Phosphoproteomic analysis on ovarian follicles reveals the involvement of LSD1 phosphorylation in Chicken follicle selection

BACKGROUND

Follicle selection in chickens refers to the process of selecting one follicle from a group of small yellow follicles (SY, 6-8 mm in diameter) for development into 12-15 mm hierarchal follicles (usually F6 follicles), which is controlled by sex hormones including follicle-stimulating factor (FSH), estrogen and progesterone. Follicle selection is a critical process impacting egg production in chicken, therefore, is the focus of many studies. Phosphorylation is important for the proper function of proteins, thus, needs to be analyzed by proteomic level.

RESULT

In this study, we compared the phosphoproteomes of SY and F6 follicles in laying hens and identified 2,386 phosphoproteins and 5,940 phosphosites, of which 4,235 sites of 1,963 phosphoproteins were quantified. From SY to F6 follicles, 190 phosphorylation sites of 149 proteins changed significantly, among which the phosphorylation level of lysine demethylase 1 A (LSD1) at the conserved 54^th serine (LSD1Ser54p) was significantly upregulated in F6 follicles compared to SY follicles (p < 0.05); however, the expression of chicken LSD1 were not significantly different on both mRNA and protein levels. LSD1Ser54p is mainly located in the nucleus of both SY and F6 follicles, and was higher in F6 follicles than that of SY follicles revealed by both immunofluorescence and Western blotting. LSD1Ser54p level increased after treatment with 5 ng/mL and 10 ng/mL of FSH in the theca cells and the granulosa cells of pre-hierarchal follicles, and with 50 ng/mL in granulosa cells of hierarchal follicles. In the theca cells of hierarchal follicles, estrogen stimulated the level of LSD1Ser54p in a dosage-dependent manner, and in granulosa cells of pre-hierarchal follicles, 10 ng/mL of estrogen increased LSD1Ser54p expression. Treatment with 50 ng/mL of progesterone increased LSD1Ser54p expression in theca cells of pre-hierarchal follicles, and with 10 to 100 ng/ml enhanced LSD1Ser54p expression in the granulosa cells of hierarchal follicles.

CONCLUSION

The expression dynamics of LSD1Ser54p in follicles from SY to F6 and its regulation by sex hormones suggest that it is involved in chicken follicle selection.

Switching of follicle destiny so that the second largest follicle becomes dominant in monovulatory species

During an ovulatory follicular wave in the monovulatory species of heifers, mares, and women, the two largest follicles deviate in diameter at the end of a common follicle growth phase. The largest follicle before deviation becomes the future ovulatory follicle in most ovulatory waves. In 10-30% of the ovulatory waves, the destiny of the two follicles switches just before or at deviation so that the second-largest follicle becomes the future ovulatory follicle, and the largest follicle becomes a subordinate. In FSH-driven switching in heifers, mares, and women, the wave-stimulating FSH surge decreases to a low concentration before the largest follicle has developed the ability to utilize the low concentrations. The concentrations of FSH then increase (mares, women) or cease to decrease (heifers), and the next largest follicle acquires the capability of becoming the future ovulatory follicle. Luteolysis-driven switching has been reported in heifers but not in mares and women. The switching in heifers occurs during ovulatory wave 3 of three wave interovulatory intervals (IOI) when the wave of follicles is in the common growth phase in synchrony with the time of luteolysis. Regression of the CL during the common growth phase of ovulatory wave 3 is accompanied by decreased activity of follicles that are adjacent to the regressing CL but not when follicles and CL are separated or in opposite ovaries. The role of luteolysis in switching in heifers has been tested by treating with PGF2α when the largest follicle of wave 2 was near the end of the common growth phase. Switching in destiny of the largest follicle from the expected future dominant to a future subordinate occurred in most waves (10 of 17) when the largest follicle and regressing CL were in the same ovary and adjacent but not when separated in the same ovary or when in opposite ovaries (0 of 11). The newly selected future ovulatory follicle may develop in the opposite ovary. Thereby, frequency of the contralateral vs ipsilateral relationship between the preovulatory follicle and CL in heifers is greater in three-wave IOI than in two-wave IOI. In summary, the second largest predeviation follicle becomes the postdeviation dominant follicle when the decreasing FSH is out of phase with the largest predeviation follicle in heifers, mares, and women or when luteolysis and predeviation are in synchrony in heifers.

Intraovarianism and differences in ovulation frequency between left and right ovaries in Bos taurus heifers

Sides of ovulation at beginning and end of an interovulatory interval (IOI) were studied for 10 successive ovulations in each of 100 heifers (1000 ovulations, 900 IOI). The frequency of side for 1000 ovulations was less (P < 0.0002) for the left ovary (LO or L; 44.4 %) than for the right ovary (RO or R; 55.6 %). Number of observed ratios of L to R was determined within each of 100 sets of 10 ovulations per set (eg, L2 to R8, L6 to R4). Expected ratios were calculated by combinatorics using the criterion that side of ovulation was an independent event. Differences in ratios between observed and expected were significant supporting the hypothesis that side of ovulation is dependent on the side of the previous ovulation. Number of pairs of ovulations for each end of the 900 IOI was significantly less for the LL pair (144, 16.0 %) than for the pairs of RR (255, 28.3 %), LR (247, 27.5 %), and RL (254, 28.2 %). The hypothesis was supported that the frequency of the pairs of ovulations at the beginning and end of an IOI differed among LL, RR, LR, and RL pairs. Novel observations were that frequency was lowest for the LL pair and similar among the the RR, LR, and RL pairs. These observations indicated that the greater frequency of RO ovulation was mathematically and functionally related to lower frequency of LO ovulation. The interpretation was that intraovarianism in the LL pair accounted for the lower frequency of LO than RO ovulation.

