Stability of curcumin in oil-in-water emulsions: Impact of emulsifier type and concentration on chemical degradation

Towards Green Nanoscience: From extraction to nanoformulation

The use of nanotechnology has revolutionized many biotechnological sectors, from bioengineering to medicine, passing through food and cosmetic fields. However, their clinic and industrial application has been into the spotlight due to their safety risk and related side effects. As a result, Green Nanoscience/Nanotechnology emerged as a strategy to prevent any associated nanotoxicity, via implementation of sustainable processes across the whole lifecycle of nanoformulation. Notwithstanding its success across inorganic nanoparticles, the green concept for organic nanoparticle elaboration is still at its infancy. This, coupled with the organic nanoparticles being the most commonly used in biomedicine, highlights the need to implement specific green principles for their elaboration. In this review, we will discuss the possible green routes for the proper design of organic nanoparticles under the umbrella of Green Nanoscience: from the extraction of nanomaterials and active compounds to their final nanoformulation.

A novel approach to develop spray-dried encapsulated curcumin powder from oil-in-water emulsions stabilized by combined surfactants and chitosan

In this study, a novel approach to prepare spray-dried encapsulated curcumin powder was investigated. The effects of surfactants viz. Tween 80 (at 0.25 to 0.75% wt) and lecithin (at 1% wt) and of a stabilizer viz. chitosan (at 0 to 0.375% wt) on the characteristics of curcumin-based emulsions as well as on physicochemical properties of the resulting spray-dried encapsulated powder were determined. The optimal emulsion was noted to be the one formulated with 0.50 and 0.25% wt, respectively, of Tween 80 and chitosan (T0.50/C0.25). Spray-dried powder prepared from the optimal emulsion was compared to that prepared from an emulsion with 0.5% Tween 80 and 0% chitosan (T0.50/C0.00), as well as that from an emulsion with 0.25% Tween 80 and 0.25% chitosan (T0.25/C0.25). Physical properties of all powders were not significantly different. However, the encapsulation efficiency of T0.50/C0.25 powder (72.28%) was significantly higher than those of T0.50/C0.00 (47.19%) and T0.25/C0.25 powder (51.61%). Ferric reducing antioxidant powers of T0.50/C0.25 and T0.25/C0.25 powders were comparable but significantly higher than that of T0.50/C0.00 powder. After reconstitution, the mean particle sizes of T0.50/C0.25 and T0.25/C0.25 remained unchanged due to the protection by chitosan. T0.50/C0.00 powder was noted to exhibit the highest bioaccessibility (89.32%) in the simulated gastrointestinal tract. PRACTICAL APPLICATION: The results of this study can be used as a guideline to develop a stable formulation of curcumin feed emulsion that can later be transformed into an encapsulated powdery form via spray drying. Such a guideline should prove useful for a company looking for a way to produce high-quality functional ingredients and/or products from curcumin.

Comparison of Emulsion and Nanoemulsion Delivery Systems: The Chemical Stability of Curcumin Decreases as Oil Droplet Size Decreases

The water dispersibility, chemical stability, and bioaccessibility of curcumin, a labile hydrophobic nutraceutical, can be enhanced by incorporating it inside the oil droplets of oil-in-water emulsions or nanoemulsions. In these multiphase systems, the curcumin remains relatively stable to degradation when surrounded by oil but degrades rapidly when surrounded by water. We hypothesized that the size of the lipid droplets would therefore impact the stability of encapsulated curcumin by altering the surface area of oil exposed to water. The effect of droplet surface area on the kinetics of curcumin degradation was therefore studied by producing emulsions with different mean droplet diameters (d₃₂) and therefore different specific surface areas (A_S): large (d₃₂ = 20.9 μm; A_S = 300 m² kg^-1); medium (d₃₂ = 2.53 μm; A_S = 2500 m² kg^-1); small (d₃₂ = 0.26 μm; A_S = 24,000 m² kg^-1); and very small (d₃₂ = 0.083 μm; A_S = 80,000 m² kg^-1) emulsions. All the emulsions initially had milky-yellow appearances and were relatively stable to aggregation during the course of the experiments. However, rapid creaming was observed in the large and medium emulsions because of their relatively large droplet size. The emulsions all exhibited some color fading during storage, with the rate of curcumin degradation increasing with decreasing droplet size. For instance, the percentage of curcumin remaining in the emulsions after 17 days storage was 91.4 ± 1.5 > 77.3 ± 6.6 > 66.7 ± 1.9 ≫ 30.6 ± 2.8% for the large, medium, small, and very small emulsions, respectively. The more rapid chemical degradation of the curcumin in the smaller droplets can be attributed to the fact that curcumin exchange between the interior and exterior of the droplets occurs more rapidly as the droplet dimensions decrease. Our results indicate that the droplet size plays a critical role in the degradation of curcumin encapsulated in emulsions, which may have important consequences for the formulation of curcumin-enriched foods and beverages with enhanced bioactivity. In particular, it suggests that emulsions are more effective at chemically stabilizing curcumin than nanoemulsions.

