Cost-Utility Analysis of Total Ankle Replacement Compared with Ankle Arthrodesis for Patients Aged 50-85 Years with End-Stage Ankle Osteoarthritis: The TARVA Study

BACKGROUND

Patients with end-stage ankle osteoarthritis suffer from reduced mobility and quality of life and the main surgical treatments are total ankle replacement (TAR) and ankle fusion (AF).

OBJECTIVES

Our aim was to calculate the mean incremental cost per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY) of TAR compared with AF in patients with end-stage ankle osteoarthritis, over 52 weeks and over the patients' lifetime.

METHOD

We conducted a cost-utility analysis of 282 participants from 17 UK centres recruited to a randomised controlled trial (TARVA). QALYs were calculated using index values from EQ-5D-5L. Resource use information was collected from case report forms and self-completed questionnaires. Primary analysis was within-trial analysis from the National Health Service (NHS) and Personal Social Services (PSS) perspective, while secondary analyses were within-trial analysis from wider perspective and long-term economic modelling. Adjustments were made for baseline resource use and index values.

RESULTS

Total cost at 52 weeks was higher in the TAR group compared with the AF group, from the NHS and PSS perspective (mean adjusted difference £2539, 95% confidence interval [CI] £1142, £3897). The difference became very small from the wider perspective (£155, 95% CI -  £1947, £2331). There was no significant difference between TAR and AF in terms of QALYs (mean adjusted difference 0.02, 95% CI -  0.015, 0.05) at 52 weeks post-operation. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was £131,999 per QALY gained 52 weeks post-operation. Long-term economic modelling resulted in an ICER of £4200 per QALY gained, and there is a 69% probability of TAR being cost effective at a cost-effectiveness threshold of £20,000 per QALY gained.

CONCLUSION

TAR does not appear to be cost effective over AF 52 weeks post-operation. A decision model suggests that TAR can be cost effective over the patients' lifetime but there is a need for longer-term prospectively collected data. Clinical trial registration ISRCTN60672307 and ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02128555.

Radiological outcomes following open versus percutaneous fixation versus arthroscopically assisted percutaneous fixation of calcaneal fractures: a ten-year retrospective observational study

BACKGROUND

Calcaneal fractures are often major injuries associated with considerable morbidity. The optimal surgical management of displaced calcaneal fractures remains contentious with open, percutaneous and arthroscopically assisted percutaneous approaches all offering potential benefits for patients. The aim of this study was to assess which of these three separate surgical approaches to the management of displaced calcaneal fractures provides the best radiographic deformity correction.

METHODS

This is a retrospective observational study of all calcaneal fractures undergoing operative fixation at a single major trauma centre in the UK. The primary outcome was pre- and post-operative assessment of the deformity correction using radiographic parameters (angle of Gissane and Bohler's angle). Secondary outcomes included fracture configuration, complications and re-operation rate.

RESULTS

Between 01/01/2009 and 31/12/2019, 152 calcaneal fractures in 134 patients underwent operative management via either an open or percutaneous approach. One-way ANOVA testing of the pre- and post-operative radiographic parameters demonstrated that an open approach offered superior post-operative correction of Bohler's angle when compared to percutaneous alone (p < 0.05); however, there was no difference in post-operative angle of Gissane (p > 0.05). The mean follow-up for complication and re-operation data was 3.5 years (range 0.1-12.4). Overall complication rate following all surgical fixation was 7.2% with a further 32.2% requiring further long-term surgical intervention for subtalar arthritis or removal of metalwork.

CONCLUSION

Arthroscopically assisted percutaneous fixation does not offer superior radiographic deformity correction compared to percutaneous technique alone. Open fixation yielded improved correction of Bohler's angle when compared to percutaneous alone; however, there was no difference in post-operative angle of Gissane.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Two to Five-Year Outcomes of Total Ankle Arthroplasty with the Infinity Fixed-Bearing Implant: A Concise Follow-up of a Previous Report

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic Level II. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Total Ankle Replacement Versus Arthrodesis for End-Stage Ankle Osteoarthritis: A Randomized Controlled Trial

BACKGROUND

End-stage ankle osteoarthritis causes severe pain and disability. There are no randomized trials comparing the 2 main surgical treatments: total ankle replacement (TAR) and ankle fusion (AF).

