National standard treatment guidelines: their impact on medicine use indicators in a resource-limited setting

Objectives

Standard treatment guidelines improve patient care outcomes. Few studies assess the impact of standard treatment guidelines on population-level medicine use indicators in resource limited settings in sub-Saharan Africa, where the burden of disease is greatest. The objective of this study was to determine the immediate and long-term impact of the national standard treatment guidelines on medicine use indicators at the population-level in Namibia.

Methods

An interrupted time-series modeling of the impact of national standard treatment guidelines implemented in Namibia in 2011, on population-level medicine use indicators. Antibiotic, generic and polypharmacy prescribing indicators were abstracted from the national Pharmaceutical Information System, over an eight-year period, 2007– 2015. This generated 15-quarterly time points. The impact was estimated by changes in trends of the indicators, immediately and after the intervention using R-software. The immediate impact was reflected by level change while long term impact was determined by trends/quarterly change after standard treatment guideline implementation.

Key findings

Data points from 522 Pharmaceutical Information System reports from 38 health facilities were included. The eight-year period estimates were, 2.9 ± 0.1 medicines prescribed per outpatient, 48.1 ± 2.5% of prescriptions had an antibiotic and 74.0 ± 4.2% of medicines were prescribed by generic name. Of the 13 regions, 61.3% and 53.8% had a decline in the average medicines per prescription and prescriptions with antibiotics respectively, as well as 53.8% of the regions had an increase in prescribing of generic medicines immediately after implementation of the standard treatment guidelines. Thereafter, quarterly trends in the three indicators did not significantly improve after the intervention at national and in all regions, except for generic prescribing in Oshikoto region, 4.5% (95% CI: 2.6 – 6.3%, P < 0.001).

Conclusion

Whilst national standard treatment guidelines immediately improved medicine use indicators, it is discouraging that the improvement over time was marginal across regions and was not sustained at the national level. Robust point of care interventions is needed for sustained and effective implementation of standard treatment guidelines.

Tenofovir disoproxil fumarate associated nephrotoxicity: a retrospective cohort study at two referral hospitals in Namibia

INTRODUCTION

The incidence and risk factors of tenofovir disoproxil fumarate (TDF)-related renal impairment (RI) in Namibia are unknown where TDF-containing ART regimens are used as the first line for HIV.

METHODOLOGY

A retrospective cohort study among HIV-infected patients at two intermediate hospitals. A decline in estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) was significant if it was ≥25% and included a change to a lower eGFR stage. New-onset RI was defined as an eGFR <50 mL/min/1.73m² .

RESULTS

10 387 patients were included: 11.4% (n = 1182) experienced the decline in eGFR. Of these, 0.6% (n = 62) migrated to eGFR stages IV and V. The incidence was 4.5 (95% CI: 4.3-4.8) per 100 patient years. RI developed in 400 patients for an incidence rate of 2.4 (95% CI: 2.2-2.6) cases per 100 patient years. Risk factors with effect sizes >2.0, for decline-in-eGFR were baseline eGFR >60 (aHR = 15.6); hyperfiltration (aHR = 5.0); and pregnancy (aHR = 2.4); while for RI, they were hyperfiltration (aHR = 4.1) and pregnancy (aHR = 29).

CONCLUSION

The incidence of decline-in-eGFR was higher than in other sub-SSA countries, but not RI. A high baseline eGFR had the greatest risk for the decline, and hyperfiltration for the RI.

Evidence-Responsive Health Training to HIV/TB Risks in Namibia

Training health-care students in settings with high-prevalence HIV and tuberculosis (TB) presents a challenge to reduce the risk of infection during their clinical training while maintaining quality education. We sought to gauge the risk of exposure to HIV and TB and identify associated variables through two cross-sectional surveys of health students at the University of Namibia. In the HIV exposure survey, overall almost one-quarter of students (N = 367) reported exposure to HIV-most often needle-stick injury-with a much higher rate reported in senior years (73% in year 6). One in 10 students responding to the TB survey were found to have been exposed to TB (N = 290). Regression analyses suggested that time-related factors were a common predictor of risk of both HIV and TB in this setting. We consider that the overall exposure rate to HIV and TB was high, suggesting that training could be improved to reduce the risks of exposure.