Recent advances in encapsulation of curcumin in nanoemulsions: A review of encapsulation technologies, bioaccessibility and applications

Curcumin is widely acknowledged for its beneficial activities. However, its application has remained challenging due to its low aqueous solubility, biochemical/structural degradation and poor bioavailability. For these reasons, many researches are aimed at overcoming these limitations using lipid-based nanosystems to encapsulate curcumin, especially nanoemulsions. This review highlights the theoretical aspects and recent advances of preparation technologies (phase inversion temperature, phase inversion composition, ultrasonication, high pressure homogenization and microfluidization) for encapsulation of curcumin in nanoemulsions. Additionally, the specific factors in designing nanoemulsions systems that affect the chemical stability and in vitro bioaccessibility of the encapsulated curcumin are discussed. Also, the importance of nanoemulsions in improving antioxidant, anti-inflammatory and anticancer activities of curcumin is underlined. Curcumin-loaded nanoemulsions preparation technologies have been proposed to provide efficient, systematic, and practical protocols for improved applications of curcumin. Additionally, key factors that influence curcumin delivery include the nature of emulsifier, the type and the amount of carrier oil and emulsifier-curcumin interactions. The pharmacological activities of curcumin including antioxidant, anti-inflammatory and anticancer activities can be improved by nanoemulsions.

Catalase to demulsify oil-in-water fish oil-polysorbate emulsion and affect lipid oxidation

The physicochemical and oxidative stability of oil emulsion has been one of the major challenges in food industry. Factors influencing the emulsion stability have seemingly been exhaustedly elucidated, such as temperature, pH, salts, proteins, polysaccharides and digestive enzymes. Here we report the previously unrecognized influence of catalase on emulsion stability. Submicron oil-in-water fish oil emulsion was prepared by high speed homogenization in the presence of polysorbate 80. Influence of catalase on the emulsion's stability was investigated in comparison with its deactivated version and bovine serum albumin (BSA) by visual examination, turbidity and DLS measurement and TEM observation. Catalase demulsified the emulsion instantly in a concentration-responsive manner at concentrations higher than 0.8 μmol/L, resulting a decreased turbidity, oil flocculation and precipitation of the enzyme itself. Neither BSA nor the thermally inactivated CAT caused demulsification at the same speed, indicating that CAT's demulsification effect was attributed to its enzymatic activity rather than its general protein properties. The enlargement of oil-polysorbate droplets and precipitation of CAT were confirmed by both TEM and DLS. Furthermore, CAT's demulsification effect was found irrelevant of the lipid oxidation. This insight into catalase's influences on emulsion not only sheds lights on food processing and shelf-life, nutritional value and potential biological effects, but also presents an exciting challenge to elucidate the mechanism behind.

Enhancement of chemical stability of curcumin-enriched oil-in-water emulsions: Impact of antioxidant type and concentration

Curcumin is claimed to have many health benefits, but it has low chemical stability. In this study, the influence of food-grade antioxidants on the chemical degradation of curcumin-enriched oil-in-water emulsions was examined. The curcumin degradation rate and extent depended on antioxidant type. The water-soluble antioxidants were more effective at protecting curcumin from degradation than the oil-soluble ones, which may have been because curcumin degrades faster in water than in oil. Interestingly, the amphiphilic antioxidant was almost as effective as the water-soluble ones. The oil-soluble antioxidant actually slightly promoted curcumin degradation. In summary, curcumin retention after storage declined in the following order: 82.6% (Trolox) ~82.2% (ascorbic acid) >79.5% (ascorbyl palmitate) ≫57.9% (control) >52.7% (α-tocopherol). The effectiveness of ascorbic acid in stabilizing curcumin increased as its concentration was raised (0-300 μM). Our results may facilitate the creation of curcumin-enriched foods and beverages with enhanced bioactivity.

