Tools for assessing health research partnership outcomes and impacts: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To identify and assess the globally available valid, reliable and acceptable tools for assessing health research partnership outcomes and impacts.

METHODS

We searched Ovid MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL Plus and PsycINFO from origin to 2 June 2021, without limits, using an a priori strategy and registered protocol. We screened citations independently and in duplicate, resolving discrepancies by consensus and retaining studies involving health research partnerships, the development, use and/or assessment of tools to evaluate partnership outcomes and impacts, and reporting empirical psychometric evidence. Study, tool, psychometric and pragmatic characteristics were abstracted using a hybrid approach, then synthesized using descriptive statistics and thematic analysis. Study quality was assessed using the quality of survey studies in psychology (Q-SSP) checklist.

RESULTS

From 56 123 total citations, we screened 36 027 citations, assessed 2784 full-text papers, abstracted data from 48 studies and one companion report, and identified 58 tools. Most tools comprised surveys, questionnaires and scales. Studies used cross-sectional or mixed-method/embedded survey designs and employed quantitative and mixed methods. Both studies and tools were conceptually well grounded, focusing mainly on outcomes, then process, and less frequently on impact measurement. Multiple forms of empirical validity and reliability evidence was present for most tools; however, psychometric characteristics were inconsistently assessed and reported. We identified a subset of studies (22) and accompanying tools distinguished by their empirical psychometric, pragmatic and study quality characteristics. While our review demonstrated psychometric and pragmatic improvements over previous reviews, challenges related to health research partnership assessment and the nascency of partnership science persist.

CONCLUSION

This systematic review identified multiple tools demonstrating empirical psychometric evidence, pragmatic strength and moderate study quality. Increased attention to psychometric and pragmatic requirements in tool development, testing and reporting is key to advancing health research partnership assessment and partnership science. PROSPERO CRD42021137932.

Tipping the balance: Chronic superior vena cava thrombosis resulting in an aberrant and inefficient venous circuit

Given there was no direct flow into the right atrium from the SVC, we deemed this inefficient venous circuit responsible for her breathlessness, with a small reduction in cardiac function 'tipping the balance' and producing symptoms this late in life. The patient opted for conservative management with the risk of intervention outweighing her currently manageable symptoms.

Effusive-constrictive cholesterol pericarditis: a case report

Background

Cholesterol pericarditis (CP) remains a rare pericardial disease characterized by chronic pericardial effusions with high cholesterol concentrations with or without the formation of cholesterol crystals. Effusions are often large and can cause ventricular compression and subsequent pericardial adhesion formation. CP can be idiopathic but has associations with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), tuberculosis and hypothyroidism.

Case summary

We present a case of a 72-year-old male with a background of seropositive RA with a finding of an incidental pericardial effusion on computed tomography thorax abdomen and pelvis. Transthoracic echocardiogram demonstrated a large effusion with echocardiographic features of tamponade. On review, he was breathless with a raised venous pressure, bilateral ankle oedema, and pulsus paradoxus was present. Pericardial drainage was performed with fluid analysis demonstrating a cholesterol concentration of 8.3 mmol/L and numerous cholesterol crystal formation. Interval imaging demonstrated recurrence of the effusion with pericardial thickening and progressive constriction. He remained asymptomatic and underwent a successful pericardial window. At present, he is under close clinical outpatient surveillance with symptoms guiding a future pericardiectomy if warranted.

Discussion

CP can present as an emergent situation with signs and symptoms of acute heart failure with prompt pericardiocentesis required in cases of clinical tamponade. However, the disease course is often one of chronicity with relapsing large effusions that tend to recur following drainage, with the development of pericardial constriction necessitating pericardiectomy for definitive management.

Mesalazine-induced myopericarditis: a case report

Background

Mesalazine is a well-established 1st line treatment for inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). Cardiotoxicity following 5-aminosalicyclic-acid therapy remains a rare yet serious complication and can often be challenging to distinguish from myocarditis presenting as an extra-intestinal manifestation of IBD.

