Epidemiologic support to state and local sexually transmitted disease control programs. Perceived need and availability. The Field Epidemiology Network for STDs (FENS)

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) comprise the majority of national infectious disease morbidity reported, yet the number of epidemiologists working in state and local STD programs is estimated to be small. Even less is known about the training and activities of those epidemiologists.

GOALS

To determine the number, training, and affiliation of epidemiologists working with STD programs and the level of satisfaction with epidemiologic support available.

STUDY DESIGN

Survey of 65 program managers in state and local health departments.

RESULTS

Program managers named 146 people working on epidemiologic activities, and 84 of those people were classified as "epidemiologist" by the criteria we applied. The median number of full-time equivalent (FTE) epidemiologists working in or with STD programs was 0.5; one quarter of all STD program had no epidemiologists. There was a significant association between number of FTE epidemiologist and population, with most programs with more than 0.5 epidemiologists located in areas with at least 1,000,000 population. State Epidemiologists do not provide technical support to most state STD programs. Almost half (45%) of all program managers indicated that they have inadequate epidemiologic support for routine program activities.

CONCLUSIONS

The current level of epidemiologic support available to most STD programs is inadequate to perform surveillance and data analyses, interpret data to develop program objectives, and perform program evaluation. An essential next step is the delineation of a set of critical, analytic STD field epidemiology functions to define appropriate standards against which epidemiologic capacity can be more precisely measured.

Screening high-risk adolescent males for Chlamydia trachomatis infection. Obtaining urine specimens in the field

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Reported case data suggest that few men are being tested for Chlamydia trachomatis (CT) infection (female:male reported case ratio is > 5:1) partially because men seek preventive health services less frequently than women and, until recently, obtaining a CT specimen from men required a urethral swab, which has low patient acceptability. A study was conducted in San Diego, CA, to determine whether urine specimens could be obtained from high-risk teen males in the field using a peer teen outreach approach.

GOALS

Identify teen males infected with CT and provide treatment and partner management services.

STUDY DESIGN

Prevalence survey of 261 teen males and a program cost evaluation.

RESULTS

During the 6.5-month study period (Dec 15, 1995 to June 30, 1996) an estimated 1,860 teen males were approached and 261 submitted a urine specimen; 16 (6.1%) were positive by polymerase chain reaction. All positive males were treated with azithromycin, 1 gm, in the field, and 9 female sex partners were treated, 7 of whom were CT positive. The cost per specimen obtained and per CT infection identified was $103 and $1,677, respectively. The annual cost for adding a peer teen outreach service to an existing STD program using existing staff and adding 1.2 full-time equivalents of outreach time is approximately $25,000.

CONCLUSION

Peer teen outreach and in-field collection of urine specimens appear to be an acceptable alternative for screening teen males for CT and should be further evaluated in other communities.

The role of young children in a community-wide outbreak of hepatitis A

An Hasidic Jewish community has experienced recurrent hepatitis A outbreaks since 1980. To assess risk factors for illness during a 1985-6 outbreak, the authors reviewed case records and randomly selected 93 households for an interview and serologic survey. In the outbreak, 117 cases of hepatitis A were identified, with the highest attack rate (4.2%) among 3-5 year olds. Among the survey households, the presence of 3-5 year olds was the only risk factor that increased a household's risk of hepatitis A (indeterminant relative risk, P = 0.02). Furthermore, case households from the outbreak were more likely to have 3-5 years olds than were control households from the survey (odds ratio = 16.4, P < 0.001). Children 3-5 years old were more likely to have hepatitis A and may have been the most frequent transmitters of hepatitis A in this community. Hepatitis A vaccination of 3-5 year olds can protect this age group and might prevent future outbreaks in the community.

Staphylococcal food poisoning caused by imported canned mushrooms

From February through April 1989, four outbreaks of staphylococcal food poisoning in the United States were associated with eating mushrooms canned in the People's Republic of China (PRC). In the four outbreaks, 99 persons who ate at a suspect facility developed gastrointestinal symptoms within 24 h, including 18 who were hospitalized. Illness was associated with eating mushrooms at a university cafeteria (relative risk [RR] = 53.0), a hospital cafeteria (RR = 13.8), a pizzeria (odds ratio [OR] = infinity), and a restaurant (OR = infinity) (all P < .0001). Staphylococcal enterotoxin A was found by ELISA in mushrooms at the sites of two outbreaks and in unopened cans from the three plants thought to have produced mushrooms implicated in outbreaks. These investigations led to multistate recalls and a US Food and Drug Administration order to restrict entry into the United States of all mushrooms produced in the PRC; until this action, the United States imported approximately 50 million pounds yearly.