Modulation of physicochemical stability and bioaccessibility of β-carotene using alginate beads and emulsion stabilized by scallop (Patinopecten yessoensis) gonad protein isolates

The colloidal delivery systems fabricated by emulsion containing natural proteins and lipids have been utilized to protect carotenoids as well as to release the carotenoids in the simulated in vitro gastrointestinal tract (GIT). In this study, β-carotene (BC) was embedded into emulsions that were stabilized by scallop gonad protein isolates (SGPIs), and the emulsion droplets containing BC were then entrapped into calcium-alginate beads. The results showed that the oil-in-water emulsions coated by SGPIs only showed good stability at pH 7-8, while the emulsion-alginate beads remained relatively intact at pH 3-8. BC encapsulated in emulsions was extremely unstable and prone to degradation when stored at the comparatively higher temperature (37 °C), whereas the stability of BC was greatly enhanced through incorporation into emulsion-alginate beads. The digestion rate and extent of lipid droplets constructed within SGPIs-stabilized emulsion-alginate beads were slower than that in emulsions during GIT. The confocal laser scanning microscopy revealed that the lipid droplets in emulsions were aggregated after exposure to the mouth and gastric phases, while the emulsion-alginate beads maintained their spherical shape after exposure to the oral and gastric phases. Moreover, the free lipid droplets in the emulsions showed a higher bioaccessibility of BC (66%) than that in the emulsion-alginate beads (38%), whereas the BC transformation was on the contrary. The findings in this study indicated that SGPIs-stabilized emulsion in alginate beads can potentially be utilized for the encapsulation and controlled release of lipophilic bioactive compounds.

Comparison of the Effects of Different Food-Grade Emulsifiers on the Properties and Stability of a Casein-Maltodextrin-Soybean Oil Compound Emulsion

The improvement of food-grade emulsifiers in the properties and stability of complex emulsion has attracted much interest. In this study, the effects of six food-grade emulsifiers with a hydrophilic-lipophilic balance (HLB) range of 3.4-8.0 on a casein-maltodextrin-soybean oil compound emulsion were investigated by centrifugal precipitation rate (CPR), emulsifying activity index (EAI), microrheological properties, zeta potential, average particle size, and Turbiscan stability index (TSI). The optimal amounts of added succinylated monoglyceride (SMG) and polyglycerol fatty acid ester were 0.0025% and 0.1% (w/w), respectively, while that of the other four emulsifiers was 0.2% (w/w), according to the CPR. Thereinto, the SMG-stabilized emulsion exhibited the highest emulsifying activity and the lowest viscosity value and possessed the highest stability over 14 days of storage, which was indicated by the lowest TSI value and the smallest change in delta backscattering signal, relative to those of the other groups. Moreover, the emulsion stabilized by SMG displayed better emulsion stability than the control under a range of pH (6.0-8.0) and calcium ion concentrations (0-10 mM), which was attributed to the increased zeta potential value and the decreased average particle size of droplets with the addition of SMG. The present study provides a basic understanding for SMG improving the properties and stability of the complex emulsion.

Influence of Ternary Emulsifier Mixtures on Oxidative Stability of Nanoemulsions Based on Avocado Oil