Case summary

We present a case of a 22-year-old man with a background of ulcerative colitis commenced on a mesalazine preparation for disease progression. He presented to our hospital 12 days following drug initiation with acute chest pain, peak troponin-T of 242 ng/L, dynamic electrocardiogram changes, and severe left ventricular systolic dysfunction on transthoracic echocardiogram. The clinical diagnosis of myopericarditis was suspected and mesalazine was stopped shortly after. Outpatient cardiac magnetic resonance performed 2 weeks following mesalazine cessation demonstrated a recovery of cardiac function with associated symptom and biochemical resolution.

Discussion

Clinicians should be aware of this potentially fatal adverse effect of a commonly prescribed medication. Symptoms of myocarditis often occur within the early stages of mesalazine initiation, which aids the clinical diagnosis. The mainstay of treatment is to simply discontinue the drug with rapid resolution of symptoms seen without any permanent or long-term cardiac dysfunction. Close liaison with the gastroenterology team is key, as 2nd line IBD therapies are often required for the ongoing management of the patient’s colitis.

Mapping catheter-related mitral valve injury: a case report

Background

An increasing number of catheter ablations are performed for symptomatic tachyarrhythmias and commonly involve the left atrium, increasing the risk of catheter interaction with the mitral valve (MV) complex. Mitral valve trauma at the time of atrial fibrillation (AF) ablations remains a rare yet emergent situation that requires prompt diagnosis and management to prevent the long-term sequelae of heart failure secondary to MV dysfunction.

Case summary

We present a case of a 69-year-old female with symptomatic paroxysmal AF and atrial flutter who underwent a combined ablation procedure. During the pulmonary vein isolation procedure, the mapping catheter became entangled within the MV apparatus but was freed. She presented to our hospital 2 weeks later with dyspnoea, lethargy, and a cough. Clinical examination revealed a pansystolic murmur and right moderate pleural effusion. Transthoracic echocardiogram (TTE) demonstrated a flail posterior MV leaflet with severe eccentric mitral regurgitation (MR). She underwent urgent valve repair at the regional cardiothoracic centre. Upon review 2 months later, she was symptom free with surveillance TTE demonstrating a preserved left ventricular systolic function with a trace of MR.

Discussion

Mitral valve injury secondary to catheter entrapment at the time of left-sided ablations is a rare yet serious complication and can present as an emergent situation requiring prompt recognition and early surgical management to salvage valve and cardiac function.

A cost-utility analysis of SIR-Spheres Y-90 resin microspheres versus best supportive care in the treatment of unresectable metastatic colorectal cancer refractory to chemotherapy in the UK

BACKGROUND

Limited treatment options are available in chemotherapy-refractory or -intolerant metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC). The objective of the present analysis was to evaluate the cost-utility of SIR-Spheres Y-90 resin microspheres relative to best supportive care (BSC) in the treatment of chemotherapy refractory mCRC from the perspective of the UK national healthcare payer.

METHODS

A cost-utility model was developed in Microsoft Excel to simulate transitions from progression-free survival to post-progression survival and death in patients with mCRC. Unit costs were captured in 2019 pounds sterling (GBP) based on the literature, formulary listings, and National Health Service (NHS) England reference costs. Future costs and effects were discounted at 3.5% per annum. A series of one-way sensitivity analyses, and probabilistic sensitivity analysis (PSA) were conducted.

RESULTS

The base case analysis showed that SIR-Spheres Y-90 resin microspheres would result in an increase in discounted quality-adjusted life years gained from 0.69 quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) to 1.50 QALYs, with an associated increase in cost from GBP 15,268 to GBP 34,168 yielding an incremental cost-utility ratio of GBP 23,435 per QALY. PSA showed that there would be a 56% likelihood that SIR-Spheres Y-90 resin microspheres would be cost-effective relative to BSC at a willingness-to-pay threshold of GBP 30,000 per QALY gained.

CONCLUSIONS

This cost-utility analysis showed that, relative to BSC, SIR-Spheres Y-90 resin microspheres would be a cost-effective treatment option for patients with mCRC in the UK setting from the national healthcare payer perspective.

Perioperative intravenous contrast administration and the incidence of acute kidney injury after major gastrointestinal surgery: prospective, multicentre cohort study

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to determine the impact of preoperative exposure to intravenous contrast for CT and the risk of developing postoperative acute kidney injury (AKI) in patients undergoing major gastrointestinal surgery.