OBJECTIVE

To determine which treatment is superior in terms of clinical scores and adverse events.

DESIGN

A multicenter, parallel-group, open-label randomized trial. (ISRCTN registry number: 60672307).

SETTING

17 National Health Service trusts across the United Kingdom.

PATIENTS

Patients with end-stage ankle osteoarthritis, aged 50 to 85 years, and suitable for either procedure.

INTERVENTION

Patients were randomly assigned to TAR or AF surgical treatment.

MEASUREMENTS

The primary outcome was change in Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire walking/standing (MOXFQ-W/S) domain scores between baseline and 52 weeks after surgery. No blinding was possible.

RESULTS

Between 6 March 2015 and 10 January 2019, a total of 303 patients were randomly assigned; mean age was 68 years, and 71% were men. Twenty-one patients withdrew before surgery, and 281 clinical scores were analyzed. At 52 weeks, the mean MOXFQ-W/S scores improved for both groups. The adjusted difference in the change in MOXFQ-W/S scores from baseline was -5.6 (95% CI, -12.5 to 1.4), showing that TAR improved more than AF, but the difference was not considered clinically or statistically significant. The number of adverse events was similar between groups (109 vs. 104), but there were more wound healing issues in the TAR group and more thromboembolic events and nonunion in the AF group. The symptomatic nonunion rate for AF was 7%. A post hoc analysis suggested superiority of fixed-bearing TAR over AF (-11.1 [CI, -19.3 to -2.9]).

LIMITATION

Only 52-week data; pragmatic design creates heterogeneity of implants and surgical techniques.

CONCLUSION

Both TAR and AF improve MOXFQ-W/S and had similar clinical scores and number of harms. Total ankle replacement had greater wound healing complications and nerve injuries, whereas AF had greater thromboembolism and nonunion, with a symptomatic nonunion rate of 7%.

PRIMARY FUNDING SOURCE

National Institute for Health and Care Research Heath Technology Assessment Programme.

2022 Roger A. Mann Award Winner: Total Ankle Replacement vs Arthrodesis (TARVA) Randomized Controlled Trial: 2 Year Results

Category:

Ankle Arthritis; Ankle; Hindfoot; Other

Introduction/Purpose:

End-stage ankle osteoarthritis (EOA) causes severe pain and chronic disability. Once non operative measures have been exhausted the two main surgical treatments include total ankle replacement (TAR) and ankle fusion (AF). Systematic reviews have confirmed that both procedures are effective but there has never been a robust randomised multicentre level I study comparing the two treatments. Our objective was to investigate and compare the clinical and cost effectiveness of TAR against AF in the treatment of end-stage ankle osteoarthritis in patients aged 50-85 years.

Methods:

TARVA is a multi-centre, parallel-group, open label randomised trial. Patients with EOA, aged 50-85, suitable for either procedure were recruited at 17 UK hospitals. Randomisation was carried out using a secure on-line service and was stratified by surgeon and the presence or absence of adjacent joint OA (based on an independently reviewed preoperative MRI scan). Participants were randomised 1:1 to either TAR or ankle arthrodesis. The primary outcome was the change in the Manchester Oxford Foot & Ankle Questionnaire (MOXFQ) walking/standing domain scores between pre-operation and 52 weeks post- operation. Secondary outcomes measures included FAAM; FAAM (ADL); and Sport subscale scores. Quality of life was measured using the EQ-5D-5L. Total range of tibia to floor motion was measured using a validated method. Health economic analysis used mean incremental cost per quality-adjusted life years (QALY) gained. Analysis was by intention to treat. The trial registration is ISRCTN60672307.

