Objective Assessment of Pathological Voice Using Artificial Intelligence Based on the GRBAS Scale

OBJECTIVES

The validity and reliability of the psychological assessment of auditory perceptions, as typified by the grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, and strain (GRBAS) scale, have been widely recognized. However, due to their subjective nature, inter- and intra-examiner reliability are unavoidable. In this study, we aimed to add objectivity to the GRBAS scale using artificial intelligence and to compare the accuracy of two methods-one based on Google's TensorFlow and another based on Apple's Core ML.

METHODS

The GRBAS scale of 1,377 vowel samples was evaluated and used as training data to create a machine learning model. We used TensorFlow and Apple's Create ML to create two machine learning models and examined the difference in their accuracies for classifying the severity of pathological Voice data based on the GRBAS scale.

RESULTS

Absolute comparisons are difficult to make because of the difference in methods; however, both training models could objectively evaluate GRBAS scales and were statistically correlated in G and B.

CONCLUSION

While TensorFlow requires creation of a training model from scratch, Create ML is a relatively easy way to create a training model for voice by adding training data for GRBAS scales to an existing training model for sounds. Although the data handling and learning methods are different, both models performed well. Findings from this study could be used for medical screening purposes, and there is the potential to change the clinical approach to voice diagnostics in the future.

Comparative Study of the Effect of Experience on Auditory Processing Abilities in Voice Therapists and Other Speech-Language Pathologist in Auditory Perceptual Judgment of Voice

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to compare the effect of experience on central auditory processing skills in voice therapists and other Speech-Language Pathologists in the auditory perceptual evaluation of voice.

STUDY DESIGN

This research is a descriptive-analytical cross-sectional observational study.

METHODS

Our study population includes three groups; first-year speech-language pathology students who have not undergone any training or education in the evaluation of auditory samples (group 1; n = 10), Speech-Language Pathologists who do not have any activity in the field of voice disorders (group 2; n = 10), and therapists who have at least 2 years of experience in auditory-perceptual judgment (group 3; n = 10). Initially, the participants underwent a basic audiological evaluation (Pure Tone Audiometry, Speech Recognition Threshold, Speech Discrimination Score, tympanometry, and acoustic reflex) to assess peripheral hearing. In the next step, the auditory processing skills of the participants were evaluated with the Buffalo model (staggered spondaic word (SSW) test, phonemic synthesis test (PST), speech in noise (SPN) test). In the third step, four recorded voice samples of patients with voice disorders and healthy individuals were randomly selected for auditory perceptual judgment. These samples were the same for all participants. All the voices were previously subjected to auditory perceptual analysis by two Speech-Language Pathologist who had at least 6 years of experience in the evaluation and treatment of voice disorders; the voices were played for participants to assess auditory perception using the grade, roughness, breathiness, asthenia, strain (GRBAS) scale.

RESULTS

All subjects had normal hearing and auditory processing abilities but there were some differences among the groups in processing skills. A difference was found in the SSW-qualifier and SPN-R components between the three groups. The third group had significant differences with the other two groups in the evaluation of auditory perception in the components of R, B, and S (from the GRBAS scale) in voice number one, and the components of G, R, and A in voice number three. In voice number two, there was a correlation between the SSW order effect component and the G component, as well as between the PST component and the A component. In voice number three, there was a correlation between the SPN-L component and the G component, and between the SSW condition, SSW qualifier, and SSW All errors components with the S component. In voice number four, there was a correlation between the SSW-RC, SSW-LC, SSW condition, SSW competing, and SSW order effect components with the A component. Lastly, there was a correlation between the SSW order effect and SSW type A components with the R component in voice number three in group three.

CONCLUSION

The results of the present study indicate that experience has an impact on auditory processing skills and the participants of the third group, who had more experience in the evaluation of voice disorders obtained better scores than the other two groups in the auditory processing skills. Additionally, the level of experience is related to the accuracy of auditory perceptual judgment of voice. The participants of the third group performed better than the other two groups, and the performance of the first and second groups was almost the same.

Effect of Anchor Voices and Listener Expertise on Auditory-Perceptual Judgments of Voice Quality Using the GRBAS Scale

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to determine the effect of anchor voices and listener expertise on auditory-perceptual judgment of voice quality using the GRBAS scale.

METHODS

This study utilized a modified crossover design with counterbalancing. Anchor voices for each parameter of the GRBAS scale were chosen based on expert consensus. A total of 28 participants were divided into three groups based on their expertise. The first and second groups consisted of nine undergraduate (UG) and nine postgraduate (PG) students of speech-language pathology. The third group consisted of 10 practicing speech-language pathologists (SLPs). These participants carried out auditory-perceptual judgment of 60 dysphonic voice samples under two counterbalanced experimental conditions (with and without anchor voices). Each of the three groups was randomly divided into two subgroups to balance the experimental conditions. Interrater reliability for each subgroup was calculated using Krippendorff's α and 95% confidence intervals.