METHODS

This prospective, multicentre cohort study included adults undergoing gastrointestinal resection, stoma reversal or liver resection. Both elective and emergency procedures were included. Preoperative exposure to intravenous contrast was defined as exposure to contrast administered for the purposes of CT up to 7 days before surgery. The primary endpoint was the rate of AKI within 7 days. Propensity score-matched models were adjusted for patient, disease and operative variables. In a sensitivity analysis, a propensity score-matched model explored the association between preoperative exposure to contrast and AKI in the first 48 h after surgery.

RESULTS

A total of 5378 patients were included across 173 centres. Overall, 1249 patients (23·2 per cent) received intravenous contrast. The overall rate of AKI within 7 days of surgery was 13·4 per cent (718 of 5378). In the propensity score-matched model, preoperative exposure to contrast was not associated with AKI within 7 days (odds ratio (OR) 0·95, 95 per cent c.i. 0·73 to 1·21; P = 0·669). The sensitivity analysis showed no association between preoperative contrast administration and AKI within 48 h after operation (OR 1·09, 0·84 to 1·41; P = 0·498).

CONCLUSION

There was no association between preoperative intravenous contrast administered for CT up to 7 days before surgery and postoperative AKI. Risk of contrast-induced nephropathy should not be used as a reason to avoid contrast-enhanced CT.

A qualitative study of the acceptability of cognitive bias modification for paranoia (CBM-pa) in patients with psychosis

BACKGROUND

Cognitive Bias Modification (CBM) has been used successfully as a computer-based intervention in disorders such as anxiety. However, CBM to modify interpretations of ambiguous information relevant to paranoia has not yet been tested. We conducted a qualitative investigation of a novel intervention called CBM for paranoia (CBM-pa) to examine its acceptability in patients with psychosis.

METHODS

Eight participants with psychosis who completed CBM-pa were identified by purposive sampling and invited for a semi-structured interview to explore the facilitators and barriers to participation, optimum form of delivery, perceived usefulness of CBM-pa and their opinions on applying CBM-pa as a computerised intervention. The interviews were transcribed and analysed using thematic analysis by researchers working in collaboration with service users.

RESULTS

Themes emerged relating to participants' perception about delivery, engagement, programme understanding, factors influencing experience, perceived impact and application of CBM-pa. CBM-pa was regarded as easy, straightforward and enjoyable. It was well-accepted among those we interviewed, who understood the procedure as a psychological intervention. Patients reported that it increased their capacity for adopting alternative interpretations of emotionally ambiguous scenarios. Although participants all agreed on the test-like nature of the current CBM-pa format, they considered that taking part in sessions had improved their overall wellbeing. Most of them valued the computer-based interface of CBM-pa but favoured the idea of combining CBM-pa with some form of human interaction.

CONCLUSIONS

CBM-pa is an acceptable intervention that was well-received by our sample of patients with paranoia. The current findings reflect positively on the acceptability and experience of CBM-pa in the target population. Patient opinion supports further development and testing of CBM-pa as a possible adjunct treatment for paranoia.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN: 90749868 . Retrospectively registered on 12 May 2016.

Predictors of healthcare professionals' attitudes towards family involvement in safety-relevant behaviours: a cross-sectional factorial survey study

OBJECTIVES

To investigate predictors of healthcare professionals' (HCPs) attitudes towards family involvement in safety-relevant behaviours.

DESIGN

A cross-sectional fractional factorial survey that assessed HCPs' attitudes towards family involvement in two error scenarios relating to hand hygiene and medication safety. Each survey comprised two randomised vignettes that described the potential error, how the family member communicated with the HCP about the error and how the HCP responded to the family member's question.

SETTING

5 teaching hospitals in London, the Midlands and York. HCPs were approached on a range of medical and surgical wards.

PARTICIPANTS

160 HCPs (73 doctors; 87 nurses) aged between 21 and 65 years (mean 37) 102 were female.

OUTCOME MEASURES

HCP approval of family member's behaviour; HCP reaction to the family member; anticipated effects on the family member-HCP relationship; HCP support for being questioned about hand hygiene/medication; affective rating responses.

