Expression of Norwalk virus capsid protein in transgenic tobacco and potato and its oral immunogenicity in mice

Alternatives to cell culture systems for production of recombinant proteins could make very safe vaccines at a lower cost. We have used genetically engineered plants for expression of candidate vaccine antigens with the goal of using the edible plant organs for economical delivery of oral vaccines. Transgenic tobacco and potato plants were created that express the capsid protein of Norwalk virus, a calicivirus that causes epidemic acute gastroenteritis in humans. The capsid protein could be extracted from tobacco leaves in the form of 38-nm Norwalk virus-like particles. Recombinant Norwalk virus-like particle (rNV) was previously recovered when the same gene was expressed in recombinant baculovirus-infected insect cells. The capsid protein expressed in tobacco leaves and potato tubers cosedimented in sucrose gradients with insect cell-derived rNV and appeared identical to insect cell-derived rNV on immunoblots of SDS/polyacrylamide gels. The plant-expressed rNV was orally immunogenic in mice. Extracts of tobacco leaf expressing rNV were given to CD1 mice by gavage, and the treated mice developed both serum IgG and secretory IgA specific for rNV. Furthermore, when potato tubers expressing rNV were fed directly to mice, they developed serum IgG specific for rNV. These results indicate the potential usefulness of plants for production and delivery of edible vaccines. This is an appropriate technology for developing countries where vaccines are urgently needed.

Transgenic Plants Created for Oral Immunization Against Diarrheal Diseases

We have created transgenic plants that express subunit antigens of infectious bacteria and viruses. These proteins have been isolated and characterized to demonstrate that they retain immunogenic properties. When raw potatoes containing the recombinant immunogens were fed to mice, the animals were orally immunized. Research completed to date has demonstrated the feasibility of using a genetically-engineered food as an inexpensive oral vaccine production and delivery system for diarrheal disease. The system could be a convenient means to deliver vaccines to travelers. It also has great potential as an appropriate technology for producing vaccines "in country" in the developing world. This review focuses on work from our group on recombinant subunit vaccines in potato tubers against enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli and Norwalk virus.

Transgenic plants as vaccine production systems

Transgenic plants that express foreign proteins with industrial or pharmaceutical value represent an economical alternative to fermentation-based production systems. Specific vaccines have been produced in plants as a result of the transient or stable expression of foreign genes. It has recently been shown that genes encoding antigens of bacterial and viral pathogens can be expressed in plants in a form in which they retain native immunogenic properties. Transgenic potato tubers expressing a bacterial antigen stimulated humoral and mucosal immune responses when they were provided as food. These results provide 'proof of concept' for the use of plants as a vehicle to produce vaccines.

Oral immunization with a recombinant bacterial antigen produced in transgenic plants

The binding subunit of Escherichia coli heat-labile enterotoxin (LT-B) is a highly active oral immunogen. Transgenic tobacco and potato plants were made with the use of genes encoding LT-B or an LT-B fusion protein with a microsomal retention sequence. The plants expressed the foreign peptides, both of which formed oligomers that bound the natural ligand. Mice immunized by gavage produced serum and gut mucosal anti-LT-B immunoglobulins that neutralized the enterotoxin in cell protection assays. Feeding mice fresh transgenic potato tubers also caused oral immunization.

Immunophysiology of the gut: a research frontier for integrative studies of the common mucosal immune system

This review highlights work that, within the past decade, transformed mucosal immunophysiology from a hypothetical concept to a fully recognized interdiscipline. The regulation of epithelial and smooth muscle functions by the mucosal immune system represents an exquisitely sensitive adaptation to local antigenic challenge. Furthermore, immunologic cells communicate with nerves via paracrine secretions to rapidly transduce antigenic signals into panmucosal changes in function. These local immunocyte-nerve interactions are modulated by the autonomic and central nervous systems. Because of the common mucosal immune system, antigen-induced changes similar to those occurring in the intestine and colon are predicted to occur in mucosa of all hollow organs. The drawing together of fields as diverse as medicine and agriculture underscores the scope of areas encompassed by immunophysiology. Newly acquired knowledge has positioned the field to advance rapidly in both basic and applied directions. Forces that will remodel the field in the next decade will be derived from public concerns about human health maintenance and the explosive and novel use of new research tools stemming from molecular biology. These forces will draw on and advance our knowledge in areas as diverse as vaccine development and prevention of allergic reactions to foods, bioengineered foods in particular.

