Clinicopathological features and endoscopic findings of spindle cell oncocytoma: A case report and review of the literature

INTRODUCTION AND IMPORTANCE

Spindle cell oncocytoma (SCO) of the pituitary gland is very difficult to differentiate from other pituitary neoplasms and is often misdiagnosed based on imaging procedure features. We report a rare case of SCO arising from the neurohypophysis and suggest a useful diagnostic criterion for accurate diagnosis and surgical pitfalls.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 53-year-old man was admitted to our hospital with slight headache and diplopia. Neuroimaging revealed pituitary tumour in the suprasellar and sellar regions with speckled gadolinium enhancement on T1-weighted magnetic resonance imaging, as a so-called blooming artefact. The enhanced anterior pituitary gland was located anteriorly. Computed tomography (CT)-scan demonstrated an isodense mass without calcification showing strong contrast enhancement with iodine contrast medium. Laboratory findings showed no abnormalities. Subtotal resection of the tumour was achieved by an endoscopic endonasal transsphenoidal approach. Histological examinations showed spindle-shaped to epithelioid tumour cells featuring eosinophilic and granular cytoplasm staining strongly for anti-mitochondrial antibody and thyroid transcription factor 1. The tumour was therefore diagnosed as SCO, belonging to tumours of the posterior pituitary. Headache and diplopia were disappeared immediately postoperatively, and follow-up at 12 months demonstrated no signs of recurrence.

CLINICAL DISCUSSION

SCO of the pituitary gland is a rare tumour that originates from the neurohypophysis and is difficult to diagnose on routine neuroimaging procedure.

CONCLUSION

Accurate diagnosis requires careful identification of clinical signs, neuroimaging features including contrast-enhanced CT, and analysis of combined results from morphological and immunohistochemical evaluation of tumour tissue.

Multiple tumorous lesions of the pituitary gland

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE

Multiple tumorous lesions in one pituitary gland are rare and mostly described in case reports. Their incidences and combinations are defined in larger collectives. Therefore, we analyzed our large collection for double tumors and combinations of tumors, cysts, and inflammation.

METHODS

The German Registry of Pituitary Tumors, including cases from 1990 to 2018, served as the database. Our collection comprises a total of 16,283 cases up until the end of 2018. Of these cases, 12,673 originated from surgical and 3,610 from autopsy material. All specimens were fixed in formalin and embedded in paraffin. The sections were stained with hematoxylin-eosin and PAS. Monoclonal (prolactin, TSH, FSH, LH, and α subunit) or polyclonal (GH and ACTH) antibodies were used to detect pituitary hormones in the lesions. Since 2017, antibodies against the transcription factors Pit-1, T-Pit, and SF-1 have been used in difficult cases. The criteria of the 2017 WHO classification have been basic principles for classification since 2018 (Osamura et al. 2017). For differentiation of other sellar tumors, such as meningiomas, chordomas, or metastases, the use of additional antibodies was necessary. For these cases, it was possible to use a broad antibody spectrum. Autopsy pituitaries were generally studied by H&E and PAS sections. If any lesions were demonstrated in these specimens, additional immunostaining was performed.

RESULTS

Multiple tumorous lesions with more than one pituitary neuroendocrine tumor (PitNET) respectively adenoma make up 1.4% (232 cases) in our collection. Within the selected cases, synchronous multiple pituitary neuroendocrine tumors (PitNETs) account for 17.3%, PANCH cases (pituitary adenoma with neuronal choristoma) for 14.7%, PitNETs and posterior lobe tumors for 2.2%, PitNETs and metastases for 5.2%, PitNETs and mesenchymal tumors for 2.6%, PitNETs and cysts for 52.2%, and PitNETs and primary inflammation for 6.0%. The mean patient age was 53.8 years, with a standard deviation of 18.5 years. A total of 55.3% of the patients were female and 44.7% were male. From 1990 to 2018, there was a continuous increase in the number of multiple tumorous lesions.

CONCLUSION

From our studies, we conclude that considering possible tumorous double lesions during surgeries and in preoperative X-ray analyses is recommended.

