Mechanical properties of human hepatic tissues to develop liver-mimicking phantoms for medical applications

Using liver phantoms for mimicking human tissue in clinical training, disease diagnosis, and treatment planning is a common practice. The fabrication material of the liver phantom should exhibit mechanical properties similar to those of the real liver organ in the human body. This tissue-equivalent material is essential for qualitative and quantitative investigation of the liver mechanisms in producing nutrients, excretion of waste metabolites, and tissue deformity at mechanical stimulus. This paper reviews the mechanical properties of human hepatic tissues to develop liver-mimicking phantoms. These properties include viscosity, elasticity, acoustic impedance, sound speed, and attenuation. The advantages and disadvantages of the most common fabrication materials for developing liver tissue-mimicking phantoms are also highlighted. Such phantoms will give a better insight into the real tissue damage during the disease progression and preservation for transplantation. The liver tissue-mimicking phantom will raise the quality assurance of patient diagnostic and treatment precision and offer a definitive clinical trial data collection.

Mechanical properties of tissue-mimicking composites formed by material jetting additive manufacturing

Capitalizing on features including high resolution, smooth surface finish, large build volume, and simultaneous multi-color/multi-material printing, material jetting additive manufacturing enables the fabrication of full-scale anatomic models. The ability to print materials that resemble relevant, compliant tissues has especially motivated implementation of material jetting for patient-specific surgical planning or training models. In an effort to broaden the material selection for the material jetting process, and to provide materials that more closely mimic the functional needs for a wider variety of tissues, a composite material system is explored that uses non-curing fluid dispersed into a photo-curable medium. The material properties of the composites are examined through both thermal and mechanical analysis (dynamic mechanical analysis, Shore hardness testing, puncture testing, and tensile testing). Higher contributions of non-curing fluid generally reduce part strength and stiffness, and exponential and second-order polynomial expressions are appropriate fits for many of the mechanical properties as functions of non-curing fluid concentration. Through the fundamental exploration of the impact of an added diluent on material properties, the study advances knowledge on the process-property relationship for multi-material jetting. Additionally, better understanding of the mechanical property space offered by these materials will expand the capabilities of material jetting in the context of biomedical applications. The collection of mechanical properties serve as reference data sets to facilitate quicker screening for tissue-mimicking, medical models.

Development of a Tissue-Mimicking Phantom of the Brain for Ultrasonic Studies

Constructing tissue-mimicking phantoms of the brain for ultrasonic studies is complicated by the low backscatter coefficient of brain tissue, causing difficulties in simultaneously matching the backscatter and attenuation properties. In this work, we report on the development of a polyvinyl alcohol-based tissue-mimicking phantom with properties approaching those of human brain tissue. Polyvinyl alcohol was selected as the base material for the phantom as its properties can be varied by freeze-thaw cycling, variations in concentration and the addition of scattering inclusions, allowing some independent control of backscatter and attenuation. The ultrasonic properties (including speed of sound, attenuation and backscatter) were optimized using these methods with talc powder as an additive. It was determined that the ultrasonic properties of the phantom produced in this study are best matched to brain tissue in the frequency range 1-3 MHz, indicating its utility for laboratory ultrasonic studies in this frequency range.

PVCP-based anthropomorphic breast phantoms containing structures similar to lactiferous ducts for ultrasound imaging: A comparison with human breasts

The purpose of this work was to obtain an anthropomorphic phantom with acoustic properties similar to those of breast tissue, possessing lactiferous duct-like structures, which would be a first for this type of phantom. Breast lesions usually grow in glandular tissues or lactiferous ducts. Shape variations in these structures are detectable by using ultrasound imaging. To increase early diagnosis, it is important to develop computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) systems and improve medical training. Using tissue-like materials that mimic known internal structures can help achieve both of these goals. However, most breast ultrasound phantoms described in the literature emulate only fat tissues and lesion-like masses. In addition, commercially available phantoms claim to be realistic, but do not contain lactiferous duct structures. In this work, we collected reference images from both breasts of ten healthy female volunteers aged between 20 and 30 years using a 10 MHz linear transducer of a B-mode medical ultrasound system. Histograms of the grey scale distribution of each tissue component of interest, the grey level means, and standard deviations of the regions of interest were obtained. Phantoms were produced using polyvinyl chloride plastisol (PVCP) suspensions. The lactiferous duct-like structures were prepared using pure PVCP. Solid scatterers, such as alumina (mesh #100) and graphite powders (mesh #140) were added to the phantom matrix to mimic glandular and fat tissue, respectively. The phantom duct-like structure diameters observed on B-mode images (1.92 mm ± 0.44) were similar to real measures obtained with a micrometer (2.08 mm ± 0.23). The phantom ducts are easy to produce and are largely stable for at least one year. This phantom allows the researchers to elaborate the structure at their will and may be used in training and as a reference for development of CAD systems.