A pragmatic approach to introducing mixed methods research training for pharmacy students in Namibia

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Pharmacy and medical training were introduced for the first time in Namibia in 2011 and 2010 respectively. All students must complete a research project as part of their training, which is supported by various courses in the respective curricula including research methods. Following a revision of the medical curriculum, there was an opportunity to review the way research methods was taught for both degrees, piloting in pharmacy then expanding to other disciplines. An educational activity that was part of the research methods course for training pharmacy students in Namibia is described.

EDUCATIONAL ACTIVITY AND SETTING

The activity described related to a new approach in the running of the research methods course for pharmacy students and included, in a portfolio-based approach, a group project. Students were tasked to collect qualitative data from medical student colleagues that they then needed to codify and ultimately articulate into a survey questionnaire. The questionnaire was subsequently sent out to collect responses on medicines-related items that could be analyzed quantitatively in subsequent teaching sessions. Supportive lectures, tutorials and portfolio assignments were provided during the project. Data were collected the following year to create a more substantive dataset and a screencast video made to benefit future students in the course.

FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION

Through the course of this activity students developed a questionnaire survey tool based on qualitative responses to brief interviews with medical students and emergent themes based on qualitative analyses. A dataset was created that allowed demonstration of quantitative analyses and extraction of sub-scales from the questionnaire. Further educational resources were developed to ensure sustainability of this educational resource and retention in the taught curriculum.

SUMMARY

The current article discusses the development, implementation and evaluation of this research methods course component. The application of data collected as part of the activity and its relevance to the educational activity is examined as well as lessons learned for the future running of the project and further evaluation.

Effect of TDF-containing regimens on creatinine clearance in HIV patients in Namibia with a baseline CrCl <60ml/min; findings and implications

Background and aims: The advent of antiretroviral therapy (ART) and early diagnosis of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) has resulted in an appreciable reduction in morbidity and mortality among people infected with HIV. However, tenofovir disoproxil fumarate (TDF)-containing ART regimens are associated with a reduction in creatinine clearance (CrCl). No evaluation has been conducted in Namibia to date on the relationship between TDF-containing ART and CrCl among patients with moderate to severe reductions in CrCl to guide future practice. We aimed to address this.Methodology: Retrospective longitudinal study between January 2008 to December 2016 evaluating CrCl in patients with a baseline CrCl <60ml/min who were receiving TDF-containing ART in a leading hospital in Namibia. We identified patients who had experienced an improvement in CrCl and compared their characteristics with those whose CrCl did not improve. We assessed factors for an association with improvement in CrCl using binary logistic regression.Results: 389 patients were included, the majority were female (n = 294). Female vs. male assessments showed no difference in age (p = 0.340), weight (p = 0.920), number who experienced an improvement (105 vs 39, p = 0.349), or absence of improvement (189 vs. 56, p = 0.349). The improvement group (male and female) had a lower baseline CrCl (45.9 vs. 55.0, p < 0.001). The follow-up CrCl for the improvement and no improvement groups were 72.6 and 55.9 respectively. Multivariate analysis showed that the odds of improvement were: 0.905 (0.871-0.940, p < 0.001) for each unit rise in the baseline CrCl, and 0.904(0.880-0.923) for each year of follow-up.Conclusion: More improvement than decline in CrCl was observed. Improvement occurred more in patients with lower baseline CrCl, and occurred in the early period of ART with reduced odds of experiencing this with time. Our findings indicate that TDF may be used in patients with a low baseline CrCl.

Competency (and Beyond): Think Patient. Collaborate. Develop. Evaluate. Improve. Repeat

The global workforce needs to be competent, flexible, adaptable, sustainable, and patient-focused. A competency approach towards education, development, and professional practice strengthens services and increases better health outcomes. This paper will provide a global perspective on competency approaches from different health care professions. It will focus on two case reports, describing the use of competency methodologies at an undergraduate and postgraduate level, as well as supporting the internship and/or pre-registration training. Challenges and opportunities will be highlighted by addressing some of the key questions posed for this special edition.