RESULTS

HCPs supported family member's intervening (88%) but only 41% agreed this would have positive effects on the family member/HCP relationship. Across vignettes and error scenarios the strongest predictors of attitudes were how the HCP (in the scenario) responded to the family member and whether an error actually occurred. Doctors (vs nurses) provided systematically more positive affective ratings to the vignettes.

CONCLUSIONS

Important predictors of HCPs' attitudes towards family members' involvement in patient safety have been highlighted. In particular, a discouraging response from HCP's decreased support for family members being involved and had strong perceived negative effects on the family member/HCP relationship.

The influence of prior expectations on facial expression discrimination in schizophrenia

BACKGROUND

Belief inflexibility is a thinking style observed in patients with schizophrenia, in which patients tend to refute evidence that runs counter to their prior beliefs. This bias has been related to a dominance of prior expectations (prior beliefs) over incoming sensory evidence. In this study we investigated the reliance on prior expectations for the processing of emotional faces in schizophrenia.

METHOD

Eighteen patients with schizophrenia and 18 healthy controls were presented with sequences of emotional (happy, fearful, angry or neutral) faces. Perceptual decisions were biased towards a particular expression by a specific instruction at the start of each sequence, referred to as the context in which stimuli occurred. Participants were required to judge the emotion on each face and the effect of the context on emotion discrimination was investigated.

RESULTS

For threatening emotions (anger and fear), there was a performance cost for facial expressions that were incongruent with, and perceptually close to, the expression named in the instruction. For example, for angry faces, participants in both groups made more errors and reaction times (RTs) were longer when they were asked to look out for fearful faces compared with the other contexts. This bias against sensory evidence that runs counter to prior information was stronger in the patients, evidenced by a group by context interaction in accuracy and RTs for anger and fear respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, the present data suggest an overdependence on prior expectations for threatening stimuli, reflecting belief inflexibility, in schizophrenia.

Computerized cognitive remediation training for schizophrenia: an open label, multi-site, multinational methodology study

A recent single-site study (Fisher et al., 2009. Am J Psychiatry. 166 (7) 805-11) showed that repeated training with the Brain Fitness Program (BFP) improved performance on a battery of neuropsychological tasks. If replicated these data suggest an important non-pharmacological method for ameliorating cognitive impairment in schizophrenia. Our study evaluated the BFP training effects in an open-label, multi-site, multinational clinical trial. Fifty-five stable adult patients with schizophrenia on regular antipsychotic medication completed ≥ 32 BFP training sessions over 8-10 weeks. Training effects on cognitive performance and functional capacity outcome measures were measured using CogState® schizophrenia battery, UCSD Performance based Skills Assessment (UPSA-2) and Cognitive Assessment Interview (CAI). BFP training showed a large and significant treatment effect on a training exercise task (auditory processing speed), however this effect did not generalize to improved performance on independent CogState® assessment. There were no significant effects on UPSA-2 or CAI scores. Our study demonstrated the feasibility of implementing BFP training in a multi-site study. However, BFP training did not show significant treatment effects on cognitive performance or functional capacity outcome measures despite showing large and significant effects on a training exercise.

An fMRI study of prefrontal dysfunction and symptomatic recovery in schizophrenia

OBJECTIVE

Prefrontal cortical dysfunction has been implicated in the pathophysiology of schizophrenia but it is unclear to what extent these are related to changes in symptomatology as well as task demand.

METHOD

We examined the neural correlates of symptom change and task demand during a longitudinal functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) study using a verbal fluency task with differential task demands in patients with schizophrenia and matched healthy control subjects. The fMRI data were acquired using clustered acquisition technique, enabling ongoing monitoring of behavioural responses, in the patient group on two occasions separated by 6-8 weeks, and the control group at baseline.

RESULTS

Positive psychotic symptoms were significantly reduced over the 6-8-week duration of the study. This change was associated with increased activation within the left middle frontal gyrus and decreased activation of the left precuneus. An interaction between symptom change and task demand was evident in the activation of the left middle frontal gyrus. The decrease in positive symptoms was associated with normalisation of activation in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and a decrease in parietal activation during the verbal fluency task.