RESULTS

For all the groups involved in the study, interrater reliability was higher when anchor voices aided perceptual judgment for most parameters of the GRBAS scale. For the different parameters of GRBAS, interrater reliability for the UG group varied from fair (20 < α ≤ 40) to moderate (40 < α ≤ 60). In contrast, it was fair (20 < α ≤ 40) to substantial (60 < α ≤ 80) for the PG group and moderate (40 < α ≤ 60) to substantial (60 < α ≤ 80) for the SLP group. Variations in reliability were the least for the SLP group compared to the UG and PG groups. However, there were overlaps in interrater reliability between the groups, as revealed by the 95% confidence intervals.

CONCLUSIONS

Anchor voices help improve the auditory-perceptual judgment of voice quality, especially interrater reliability. Listener expertise is also shown to influence the interrater reliability of auditory-perceptual judgment of voice quality.

Validation of the Acoustic Breathiness Index in Speakers of Finnish Language

Breathiness (perception of turbulence noise in the voice) is one of the major components of hoarseness in dysphonic voices. This study aims to validate a multiparameter analysis tool, the Acoustic Breathiness Index (ABI), for quantification of breathiness in the speaking voice, including both sustained vowels and continuous speech. One hundred and eight speakers with dysphonia (28 M, 80 F, mean age 50, SD 15.4 years) and 87 non-dysphonic controls (18 M, 69 F, mean age 42, SD 14 years) volunteered as participants. They read a standard text and sustained vowel /a:/. Acoustic recordings were made using a head-mounted microphone. Acoustic samples were evaluated perceptually by nine voice experts of different backgrounds (speech therapists, vocologists and laryngologists). Breathiness (B) from the GRBAS scale was rated. Headphones were used in the perceptual analysis. The dysphonic and non-dysphonic speakers differed significantly from each other in the auditory perceptual evaluation of breathiness. A significant difference was also found for ABI, which had a mean value of 2.26 (SD 1.15) for non-dysphonic and 3.07 (SD 1.75) for dysphonic speakers. ABI correlated strongly with B (rs = 0.823, p = 0.01). ABI's power to distinguish the groups was high (88.6%). The highest sensitivity and specificity of ABI (80%) was obtained at threshold value 2.68. ABI is a valid tool for differentiating breathiness in non-dysphonic and dysphonic speakers of Finnish.

Construction of an Anchor and Training Sample Set for Auditory-Perceptual Voice Evaluation With the GRBAS-scale

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to construct a representative and comprehensive set of reliable anchor and training voice samples for all parameters and grades of the GRBAS-scale, in order to develop a standardized online training tool for perceptual voice evaluation.

METHODS

140 voice samples varying from normal to severely dysphonic, consisting of the vowel /a/ and a Dutch standard text, were recorded. Samples were duplicated and added to a data folder in random order. A panel of five highly experienced judges rated GRBAS parameters for each voice sample. Intra- and interrater reliability were determined using intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and percentage agreement. Samples with agreement percentages of >0.90 for at least one parameter were qualified as anchor voices, whereas samples with a percentage agreement between 0.70 and 0.80 were considered valid training samples.

RESULTS

Intrarater reliability was moderate to good for all raters and parameters. Interrater reliability was good for parameter G and moderate for R, B, A and S. 83 samples were found to be valid anchor samples with 90-100% expert agreement for at least one parameter, covering all of the GRBAS parameter/score combinations. An additional 37 samples fulfilled the criteria for adoption in the online tool as a training sample, showing 70-80% agreement for one or more parameters.

CONCLUSION

Based on well-defined and stringent selection criteria, this study identifies a substantial number of valid anchor and training voices that qualify for implementation in a standardized multi-level training tool for the auditory-perceptual evaluation of voice by means of the GRBAS scale.

Acoustical and Perceptual Analysis of Voice in Individuals with Parkinson's Disease

Parkinson's disease is a neurodegenerative disorder that affects motor efficiency which is also required for voice production. Voice is part of the identity of a person, any abnormality in voice quality hampers the quality of communication, and quality of life. This study aimed to analyse the voice of individuals with Parkinson's disease objectively through acoustic analysis, and subjectively through perceptual analysis. Quasi-experimental study conducted in a tertiary health care centre. The study comprised two groups: 12 individuals with Parkinson's disease (11 males and 1 female, mean age: 72.41 years), and 12 healthy controls (10 males and 2 females, mean age: 53.83 years). The voice samples of all the participants were recorded and analyzed using the MDVP software of CSL 4500. The voice samples were analyzed for eleven acoustical parameters, and the perceptual analysis was carried out using the GRBAS scale by two experienced Speech Language Pathologists. Mann-Whitney U test was performed to compare the two groups of participants, and Cronbach's alpha test was performed to find the inter-judge reliability between the perceptual ratings of two listeners. Acoustical comparison showed significant variations in seven parameters (jitter, shimmer, PPQ, APQ, Fatr Hz, Fftr, ATRI), and the perceptual analysis between two listeners showed a fair amount of reliability.