Surgical management of pituicytomas: a single-center case series

OBJECTIVE

Pituicytomas (PT) are rare benign sellar and/or supra sellar tumors which surgical treatment might be challenging, owing to the hypervascularity of the tumor. Here, we report our experience with PTs, describe their clinical and radiological features, and propose an optimal therapeutic strategy.

METHODS

This is a retrospective single-center study, reporting the clinical manifestations, radiological characteristics, histopathological features, treatment strategies and long-term outcomes of four patients who have been treated for a PT at Bicêtre University Hospital in Paris, France, over the past 7 years.

RESULTS

Four patients were operated mean age at presentation was 60.25 years. Main symptoms, which tended to be progressive, included visual field defects and pituitary-hypothalamic dysfunction. Radiologically, all our cases resented with sellar and suprasellar localization with cavernous invasion in 75% of cases. Endoscopic transphenoidal approach was performed as first surgery for all cases. Transcranial route was done in one case. During surgery, important bleeding was observed in all cases. Gross total resection was obtained with a single surgery in two cases and a second surgery was necessary in the two remaining cases. Pathological diagnosis was confirmed in all cases. No recurrences were noted after an average follow-up of 3.6 years.

CONCLUSIONS

PT is a rare differential diagnosis of sellar and/or parasellar tumors, whose hemorrhagic nature can become a challenge during surgery. We added four more cases to the literature to make physicians establish Piticytomas at suspicion diagnosis for sellar and/or suprasellar masses. Knowing the diagnosis, a preparation should be made preoperatively to avoid possible complications peroperatively.

Co-occurrence of Pituitary Neuroendocrine Tumors (PitNETs) and Tumors of the Neurohypophysis

Between 1996 and 2020, 12,565 cases were enrolled in the German Registry of Pituitary Tumors including 10,084 PitNETs (10,067 adenomas and 19 carcinomas obtained surgically and 193 adenomas diagnosed at autopsy) as well as 69 spindle cell tumors of the neurohypophysis (64 surgical specimens and 5 autopsies). In six patients (1 post mortem and 5 surgical specimens), PitNETs as well as posterior lobe tumors were found in the specimens. Two of the PitNETs were sparsely granulated prolactin-producing tumors, combined in one case with a granular cell tumor and in one case with a pituicytoma. One of the PitNETs revealed that autopsy was a sparsely granulated GH tumor combined with a neurohypophyseal granular cell tumor. Two PitNETs were null cell adenomas combined with a pituicytoma and a spindle cell oncocytoma, respectively. Further, one Crooke cell tumor was combined with a spindle cell oncocytoma. In five cases, the PitNETs were larger than the posterior lobe tumors and accounted for the clinical symptoms. Previously, four cases of co-existing pituitary anterior and posterior lobe tumors were described in the literature, comprising two ACTH PitNETs, one gonadotrophic PitNET and one null cell PitNET, each in combination with a pituicytoma. PitNETs and concomitant granular cell tumor or spindle cell oncocytoma, as observed in our cohort, have not been reported before.

Genetic and epigenetic characterization of posterior pituitary tumors

Pituicytoma (PITUI), granular cell tumor (GCT), and spindle cell oncocytoma (SCO) are rare tumors of the posterior pituitary. Histologically, they may be challenging to distinguish and have been proposed to represent a histological spectrum of a single entity. We performed targeted next-generation sequencing, DNA methylation profiling, and copy number analysis on 47 tumors (14 PITUI; 12 GCT; 21 SCO) to investigate molecular features and explore possibilities of clinically meaningful tumor subclassification. We detected two main epigenomic subgroups by unsupervised clustering of DNA methylation data, though the overall methylation differences were subtle. The largest group (n = 23) contained most PITUIs and a subset of SCOs and was enriched for pathogenic mutations within genes in the MAPK/PI3K pathways (12/17 [71%] of sequenced tumors: FGFR1 (3), HRAS (3), BRAF (2), NF1 (2), CBL (1), MAP2K2 (1), PTEN (1)) and two with accompanying TERT promoter mutation. The second group (n = 16) contained most GCTs and a subset of SCOs, all of which mostly lacked identifiable genetic drivers. Outcome analysis demonstrated that the presence of chromosomal imbalances was significantly associated with reduced progression-free survival especially within the combined PITUI and SCO group (p = 0.031). In summary, we observed only subtle DNA methylation differences between posterior pituitary tumors, indicating that these tumors may be best classified as subtypes of a single entity. Nevertheless, our data indicate differences in mutation patterns and clinical outcome. For a clinically meaningful subclassification, we propose a combined histo-molecular approach into three subtypes: one subtype is defined by granular cell histology, scarcity of identifiable oncogenic mutations, and favorable outcome. The other two subtypes have either SCO or PITUI histology but are segregated by chromosomal copy number profile into a favorable group (no copy number changes) and a less favorable group (copy number imbalances present). Both of the latter groups have recurrent MAPK/PI3K genetic alterations that represent potential therapeutic targets.