Introduction of an Alcohol-Related Electronic Screening and Brief Intervention (eSBI) Program to Reduce Hazardous Alcohol Consumption in Namibia's Antiretroviral Treatment (ART) Program

Alcohol is the most widely abused substance in Namibia and is associated with poor adherence and retention in care among people on antiretroviral therapy (ART). Electronic screening and brief interventions (eSBI) are effective in reducing alcohol consumption in various contexts. We used a mixed methods approach to develop, implement, and evaluate the introduction of an eSBI in two ART clinics in Namibia. Of the 787 participants, 45% reported some alcohol use in the past 12 months and 25% reported hazardous drinking levels. Hazardous drinkers were more likely to be male, separated/widowed/divorced, have a monthly household income > $1000 NAD, and report less than excellent ART adherence. Based on qualitative feedback from participants and providers, ART patients using the eSBI for the first time found it to be a positive and beneficial experience. However, we identified several programmatic considerations that could improve the experience and yield in future implementation studies.

Health workforce planning in Namibia: assessing a pilot workforce survey of pharmacists

Background

Southern Africa lacks resources necessary to combat presenting health challenges. This crisis will likely be remedied through the in-country training of healthcare professionals, for example, in Namibia. Monitoring the workforce will be essential to inform planning in health services and training. A national pilot workforce survey in Namibia using a multi-modal sampling approach aimed to test methodology for describing the pharmacy workforce and quantifying preferences towards further training.

Methods

The survey tool included questions relating to socio-demographics, professional and practice aspects. A conjoint analysis approach was utilised to quantify preferences around study programme, modality of study and cost.

Key findings

Respondents (N = 135; ~20% response) represented a diverse range of individuals in various pharmacy sectors in Namibia. The majority of respondents reported female gender, private sector working, studying outside Namibia and societal group membership. Societal membership and pharmacy ownership – indicators of professional engagement – were associated with higher age; ownership was also associated with study outside Namibia and practice in community pharmacy. Regarding further study preferences, respondents placed more importance on study programme and modality over cost with the most preferred scenario being a 2-year full-time Masters programme in pharmaceutical industry/regulation by distance learning at the highest cost bracket.

Conclusions

This national survey sampled the population of pharmacists in Namibia exploring the composition of the profession and preferences towards training. Further work will validate the findings and provide ongoing monitoring of the pharmacy workforce that can be expanded to other professional groups over a larger geographical area.

Renal function of MDR-TB patients treated with kanamycin regimens or concomitantly with antiretroviral agents

SETTING

To compare renal insufficiency among multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) patients treated with kanamycin (KM) based regimens and those treated concomitantly with tenofovir disoproxil fumarate (TDF) or other antiretroviral therapy (ART) regimens in Namibia.

DESIGN

Retrospective review of the treatment records and laboratory tests of patients initiated on MDR-TB treatment (January-December 2014). The glomerular filtration rates (eGFR) estimated pre- and post-treatment were compared using the analysis of variance test. Renal insufficiency was defined as an eGFR of <60 ml/min/1.73 m2. Use of KM or TDF and association with renal insufficiency was assessed using Kaplan-Meier plots and Cox proportional hazards analysis.

RESULTS

The baseline mean eGFR for the three groups was similar (P = 0.24): 139.3 ± 25.6 ml/min for the KM group (n = 68), 131.1 ± 25.7 ml/min for the KM+TDF group (n = 44) and 134.2±34.4 ml/min for the KM+Other group (n = 23). After 8 months, the values had declined significantly to respectively 104.8 ± 37.5 ml/min (P < 0.001), 101.5 ± 38.3 ml/min (P < 0.001) and 111.5 ± 41.7 ml/min (P = 0.01). Co-treatment with KM+ART was associated with an increased risk of renal insufficiency (hazard ratio [HR] 1.8, 95%CI 0.7-4.1, P = 0.20 for KM+TDF, and HR 3.5, 95%CI 1.4-8.2, P = 0.005 for KM+Other ART).