Muscle Tension Dysphonia: Experience from a Conflict Zone

We sought to explore the frequency of stress among OPD attending Kashmiri public diagnosed as muscle tension dysphonia (MTD) and determine the subjective consequences of voice therapy in management of muscle tension dysphonia. 72 subjects that attended to ENT and HNS OPD with change of voice were prospectively evaluated and also underwent an extensive otolaryngological examination. Patients identified as MTD were provided a questionnaire which was split into 3 parts: First part dealt with the identification of the subject (age, geography, gender, profession) and also provided evaluation of perceived anxiety using Perceived Stress Scale-10. In the next part the individuals needed to assess their vocal quality based on parameters of GRBAS 4-point score scale before and also after the treatment. In the final component the subjects also needed to answer the VHI-10 (Voice Handicap Index) and also the outcome was compared with those acquired at the assessment before the beginning of the treatment. The mean age of the cohort was 30.31 ± 07.43 (age range, 12-71) and every subject was an indigenous Kashmiri. As expected, vast majority of subjects were females (43 patients). In the pooled information set, women had numerically higher PSS-10 scores than males. For women, the typical stress score was M = 18.6 and for men the average stress score was M = 16.65. In a healthy population, the typical PSS stress score is described to be 13.7 (SD = 6.6) for women and 12.1 (SD = 5.9) for men. At the Wilcoxon test for paired data, we observed a significant difference between the VHI pretreatment (mean = 19.7) and VHI post-treatment, that's at time of the research (mean = 9.73; P = 0.017). The grade (G) was assessed in terms of improvement of the vocal quality as opposed with before treatment and also the individuals demonstrated a high level of satisfaction (mean = 0.65). When looking at roughness (R) as well as breathiness (B), the individuals remember that their speech is seldom rough (mean = 0.62) and also less breathy (median = 0.44). Patients likewise noted improvement in other variables of GRBAS scale. Stress is persistent, pervasive and nearly unavoidable in contemporary life. The decades old perplexing and mind baffling pandemonium hovering around the Kashmiri population has had a tremendous impression on the psychological development of people in this region. A careful conclusion is the fact that emotional stress might play a major role in the upkeep of MTD. MTD has to be approached in a multidisciplinary environment in which closer cooperation between a laryngologist, a speech language pathologist and also a psychologist is likely.

Predictions for Three-Month Postoperative Vocal Recovery after Thyroid Surgery from Spectrograms with Deep Neural Network

Despite the lack of findings in laryngeal endoscopy, it is common for patients to undergo vocal problems after thyroid surgery. This study aimed to predict the recovery of the patient's voice after 3 months from preoperative and postoperative voice spectrograms. We retrospectively collected voice and the GRBAS score from 114 patients undergoing surgery with thyroid cancer. The data for each patient were taken from three points in time: preoperative, and 2 weeks and 3 months postoperative. Using the pretrained model to predict GRBAS as the backbone, the preoperative and 2-weeks-postoperative voice spectrogram were trained for the EfficientNet architecture deep-learning model with long short-term memory (LSTM) to predict the voice at 3 months postoperation. The correlation analysis of the predicted results for the grade, breathiness, and asthenia scores were 0.741, 0.766, and 0.433, respectively. Based on the scaled prediction results, the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for the binarized grade, breathiness, and asthenia were 0.894, 0.918, and 0.735, respectively. In the follow-up test results for 12 patients after 6 months, the average of the AUC values for the five scores was 0.822. This study showed the feasibility of predicting vocal recovery after 3 months using the spectrogram. We expect this model could be used to relieve patients' psychological anxiety and encourage them to actively participate in speech rehabilitation.

Assessment of Dysphonia in Children with Pompe Disease Using Auditory-Perceptual and Acoustic/Physiologic Methods

Bulbar and respiratory weakness occur commonly in children with Pompe disease and frequently lead to dysarthria. However, changes in vocal quality associated with this motor speech disorder are poorly described. The goal of this study was to characterize the vocal function of children with Pompe disease using auditory-perceptual and physiologic/acoustic methods. High-quality voice recordings were collected from 21 children with Pompe disease. The Grade, Roughness, Breathiness, Asthenia, and Strain (GRBAS) scale was used to assess voice quality and ratings were compared to physiologic/acoustic measurements collected during sustained phonation tasks, reading of a standard passage, and repetition of a short phrase at maximal volume. Based on ratings of grade, dysphonia was present in 90% of participants and was most commonly rated as mild or moderate in severity. Duration of sustained phonation tasks was reduced and shimmer was increased in comparison to published reference values for children without dysphonia. Specific measures of loudness were found to have statistically significant relationships with perceptual ratings of grade, breathiness, asthenia, and strain. Our data suggest that dysphonia is common in children with Pompe disease and primarily reflects impairments in respiratory and laryngeal function; however, the primary cause of dysphonia remains unclear. Future studies should seek to quantify the relative contribution of deficits in individual speech subsystems on voice quality and motor speech performance more broadly.

