Protease resistance of infectious prions is suppressed by removal of a single atom in the cellular prion protein

Resistance to proteolytic digestion has long been considered a defining trait of prions in tissues of organisms suffering from transmissible spongiform encephalopathies. Detection of proteinase K-resistant prion protein (PrP^Sc) still represents the diagnostic gold standard for prion diseases in humans, sheep and cattle. However, it has become increasingly apparent that the accumulation of PrP^Sc does not always accompany prion infections: high titers of prion infectivity can be reached also in the absence of protease resistant PrP^Sc. Here, we describe a structural basis for the phenomenon of protease-sensitive prion infectivity. We studied the effect on proteinase K (PK) resistance of the amino acid substitution Y169F, which removes a single oxygen atom from the β2–α2 loop of the cellular prion protein (PrP^C). When infected with RML or the 263K strain of prions, transgenic mice lacking wild-type (wt) PrP^C but expressing MoPrP^169F generated prion infectivity at levels comparable to wt mice. The newly generated MoPrP^169F prions were biologically indistinguishable from those recovered from prion-infected wt mice, and elicited similar pathologies in vivo. Surprisingly, MoPrP^169F prions showed greatly reduced PK resistance and density gradient analyses showed a significant reduction in high-density aggregates. Passage of MoPrP^169F prions into mice expressing wt MoPrP led to full recovery of protease resistance, indicating that no strain shift had taken place. We conclude that a subtle structural variation in the β2–α2 loop of PrP^C affects the sensitivity of PrP^Sc to protease but does not impact prion replication and infectivity. With these findings a specific structural feature of PrP^C can be linked to a physicochemical property of the corresponding PrP^Sc.