Chlamydia trachomatis infection among Hispanic women in the California-Mexico border area, 1993: establishing screening criteria in a primary care setting

BACKGROUND

Chlamydia prevalence and transmission patterns in California-Mexico border communities are unknown, and selective screening strategies for Hispanic populations have not been evaluated.

GOAL OF THIS STUDY

To determine chlamydia prevalence among Hispanic women in the California-Mexico border area and established screening criteria.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a cross-sectional prevalence survey of family planning/prenatal Hispanic clients (n = 2378) in San Diego and Imperial Counties, California, and Tijuana, Mexico.

RESULTS

Overall, chlamydia prevalence was 3.2% (3.3% in California; 2.1% in Mexico). Women born in Mexico or those who visited Mexico for at least 1 week in the recent past had a prevalence rate similar to women without those characteristics. Multivariate analysis showed that young age (less than 25 years old), unmarried status, or having clinical signs of a chlamydia syndrome (primarily cervicitis) or vaginosis independently predicted chlamydia infection. Applying minimum screening criteria recommended by the Centers for Disease Control would require screening less than half of the clients. However, only 69% of infections would be identified. Using survey-based criteria (less than 25 years old, unmarried, and clinical signs of a chlamydia syndrome) would require screening 64% of clients, but would identify 92% of those infected.

CONCLUSION

Chlamydia prevalence among Hispanic women seeking reproductive healthcare was similar (< 5%) on both sides of the California-Mexico border. Among Hispanic women, using easily obtained demographic data (age and marital status) and clinical signs (primarily cervicitis), an effective selective screening strategy can be implemented.

Syphilis in San Diego County 1983-1992: crack cocaine, prostitution, and the limitations of partner notification

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Recent epidemics of syphilis have been associated with crack cocaine use and anonymous sex for drugs, suggesting a potential limitation of sex partner notification as a disease control strategy. To assess these factors in an inner city epidemic of syphilis in San Diego County, California, we performed a descriptive epidemiologic analysis.

STUDY DESIGN

Descriptive epidemiologic data were obtained from case investigation reports of primary and secondary syphilis.

RESULTS

In the middle and late phases of the epidemic (1990-1992), the incidence of syphilis in the inner city area was more than six times that in remainder of the county. Illegal drug use was reported by 30% of patients. Drug use, especially crack cocaine, was related to prostitution. The estimated total number of sex partners per patient ratio was 4.2, whereas the named sex partners per patient ratio was only 1.5. Twenty-two percent of patients did not report any named partners. Overall, only 26% of the estimated total number of sex partners received treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Expanding partner notification to include more high-risk persons identified through social networks and increasing screening among high-risk populations may improve control of inner city drug/prostitution-related syphilis epidemics.

Epidemiologic aspects of a St. Louis encephalitis outbreak in Fort Walton Beach, Florida in 1980

From July 10 through August 4, 1980, five cases of St. Louis encephalitis (SLE) occurred in and near Fort Walton Beach on the Gulf Coast of northwest Florida. These were the first cases of SLE ever reported from the Florida panhandle. To determine the extent of SLE infection in the community, sera (n = 968) were collected from patients at the local hospital and county public health unit and tested for SLE virus antibody. The SLE attack rate was highest in a centrally located impoverished census tract. There was a trend toward decreasing seroprevalence with distance from the central area of the city. Overall, seroprevalence was higher in males (prevalence ratio = 2.7) and in all areas, seroprevalence increased with age. The serosurvey results suggest that SLE has been endemic in the Fort Walton Beach area.

HIV seroprevalence and reasons for refusing and accepting HIV testing

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

We sought to evaluate the HIV seropositivity of patients who refused or accepted human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) testing in a South Carolina sexually transmitted diseases (STD) clinic, and the patients' reasons for refusing or accepting testing.