Validation of the Brazilian Portuguese CAPE-V Instrument-Br CAPE-V for Auditory-Perceptual Analysis

INTRODUCTION

The Consensus Auditory Perceptual Evaluation of Voice (CAPE-V) scale is a modern, clinical-scientific approach to voice analysis. It has been translated and culturally adapted to Brazilian Portuguese, but it still lacks validation.

OBJECTIVE

To validate the Brazilian Portuguese version of the CAPE-V scale using the previously translated and culturally adapted version.

METHOD

Forty voice samples were selected (30 dysphonic, 10 nondysphonic), and the degree of vocal deviation was evaluated by a committee of three voice specialists. Nine voice specialists judged the 40 voice samples plus 20% repetition (total of 48 samples) using the CAPE-V. To ensure construct validity of the CAPE-V, its analysis was compared to the Grade-Roughness-Breathiness-Asthenia-Strain (GRBAS) scale that was performed 48-72 hours later. Finally, the intra- and inter-rater reliability values were verified and the correlation between the nine judges and the previously defined evaluation was analyzed.

RESULTS

The Brazilian CAPE-V presented significant intra (0.860-0.997) and inter-rater reliability values (0.707-0.964) for the overall degree and strong correlation with GRBAS (above 0.828). Deviant voice quality had greater consensus among raters than normal voices. A strong correlation was observed between the analysis of the nine raters and that of the committee.

CONCLUSION

CAPE-V is an important diagnostic instrument that contributes to the standardization of vocal quality evaluation in several languages, including Brazilian Portuguese. Thus, its usefulness is neither related to a single language nor to a single set of raters.

Unsedated Office-Based Thulium Laser Therapy in Patients With Reinke's Edema

OBJECTIVE

To report the outcome of unsedated office based Thulium laser therapy for Reinke's edema.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective chart review of patients operated between March 2017 and November 2018 was conducted. Twelve patients were included, two of whom had two procedures performed. Demographic data included age, gender, smoking status, and grade of Reinke's edema. Outcome measures included Voice Handicap Index-10 (VHI), perceptual evaluation, extent of disease regression, acoustic analysis, and maximal phonation time.

RESULTS

Twelve patients were enrolled in this study, one of whom was lost for follow-up. There were eight females and three males. The mean age was 51.27 ± 9.12 years. Endoscopic evaluation 6-12 weeks after surgery revealed complete and partial regression of disease in three and eight patients, respectively. There was a significant improvement in the mean score of VHI-10 (15.00 ± 9.45 vs 3.07 ± 3.81) and the mean score of GRABS parameters following surgery (P < 0.05). The mean habitual pitch increased from 125.11 ± 28.48 Hz to 155.86 ± 55.14 Hz (P = 0.070). There was improvement in the mean jitter and shimmer but none reached a statistical significance. There was no significant change in the mean Maximum phonation time (MPT) scores before and after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Unsedated office-based Thulium laser therapy can be considered as an alternative therapy to patients with Reinke's edema who are not willing to undergo conventional microlaryngeal surgery.

Subjective Evaluation of Voice Characteristics of School Aged Children in a Basket Ball Team

Voice disorders have been estimated to be present in between 3 and 9% of general population. Sports children have vocal abusive behavior i.e. the extra effort which they put on their voice while playing, leading to voice disorders. It is imperative to find out the voice characteristics of children involved in sports activity. To assess voice characteristics of school aged children, who are active participants in a basket ball team. A group of twenty children (13 males and 7 females) were included in the study. He or she was member of school basket ball team and had participated in many events. The perceptual voice assessment was conducted using GRBAS scale, Buffalo III Voice Profile and Voice Handicap Index (VHI). Findings on GRBAS voice rating scale-In the first parameter i.e. grade 46.7% of the subjects reported slight hoarse component. In the second parameter i.e. Roughness 46.7% of the subjects showed slight roughness component. In another parameter i.e. the asthenia 20% % of the subjects reported slight asthenia component in their voice. In the next parameter i.e. strain in the voice, 26.7% of the subjects showed slight strain component in their voice. Finding on BUFFALO III voice screening profile-In the laryngeal tone, 46.7% of the subjects showed mild hoarse component. Findings on voice handicap index (VHI)-28% of the subjects had functional symptoms of voice problems. 43% of the subjects had some physical symptoms while 28% had affected emotional component. Present study is first of its kind to focus on voice disorders among school going children who are members of a basket ball team. During sport events players tend to scream in order to communicate among their team mates, to show their aggressiveness to their opponents and to show excitement of win or frustration of the lost match leading to various voice problems. There is a high probability of occurrence of voice disorders among children who are active participants of basket ball. Proper counselling of these children is required for preventive measures and to seek voice therapy when required.