Expression of hepatitis B surface antigen in transgenic plants

Tobacco plants were genetically transformed with the gene encoding hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) linked to a nominally constitutive promoter. Enzyme-linked immunoassays using a monoclonal antibody directed against human serum-derived HBsAg revealed the presence of HBsAg in extracts of transformed leaves at levels that correlated with mRNA abundance. This suggests that there were no major inherent limitations of transcription or translation of this foreign gene in plants. Recombinant HBsAg was purified from transgenic plants by immunoaffinity chromatography and examined by electron microscopy. Spherical particles with an average diameter of 22 nm were observed in negatively stained preparations. Sedimentation of transgenic plant extracts in sucrose and cesium chloride density gradients showed that the recombinant HBsAg and human serum-derived HBsAg had similar physical properties. Because the HBsAg produced in transgenic plants is antigenically and physically similar to the HBsAg particles derived from human serum and recombinant yeast, which are used as vaccines, we conclude that transgenic plants hold promise as low-cost vaccine production systems.

Deletion Mutagenesis of the Cytochrome b559 Protein Inactivates the Reaction Center of Photosystem II

In green plant-like photosynthesis, oxygen evolution is catalyzed by a thylakoid membrane-bound protein complex, photosystem II. Cytochrome b559, a protein component of the reaction center of this complex, is absent in a genetically engineered mutant of the cyanobacterium, Synechocystis 6803 [Pakrasi, H.B., Williams, J.G.K., and Arntzen, C.J. (1988). EMBO J. 7, 325-332]. In this mutant, the genes psbE and psbF, encoding cytochrome b559, were deleted by targeted mutagenesis. Two other protein components, D1 and D2 of the photosystem II reaction center, are also absent in this mutant. However, two chlorophyll-binding proteins, CP47 and CP43, as well as a manganese-stabilizing extrinsic protein component of photosystem II are stably assembled in the thylakoids of this mutant. Thus, this deletion mutation destabilizes the reaction center of photosystem II only. The mutant also lacks a fluorescence maximum peak at 695 nm (at 77 K) even though the CP47 protein, considered to be the origin of this fluorescence peak, is present in this mutant. We propose that the fluorescence at 695 nm originates from an interaction between the reaction center of photosystem II and CP47. The deletion mutant shows the absence of variable fluorescence at room temperature, indicating that its photosystem II complex is photochemically inactive. Also, photoreduction of QA, the primary acceptor quinone in photosystem II, could not be detected in the mutant. We conclude that cytochrome b559 plays at least an essential structural role in the reaction center of photosystem II.

Deletion Mutagenesis of the Cytochrome b559 Protein Inactivates the Reaction Center of Photosystem II

In green plant-like photosynthesis, oxygen evolution is catalyzed by a thylakoid membrane-bound protein complex, photosystem II. Cytochrome b559, a protein component of the reaction center of this complex, is absent in a genetically engineered mutant of the cyanobacterium, Synechocystis 6803 [Pakrasi, H.B., Williams, J.G.K., and Arntzen, C.J. (1988). EMBO J. 7, 325-332]. In this mutant, the genes psbE and psbF, encoding cytochrome b559, were deleted by targeted mutagenesis. Two other protein components, D1 and D2 of the photosystem II reaction center, are also absent in this mutant. However, two chlorophyll-binding proteins, CP47 and CP43, as well as a manganese-stabilizing extrinsic protein component of photosystem II are stably assembled in the thylakoids of this mutant. Thus, this deletion mutation destabilizes the reaction center of photosystem II only. The mutant also lacks a fluorescence maximum peak at 695 nm (at 77 K) even though the CP47 protein, considered to be the origin of this fluorescence peak, is present in this mutant. We propose that the fluorescence at 695 nm originates from an interaction between the reaction center of photosystem II and CP47. The deletion mutant shows the absence of variable fluorescence at room temperature, indicating that its photosystem II complex is photochemically inactive. Also, photoreduction of QA, the primary acceptor quinone in photosystem II, could not be detected in the mutant. We conclude that cytochrome b559 plays at least an essential structural role in the reaction center of photosystem II.