Clinical-Pathological, Immunohistochemical, and Genetic Characterization of a Series of Posterior Pituitary Tumors

Posterior pituitary tumors are supposed to represent the morphological spectrum of a single entity. Herein, we report the clinical-pathological, immunohistochemical, and genetic features of 5 spindle cell oncocytomas (SCOs), 3 pituicytomas, and 1 granular cell tumor (GCT). SCOs had the highest local invasiveness and affected older subjects. The 3 histotypes differed in the content of spindle cells (predominant in pituicytoma and absent in GCT), presence of lymphocytic infiltrate (in SCO and GCT, but not in the pituicytoma) and EMA/GFAP staining (negative in GCT; EMA-positive/GFAP-negative in 4/5 SCO and GFAP-positive in 3/3 pituicytomas). Three SCOs and 1 pituicytoma analyzed with next-generation sequencing had no mutations in 409 genes. However, 1 SCO had previously unreported homozygous deletion of CDKN2A/B and another of SMARCA4, SMARCB1, and NF2. All 3 SCOs had loss of heterozygosity of chromosome 1p, while the pituicytoma had chromosome 19 homozygous loss and chromosomes 10, 13q, and 18q loss of heterozygosity. Since 1p and 13q losses were previously reported in 1 pituicytoma and 1 SCO, respectively, our data demonstrate that posterior pituitary tumors share common genetic alterations. The possibility that posterior pituitary tumors are SMARCA4/SMARCB1-deficient should be kept in mind in the differential diagnosis toward other entities.

Risk factors for tumor recurrence and progression of spindle cell oncocytoma of the pituitary gland: a systematic review and pooled analysis

INTRODUCTION

Spindle cell oncocytoma (SCO) is an extremely rare sellar neoplasm. No observational studies have been reported so far to investigate the prognostic factors of this tumor entity. This systematic review aimed to elucidate the risk factors for tumor recurrence/progression of SCO.

METHODS

We searched for relevant articles in PubMed and Web of Science. Studies providing individual patient data with follow-up information of SCO cases were included. Pearson's Chi square and Fisher's exact test were used for categorical variables while t test or Mann-Whitney tests were applied for continuous variables, if applicable. We used the Cox regression model to assess the effects of suspected variables on progression-free survival (PFS).

RESULTS

A total of 38 case reports and case series comprising of 67 SCOs were included for final analyses. Recurrent/progressive tumors were noted in 38.8% of cases. Among the clinicopathological factors, only the extent of surgery was a significant risk factor for tumor recurrence/progression. SCO patients with a subtotal resection had a significantly higher risk for tumor relapse in comparison with complete removal (HR 7.51; 95% CI 1.75-32.31; p = 0.007).

CONCLUSION

Our study demonstrated the characteristic clinicopathological features of SCOs with a high recurrence/progression rate and outlined the predictor for tumor relapse. Failure to achieve gross total resection is the only risk factor for tumor recurrence/progression.

A Comprehensive Study of Spindle Cell Oncocytoma of the Pituitary Gland: Series of 6 Cases and Meta-Analysis of 85 Cases

OBJECTIVE

To discuss optimal treatment strategy for spindle cell oncocytoma (SCO) of the pituitary gland.

METHODS

Institutional cases were retrospectively reviewed. A systematic literature search and subsequent quantitative synthesis were performed for further analysis. The detailed features were summarized and the tumor control rate (TCR) was calculated.