Results:

Of 933 eligible patients 303 were randomised. 282 underwent surgery. Mean age 68 (71% male). Aetiology was post- trauma in 55.3%, and inflammatory in 7.1%. Groups were well balanced at baseline on all parameters. 54% TARs were fixed bearing. 61% of fusions were performed arthroscopically. At 2 years the adjusted mean difference in the change in MOXFQ W/S between TAR & AF was -4.4(95% CI -11.38 to 2.68, p=0∙23). Post hoc analysis of the commonest implant type (fixed bearing TAR) did show a statistically significant improvement over AF (p=0∙04, -8.9, 95% CI -17.2 to -0.6). Secondary outcomes, EQ5D-VAS and FAAM were significant. Complications included wound healing issues (13.8% vs 5.5%); nerve injuries (4.3% vs 0.7%). 11.8% of AF patients had plain radiographic evidence of non-union but only 6.9% had symptoms. Reoperation rate was 7.2% for TAR vs 5.2% for AF; and revision rate was 0.7% for TAR vs 2.8% for AF.

Conclusion:

Patients improved in all outcomes in both arms. We did not show a significant difference in our primary outcome measure between TAR and AF overall(p=0.23), but did show significance when fixed bearing TAR alone was compared against AF(p=0.04). Secondary outcomes did show significance. Adjacent joint arthritis increases the size of effect noted between arms. There were more wound healing issues and nerve injuries in TAR group. The symptomatic non-union rate for AF is 6.9%. TAR is likely to be cost-effective compared to AF at the NICE cost-effectiveness threshold of £20,000 per Quality Adjusted Life Year gained over the patients' lifetime.

The symptomatic adult flatfoot: Is there a relationship between severity and degree of pre-existing arthritis in the foot and ankle?

BACKGROUND

The acquired adult flatfoot deformity (AFFD) is a potentially debilitating foot condition with a prevalence thought to be between 3 %-10 %. To the authors' best knowledge, no association has been described between severity of AFFD and degree of pre-existing ankle or foot arthritis. The degree and pattern of preexisting ipsilateral arthritis of the foot and ankle was investigated in those with symptomatic AFFD presenting to hospital.

METHODS

Retrospective observational study between May 2015 and May 2018, of patients who presented to our tertiary clinic with symptomatic AFFD. Radiographs of one hundred and forty-eight (n=148) patients were reviewed, excluding those with charcot arthropathy, previous trauma or coalition. The primary outcome measure was severity of OA in the ankle, subtalar, talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints. Secondary outcome was severity of radiographic planovalgus deformity. The independant variables used were age and severity of planovalgus deformity as measured by the Meary angle, calcaneal pitch and medial cuneiform-fifth metatarsal height. A linear regression model was carried out on the outcomes.

RESULTS

Median age was 60.0 years (IQR 22). There were 56 males to 92 females, with 75 left sided deformities observed and 73 right sided. With increasing severity of planovalgus measurements, there was no significant association observed in severity of arthritis in the ankle joint (p = 0.766), subtalar joint (p = 0.090), talonavicular joint (p = 0.256) and calcaneocuboid joint (p = 0.091). With increasing age, there was significance observed in degree of ankle arthritis, subtalar, talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints (p = 0.001). There was no significant correlation observed with age for the angular break of Meary's line (p = 0.73), calcaneal pitch (0.262) and medial cuneiform-fifth metatarsal height (p = 0.937).

CONCLUSION

This observational study shows no significant association between severity of radiographic planovalgus deformity and pre-existing arthritis of the ankle, hindfoot and midtarsal joints.

13. Idiopathic inflammatory myopathy, everything it should not be: asymmetrical, normal CK, high fever

Introduction

Myositis can be infective, metabolic or immune-mediated. Idiopathic inflammatory myopathy, which is immune-mediated, tends to be subacute, with symmetrical symptoms, overlap clinical features and positive autoimmune serology. We present a case of acute onset lower limb seronegative inflammatory myopathy with a normal creatinine kinase (CK), a marked acute phase response that responded promptly to immunomodulatory therapy.

Case description

A 68-year-old man presented with a 2-week history of lower limb pain with subjective weakness, on a background of well-controlled type 2 diabetes mellitus and hypertension. He was admitted with worsening symptoms of marked left thigh pain, night sweats, and fevers.

On admission, he had swinging pyrexia (above >39 °C) while remaining haemodynamically stable. He had focal tenderness over the left anterolateral thigh, with a good range of movement, normal power and no signs of focal collection or cellulitis. There were no extra-muscular features to suggest systemic infection or overlap connective tissue disease.