STUDY DESIGN

A serologic and self-administered survey done Jan. 9 through June 1, 1989. For those who refused HIV testing, a routine syphilis serology sample was tested blindly for HIV.

RESULTS

Of 1,929 patients in the study, 398 (21%) refused HIV testing. HIV test refusers were 2.2 times more likely to be HIV antibody positive than HIV test acceptors (3.0% versus 1.4%, prevalence ratio = 2.2, CI95 1.1-4.4), with this difference mainly occurring among males. Seven of eight patients reporting that they refused testing because they were HIV positive were found to be HIV negative. The principal reason indicated for test refusal was not feeling at risk for HIV infection. The principal reasons indicated for test acceptance were wanting to know the results for their own health status and wishing to prevent spread of the virus to partners.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that: (1) a higher seropositivity exists among HIV test refusers than acceptors; (2) patient reporting HIV seropositivity should be viewed with caution; (3) many STD patients deny their risk for HIV; and (4) STD patients are concerned about transmission of HIV to their partners.

Use of multiple molecular subtyping techniques to investigate a Legionnaires' disease outbreak due to identical strains at two tourist lodges

A multistate outbreak of Legionnaires' disease occurred among nine tour groups of senior citizens returning from stays at one of two lodges in a Vermont resort in October 1987. Interviews and serologic studies of 383 (85%) of the tour members revealed 17 individuals (attack rate, 4.4%) with radiologically documented pneumonia and laboratory evidence of legionellosis. A survey of tour groups staying at four nearby lodges and of Vermont-area medical facilities revealed no additional cases. Environmental investigation of common tour stops revealed no likely aerosol source of Legionella infection outside the lodges. Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 was isolated from water sources at both implicated lodges, and the monoclonal antibody subtype matched those of the isolates from six patients from whom clinical isolates were obtained. The cultures reacted with monoclonal antibodies MAB1, MAB2, 33G2, and 144C2 to yield a 1,2,5,7 or a Benidorm 030E pattern. The strains were also identical by alloenzyme electrophoresis and DNA ribotyping techniques. The epidemiologic and laboratory data suggest that concurrent outbreaks occurred following exposures to the same L. pneumophila serogroup 1 strain at two separate lodges. Multiple molecular subtyping techniques can provide essential information for epidemiologic investigations of Legionnaires' disease.

Risk factors for developing eosinophilia myalgia syndrome among L-tryptophan users in New York

Using a case-control study design, patients with eosinophilia myalgia syndrome (EMS) who had used L-tryptophan (LT) were compared with LT users who did not develop EMS. Of the 113 case patients and 95 controls who had used a retail brand that could be traced to a bulk LT producer, all (100%) case-patients and 69 (73%) controls used LT brands that were traced to Showa Denko K.K. (lower 95% CL = 10.0). Among the users of LT produced by Showa Denko K.K., the risk of EMS was greater for persons who used LT produced after December 1, 1988 (OR = 25.8, [95% CL = 7.1, 101.4]). The risk of developing EMS increased with increased dosage of LT, increased age, and use of LT as a sleeping aid. These epidemiologic data support the hypothesis that the etiologic agent in EMS is a contaminant introduced into LT products during production.

Fatal incident risk factors in recreational boating in Ohio

To identify risk factors predicting the involvement of boat operators in incidents resulting in at least one fatality, the authors obtained data from a mail survey of registered boat owners in the State of Ohio and from the Boating Accident Report (BAR) files for 1983-86 compiled by the Ohio Department of Natural Resources. Additionally, they reviewed Ohio death certificates for those years to identify cases missed by the BAR system. Forty percent of the fatal incidents would have been missed by a search of death certificates alone. During the period studied, 107 boating incidents resulted in 124 deaths. There were 0.9 fatal incidents per million boat-operator hours. Factors found to be associated with an increased risk of a fatal boating incident were the operator being younger than 30 years, having fewer than 20 hours of boat operating experience, and lacking formal boat safety training. Canoes, kayaks, rowboats, and inflatables were associated with a higher rate of fatal incidents per million hours of use than were motorboats. Young age and lack of experience were associated independently with increased risk, explaining some of the effects associated with types of boats and with lack of training. The findings suggest that supervised experience, safety training programs aimed at young operators, and interventions specific to certain types of boats are likely to reduce boating fatalities.