Voice Quality After Radiotherapy and Cordectomy in Early-Stage Glottic Carcinomas

Laryngeal carcinomas are the most common upper respiratory tract cancers and most commonly involve the glottic region. The aim of this study is to evaluate the voice quality after radiotherapy (RT) and microsurgical cordectomy (MC) treatments using Voice Handicap Index (VHI) and Grade, Roughness, Breathiness, Astenicity, and Strain (GRBAS) perceptual evaluation scale in patients with early-stage glottic carcinoma. A total of 37 patients with early-stage glottic carcinomas, 19 patients had RT and 18 patients with MC, were included in our study. The patients were evaluated in terms of their sound quality by using VHI-10 and GRBAS perceptual assessment scale 3 months after the treatment was completed. Although the findings were better in favor of RT according to GRBAS perceptual assessment scale of patients who received RT (n = 19) and MC (n = 18), no statistically significant difference was found between the 2 groups (P = .613). Patients in both groups were evaluated with VHI-10, emotional (P = .036) and physiological (P = .038) scores were significantly higher in MC group and no significant difference was found in functional scores (P = .192). However, there was no statistically significant difference between the 2 groups in terms of voice quality (P = .185). In early-stage (Tis, T1a, T1b) glottic carcinoma, there was no significant difference between RT and MC in terms of voice quality. Therefore, the choice of treatment modality in patients with early-stage glottic carcinoma should be taken into account in terms of the patient's occupation, comorbid diseases, cost of treatment, hospital stay, and, most importantly, patient preference.

Liuzijue Qigong: A Voice Training Method For Unilateral Vocal Fold Paralysis Patients

OBJECTIVES

Liuzijue Qigong (LQG), a kind of traditional Chinese health exercise (TCHE), is not only widely used to strengthen physical fitness and maintain psychological well-being in the elderly but has also been utilized to help improve respiratory function. As respiratory support is an important driving force for speech production, it is logical to postulate that the LQG training method with 6 monosyllabic speech sounds, xū, hē, hū, sī, chuī, and xī, can help individuals (1) experience a relaxing and natural state of speech production, (2) eliminate voice symptoms, and (3) improve their overall body function and mood. In the current study, we hypothesized that the LQG method with these 6 sounds can be effective in improving vocal function in subjects with unilateral vocal fold paralysis (UVFP) in comparison with a conventional voice therapy method.

METHODS

A total of 48 patients with UVFP who met the inclusion criteria were randomly divided into 2 groups. Twenty-four subjects in the experimental group were trained with LQG, and those in the control group received conventional voice training (abdominal breathing and yawn-sign exercises) for a total of 4 sessions, twice a week. Patients in both groups were assessed with acoustic tests, the GRBAS scale, the Voice Handicap Index (VHI-10), and the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) pre- and posttreatment. Statistical analysis was conducted using nonparametric tests and t tests.

RESULTS

There existed significant changes in maximum phonation time (MPT), jitter, shimmer, normalized noise energy (NNE), GRBAS scores, VHI-10 scores, and grade of A in HADS scores pre- and posttreatment in both the experimental group and the control group ( P < .004). However, no significant changes were seen posttreatment between the 2 groups ( P > .05).

CONCLUSIONS

LQG could help improve vocal function in UVFP patients as our preliminary data showed no significant differences between LQG and conventional voice therapy methods.

Components of Voice Evaluation

This article provides a concise review of contemporary options for evaluating voice disorders. Focus is given to patient history and patient-derived voice handicap and quality of life assessments, clinician-derived perceptual analysis of voice, and finally flexible and rigid, high-definition laryngoscopy with videostroboscopy to fully evaluate laryngeal function and biomechanics.

Perceptual Judgment of Voice Quality in Nondysphonic French Speakers: Effect of Task-, Speaker- and Listener-Related Variables

PURPOSE

Several perceptual scales have been developed to assess voice quality in dysphonic voices, among which the Grade Roughness Breathiness Asthenia Strain and a Rate of Dysphonia scale is probably the most frequently used. However, this clinical tool has not been properly validated with a normophonic population yet. The aim of the present study was to provide a first set of reference data gathered from a normal population, to serve as a basis of comparison for vocologists and laryngologists working with French-speaking patients. A second goal was to investigate the influence on this normal voice dataset, of variables known to affect perceptual judgments of pathological voice.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Sustained vowels and sentences produced by 80 healthy, normophonic French native speakers were perceptually assessed by a panel of 18 raters (nine students, nine experts) using the Grade Roughness Breathiness Asthenia Strain and a Rate of Dysphonia scale.