RESULTS

Eighty-five patients (6 institutional and 79 literature) were included. The annual incidence was approximately 0.01-0.03/100,000. The mean age was 56 years. Vision loss was present in 60%. Seventy-three percent showed hormonal abnormalities. On magnetic resonance imaging, tumor was avidly enhancing, and the normal gland was commonly displaced anterosuperiorly. Evidence of hypervascularity was seen in 77%. Gross total resection (GTR) was achieved in only 24% because of its hypervascular, fibrous, and adhesive nature. The mean postoperative follow-up was 3.3 years for institutional cases and 2.3 years for the integrated cohort. The TCR was significantly better after GTR (5-year TCR, 75%; P = 0.012) and marginally better after non-GTR + upfront radiotherapy (5-year TCR, 76%; P = 0.103) than after non-GTR alone (5-year TCR, 24%). The TCRs for those with low Ki-67 index (≤5%) were marginally better than those with higher Ki-67 index (5-year rate, 57% vs. 23%; P = 0.110).

CONCLUSIONS

Frequent endocrine-related symptoms, hypervascular signs, and anterosuperior displacement of the gland support preoperative diagnosis of SCO. GTR seems to have better long-term tumor control, whereas the fibrous, hypervascular, and adhesive nature of SCO makes it difficult to achieve GTR. In patients with non-GTR, radiotherapy may help decrease tumor progression.

Primary Tumors of the Posterior Pituitary Gland: A Systematic Review of the Literature in Light of the New 2017 World Health Organization Classification of Pituitary Tumors

OBJECTIVE

The rare clinical entity of primary posterior pituitary tumors (PPTs) includes pituicytomas, granular cell tumors, spine cell oncocytomas, and sellar ependymomas. The recent World Health Organization classification of PPTs based on thyroid transcription factor 1 positivity has led to more investigations into the epidemiology, clinical presentation, nature history, histologic features, and operative characteristics of these tumors. The aim of this review is to summarize the characteristics of primary PPTs.

METHODS

Our summary involved an in-depth review of the literature on PPTs. Our systematic review was carried out using the PubMed database and PRISMA guidelines.

RESULTS

An initial search identified 282 publications. After strict application of the inclusion criteria, we found 16 articles for case series of patients with primary PPT (N > 5), which were included in our table for literature review. An additional 10 articles were review articles on PPTs published in the last 20 years and were used as resource for our systematic review. An extensive analysis was then performed to extract relevant clinical data with respect to the clinical radiologic histopathologic profile of primary PPTs and their treatment outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

Primary PPTs are a rare group of pituicyte-derived low-grade nonneuroendocrine neoplasms that arise from the sellar region. The nondescript radiographic findings and subtle endocrine abnormalities also veil their accurate diagnostic prediction. As shown through the narrative as well as the literature review, there is still a lot to be understood about PPTs. A prospective multicenter registry of these rare tumors would benefit both the neurosurgical as well as the endocrinologic knowledge base.

Primary tumors of the posterior pituitary: A systematic review

In 2017, the World Health Organization established that pituicytoma, granular cell tumor (GCT), spindle cell oncocytoma (SCO) and sellar ependymomas (SE) are posterior pituitary tumors (PPT). They probably arise from the pituicytes and may constitute a unique histopathological entity. We carried out a systematic review using PubMed's database. A total of 266 patients with pathological diagnosis of PPT (135 pituicytomas, 69 GCT, 47 SCO, 8 SE and 7 mixed histology tumors) were analyzed. Gender distribution was identical and median age at diagnosis was 48 ± 21.8 years. Main presentation symptoms were visual disorders (n = 142; 58.1%), headache (n = 99; 40.5%), hypopituitarism (n = 84; 34.4%), hypercortisolism (n = 10; 4.1%), polyuriapolydipsia (n = 6; 2.4%) and acromegaly features (n = 5; 2.0%). On MRI, 122 (47.6%) patients showed sellar with suprasellar extension masses, 67 (23.1%) were suprasellar and 63 (24.6%) exclusively sellar. Median tumor size was 22.0 ± 14.2 mm. Two hundred sixty four patients underwent surgery, transphenoidal access was selected in 132 (64.4%) and craniotomy in 58 (28.3%). Complications were hypopituitarism (n = 70; 42.1%), diabetes insipidus (n = 55; 33.1%) and hemorrhage (n = 50; 30.1%). Tumor persisted in 93 patients (45.6%) and recurred in 13 (6.4%). Regarding comparison between main types of PPT, SCO patients were diagnosed later (60.0 vs 47.0 vs 47.0 years, p = 0.023), the tumor was larger 25.0 mm [10.8] vs 20.0 mm [14.2] vs 2.0 mm [15.0] and they were frequently sellar with suprasellar extension tumors (71.7% vs 46.2% vs 32.8%, p = 0.003) compared to pituicytoma and GCT. In conclusion, PPT are rare tumors and have been misdiagnosed mainly as non-functioning pituitary adenomas. Different types of PPT share similar epidemiology, clinical manifestations and surgical outcomes. Surgery is the only curative option but complications and subtotal resection are common.