The protective effect of alcohol on the occurrence of epidemic oyster-borne hepatitis A

Limited data indicate that drinking alcoholic beverages along with eating food contaminated with Shigella or Salmonella decreases the risk and/or the severity of illness. No such study has been reported following exposure to a viral pathogen. During an oyster-borne outbreak of hepatitis A, we studied the effect of ingestion of alcoholic beverages concomitant with consumption of contaminated oysters. The analysis was restricted to 51 cases and 33 controls who had consumed the implicated raw oysters. After controlling for potential confounders, we found a protective effect for beverages that have an alcohol concentration of greater than or equal to 10% (odds ratio = 0.1, 95% confidence interval = 0.02-0.9), but not for beverages with an alcohol concentration of less than 10% (odds ratio = 0.7, 95% confidence interval = 0.2-2.9).

Vitamin A levels and severity of measles. New York City

Recent studies show that vitamin A levels decrease during measles and that vitamin A therapy can improve measles outcome in children in the developing world. Vitamin A levels of children with measles have not been studied in developed countries. We therefore measured vitamin A levels in 89 children with measles younger than 2 years and in a reference group in New York City, NY. Vitamin A levels in children with measles ranged from 0.42 to 3.0 mumol/L; 20 (22%) were low. Children with low levels were more likely to have fever at a temperature of 40 degrees C or higher (68% vs 44%), to have fever for 7 days or more (54% vs 23%), and to be hospitalized (55% vs 30%). Children with low vitamin A levels had lower measles-specific antibody levels. No child in the reference group had a low vitamin A level. Our data show that many children younger than 2 years in New York City have low vitamin A levels when ill with measles, and that such children seem to have lower measles-specific antibody levels and increased morbidity. Clinicians may wish to consider vitamin A therapy for children younger than 2 years with severe measles. Additional studies of vitamin A in measles and other infectious diseases, and in vaccine efficacy trials, should be done.

Needlestick injuries and hepatitis B immunization in Florida paramedics: a statewide survey

STUDY OBJECTIVES

To determine the incidence of needlestick injury among paramedics working in Florida during 1987, to describe the circumstances surrounding such injuries, and to assess the hepatitis B vaccination status of this group.

DESIGN

Survey of a systematic random sample of paramedics using a self-administered questionnaire.

SETTING

Florida.

TYPE OF PARTICIPANTS

Paramedics.

MAIN RESULTS

A completed questionnaire was returned by 300 of 500 paramedics (60%) who received the mailed questionnaire. Sixty-nine paramedics (23%) reported a total of 110 needlestick injuries. More than one third of injuries occurred in conjunction with recapping needles. Almost 62% of reported injuries could have been prevented had proper needle disposal technique been used. Sixty-two percent of paramedics reported having had at least one dose of the hepatitis B vaccine. Sixty-five percent of the unvaccinated paramedics said they would take the hepatitis B vaccine if it was offered free.

CONCLUSION

The majority of needlestick injuries among paramedics in Florida could be prevented with proper needle disposal. Offering the hepatitis B vaccine at no charge to paramedics in Florida could increase the vaccination rate substantially.

The raw oyster consumer--a risk taker? Use of the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System

We used the 1988 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System in Florida to determine the prevalence of consumption of raw oysters, a vehicle implicated in the transmission of several pathogens. One-third of survey respondents reported ever eating raw oysters. The prevalence was higher for persons 18-49 years old and for males, and, when controlled for age and sex, for persons who reported being cigarette smokers or acute or chronic alcohol drinkers, and driving while intoxicated.

A multistate outbreak of hepatitis A caused by the consumption of raw oysters

BACKGROUND

In August 1988 we investigated a multistate outbreak of hepatitis A caused by Panama City, Florida, raw oysters.

METHODS

Cases of hepatitis A (HA) with onset in July-August 1988 were identified among persons who ate seafoods harvested in the coastal waters of Panama City, Florida. We conducted a case-control study, using eating companions of case-patients, and calculated attack rate (AR) per 1000 dozen raw oysters served. Enzyme immunoassay (EIA) and a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technique were performed on samples of raw shellfish obtained from Panama City coastal waters.