Bloods showed C-reactive protein (CRP) 225, normal CK 212 and negative blood cultures. X-rays knee, femur and pelvis were normal. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) on T2, fat-suppressed STIR sequences demonstrated increased signal/oedema both thighs throughout the anterior muscle compartment and along the fascial plane, notably most severe in the left vastus lateralis. He was treated empirically for infective myositis. Despite 14 days of broad-spectrum antibiotics, he remained febrile with persistently elevated CRP. There was no focal collection, lymphadenopathy or occult malignancy on CT abdomen and pelvis. Trans-oesophageal echocardiogram showed no evidence of infective endocarditis but revealed incidental moderate aortic stenosis.

The patient described persistent now bilateral thigh pain with continued normal CK and high CRP. Full autoimmune screen (ANA, ANCA, ACE and complement studies) was negative. Despite negative nuclear and cytoplasmic HEp-2 immunofluorence, extended myositis immunoblot was negative. Muscle biopsy from the left vastus lateralis demonstrated inflammation within the perimysium and perivasculature. In view of biopsy findings and no response to anti-microbial therapy, prednisolone (0.5mg/kg) with significant clinical response (resolution of fever and pain) with concurrent normalisation in CRP. The patient remains in remission following steroid reduction with no additional immunomodulatory therapy required.

Discussion

We report a case of idiopathic inflammatory myopathy presenting with predominantly asymmetrical symptoms, normal CK, marked inflammatory response and negative myositis autoantibodies. Diagnosis was confirmed on MRI and muscle biopsy. The normal CK can be explained by the histology demonstrating inflammation in perivascular regions and around muscle fibres, rather than inflammation or necrosis in the muscle fascicles and fibres themselves. Idiopathic inflammatory myopathy including sporadic inclusion-body myositis, dermatomyositis, overlap CTD myositis and polymyositis/necrotising myopathy subsets are distinguishable based on clinical features, autoantibodies, MRI and biopsy features. The table below summarises the atypical aspects of this case. Differential diagnoses for this case include atypical infection, sarcoid myopathy and amyloid myonecrosis secondary to diabetes.

Complications after revision surgery of malreduced ankle fractures

Ankle fractures are common orthopedic injuries requiring reduction and cast immobilization or fixation. Fractures fixed in a malreduced (misaligned) position can require revision surgery. However, because this has been a relatively rare occurrence, little is known about the complications that can occur after such surgery. We reviewed all adult closed ankle fractures that underwent revision surgery for technical failure in a regional trauma hospital from January 2007 to January 2010. Those with open fractures and those who required external fixation at any point in their treatment were excluded. Nine patients underwent revision surgery during the study period. Of these 9 patients, 3 (33%) developed a deep infection, all with positive microbiology cultures for methicillin-sensitive Staphylococcus aureus. Each of these patients underwent removal of the metalwork and wound debridement, followed by plastic surgery free flap coverage. In addition to the 3 infection cases, those with noninfected complications included 1 patient (11%) with chronic regional pain syndrome, 1 (11%) with failure of plate fixation, and 1 (11%) with persistent pain requiring arthroscopy and debridement. The overall incidence of complications was 66.67% in this group of 9 patients who had undergone revision surgery for the treatment of a malreduced malleolar ankle fracture. Although our observational study involved a small subset of patients who had undergone surgical repair for ankle fracture, we suggest that if revision surgery will be undertaken, the high incidence of infection and the potential need for plastic surgery should be highlighted during the consent process before the original, open reduction internal fixation procedure.

The role of ankle arthroscopy in acute ankle injuries of the athlete

This article discusses the role of ankle arthroscopy in the acute management of ankle trauma in athletes. The rate of intra-articular pathology associated with ankle trauma is high and arthroscopic treatment often has an important role to play. Its major role is in the assessment and treatment of joint surface damage, syndesmotic instability, and intra-articular fractures.