Evaluation of expression of somatostatin receptor 1, 2, 3, 5 and dopamine D2 receptor in spindle cell oncocytomas of posterior pituitary

PURPOSE

Spindle cell oncocytomas (SCOs) are very rare tumors of the posterior pituitary with potential for locally aggressive behaviour. Their treatment includes surgery and possibly radiotherapy, however other options are lacking. Somatostatin receptors (SSTs) are a possible therapeutic target for somatostatin analogues and their expression has been demonstrated recently in closely related pituicytomas, but there are no data about their presence in SCOs.

METHODS

We collected five cases of SCO from four patients including one recurrent case. Immunohistochemical detection of TTF1, GFAP, CD68, SST₁, SST₂, SST₃, SST₅ and D2 dopamine receptor (D2DR) was performed. Intensity, percentage of positive cells and pattern of expression was evaluated in semiquantitative fashion. Protein expression of SST_1-5 and D2DR was further evaluated by western blot.

RESULTS

Mean patient age was 61.8 years (range 47-71 years) with male to female ratio 1:1. In one patient, samples from the original tumor and its recurrence 16 years later were assessed. TTF1 was positive in all five cases, no expression of GFAP and CD68 was seen. Immunohistochemical expression of SST₁ was noted in 1/5 cases, SST₂ in 2/5 cases, including recurrent case but not the original case. SST₃ was expressed in 3/5 tumors and D2 dopamine receptor in 4/5 cases. Western blot was successfully performed in four samples. SST₂, SST₃ and D2DR expression was identified in all the samples, including two cases originally negative for SST₂ and one case negative for SST₃ by immunohistochemistry. The number of positive cells and level of expression varied among different areas of the same tumors. No expression of SST₅ was observed. In the patient with the recurrent tumor, intensity of SST₂, SST₃ and D2DR expression varied between original tumor and its recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated presence of different SST subtypes and D2DR in spindle cell oncocytomas. The most commonly expressed subtype was SST₂ and SST₃, while no expression of SST₅ was observed. Expression showed spatial heterogeneity and temporal changes as seen in the recurrent case. The biological meaning of SSTs expression in SCOs is unclear as well as whether it may be exploited in treatment of selected cases.

Posterior pituitary tumours: the spectrum of a unique entity. A clinical and histological study of a large case series

PURPOSE

In 2017, the WHO established that pituicytoma, granular cell tumour (GCT) and spindle cell oncocytoma (SCO) are posterior pituitary tumours (PPT). Recent data suggests that these tumours probably arise from the pituicytes and may constitute a spectrum of a unique histopathological entity. Our aim is to report the clinical findings and surgical outcomes of 16 patients with PPT. We also evaluated the tissue specimens available in light of current knowledge.

METHOD

Cross-sectional study with retrospective data.

RESULTS

PPT were 7 pituicytomas, 3 GCT and 6 SCO. Patients mean age was 55 years old and 75% were female. Basal hormonal study showed hyperprolactinemia (43.7%) and hypopituitarism (37.5%). There was no case of diabetes insipidus (DI). MRI showed sellar/suprasellar masses with mean size of 19.7mm. PPT was not suspected in any patient. Fifteen patients underwent surgery and complications were common: 20% had perioperative bleeding (one patient died because of a massive haemorrhage), 57.1% hypopituitarism, 35.7% permanent DI and 21.4% underwent a second surgery. Pathological findings shown positivity for thyroid transcription factor 1, vimentin and negativity for cytokeratin and chromogranin A in all specimens evaluated. S100 protein was positive in 88.8% of tumours. Ki67 was ≥ 3% in 66.6% and ranged from 4-7% in SCO.