Transcriptome analysis to unravel the gene expression profile of ovarian follicular development in Magang goose

Magang geese exhibit a unique characteristic of follicular development, with eight largest orderly arranged pre-ovulatory follicles in the abdominal cavity. However, little is known about the mechanisms underlying this follicular development. This study aimed to compare gene expression profiles of granulosa cells (GCs) at different stages of follicular development and provide comprehensive insights into follicle selection and the mechanisms underlying the well-defined follicle hierarchy in Magang geese. GCs of large white follicles (LWFs), small yellow follicles (SYFs), F8, F4, and F1 were used for RNA-seq analysis; 374, 1117, 791, and 593 genes were differentially expressed in stages LWFs to SYFs, SYFs to F8, F8 to F4, and F4 to F1, respectively, suggesting that these genes contribute to follicle selection and development. Reliability of sequencing data was verified through qPCR analysis of 24 genes. Gene Ontology and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes pathways revealed a complex mechanism that remodels the extracellular matrix and turnover of extracellular matrix components in follicular development and ovulation and involves multiple pathway, such as focal adhesion, adherens junction, and extracellular matrix–receptor interaction. Some unique characteristics were observed during the different follicular development stages. For instance, some differentially expressed genes were enriched in progesterone-mediated oocyte maturation and steroid biosynthesis from stage SYFs to F8, whereas others were enriched in actin cytoskeleton regulation and vascular smooth muscle contraction from stage F4 to F1. These findings enhance our current understanding of GC function and ovarian follicles during the key stages of follicular development.

Hormonal mechanisms regulating follicular wave dynamics II: Progesterone decreases diameter at follicle selection regardless of whether circulating FSH or LH are decreased or elevated

Selection of a single dominant follicle is morphologically manifested by diameter deviation between the future dominant follicle (F1) and the future largest subordinate follicle (F2). Conventional deviation is defined as F2≥7 mm when F1 reaches ∼8.5 mm whereas, undersized deviation is if F2<7 mm when F1 reaches ∼8.5 mm. Greater frequency of undersized deviation has been temporally associated with greater circulating progesterone (P4) and greater FSH but reduced LH in observational studies. Experiment 1 was conducted to directly test if elevating P4 increased the likelihood of undersized deviation and altered circulating concentrations of LH and FSH. Experiment 2 was conducted to test if increasing LH action by treatment with exogenous porcine LH or human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) in the presence of elevated P4, would stimulate growth of F2 and increase the likelihood of conventional deviation. Ovaries were evaluated by ultrasound and blood samples collected every 12 h after development of a new wave following follicle ablation on D6 (D0 = ovulation). Data were normalized to F1≥7.5 mm and compared using SAS software. In experiment 1 (n = 20), the CL was regressed by prostaglandin F2α treatment and heifers were randomized on D6 into control (no P4 treatment) or P4 treatment (75 mg every 12 h for 5.5 d) beginning when F1 reached ∼3 mm (P4-3 mm group) or ∼6 mm (P4-6 mm group). The P4 treatment significantly increased the frequency of undersized deviation from 0% (controls) to 54%, decreased LH by 44%, and increased FSH by 32%. In experiment 2 (n = 27) heifers were randomized on D6 into control (saline) or treatment with the LH analogs - pLH (1.25 mg porcine LH/12 h) or hCG (160 IU initially and subsequently 96 IU/24 h). Treatment with LH analogs significantly increased P4 (control, 4.6 ± 0.3 ng/mL; pLH, 6.6 ± 0.4 ng/mL; and hCG, 8.9 ± 0.4 ng/mL) and decreased FSH (control, 0.46 ± 0.03 ng/mL; combined-pLH/hCG, 0.34 ± 0.02 ng/mL). However, F1 and F2 diameter and frequency of conventional (37%) and undersized (48%) deviations were similar between the control and combined-pLH/hCG groups. In conclusion, elevated P4 was directly linked to undersized deviation but the P4 effect on decreasing F2 diameter occurred independently of the P4 effects on FSH and LH concentrations.