CONCLUSION

Renal function declined at a similar rate in MDR-TB patients treated with KM-based regimens compared with patients treated concomitantly with TDF-based or other ART. The risk of renal insufficiency was greater for patients on ART.

Assessment tool for establishing local pharmaceutical manufacturing in low- and middle-income countries

OBJECTIVE

In many low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), limited availability, substandard quality and high prices of pharmaceutical products lead to lack of access to essential medicines and poor health outcomes. Manufacturing pharmaceuticals in LMICs may improve access for patients while increasing the market size for manufacturers.

METHODS

We present a tool for assessment of local manufacturing feasibility of pharmaceuticals, intended for use among key stakeholders during the business development process. The tool consists of five domains: product selection and capacity, market sizing, market entry, funding and quality assurance.

KEY FINDINGS

The tool is intended to identify barriers and facilitators for local manufacturing and provide a roadmap for decision-making across multiple stakeholders. A case study in Namibia identified key barriers and facilitators to successful manufacturing in that county.

CONCLUSIONS

Careful consideration of feasibility and potential for success may lead to improved health for the populations of LMIC as well as significant market potential for pharmaceutical manufacturers.

Adverse events and patients' perceived health-related quality of life at the end of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis treatment in Namibia

PURPOSE

The health-related quality of life (HRQoL) of patients completing multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) treatment in Namibia and whether the occurrence of adverse events influenced patients' rating of their HRQoL was evaluated.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A cross-sectional analytic survey of patients completing or who recently completed MDR-TB treatment was conducted. The patients rated their HRQoL using the simplified Short Form-™ (SF-8) questionnaire consisting of eight Likert-type questions. Three supplemental questions on the adverse events that the patients may have experienced during their MDR-TB treatment were also included. Scoring of HRQoL ratings was norm-based (mean =50, standard deviation =10) ranging from 20 (worst health) to 80 (best health), rather than the conventional 0-100 scores. We evaluated the internal consistency of the scale items using the Cronbach's alpha, performed descriptive analyses, and analyzed the association between the patients' HRQoL scores and adverse events.

RESULTS

Overall, 36 patients (20 males, 56%) aged 17-54 years (median =40 years) responded to the questionnaire. The median (range) HRQoL score for the physical component summary was 58.6 (35.3-60.5), while the median score for the mental component summary was 59.3 (26.6-61.9), indicating not-so-high self-rating of health. There was good internal consistency of the scale scores, with a Cronbach's alpha value of >0.80. In all, 32 (89%) of the 36 patients experienced at least one adverse drug event of any severity during their treatment (median events =3, range 1-6), of which none was life-threatening. The occurrence of adverse events was not related to HRQoL scores. For patients reporting zero to two events, the median (range) HRQoL score was 56.8 (44.4-56.8), while for those reporting three or more events, the median score was 55.2 (38.6-56.8); P=0.34 for difference between these scores.

CONCLUSION

Patients completing treatment for MDR-TB in Namibia tended to score moderately low on their HRQoL, using the generic SF-8 questionnaire. The occurrence of adverse events did not lead to lower HRQoL scores upon treatment completion.

Comparing amikacin and kanamycin-induced hearing loss in multidrug-resistant tuberculosis treatment under programmatic conditions in a Namibian retrospective cohort

BACKGROUND

Amikacin and kanamycin are mainly used for treating multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB), especially in developing countries where the burden of MDR-TB is highest. Their protracted use in MDR-TB treatment is known to cause dose-dependent irreversible hearing loss, requiring hearing aids, cochlear implants or rehabilitation. Therapeutic drug monitoring and regular audiological assessments may help to prevent or detect the onset of hearing loss, but these services are not always available or affordable in many developing countries. We aimed to compare the cumulative incidence of hearing loss among patients treated for MDR-TB with amikacin or kanamycin-based regimens, and to identify the most-at-risk patients, based on the real-life clinical practice experiences in Namibia.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective cohort study of patients treated with amikacin or kanamycin-based regimens in four public sector MDR-TB treatment sites in Namibia between June 2004 and March 2014. Patients were audiologically assessed as part of clinical care. The study outcome was the occurrence of any hearing loss. Data were manually extracted from patients' treatment records. We compared proportions using the Chi-square test; applied stratified analysis and logistic regression to study the risk of hearing loss and to identify the most-at-risk patients through effect-modification analysis. A P-value < 0.05 was statistically significant.