The aim of this work was to study the effect of two emulsifiers (M1: SL-soy lecithin, Tw80-Tween 80 and CasCa-calcium caseinate and M2: SL-soy lecithin, Tw80-Tween 80 and SE-sucrose esters) on the oxidative stability of avocado oil-based nanoemulsions. Oil-in-water nanoemulsions were prepared using 3.6% w/w of two emulsifier mixtures, which were optimized by mixture experimental design in order to minimize particle size (PS) and polydispersity index (PdI). Then, the oxidative stability of nanoemulsions was evaluated through both an induction period and a quantification of hydroperoxides and thiobarbituric acid reactive species (TBARs) under accelerated storage conditions. The simplex-centroid mixture design showed that PS and PdI varied when proportions of different emulsifiers were modified, obtaining an optimized concentration for each mixture of: 85% SL, 10% Tw80 and 5%CasCa (M1) and 85% SL, 7.4% Tw80 and 7.6% SE (M2) that produced nanoemulsions with PS ~116 nm and PdI < 0.2. Nanoemulsions elaborated with M1 and M2 presented similar particle characteristics and physical stability to the control sample with Tw80. However, M1 nanoemulsions were more stable against lipid oxidation, since they showed the highest induction period and lower formation of hydroperoxides and TBARs during storage.

Physicochemical characterization and antimicrobial activity in novel systems containing buriti oil and structured lipids nanoemulsions

Buriti oil nanoemulsions were prepared using non-interesterified buriti oil or buriti oil interesterified for 6 or 24 h (NBO, NBO6h, and NBO24 h), respectively. The aim was to investigate the effects of interesterified oils on the physicochemical and biological properties of nanoemulsions. Samples were stored at 4 and 25 °C for 30 days, and their physicochemical properties and biological activities were evaluated. The mean droplet diameter of nanoemulsions ranged from 196 to 270 nm. NBO24 h had the smallest droplet size and was the most stable during the storage period. Furthermore, NBO24 h demonstrating the good oxidative stability, had a high antioxidant capacity, and was less susceptible to droplet aggregation. NBO and NBO24 h had similar biological activity against Gram-negative bacteria (Escherichia coli O157: H7); bacterial growth was inhibited by at least 60% at 3.12 mg mL-1. The nanoemulsions have interesting properties for the production of pharmaceutical, cosmetic, and food formulations with antimicrobial activity.

Recent advances in colloidal delivery systems for nutraceuticals: A case study - Delivery by Design of curcumin

Curcumin is a polyphenolic compound found in turmeric (Curcuma longa) rhizome that has potential biological benefits, including antioxidant, antimicrobial, anti-inflammatory, and anti-cancer activity. Incorporation of curcumin into functional food and beverage products, however, is challenging due to its low water-solubility, poor chemical stability, rapid metabolism, and low oral bioavailability. Researchers are, therefore developing a suite of particle-based delivery systems to maximize the potential health benefits of curcumin. Colloidal delivery systems, such as micelles, microemulsions, nanoemulsions, emulsions, solid lipid nanoparticles, nanostructured lipid carriers, biopolymer nanoparticles, and microgels have all been developed for this purpose. The functional performance of each of these delivery systems depends on its structure and physicochemical properties, such as particle composition, particle size, morphology, physicochemical stability, optical properties, rheology, and sensory attributes. As a result, each delivery system has its advantages and disadvantages for particular applications. Consequently, a delivery system must be specifically designed for the particular bioactive agent to be encapsulated, as well as the particular food matrix it will be incorporated into. In this review, we highlight the potential of the Delivery by Design (DbD) approach for identifying and selecting the most appropriate colloidal delivery system for a particular food application, using curcumin as a model bioactive agent.

Improvement on stability, loading capacity and sustained release of rhamnolipids modified curcumin liposomes

A novel cholesterol-free curcumin delivery system was fabricated by rhamnolipids modified liposomes (RL-Lps). The incorporation of the rhamnolipids increased the sphericity, reduced the size, and decreased the polydispersity of the liposomes compared with pure liposomes (Lps). Analysis of the environmental stability of the RL-Lps showed they have good long-term stability over a wide range of pH (2-3 and 5-8), ionic strengths (0-200 mM), and accelerated centrifugal conditions. The curcumin-loaded rhamnolipids modified liposomes (Cur-RL-Lps) could be prepared with a relatively high loading efficiency (LE > 90%) and loading capacity (LC > 3.5%). The thermal and photochemical stability of the curcumin was improved after encapsulation in the Cur-RL-Lps. In vitro release studies indicated that the sustained release of the curcumin was prolonged when rhamnolipids were incorporated into the liposomes. This study shows that rhamnolipids have great potential for liposomal delivery system suitable for utilization in functional foods, dietary supplements, and pharmaceutical preparations.