Targeted mutagenesis of the psbE and psbF genes blocks photosynthetic electron transport: evidence for a functional role of cytochrome b559 in photosystem II

The genes encoding the two subunits (alpha and beta) of the cytochrome b559 (cyt b559) protein, psbE and psbF, were cloned from the unicellular, transformable cyanobacterium, Synechocystis 6803. Cyt b559, an intrinsic membrane protein, is a component of photosystem II, a membrane-protein complex that catalyzes photosynthetic oxygen evolution. However, the role of cyt b559 in photosynthetic electron transport is yet to be determined. A high degree of homology was found between the cyanobacterial and green plant chloroplastidic psbE and psbE genes and in the amino acid sequences of their corresponding protein products. Cartridge mutagenesis techniques were used to generate a deletion mutant of Synechocystis 6803 in which the psbE and psbF genes were replaced by a kanamycin-resistance gene cartridge. Physiological analyses indicated that the PSII complexes of the mutant were inactivated. We conclude that cyt b559 is an essential component of PSII.

Sequencing and modification of psbB, the gene encoding the CP-47 protein of Photosystem II, in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis 6803

The Photosystem II protein CP-47 has been hypothesized to be involved in binding the reaction center chlorophyll. The psbB gene, encoding this protein, was cloned from the genome of the cyanobacterium Synechocystis 6803, and sequenced. The DNA sequence is 68% homologous with that of the psbB gene from spinach, whereas the predicted amino acid sequence is 76% homologous. The hydropathy patterns of Synechocystis and spinach CP-47 are almost indistinguishable, indicating the same general CP-47 folding pattern in the thylakoid membrane in the two species. There are five pairs of histidine residues in CP-47 that are spaced by 13 or 14 amino acids and that are located in hydrophobic regions of the protein; these histidine residues may be involved in chlorophyll binding. Interruption of the psbB gene by a DNA fragment carrying a gene conferring kanamycin resistance results in a loss of Photosystem II activity. This indicates that an intact CP-47 is required for a functional Photosystem II complex, but does not necessarily indicate that this protein would house the reaction center.

Evidence for two-step processing of nuclear-encoded chloroplast proteins during membrane assembly

A plastome (chloroplast genome) mutant of tobacco, lutescens-1, displays abnormal degradation of the chloroplast-encoded polypeptides which form the core complex of photosystem II (PSII). Two nuclear-encoded proteins (present in polymorphic forms), which normally function in the water oxidation process of PSII, accumulate as larger size-class polypeptides in mutant thylakoid membranes. These accumulated proteins are intermediate in size between the full-length primary protein synthesized in the cytoplasm and the proteolytically processed mature polypeptides. Trypsin treatment of unstacked mutant thylakoids and of inside-out vesicle (PSII-enriched) preparations indicated that the intermediate size forms were correctly localized on the inner surface of the thylakoid membrane, but not surface-exposed in the same way as the mature proteins. Only one of the intermediate size-class proteins could be extracted by salt washes. We interpret these data to be consistent with the idea that the two imported proteins that function in the water oxidation step of photosynthesis and are localized in the loculus (the space within the thylakoid vesicles) undergo two-step processing. The second step in proteolytic processing may be related to transport through a second membrane (the first transport step through the chloroplast envelope having been completed); this step may be arrested in the mutant due to the absence of the PSII core complex.