CONCLUSION

The data supports the role of dysfunctional prefronto-parietal relationships in the genesis of positive psychotic symptoms.

Subjective Cognitive Impairment: Functional MRI During Divided Attention and Measurement of Amyloid Load Using 11C-PIB PET

Background:

Evidence suggests that healthy older adults with subjective memory complaints are at increased risk of dementia. Subjective Cognitive Impairment (SCI) may precede Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) in the clinical continuum of Alzheimer's disease (AD). Attentional deficits may be present early in AD, and associated functional changes have been reported in both MCI and AD. In the present study, activation during divided attention in SCI subjects was investigated using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). Additionally, amyloid uptake was investigated using 11C-PIB with positron emission tomography (PET).

Methods:

Brain activation in 11 SCI subjects and 10 controls was compared during a divided attention task using fMRI. Additionally, five SCI subjects and 14 cognitively normal healthy controls underwent 11C-PIB PET scanning. Criteria for diagnosis of SCI were:1.

Results:

There were no differences in performance between SCI and control groups in terms of cognitive or behavioural measures. However, SCIs had increased activation in left medial temporal lobe, and bilateral thalamus, posterior cingulate and caudate. One SCI subject and one control subject had a pattern of 11C-PIB uptake similar to that seen in AD.

Conclusions:

The activation changes identified in SCI may relate to compensatory increased activation in the face of early AD pathology. Larger, longitudinal studies are needed to determine the extent and significance of PIB uptake in SCI.

Three years survival in patients with a clinical diagnosis of dementia with Lewy bodies

The majority of information available on the prognosis of dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) is based on retrospective data from autopsy series, which are subject to selection bias due to the specific reasons patients are referred for post-mortem studies. The earlier studies comparing DLB patients with patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) suggest that the mean duration of illness is shorter in DLB patients than in patients with AD. However, more recent studies have not observed significant differences between DLB and AD in age of onset, age at death or duration of illness. We report a 3 year follow-up of a cohort of 114 consecutive patients with dementia, referred to an old age psychiatric service and diagnosed using ICD 10 criteria and the McKeith and Byrne DLB criteria. The case notes of all patients were reviewed to determine the date of onset of symptoms and the date of first presentation to the psychiatric services. Information about outcome was gathered from case notes, hospital files and general practitioner (GP) records. Of the original sample of 114 patients, 106 could be traced. Sixty-four had died and 42 were still alive at the time of the follow-up. Thirty-two patients had originally been assigned the diagnosis of DLB, 43 the diagnosis of AD, 31 vascular dementia and other diagnoses. There were no differences between the AD and DLB group in age at onset, age at death or survival. We have not found any evidence that the prognosis of clinically diagnosed DLB patients is worse than that of patients with a clinical diagnosis of AD.

Screening for alcohol misuse in older people

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate whether the CAGE, MAST-G or an abnormally high MCV are effective screening instruments for alcohol misuse and if not to devise a new instrument.

DESIGN

Questionnaire survey of randomly selected patients.

SETTING

Acute admission wards of two district general hospitals.

PERIOD

9 months.

SUBJECTS

Randomly selected patients, aged 65 and over, admitted as emergencies.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Excessive alcohol intake, alcohol dependence.

RESULTS

The sensitivities of the CAGE, MAST-G and an abnormally high MCV for excess alcohol intake and alcohol abuse are low, ranging from 0.13 to 0.54.

CONCLUSION

The results confirm previous UK studies which indicate that the CAGE and an abnormally high MCV are poor screening instruments for alcohol misuse in older patients and also indicate that the MAST-G is an insensitive screening instrument. A new two-step instrument with five questions in total was generated. This requires further validation.

Neuropsychological performance in Lewy body dementia and Alzheimer's disease

BACKGROUND

Lewy body dementia (LBD) is emerging as a common cause of degenerative dementia. However, LBD cannot yet be diagnosed with certainty in life. There is some preliminary evidence that the pattern of cognitive impairment in LBD is different from that in Alzheimer's disease (AD). We set out to compare the performance on different subtests of the Cambridge Cognitive Examination (CAMCOG) of LBD patients and AD patients who were similar in overall degree of cognitive impairment.