RESULTS

Sixty-one case-patients were identified in five states: Alabama (23), Georgia (18), Florida (18), Tennessee (1), and Hawaii (1). We found an increased risk of HA for raw oyster eaters (odds ratio = 24.0; 95% confidence interval = 5.4-215.0; P less than .001). The AR of HA in seafood establishments was 1.9/1000 dozen raw oysters served. The EIA and PCR revealed HA virus antigen and nucleic acid in oysters from both unapproved and approved oyster beds, in confiscated illegally harvested oysters, and in scallops from an approved area.

CONCLUSIONS

The monitoring of coastal waters and the enforcement of shellfish harvesting regulations were not adequate to protect raw oyster consumers. More emphasis should be placed on increasing public awareness of health hazards associated with eating raw shellfish.

Public health intervention in a cocaine-related syphilis outbreak

BACKGROUND

Cocaine users and prostitutes are at high risk for syphilis, but disease control is difficult among these populations. During a cocaine-related syphilis outbreak in Chester, Pennsylvania, in 1989, we conducted a control program at sites where sex and drugs were sold.

METHODS

During a 2-week period, investigators recruited persons from these sites for interview, serologic testing, and empiric treatment.

RESULTS

Among 136 persons screened, 25 (18%) had early syphilis and 26 others (19%) had recent sexual contact with early syphilis patients. All were treated at initial screening at a cost of $402 and 12 investigator hours per case, compared to $470 and 20 hours per case when treated during routine investigator activities. This program may have contributed to a short-term decline in syphilis incidence in Chester by reducing the period of infectivity of these patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Screening and empiric treatment of persons at sites where sex and drugs are sold can be useful in short-term control of cocaine-related syphilis outbreaks.

The syphilis epidemic in Connecticut: relationship to drug use and prostitution

Syphilis rates in Connecticut increased four-fold between 1986 and 1988. During this time there were also signs of a large increase in cocaine use in the state. We studied links between these parallel trends in drug use and syphilis by examining two sources of data: information collected during syphilis case interviews and information from the syphilis screening program at the state's prison for women. As syphilis rates rose, there were large increases in the percentage of women with syphilis who reported prostitution or illicit drug use. In 1988, 41% of women with syphilis reported cocaine use, and 19% reported prostitution; 21% of male heterosexuals with syphilis reported cocaine use, and 31% reported sexual contact with prostitutes. Among incarcerated women, syphilis infection was frequent: of 113 women incarcerated for possession of illicit drugs in 1987-88, 7% were found to be infected with Treponema pallidum, and of 187 women incarcerated for prostitution in these years, 14% were infected. In both groups of incarcerated women studied, cocaine users had the highest syphilis rates, and those who administered drugs nonintravenously had rates similar to those who administered drugs intravenously. We concluded that the syphilis epidemic in Connecticut is related to the increase in use of illicit drugs (primarily cocaine) and that female drug users are at very high risk of syphilis regardless of whether they administer drugs intravenously or nonintravenously. We recommend that syphilis control efforts focus on wider serologic screening and early treatment of drug users, prostitutes, and their sex partners.

Partner acceptance of health department notification of HIV exposure, South Carolina

To determine the acceptability of health department notification of sex and needle-sharing partners of persons infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), we administered an anonymous questionnaire to partners notified of their exposure to HIV during the previous 2 years. Of the 202 partners notified, 132 (65%) were locatable and completed the questionnaire. Only 12 (9%) thought they may have been exposed to HIV before health department notification. When the 132 partners were asked if they thought the health department did the right thing in telling them about their exposure, 87% responded "yes;" when asked if the health department should keep notifying persons exposed to HIV, 92% responded "yes." Responses were similar for homosexual-bisexual men, heterosexuals, and intravenous drug users; men and women; and whites and blacks. We conclude that health department notification is acceptable to persons exposed to HIV in this rural South Carolina district.

Lyme disease in New Jersey

Lyme disease is a spirochetal infection endemic throughout New Jersey. Case reports from 1984 through 1986 suggest different high-risk groups and different disease severity than had been observed in earlier cases in the state. Both sexes now appear equally at risk, while younger age groups, particularly children less than ten years old, appear to be at increased risk. Mild disease is usual, although classic rheumatologic and neurologic complications can occur. Informal surveys suggest Lyme disease is under-reported by a factor of five- to tenfold in New Jersey. Early recognition by physician and patient is necessary for prompt treatment to reduce complications.