Monoclonal antibodies to the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b protein complex of photosystem II

A collection of 17 monoclonal antibodies elicited against the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b protein complex which serves photosystem II (LHC-II) of Pisum sativum shows six classes of binding specificity. Antibodies of two of the classes recognize a single polypeptide (the 28- or the 26- kD polypeptides), thereby suggesting that the two proteins are not derived from a common precursor. Other classes of antibodies cross-react with several polypeptides of LHC-II or with polypeptides of both LHC-II and the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b polypeptides of photosystem I (LHC-I), indicating that there are structural similarities among the polypeptides of LHC-II and LHC-I. The evidence for protein processing by which the 26-, 25.5-, and 24.5-kD polypeptides are derived from a common precursor polypeptide is discussed. Binding studies using antibodies specific for individual LHC-II polypeptides were used to quantify the number of antigenic polypeptides in the thylakoid membrane. 27 copies of the 26-kD polypeptide and two copies of the 28-kD polypeptide were found per 400 chlorophylls. In the chlorina f2 mutant of barley, and in intermittent light-treated barley seedlings, the amount of the 26-kD polypeptide in the thylakoid membranes was greatly reduced, while the amount of 28-kD polypeptide was apparently not affected. We propose that stable insertion and assembly of the 28-kD polypeptide, unlike the 26-kD polypeptide, is not regulated by the presence of chlorophyll b.

Developmental Loss of Photosystem II Activity and Structure in a Chloroplast-Encoded Tobacco Mutant, Lutescens-1

Lutescens-1, a tobacco mutant with a maternally inherited dysfunction, displayed an unusual developmental phenotype. In vivo measurement of chlorophyll fluorescence revealed deterioration in photosystem II (PSII) function as leaves expanded. Analysis of thylakoid membrane proteins by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis indicated the physical loss of nuclear- and chloroplast-encoded polypeptides comprising the PSII core complex concomitant with loss of activity. Freeze fracture electron micrographs of mutant thylakoids showed a reduced density, compared to wild type, of the EF(s) particles which have been shown previously to be the structural entity containing PSII core complexes and associated pigment-proteins. The selective loss of PSII cores from thylakoids resulted in a higher ratio of antenna chlorophyll to reaction centers and an altered 77 K chlorophyll fluorescence emission spectra; these data are interpreted to indicate functional isolation of light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b complexes in the absence of PSII centers. Examination of PSII reaction centers (which were present at lower levels in mutant membranes) by monitoring the light-dependent phosphorylation of PSII polypeptides and flash-induced O(2) evolution patterns demonstrated that the PSII cores which were assembled in mutant thylakoids were functionally identical to those of wild type. We conclude that the lutescens-1 mutation affected the correct stoichiometry of PSII centers, in relation to other membrane constituents, by disrupting the proper assembly and maintenance of PSII complexes in lutescens-1 thylakoid membranes.

Reconstitution of the Light Harvesting Chlorophyll a/b Pigment-Protein Complex into Developing Chloroplast Membranes Using a Dialyzable Detergent

Conditions were developed to isolate the light-harvesting chlorophyll-protein complex serving photosystem II (LHC-II) using a dialyzable detergent, octylpolyoxyethylene. This LHC-II was successfully reconstituted into partially developed chloroplast thylakoids of Hordeum vulgare var Morex (barley) seedlings which were deficient in LHC-II. Functional association of LHC-II with the photosystem II (PSII) core complex was measured by two independent functional assays of PSII sensitization by LHC-II. A 3-fold excess of reconstituted LHC-II was required to equal the activity of LHC developing in vivo. We suggest that a linker component may be absent in the partially developed membranes which is required for specific association of the PSII core complex and LHC-II.