RESULTS

The average overall grade was close to 1 on the (0 to 3) scale, questioning the notion of "normal" voice as opposed to dysphonic voice. Rating reliability as well as perceptual scores were affected by task-, speaker-, and listener-related factors: speech stimuli led to better rating reliability and were judged less severely than voice stimuli; experts were slightly more reliable and less severe than students; older speakers were unanimously considered as more dysphonic. Multiple interactions between these factors were observed, confirming the multidimensional nature of voice quality.

Perceptual Evaluation of Voice Disorder in Children Who Have Had Laryngotracheal Reconstruction Surgery and the Relationship Between Clinician Perceptual Ratingof Voice Quality and Parent Proxy/Child Self-Report of Voice-Related Quality of Life

Reliability of the GRBAS tool for perceptual evaluation of paediatric voice disorder is measured in this study of children with a history of laryngotracheal reconstruction surgery (LTR). Additionally, the relationship between parent proxy/child self-report of voice-related quality of life with clinician perceptual rating of voice quality is analysed. Eleven children with a history of LTR provided voice recordings following the stimuli set by the CAPE-V protocol. Subjective impact of voice quality on life was measured using the paediatric voice-related quality of life questionnaire. Four trained judges rated the sound files according to both the GRBAS and CAPE-V protocol. Intra-class correlation coefficients were high for both intra-rater and inter-rater judgments across all parameters of the GRBAS protocol, and a strong correlation was found between the grade rating of the GRBAS and the overall severity rating of the CAPE-V. Some elements of parent proxy reporting of voice-related quality of life were significantly negatively correlated with clinician perceptual rating of voice quality, while there was no significant relationship between child self-report and clinician perceptual rating.

Reliability and Validity of the Turkish Version of the Consensus Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Voice (CAPE-V)

OBJECTIVES

The main purpose of this study was to culturally adapt the Consensus Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Voice (CAPE-V) to Turkish and to evaluate its internal consistency, validity, and reliability.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The Turkish version of CAPE-V was developed, and with the use of a prospective case-control design, the voice recordings of 130 participants were collected according to CAPE-V protocol. Auditory-perceptual evaluation was conducted according to CAPE-V and Grade, Roughness, Breathiness, Asthenia, and Strain (GRBAS) scale by two ear, nose, and throat specialists and two speech and language therapists. The different types of voice disorders, classified as organic and functional disorders, were compared in terms of their CAPE-V scores.

RESULTS

The overall severity parameter had the highest intrarater and inter-reliability values for all the participants. For all four raters, the differences in the six CAPE-V parameters between the study and the control groups were found to be statistically significant. Among the correlations for the comparable parameters of the CAPE-V and the GRBAS scales, the highest correlation was found between the overall severity-grade parameters. There was no difference found between the organic and functional voice disorders in terms of the CAPE-V scores.

CONCLUSIONS

The Turkish version of CAPE-V has been proven to be a reliable and valid instrument to use in the auditory-perceptual evaluation of voice. For the future application of this study, it would be important to investigate whether cepstral measures correlate with the auditory-perceptual judgments of dysphonia severity collected by a Turkish version of the CAPE-V.

How Do Voice Perceptual Changes Predict Acoustic Parameters in Persian Voice Patients?

INTRODUCTION

Perceptual and acoustic analyses are essential tools that help voice therapists comprehensively assess voice quality. While perceptual evaluations are subjective and are influenced by external and culturally driven factors, acoustic analysis is an objective and reliable means of evaluating voice. The goals of this study were (1) to determine which acoustic parameters were predicted by perceptual voice quality and (2) to assess the effect of a short period of training on the reliability of perceptual voice analyses for Persian speakers.

METHOD

This was a cross-sectional study. Subjects were 20 patients with various voice disorders. Voice samples were obtained during text reading and /a/ prolongation. Fifteen expert voice clinicians completed perceptual evaluations on voice samples using the Grade, Roughness, Breathiness, Asthenia, and Strain scale. We repeated this process after a short period of perceptual voice evaluation training. Acoustic analysis was completed using the Praat program. We used the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) for reliability measurement of the perceptual evaluation results and ordinal regression procedures to analyze all data. Significance level was set at P < 0.05.

RESULTS

Both intrarater and interrater reliability increased after training, for all five parameters. The ICC for grade increased to 0.95 after training. Grade and roughness significantly predicted fundamental frequency (F0) (P = 0.021 and P = 0.030, respectively) and harmonic-to-noise ratio (HNR) (P = 0.019 and P = 0.016, respectively). Breathiness significantly predicted shimmer (P = 0.013).

CONCLUSION

Training had a positive effect and increased the reliability of perceptual voice evaluation. For Persian listeners, changes in F0, increases in HNR, and shimmer were perceptually associated with poor voice quality.

Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Dysphonia: A Comparison Between Narrow and Broad Terminology Systems

OBJECTIVE

In auditory-perceptual voice analysis, a multiparameter approach and a more reductionist approach may be compared with narrow and broad phonetic transcription and used interchangeably, depending on the purpose. The aim of this study was to investigate the perspectives of a translation of the terminology used in the multiparameter Danish Dysphonia Assessment (DDA) approach into the five-parameter GRBAS system.