Role of intraovarian mechanisms and side of ovary on characteristics of follicle selection in Bos taurus heifers

Intraovarian effects on diameter of future dominant follicle (DF or F1) and future largest subordinate follicle (F2) during the few days before selection of the future DF and subordinate follicles were studied in 147 bovine interovulatory intervals. Follicle selection involves diameter deviation or the beginning of separation of growth rates between F1 and F2. Diameter deviation is classified as conventional (F2 ≥ 7.0 mm when F1 is 8.5 mm or at expected deviation) and as undersized (F2 < 7.0 mm when F1 is 8.5 mm). Diameter separation of F1 and F2 in conventional and undersized deviations is characteristically abrupt and gradual, respectively. The predeviation diameter of F2 when located in an ovary that later becomes the F1 intraovarian patterns of DF-CL, devoid (ovary without a DF or CL), DF alone, or CL alone and in left or right ovaries (LO, RO) was compared between conventional and undersized deviations. In conventional deviation, ovaries with the future DF (combined DF-CL and DF patterns) were associated with greater (P < 0.02) predeviation growth rate of F2 when the DF was in the right ovary (DF/RO, 1.6 ± 0.1 mm/d) than when in the left ovary (DF/LO, 1.2 ± 0.1 mm/d). The F2 was in DF/RO more frequently (75%, P < 0.002) than in non-DF/RO. When F2 was in the future devoid F1 pattern and F1 was 6 mm, F2 was smaller (P < 0.002) in the undersized class (5.3 ± 0.2 mm) than in the conventional class (6.3 ± 0.1) but not when F2 was in one of the other future F1 patterns. Only the devoid pattern was greater in frequency (P < 0.03) in the undersized class than in the conventional class. The novel hypothesis was supported that location of F2 in ovaries with different future F1 intraovarian patterns and on different sides affects the predeviation diameter and growth rate of F2 and thereby the frequencies of conventional and undersized deviations during follicle selection.

Systemic and intrafollicular components of follicle selection in mares

Mares are superb models for study of follicle selection owing to similarities between mares and women in relative follicle diameters at specific events during the follicular wave and follicle accessibility for experimental sampling and manipulation. Usually, only 1 major follicular wave with a dominant follicle (DF) greater than 30 mm develops during the 22 to 24 d of the equine estrous cycle and is termed the primary or ovulatory wave. A major secondary wave occasionally (25%) develops early in the cycle. Follicles of the primary wave emerge at 6 mm on day 10 or 11 (day 0 = ovulation). The 2 largest follicles begin to deviate in diameter on day 16 when the future DF and largest subordinate follicle (SF) are 23 mm and 20 mm, respectively. The deviation process begins the day before diameter deviation as indicated in the future DF but not in the future SF by (1) increase in prominence of an anechoic layer and vascular perfusion of the wall and (2) increase in follicular-fluid concentrations of IGF1, vascular endothelial growth factor, estradiol, and inhibin-A. A systemic component of the deviation process is represented by suppression of circulating FSH from secretion of inhibin and estradiol from the developing DF. Production of inhibin is stimulated by IGF1 and LH, and estradiol is stimulated by LH and not by IGF1 in mares. A local intrafollicular component involves the production of IGF1, which apparently increases the responsiveness of the future DF to FSH. The roles of the IGF system have been well studied in mares, but the effect of IGF1 on increasing the sensitivity of the follicle cells to FSH is based primarily on studies in other species. The greater response of the future DF than the SF to the low concentrations of FSH is the essence of selection. During the common growth phase that precedes deviation, diameter of the 2 largest follicles increases in parallel on average when normalized to emergence or retrospectively to deviation. Study of individual waves indicates that (1) the 2 follicles change ranks (relative diameters) during the common growth phase in about 30% of primary waves and (2) after ablation of 1, 2, or 3 of the largest follicles at the expected beginning of deviation, the next largest retained follicle becomes the DF indicating that several follicles have the capacity for dominance; therefore, it is proposed that the deviation process represents the entire mechanism of follicle selection in mares.

The theory of follicle selection in cattle

Selection of the dominant follicle (DF) during a follicular wave is manifested by diameter deviation or continued growth rate of the largest follicle (F1) and decreased growth rate of the next largest follicle (F2) when F1 reaches about 8.5 mm in cattle. The process of deviation in the future DF begins about 12 h before diameter deviation and involves an F1 increase in granulosa LH receptors and estradiol and maintenance of intrafollicular free insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF1). Thereby, only F1 is developmentally prepared to use the declining FSH in the wave-stimulating FSH surge and to respond to a transient increase in LH to become the DF. A follicle that emerges first may maintain an F1 ranking and become the DF by being first to reach a critical developmental stage. However, an early size advantage is not a requisite component of the deviation process as indicated by (1) F1 and F2 may switch diameter rankings during a common growth phase that precedes diameter deviation owing to intraovarian factors that affect growth of individual follicles; (2) any follicle that reaches 5 mm regardless of diameter ranking may become a DF unless it is selected against during deviation; (3) a subordinate follicle may become dominant if the DF is ablated; (4) when F1 is ablated at 8.5 mm, the next largest follicle that is greater than 7.0 mm or the first follicle to subsequently reach 7.0 mm becomes the DF; (5) after ablation of F1 at 8.5 mm, IGF1 and estradiol increase in the intrafollicular fluid of F2 beginning at 6 h, and F2 grows to 8.5 mm in 12 h to become the DF. These considerations indicate that selection of a DF or partitioning into a DF and subordinate follicles is not initiated before the end of the common growth phase. That is, the deviation process represents the entire follicle selection mechanism.