CONCLUSION

PPT have similar histology, clinical features and are frequently misdiagnosed as nonfunctioning pituitary tumours. However, post-surgical complications including haemorrhage are common. A high clinical suspicion is needed to presume the diagnosis prior surgery and diminish the high morbidity of these tumours.

Management of pituicytomas: a multicenter series of eight cases

PURPOSE

Pituicytomas and spindle cell oncocytomas (SCOs) are two rare neoplasms of the sellar and suprasellar region, known to be challenging as they are extremely vascular and almost always misdiagnosed, altering our surgical planning and the patients' outcomes. Also we argue that recent update concerning the pathology findings of these tumors should be more widely generalized to our practice.

METHODS

This is a retrospective multicenter study, reporting the clinical manifestations, radiological characteristics, histopathological features, treatment strategies and long-term outcomes of patients who have been treated for a Pituicytoma at various institutions in Paris, France over the past 10 years. In addition, we compared our results to the world literature in order to identify similarities concerning the radiographic diagnosis and the treatment strategies of these tumors.

RESULTS

Eight patients were operated on in four different hospitals. Misdiagnosis was constant before surgery, pituitary adenoma or craniopharyngioma being suspected. During surgery (transsphenoidal approach: six cases, transcranial approach: two cases) unusual tumors were noted, with important bleeding in most cases. Complete resection could be obtained in five patients. Pathological diagnosis was confirmed in all cases. During the follow up two recurrences occurred. One was subsequently treated with radiotherapy, the other underwent a second surgery.

CONCLUSION

Recent updates concerning the histological diagnosis of pituicytomas should be generalized to our practice in order to provide a better understanding of this rare pathology and its natural course.

Welcoming the new WHO classification of pituitary tumors 2017: revolution in TTF-1-positive posterior pituitary tumors

The fourth edition of the World Health Organization classification of endocrine tumors (EN-WHO2017) was released in 2017. In this new edition, changes in the classification of non-neuroendocrine tumors are proposed particularly in tumors arising in the posterior pituitary. These tumors are a distinct group of low-grade neoplasms of the sellar region that express thyroid transcription factor-1, and include pituicytoma, granular cell tumor of the sellar region, spindle cell oncocytoma, and sellar ependymoma. This short review focuses on the classification of posterior pituitary tumors newly proposed in EN-WHO2017, and controversies in their pathological differential diagnosis are discussed based on recent cases.

Immunoprofiling of glial tumours of the neurohypophysis suggests a common pituicytic origin of neoplastic cells

PURPOSE

To analyse the antigen expression profiles of 27 cases of pituicytoma, spindle cell oncocytoma, and granular cell tumour of the sellar region concerning a common pituicytic origin of neoplastic cells.

METHODS

Material from 12 female and 15 male patients (13 granular cell tumours of the sellar region, 10 pituicytomas, four spindle cell oncocytomas) collected in the German Registry of Pituitary Tumours between 1993 and 2015 was re-evaluated according to the current WHO classification of tumours of the central nervous system and supplementary immunohistochemistry including S100-protein, CD56, CD68, thyroid transcription factor-1 (TTF-1), and Ki-67 was performed.

RESULTS

S100-protein was detected in all 27 tumours and TTF-1 in all 16 tumours that were assessed. Vimentin was expressed in all 13 cases investigated whereas broad spectrum cytokeratin was not detected in any of 14 evaluated cases. GFAP was observed in nine out of 21 cases. 15 out of 17 investigated lesions showed some CD68 expression and five out of 14 cases were labelled with CD56 antibodies. Proliferative activity did not differ significantly between the three tumour subgroups although one primary and one recurrent pituicytoma showed exceptionally high Ki-67-proliferation indices of 15.3 and 12.7 %, respectively (means: granular cell tumour of the sellar region 2.0 %, pituicytoma 2.8 %, spindle cell oncocytoma 2.7 %).

CONCLUSIONS

The study confirms and expands earlier data and is in line with the notion that the three tumour types are variants of pituicytoma.