METHODS

Voice samples illustrating type and grade of the voice qualities included in DDA were rated by five speech language pathologists using the GRBAS system with the aim of estimating inter- and intrarater reliability. The same samples were then rated using the DDA terminology.

RESULTS

Both inter- and intrarater reliability were found to be very high for the GRBAS parameters grade, rough, and breathy, but somewhat lower for asthenic and strained. Further, strong and clear associations were found between the DDA and GRBAS rating for grade, rough, breathy, and strained, whereas the relation between DDA ratings and asthenic was weaker and less clear.

CONCLUSION

The data strongly support that the DDA system can be translated into the GRBAS system for auditory-perceptual voice analysis. The consensus discussion prior to the listening test is believed to have contributed to the high degree of inter- and intrarater reliability. We suggest for future use of the GRBAS system that rater reliability for asthenic and strained can increase, if these parameters are defined as behavioral terms and antagonists, reflecting muscular hypo- and hyperfunction.

Is OperaVOX a clinically useful tool for the assessment of voice in a general ENT clinic?

Background

Objective acoustic analysis is a key component of multidimensional voice assessment. OperaVOX is an iOS app which has been shown to be comparable to Multi Dimensional Voice Program for most principal measures of vocal function. As a relatively cheap, portable and easily accessible form of acoustic analysis, OperaVOX may be more clinically useful than laboratory-based software in many situations. This study aims to determine whether correlation exists between acoustic measurements obtained using OperaVOX, and perceptual evaluation of voice.

Methods

Forty-four voices from the multidisciplinary voice clinic were examined. Each voice was assessed blindly by a single experienced voice therapist using the GRBAS scale, and analysed using OperaVOX. The Spearman rank correlation co-efficient was calculated between each element of the GRBAS scale and acoustic measurements obtained by OperaVOX.

Results

Significant correlations were identified between GRBAS scores and OperaVOX parameters. Grade correlated significantly with jitter (ρ = 0.495, p < 0.05), shimmer (ρ = 0.385, p < 0.05), noise-to-harmonic ratio (NHR; ρ = 0.526, p < 0.05) and maximum phonation time (MPT; ρ = −0.415, p < 0.05). Roughness did not correlate with any of the measured variables. Breathiness correlated significantly with jitter (ρ = 0.342, p < 0.05), NHR (ρ = 0.344, p < 0.05) and MPT (ρ = −0.336, p < 0.05). Aesthenia correlated with NHR (ρ = 0.413, p < 0.05) and MPT (ρ = −0.399, p < 0.05). Strain correlated with Jitter (ρ = 0.560, p < 0.05), NHR (ρ = 0.600, p < 0.05) and MPT (ρ = −0.356, p < 0.05).

Conclusions

OperaVOX provides objective acoustic analysis which has shown statistically significant correlation to perceptual evaluation using the GRBAS scale. The accessibility of the software package makes it possible for a wide range of health practitioners, e.g. general ENT surgeons, vascular surgeons, thyroid surgeons and cardiothoracic surgeons to objectively monitor outcomes and complications of surgical procedures that may affect vocal function. Given the increasing requirement for surgeons to monitor their outcomes as part of the move towards ‘surgeon reported outcomes’ this may become an invaluable tool towards that goal.

Vocal Function Exercises for Muscle Tension Dysphonia: Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation and Self-Assessment Rating

OBJECTIVE

Muscle tension dysphonia (MTD) is a functional dysphonia, which appears with an excessive tension in the intrinsic and extrinsic laryngeal musculatures. MTD can affect voice quality and quality of life. The purpose of the present study was to assess the effectiveness of vocal function exercises (VFEs) on perceptual and self-assessment ratings in a group of 15 subjects with MTD.

METHODS

The study comprised 15 subjects with MTD (8 men and 7 women, mean age 39.8 years, standard deviation 10.6, age range 24-62 years). All participants were native Persian speakers who underwent a 6-week course of VFEs. The Voice Handicap Index (VHI) (the self-assessment scale) and Grade, Roughness, Breathiness, Asthenia, Strain (GRBAS) scale (perceptual rating of voice quality) were used to compare pre- and post-VFEs.

RESULTS

GRBAS data of patients before and after VFEs were compared using Wilcoxon signed-rank test, and VHI data of patients pre- and post-VFEs were compared using Student paired t test. These perceptual parameters showed a statistically significant improvement in subjects with MTD after voice therapy (significant at P < 0.05 (*) and P < 0.004 (**)). Also results indicated statistically noticeable reduction in the mean VHI scores across subjects with MTD (significant at P < 0.05 (*) and P < 0.004 (**)).

CONCLUSIONS

Significant improvement after therapy for participants has been observed by the aid of auditory-perceptual ratings of voice quality (with the GRBAS scale) and the patient's self-assessment ratings measurements (with the VHI). As a result, the data provide evidence regarding the efficacy of VFEs in the treatment of patients with MTD.