Stability of chloroplastic triazine resistance in rutabaga backcross generations

Triazine resistance originally observed in a weed biotype of birdsrape (Brassica campestris L.) has been transferred through cytoplasmic substitution into rutabaga (Brassica napus ssp. Rapifera [Metzg.] Minsk.) by conventional backcrossing. Photosynthetic function and resistance to triazines were examined in six backcross generations of rutabaga as well as in the original parents. Chloroplast thylakoid membranes were isolated and their sensitivity to atrazine, metribuzin, and diuron assayed by measuring the inhibition of photoreduction of 1,6-dichlorophenol indophenol as well as the alteration of in vitro chlorophyll fluorescence rise characteristics. Both assay methods indicated that triazine resistance persisted in all rutabaga backcross generations, and that it involved triazine binding sites in chloroplasts. There was little resistance to diuron. In vivo chlorophyll fluorescence was also monitored, in the absence of herbicides, as an indicator of the electron transfer properties of the chloroplast photosystem II complex. The results indicated that electron transport from Q(A) to Q(B) was slower (as indicated by a larger intermediate level fluorescence during the transient rise) in the triazine resistant parents as well as in all the rutabaga backcross generations.

Analysis of Photosynthetic Antenna Function in a Mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Lacking trans-Hexadecenoic Acid

Several lines of evidence support the proposal that the unusual chloroplast-specific lipid acyl group Delta3,trans-hexadecenoic acid (trans-C(16:1)) stimulates the formation or maintenance of the oligomeric form of the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b complex (LHCP). To assess the functional significance of this apparent association we have analyzed LHCP structure and function in a mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) which lacks trans-C(16:1) by electrophoretic analysis of the protein-chlorophyll complexes and by measurements of chlorophyll fluorescence under a variety of conditions. By these criteria the putative oligomeric form of LHCP appears to be slightly more labile to detergent-mediated dissociation in the mutant. The oligomeric PSI chlorophyll-protein complex, associated with PSI, was also more labile to detergent-mediated dissociation in the mutant, suggesting a previously unsuspected association of trans-C(16:1) with the PSI complex. However, no significant effect of the mutation on the efficiency of energy transfer from LHCP to the photochemical reaction centers was observed under any of the various conditions imposed. Also, the stability of the chlorophyll-protein complexes to temperature-induced dissociation was unaffected in the mutant. The role of trans-C(16:1) is very subtle or is only conditionally expressed.

Paraquat resistance in conyza

A biotype of Conyza bonariensis (L.) Cronq. (identical to Conyza linefolia in other publications) originating in Egypt is resistant to the herbicide 1,1'-dimethyl-4,4'-bipyridinium ion (paraquat). Penetration of the cuticle by [(14)C]paraquat was greater in the resistant biotype than the susceptible (wild) biotype; therefore, resistance was not due to differences in uptake. The resistant and susceptible biotypes were indistinguishable by measuring in vitro photosystem I partial reactions using paraquat, 6,7-dihydrodipyrido [1,2-alpha:2',1'-c] pyrazinediium ion (diquat), or 7,8-dihydro-6H-dipyrido [1,2-alpha:2',1'-c] [1,4] diazepinediium ion (triquat) as electron acceptors. Therefore, alteration at the electron acceptor level of photosystem I is not the basis for resistance. Chlorophyll fluorescence measured in vivo was quenched in the susceptible biotype by leaf treatment with the bipyridinium herbicides. Resistance to quenching of in vivo chlorophyll fluorescence was observed in the resistant biotype, indicating that the herbicide was excluded from the chloroplasts. Movement of [(14)C] paraquat was restricted in the resistant biotype when excised leaves were supplied [(14)C]paraquat through the petiole. We propose that the mechanism of resistance to paraquat is exclusion of paraquat from its site of action in the chloroplast by a rapid sequestration mechanism. No differential binding of paraquat to cell walls isolated from susceptible and resistant biotypes could be detected. The exact site and mechanism of paraquat binding to sequester the herbicide remains to be determined.