METHODS

All patients were recruited from a memory clinic LBD (n = 17) was diagnosed according to the McKeith clinical criteria. AD (n = 17) was diagnosed according to NINCDS-ADRDA criteria. The performances of LBD and AD patients on the neuropsychological subscales of the CAMCOG were compared by applying Hotelling's multivariate test of significance and subsequent univariate F tests.

RESULTS

There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups on Mini-Mental State Examination and global CAMCOG rating. Hotelling's test with LBD and AD as the between-group factor and the neuropsychological subtests from CAMCOG as dependent variables revealed a statistically significant group effect (P < 0.05). Univariate F tests showed that recall (P < 0.02) and praxis (P < 0.003) significantly contributed to this effect.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that there may be different neuropsychological profiles in the two conditions, with LBD subjects being better on recall but worse on praxis than those with AD.

Closure of an asylum: the Friern study of older people

This article reports a naturalistic study following the closure of Friern Hospital and the movement of elderly long-stay patients, who in the main suffered from severe dementia, to psychiatric nursing homes and hospital beds. It describes changes in the environments and in the patients' cognition, behaviour and use of medical services. The results suggest that psychiatric nursing homes seem able to care for the majority if patients with severe dementia. Future studies should consider whether long-stay hospital beds may, however, be necessary for those with both psychiatric and physical health needs, where increased contact with health service personnel is essential. Prospective examination of the reasons for breakdown of placements in nursing homes and the differences between those placed in various settings may help future planning of services. Relatives' opinions of the long-stay settings also require study.

Management of depression in the elderly by general practitioners: I. Use of antidepressants

Depression is a common problem in the elderly but studies have suggested that it is often inadequately treated by general practitioners (GPs). This study aims to investigate how GPs manage depression in the elderly. A national questionnaire study on the management of depression in the elderly was carried out. Case vignettes were used to investigate how GPs manage depression and what influenced their decision making process. Each case vignette had a factor complicating the use of the older tricyclics. The questionnaire was completed by 407 out of 667 GPs (61%). Many GPs chose the newer antidepressants but a substantial proportion preferred the older tricyclics. Many GPs selected subtherapeutic doses, particularly of the older tricyclics. Few GPs said they maintained patients on antidepressants for more than 3 months after recovery and only 1 in 12 continued antidepressants for over 6 months. If these results reflect GPs practice there is a danger that many patients will be inadequately treated and also at risk of relapse because of their antidepressants being stopped too soon after recovery.

Annett's theory that individuals heterozygous for the right shift gene are intellectually advantaged: theoretical and empirical problems

Annett & Manning (1989; 1990a,b) have proposed that left-handedness is maintained by a balanced polymorphism, whereby the rs+/-heterozygote manifests increased intellectual ability compared with the rs-/- and rs+/+ homozygotes. In this paper we demonstrate that Annett's method of dividing subjects into putative genotypes does not allow the rs+/- genotype to be compared with the rs-/- genotype within handedness groups. Our alternative method does allow heterozygous right-handers to be compared both with rs+/+ and rs-/- homozygotes. Using this method in undergraduates we find no evidence that supposed heterozygotes are relatively more intellectually able than homozygotes on tests of verbal IQ, spatial IQ, diagrammatic IQ or vocabulary. Theoretical analysis of the balanced polymorphism hypothesis reveals additional limitations. Although estimation of the size of the heterozygote advantage suggests that it must be very large (21 or 45 IQ points) to explain the effects found by Annett & Manning, it nevertheless must be very small (3.4 IQ points) to be compatible with the known differences between right- and left-handers in social class and intelligence. Moreover power analysis shows that the latter effect size is too small for Annett & Manning to have found effects in their studies. Additional power analyses show that studies looking for effects in groups of high intellectual ability, such as university students, are incapable of finding significant results, despite Annett claiming such effects. If the Annett & Manning paradigm does demonstrate differences in intellectual ability related to skill asymmetry then those differences are unlikely to result from a balanced polymorphism, but instead probably reflect motivational or other differences between right-handers of high and low degrees of laterality.