Associations between membership of farm assurance and organic certification schemes and compliance with animal welfare legislation

Animal health (AH) defines the outcome of their inspections of livestock holdings as full compliance with the legislation and welfare code (A), compliance with the legislation but not the code (B), non-compliance with legislation but no pain, distress or suffering obvious in the animals (C) or evidence of unnecessary pain or unnecessary distress (D). The aim of the present study was to investigate whether membership of farm assurance or organic certification schemes was associated with compliance with animal welfare legislation as inspected by AH. Participating schemes provided details of their members, past and present, and these records were matched against inspection data from AH. Multivariable multilevel logistic binomial models were built to investigate the association between compliance with legislation and membership of a farm assurance/organic scheme. The percentage of inspections coded A, B, C or D was 37.1, 35.6, 20.2 and 7.1 per cent, respectively. Once adjusted for year, country, enterprise, herd size and reason for inspection, there was a pattern of significantly reduced risk of codes C and D compared with A and B, in certified enterprises compared with the enterprises that were not known to be certified in all species.

Tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis with a curved, interlocking, intramedullary nail

BACKGROUND

Tibiotalocalcaneal fusion with a straight rod has a risk of damaging the lateral plantar neurovascular structures and may interfere with maintaining normal heel valgus position.We report the results of a prospective study of tibiotalocalcaneal (TTC) arthrodesis with a short, anatomically curved interlocking, intramedullary nail.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Forty-five arthrodesis in 42 patients, performed between Jan 2003 and Oct 2008, were prospectively followed. The mean followup was 48 (range, 10 to 74) months. The main indications for the procedure were failed ankle arthrodesis with progressive subtalar arthritis, failed ankle arthroplasty and complex hindfoot deformity. The outcome was measured by a combination of pre and postoperative clinical examination, AOFAS hindfoot scores, SF-12 scores and radiological assessment.

RESULTS

Union rate was 89% (40/45). Eighty-two percent (37/45) reported improvement in pain and 73% (33/45) had improved foot function. Satisfactory hindfoot alignment was achieved in 84% (38/45). Postoperatively there was a mean improvement in the AOFAS score of 37. Complications included a below knee amputation for persistent deep infection, five nonunions, and three delayed unions. Four nails, six proximal and six distal locking screws were removed for various causes. Other complications included two perioperative fractures, four superficial wound infections and one case of lateral plantar nerve irritation.

CONCLUSION

With a short, anatomically curved intramedullary nail, we had a high rate of tibiotalocalcaneal fusion with minimal plantar neurovascular complications. We believe a short, curved intramedullary nail, with its more lateral entry point, helped maintain hindfoot alignment.

Tibiotalocalcaneal (hindfoot) arthrodesis by retrograde intramedullary nailing using a curved locking nail. The results of 52 procedures

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to report the results of 52 combined subtalar and ankle arthrodesis using an intramedullary nail.

METHODS

Retrospective review identified 49 patients who had 52 combined ankle and subtalar arthrodeses with an ACE retrograde locked intramedullary humeral nail (DePuy-Ace), Warsaw, IN). Most procedures included bone grafts from the fibula, proximal tibia, or iliac crest or femoral head allograft. Intraoperative complications included one fractured tibia and one fractured medial malleolus. The procedure was done mainly for the treatment of combined ankle and subtalar arthritis (31) or complex hindfoot deformities (12). Outcome was assessed by a combination of chart review, clinical examination, and telephone questionnaire. Followup averaged 34 (8 to 73) months.

RESULTS

At followup 82% of patients were satisfied with the results of surgery, 82% reported improvements in pain levels, and 67% reported improved foot function. The average postoperative American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) hindfoot score was 63. Postoperative complications included deep infection, amputation, stress fracture, nonunion, and prominent hardware.

CONCLUSION

Hindfoot arthrodesis with intramedullary nailing is an effective technique for treating complex foot deformities and often is the only alternative to amputation. Patient satisfaction is high, but the procedure is demanding and complications are frequent.

Osteochondral lesions of the talus: a revised classification

Osteochondral lesions of the talus present a numerically small but therapeutically significant problem to the foot surgeon. The diagnosis and investigation of such lesions have been greatly enhanced by modern high resolution magnetic resonance imaging capabilities, which have provided far greater detail of the pathological anatomy. We have reviewed our experience in this area and suggest a revised classification for osteochondral lesions appropriate to the detail available on magnetic resonance imaging scans. The cause of osteochondral lesions is also discussed.