The origin of the long-wavelength fluorescence emission band (77 degrees K) from photosystem I

Isolated photosystem I (PSI)-110 particles, prepared using a minimal concentration of Triton X-100 [J. E. Mullet, J. J. Burke, and C. J. Arntzen (1980) Plant Physiol. 65, 814-822] and further subjected to short-term solubilization with sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), were resolved into four pigment-containing bands on polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). We have identified these in order of increasing electrophoretic mobility as being (a) CPIa, (b) CPI, (c) the light-harvesting complex of photosystem I (LHC-I), and (d) a free pigment-zone. LHC-I had an absorption maximum in the red at 668-669 nm and a shoulder at 650 nm, which was resolved by its first-derivative spectrum to indicate the presence of chlorophyll b. LHC-I exhibited a 77 degrees K fluorescence emission maximum at 729-730 nm. The 77 degrees K fluorescence emission maxima of CPIa and CPI, excised from the gel, were at 729 and 722 nm, respectively. The LHC-I band, excised from the gel and rerun on dissociating SDS-PAGE, was resolved into two polypeptide doublets of 24-22.5 and 21-20.5 kDa. The CPIa band under similar conditions was resolved into polypeptides of 68, 24, 22.5, 21, 20.5, 19, 15, and 14 kDa; on the contrary, CPI contained only the 68-kDa polypeptide. When intact thylakoids were subjected to "nondenaturing" SDS-PAGE, LHC-I comigrated with an oligomeric form (dimer) of the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b pigment-protein that preferentially serves photosystem II (LHCP-II). When this combined LHC-I/LHCP-II pigment-protein band was prepared by SDS-PAGE from isolated stroma lamellae, it exhibited a long-wavelength fluorescence band near 730 nm at 77 degrees K. When a similar preparation was obtained from sucrose density gradients containing SDS [J. Argyroudi-Akoyunoglou and H. Thomou (1981) FEBS Lett. 135, 171-181], it was found to be enriched in a 21-kDa polypeptide. The data suggest that the 21-kDa polypeptide of LHC-I is the chlorophyll-containing polypeptide responsible for the long-wavelength fluorescence of LHC-I; other polypeptides in the complex (20.5, 22.5, and 24 kDa) presumably bind chlorophyll and also serve an antennae function.

Membrane protein damage and repair: removal and replacement of inactivated 32-kilodalton polypeptides in chloroplast membranes

Incubation of Chlamydomonas reinhardii cells at light levels that are several times more intense than those at which the cells were grown results in a loss of photosystem II function (termed photoinhibition). The loss of activity corresponded to the disappearance from the chloroplast membranes of a lysine-deficient, herbicide-binding protein of 32,000 daltons which is thought to be the apoprotein of the secondary quinone electron acceptor of photosystem II (the QB protein). In vivo recovery from the damage only occurred following de novo synthesis (replacement) of the chloroplast-encoded QB protein. We believe that the turnover of this protein is a normal consequence of its enzymatic function in vivo and is a physiological process that is necessary to maintain the photosynthetic integrity of the thylakoid membrane. Photoinhibition occurs when the rate of inactivation and subsequent removal exceeds the rate of resynthesis of the QB protein.

Characterization of chloroplast thylakoid polypeptides in the 32-kDa region: polypeptide extraction and protein phosphorylation affect binding of photosystem II-directed herbicides

In order to distinguish between two photosystem II proteins with apparent molecular weights of about 32 kDa, mild extraction procedures were used to remove several thylakoid membrane components. A 32-kDa protein that stained intensely with Coomassie brilliant blue could be extracted from the thylakoid membranes without removing the 32-kDa herbicide receptor protein, which stained poorly with Coomassie brilliant blue. The nonextracted protein was readily detectable after in vivo polypeptide labeling with [35S]methionine or after in vitro covalent tagging with [14C]azidoatrazine. The procedures used to extract the intensely stained, 32-kDa polypeptide resulted in changes in herbicide-binding characteristics, presumably due to conformational changes in the herbicide-binding environment. Alterations of membrane surface charge by protein phosphorylation also influenced herbicide binding.