Voice outcomes after thyroidectomy without superior and recurrent laryngeal nerve injury: VoiSS questionnaire and GRBAS tool assessment

Voice symptoms are frequently reported early after thyroidectomy, even in the absence of laryngeal nerves injury. We evaluated the short-term outcomes of these functional alterations. Thirty-nine patients were enrolled in a prospective observational trial, evaluating voice function before and 3 months after uncomplicated thyroidectomy, using VoiSS as assessed using a validated patient rated questionnaire; and perceptual voice analysis using GRBAS scale (Grade, Roughness, Breathiness, Asthenia, Strain). Impact of dysphonia on patient's life using VoiSS questionnaire revealed differences between pre- and postoperative assessment. There was statistically significant worsening in the impairment subgroup of VoiSS (p = 0.027). GRBAS evaluation was consistent between the three independent raters but showed differences between pre- and postoperative voice assessment. Age, TSH and a preoperative finding of laryngopharyngeal reflux significantly predicted quality of voice after thyroid surgery (all p < 0.004), as identified by the GRBAS assessment tool, but not type of surgery, gender or smoking status; although prediction of total variance in changes of voice was modest (r ² = 0.07). Voice changes may occur after thyroidectomy without evident laryngeal nerve injury. Patients should be made aware of possible mild changes in voice even after uncomplicated thyroid surgery and this might be considered to be part of the informed consent.

Assessment of voice, speech, and related quality of life in advanced head and neck cancer patients 10-years+ after chemoradiotherapy

OBJECTIVES

Assessment of long-term objective and subjective voice, speech, articulation, and quality of life in patients with head and neck cancer (HNC) treated with concurrent chemoradiotherapy (CRT) for advanced, stage IV disease.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-two disease-free survivors, treated with cisplatin-based CRT for inoperable HNC (1999-2004), were evaluated at 10-years post-treatment. A standard Dutch text was recorded. Perceptual analysis of voice, speech, and articulation was conducted by two expert listeners (SLPs). Also an experimental expert system based on automatic speech recognition was used. Patients' perception of voice and speech and related quality of life was assessed with the Voice Handicap Index (VHI) and Speech Handicap Index (SHI) questionnaires.

RESULTS

At a median follow-up of 11-years, perceptual evaluation showed abnormal scores in up to 64% of cases, depending on the outcome parameter analyzed. Automatic assessment of voice and speech parameters correlated moderate to strong with perceptual outcome scores. Patient-reported problems with voice (VHI>15) and speech (SHI>6) in daily life were present in 68% and 77% of patients, respectively. Patients treated with IMRT showed significantly less impairment compared to those treated with conventional radiotherapy.

CONCLUSION

More than 10-years after organ-preservation treatment, voice and speech problems are common in this patient cohort, as assessed with perceptual evaluation, automatic speech recognition, and with validated structured questionnaires. There were fewer complaints in patients treated with IMRT than with conventional radiotherapy.

Voice disorder in patients with Fibromyalgia

OBJECTIVE

To investigate several perceptual, acoustic and aerodynamic voice evaluation parameters in Fibromyalgia patients.

METHODS

A total number of 30 Fibromyalgia patients had voice evaluations by means of laryngostroboscopy, acoustic analysis (jitter, shimmer, and harmonic to noise ratio), aerodynamic measurements (maximum phonation time, s/z ratio), and perceptual analysis (GRBAS and Voice Handicap Index-10 scales). Data obtained from the patients was compared to control subjects.

RESULTS

Mean intensity was found to be significantly higher in control subjects (73.70±4.73dB) than Fibromyalgia patients (64.50±6.92dB), (p<0.001). There was no statistically significant difference in fundamental frequency, perturbation parameters (jitter and shimmer) and harmonic to noise ratio between groups. Maximum phonation time in control subjects (22.53±4.95s) was found to be significantly longer than Fibromyalgia patients (16.07±4.87s), (p<0.001), and s/z ratio was found to be nearly equal between patients (1.00±0.24) and control subjects (0.96±0.16). On the basis of perceptual evaluation by using a GRBAS scale, the patients showed a mean score of 2.50±1.97 and the control group showed a mean score of 0.56±1.04 (p<0.001). "Grade" and "asthenia" parameters of GRBAS scale in Fibromyalgia patients were significantly different from the parameters of control group (p<0.001). The Voice Handicap Index-10 scales revealed a mean score of 7.90±7.58 in Fibromyalgia patients and 1.83±2.82 in control subjects (p<0.001).

CONCLUSION

Fibromyalgia impairs perceived voice quality either in patient self evaluated or in clinician evaluated rating scales. Furthermore, the results confirm that Fibromyalgia caused short maximum phonation time and low voice intensity. This study is the first report with regards to voice evaluation in Fibromyalgia and in order to make a generalization further researches are needed.