a clinical significant difference in the mineralized bone to implant contact between test and control group for the last two timepoints (i.e. 4-week specimens: test group 2.3 +/- 0.9%, control group 26.8 +/- 11.1%; 3-month specimens: test group 10.5 +/- 12.7%, control group 60.7 +/- 13.7%). This study indicates that the use of the calcium hydroxide suspension Osteoinductal has a detrimental effect on wound healing and osseointegration of dental implants and cannot be recommended for use with dental implants.