Improving the Physical and Oxidative Stability of Emulsions Using Mixed Emulsifiers: Casein-Octenyl Succinic Anhydride Modified Starch Combinations

This study aims to investigate the influence of casein and octenyl succinic anhydride modified starch (OSAS) combinations on the physical and oxidative stability of fish oil-in-water emulsions. The interaction between casein and OSAS was manifested in changes in protein structure and hydrogen-bonding interaction. Casein-OSAS combinations could effectively inhibit droplet aggregation at pH 4 and attenuate droplet growth at a high CaCl2 concentration of 0.2 mol/L, compared with casein as an emulsifier. Nanoemulsions stabilized by casein-OSAS combinations or casein showed better oxidative stability compared with OSAS-stabilized emulsions. Therefore, casein-OSAS combinations can improve some physical properties of protein-based emulsions and oxidative stability of modified starch-based emulsions, suggesting protein-modified starch combinations are more promising in the emulsion-based food industry compared to each of the two emulsifiers alone.

Improved water dispersibility and photostability in folic acid nanoparticles with transglycosylated naringin using combined processes of wet-milling and freeze-drying

We successfully prepared folic acid (FA) nanoparticles with excellent dispersibility and photostability using a combination of bead milling and freeze-drying with transglycosylated naringin (Naringin-G), a newly developed transglycosylated food additive. Poly-vinyl pyrrolidon (PVP) was used for comparison with Naringin-G. Water dispersibility and photostability of the freeze-dried formulations were assessed. The dispersibility and physicochemical properties of nanoparticle formulations were evaluated using dynamic light scattering, powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD), and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Results indicated that the median particle size of FA in the slurry bead milled with Naringin-G decreased notably with time and fell below 100 nm after milling for 300 min. Further, FA nanoparticles with Naringin-G were stable without aggregation following re-dispersion of freeze-dried FA formulations in water. Contrarily, the addition of PVP did not prevent the aggregation of FA nanoparticles following re-dispersion of freeze-dried FA formulations. Solid structures of freeze-dried FA formulations with Naringin-G or PVP were assessed using PXRD and SAXS. PXRD patterns of all freeze-dried formulations highlighted broadening and weakening of peaks, indicating a decrease in FA crystallinity following bead milling, regardless of the additive concentration of Naringin-G and PVP. The scattering intensity profiles of FA formulations with PVP dramatically decreased after milling, whereas FA formulations with Naringin-G did not exhibit changes in SAXS patterns. FA formulations with Naringin-G registered faster enhancement in release rate than PVP in pH 1.2 buffer solutions. The release rate of freeze-dried FA formulation with Naringin-G exhibited at least five-fold enhancement when compared to untreated FA. FA formulation with Naringin-G was stable to photodegradation under fluorescent light. Naringin-G prevented photodegradation of FA due to its antioxidant effect and scavenged radicals. These findings indicated that freeze-dried FA formulation with Naringin-G can improve its water-dispersibility and photodegradation due to the effectiveness of Naringin-G as a dispersant and cryoprotectant.

Encapsulation and release behavior of curcumin based on nanoemulsions-filled alginate hydrogel beads

To provide the bilateral advantages of emulsions and hydrogels, a facile approach was used to fabricate nanoemulsions filled hydrogel beads through combining the method of self-emulsification and sodium alginate (SA) ionic gelation. The encapsulation and release behavior of curcumin (Cur) were further investigated. The results indicated that Cur packaged nanoemulsions were with the size of 24.26 ± 0.22 nm. The nanoemulsions filled SA hydrogel beads were spherical shell with the diameter of 0.46 ± 0.02 mm. For Cur, the EE and LC of emulsion filled SA hydrogel beads were 99.15 ± 0.85% and 7.25 ± 3.16 mg/g respectively. The release behavior could be regulated by external pH condition. The release behavior at pH 9.0 displayed a higher release rate than that at pH 7.0. Cur released behavior well followed the Hixcon-Crowell model which indicated that Cur was released in a diffusion-controlled model. Comparatively investigation of microstructure using field emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) further investigates the corrosion behavior of SA gel beads during Cur release. The worth-while endeavor provided a practical combined technique of emulsions and ionic gelation to fabricate hybrid hydrogel beads that have potential in delivery system for hydrophobic composition.