Simultaneous Evaluation of Thermal and Non-Thermal Effects of High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound on a Tissue-Mimicking Phantom

Physiologically relevant phantoms with high reliability are essential for extending the therapeutic applications of high-intensity therapeutic ultrasound. Here we describe a tissue-mimicking phantom capable of quantifying temperature changes and observing non-thermal phenomena by high-intensity therapeutic ultrasound. Using polydiacetylene liposomes, we fabricated agar-based polydiacetylene hydrogel phantoms (PHPs) that not only respond to temperature, but also have acoustic properties similar to those of human liver tissue. The color of PHPs changed from blue to red depending on the temperature in the range 40°C-70°C, where the red/blue ratio of PHP had a good linearity of 99.06% for the temperature changes. Furthermore, repeated high-intensity focused ultrasound led to histotripsy on the PHP with liquefied and damaged areas measuring 0.7 and 4.0 cm², respectively, at the signal generator amplitude setting voltage of 80 mV. Our results indicate not only the usability of the thermochromic phantom, but also its potential for evaluating non-thermal phenomena in various high-intensity focused ultrasound therapies.

Characterization and evaluation of tissue-mimicking gelatin phantoms for use with MRgFUS

Background

A tissue-mimicking phantom that accurately represents human-tissue properties is important for safety testing and for validating new imaging techniques. To achieve a variety of desired human-tissue properties, we have fabricated and tested several variations of gelatin phantoms. These phantoms are simple to manufacture and have properties in the same order of magnitude as those of soft tissues. This is important for quality-assurance verification as well as validation of magnetic resonance-guided focused ultrasound (MRgFUS) treatment techniques.

Methods

The phantoms presented in this work were constructed from gelatin powders with three different bloom values (125, 175, and 250), each one allowing for a different mechanical stiffness of the phantom. Evaporated milk was used to replace half of the water in the recipe for the gelatin phantoms in order to achieve attenuation and speed of sound values in soft tissue ranges. These acoustic properties, along with MR (T₁ and T₂*), mechanical (density and Young’s modulus), and thermal properties (thermal diffusivity and specific heat capacity), were obtained through independent measurements for all three bloom types to characterize the gelatin phantoms. Thermal repeatability of the phantoms was also assessed using MRgFUS and MR thermometry.

Results

All the measured values fell within the literature-reported ranges of soft tissues. In heating tests using low-power (6.6 W) sonications, interleaved with high-power (up to 22.0 W) sonications, each of the three different bloom phantoms demonstrated repeatable temperature increases (10.4 ± 0.3 °C for 125-bloom, 10.2 ± 0.3 °C for 175-bloom, and 10.8 ± 0.2 °C for 250-bloom for all 6.6-W sonications) for heating durations of 18.1 s.

Conclusion

These evaporated milk-modified gelatin phantoms should serve as reliable, general soft tissue-mimicking MRgFUS phantoms.

Reusable tissue-mimicking hydrogel phantoms for focused ultrasound ablation

The ability of N-isopropylacrylamide (NIPAM)-based hydrogel phantoms to mimic tissues with different acoustic and thermal properties under high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) ablation was investigated. These phantoms were designed to model the formation of thermal lesions in tissues above the threshold temperature of protein denaturation. By adjusting the concentration of acrylic acid (AAc) in the NIPAM-based hydrogel phantoms, the cloud point (i.e., lower critical solution temperature) of the phantoms could be tailored to produce HIFU thermal lesions similar to those formed in different swine tissues in terms of size and shape. Additionally, energy thresholds for inducing transient or permanent bubbles in the phantoms during HIFU ablation were also identified to shed light on the onset of cavitation or material damage. The NIPAM-based hydrogel phantoms developed in this study possess major advantages such as transparent, reusable and tailorable properties, and are practical tools for characterizing an ablative device (or treatment) to determine its efficacy and safety.

Paraffin-gel tissue-mimicking material for ultrasound-guided needle biopsy phantom

Paraffin-gel waxes have been investigated as new soft tissue-mimicking materials for ultrasound-guided breast biopsy training. Breast phantoms were produced with a broad range of acoustical properties. The speed of sound for the phantoms ranged from 1425.4 ± 0.6 to 1480.3 ± 1.7 m/s at room temperature. The attenuation coefficients were easily controlled between 0.32 ± 0.27 dB/cm and 2.04 ± 0.65 dB/cm at 7.5 MHz, depending on the amount of carnauba wax added to the base material. The materials do not suffer dehydration and provide adequate needle penetration, with a Young's storage modulus varying between 14.7 ± 0.2 kPa and 34.9 ± 0.3 kPa. The phantom background material possesses long-term stability and can be employed in a supine position without changes in geometry. These results indicate that paraffin-gel waxes may be promising materials for training radiologists in ultrasound biopsy procedures.