RESULTS

All 353 patients had normal baseline hearing, 46 % were HIV co-infected. Cumulative incidence of any hearing loss was 58 %, which was mostly bilateral (83 %), and mild (32 %), moderate (23 %), moderate-severe (16 %), severe (10 %), or profound (15 %). Patients using amikacin had a greater risk of developing the more severe forms of hearing loss than those using kanamycin (adjusted odds ratio (OR) = 4.0, 95 % CI: 1.5-10.8). Patients co-infected with HIV (OR = 3.4, 95 % CI: 1.1-10.6), males (OR = 4.5, 95 %1.5-13.4) and those with lower baseline body weight (40-59 kg, OR = 2.8, 95 % CI: 1.1-6.8), were most-at-risk of developing hearing loss.

CONCLUSION

Amikacin use in the long-term MDR-TB treatment led to a higher risk of occurrence of the more severe forms of hearing loss compared to kanamycin use. Males, patients with low baseline body weight and those co-infected with HIV were most-at-risk. MDR-TB treatment programmes should consider replacing amikacin with kanamycin and strengthen the routine renal, serum therapeutic drug levels and audiometric monitoring in the most-at-risk patients treated with aminoglycosides.

Reflecting on interprofessional education in the design of space and place: lessons from Namibia

Education at the University of Namibia, School of Medicine and School of Pharmacy relies on a community-centred curriculum. The aim is to nurture "7-star" doctors and pharmacists that will address the current social and health needs within the country. A sound understanding of the interplay between learning and the learning environment is said to improve interprofessional educational activities. This relationship is dependent on constrictive alignment of not only the aspects of pedagogy, but also that of educational leadership in context of the current and social health needs. In this report, we reflect on the interprofessional-learning environment that was created out of necessity within a Namibian context.

Knowledge and use of complementary and alternative medicine among British undergraduate pharmacy students

AIM

Attitudes and practice concerning complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) are currently an area of considerable importance. However, little is known about the overall importance of CAM in groups of health care professionals. Therefore, the primary objective was to analyse the knowledge about and use of CAM in an ethnically diverse student population at the London School of Pharmacy.

METHODS

A questionnaire was administered to students (264 completed questionnaires, response rate: 59.1%) and in-depth interviews were carried out with a sample of seven students.

RESULTS

Forty-three percent reported using at least one type of CAM during the last 12 months. The types of CAM used that were most frequently mentioned include aromatherapy, Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) and medicinal herbalism. TCM was reported by students of Chinese origin and by students from other ethnic backgrounds. However, Ayurvedic (Indian) medicine and medicine from Africa were only used in cultures from which the users originated. The study shows that a large number of herbal medical products were commonly reported by students of pharmacy.

CONCLUSION

The knowledge about and use of CAM is widespread among this group of future health care professionals and the students also expressed a strong interest in the topic. In-depth studies on the knowledge and use of CAM among other health care professionals and among ethnic minorities are urgently needed and may help to better manage the treatment of minor disorders as well as chronic diseases.

Beef cattle productivity under traditional and improved management in Botswana

A comparison of productivity over a 4-year period from indigenous type beef cattle under two production systems in Botswana is reported. The two systems are: the traditional system on unenclosed communal grazing (cattle post) and ranching within fenced paddocks. Calving percentages, 7-month old calf weight, calf mortality and post-weaning growth to 18 months of age under cattle post conditions were 46.4 per cent, 122.5 kg, 10.2 percent and 88.5 kg respectively. Corresponding figures for cattle on the fenced ranches were 74.0 per cent, 177.4 kg, 8.5 per cent and 105.8 kg. These results indicate overall productivity estimates of 51 and 120 kg of weaner calf per cow per year and 86 and 188 kg of 18-month old calf per cow per year for the cattle post and fenced ranch respectively.