Genetic and biochemical dissection of transgenic RNA-mediated virus resistance

RNA-DNA interactions and DNA methylation in post-transcriptional gene silencing

Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) is a homology-dependent process that reduces cytoplasmic RNA levels. In several experimental systems, there is also an association of PTGS with methylation of DNA. To investigate this association, we used plants carrying a transgene encoding the green fluorescent protein (GFP). Gene silencing was induced using potato virus X RNA vectors carrying parts of the coding sequence or the promoter of the GFP transgene. In each instance, homology-based, RNA-directed methylation was associated with silencing. When the GFP-transcribed region was targeted, PTGS affected both transgene and viral RNA levels. When methylation was targeted to a promoter region, transgene RNA levels were reduced; however, viral RNA levels were unaffected. For comparison, we induced PTGS of the gene encoding the endogenous ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase oxygenase (Rubisco) small subunit (rbcS) by inoculation with potato virus X-rbcS. In this example, no methylation of the rbcS DNA was associated with the reduction in rbcS transcript levels, and viral RNA levels were unaffected. Finally, we investigated DNA methylation by using GFP-transformed plants in which PTGS was induced by localized introduction of a T-DNA carrying GFP sequences. In these plants, there was methylation of a GFP transgene associated with systemic spread of a gene-silencing signal from the infiltrated part of the plant. This transgene methylation was not affected when systemic PTGS was blocked by suppressors of silencing encoded by potato virus Y and cucumber mosaic virus. Combined, these data support an epigenetic model of PTGS in which transgene methylation is associated with an RNA-DNA interaction that ensures that PTGS is maintained.

Sequences throughout the basic beta-1,3-glucanase mRNA coding region are targets for homology dependent post-transcriptional gene silencing

In the transgenic tobacco line T17, plants homozygous for the gn1 transgene display developmentally regulated post-transcriptional silencing of basic beta-1,3-glucanase genes. Previously, it has been shown that silencing involves a markedly increased turnover of silencing-target glucanase mRNAs. Using a two-component viral reporter system facilitated a comparison, in a quantitat- ive manner, of the relative silencing efficiencies of various sequences derived from the gn1 transgene. The results show that target sites for the silencing mechanism are present throughout the coding region of the gn1 mRNA. Similar-sized coding region sequences along the entire gn1 mRNA display a similar susceptibility to the silencing mechanism. The susceptibility to silencing increases as the coding region elements increase in size. Relative to internal sequences, the 5' and 3' terminal regions of the gn1 mRNA are inefficient targets for the silencing machinery. Importantly, sequences of the gn1 transgene that are not part of the mature gn1 mRNA are not recognized by the silencing machinery when expressed in chimeric viral RNAs. These results show that the glucanase silencing mechanism in T17 plants is primarily directed against gn1 mRNA-internal sequences and that terminal sequences of the gn1 mRNA are relatively unaffected by the silencing mechanism.

Posttranscriptional gene silencing of gn1 in tobacco triggers accumulation of truncated gn1-derived RNA species

Posttranscriptional silencing of basic beta-1,3-glucanase genes in the tobacco line T17 is manifested by reduced transcript levels of the gn1 transgene and homologous, endogenous basic beta-1,3-glucanase genes. An RNA ligation-mediated rapid amplification of cDNA ends (RLM-RACE) technique was used to compare the 3' termini of gn1 RNAs present in expressing (hemizygous and young homozygous) and silenced (mature homozygous) T17 plants. Full-length, polyadenylated gn1 transcripts primarily accumulated in expressing plants, whereas in silenced T17 plants, mainly 3'-truncated, nonpolyadenylated gn1 RNAs were detected. The relative abundance of these 3'-truncated gn1 RNA species gradually increased during the establishment of silencing in homozygous T17 plants. Similar 3'-truncated, nonpolyadenylated gn1 RNA products were observed in an independent case of beta-1,3-glucanase posttranscriptional gene silencing. This suggests that these 3'-truncated gn1 RNAs are a general feature of tobacco plants showing posttranscriptional silencing of the gn1 transgene.

Expression and sequence requirements for nitrite reductase co-suppression

We have previously reported that the introduction of a full-length tobacco nitrite reductase Nii1 cDNA under the control of the 35S promoter triggers co-suppression of endogenous Nii genes in 25% of tobacco transformants. Here we show that introduction of chimeric Nii1-uidA, uidA-Nii1 and Nii1-uidA-Nii1 transgenes carrying 186 bp of the 5' end and/or 241 bp of the 3' end of the Nii1 cDNA do not trigger co-suppression of endogenous Nii genes. In addition, we show that when introduced by crossing or transformation into co-suppressed transgenic tobacco lines carrying full-length Nii1 transgenes, these chimeric transgenes are not silenced. These results therefore suggest that the 5' and 3' ends of the Nii1 cDNA are not sufficient to trigger co-suppression and are not targets for homology-dependent RNA degradation. Surprisingly, co-suppression was released in a double transformant obtained by introduction of one of these constructs into the co-suppressed transgenic tobacco line 461-2.1 homozygous for a full-length Nii1 transgene, and in one plant regenerated from untransformed leaf discs (plant 461-2.1*). The reappearance of co-suppression at very low frequency (less than 10(-3)) in the F2 progeny of plant 461-2.1* and the apparent absence of structural modification of the transgene locus suggest a metastable epigenetic modification. The steady-state level of Nii mRNAs in the plant 461-2-.1* was higher than in wild-type plants but lower than in hemizygous plants 461-2.1 which never trigger silencing. These results therefore confirm that transcription of the transgene above a particular threshold is required to trigger co-suppression.

Tomato Spotted Wilt Tospovirus Adapts to the TSWV N Gene-Derived Resistance by Genome Reassortment

ABSTRACT Pathogen- and host-derived resistance have been shown to suppress infection by many plant viruses. Tomato spotted wilt tospovirus (TSWV) is among these systems; however, it has easily overcome nearly all host resistance genes and has recently been shown to overcome resistance mediated by the TSWV N gene. To better understand the resistance-breaking mechanisms, we have chosen TSWV N gene-derived resistance (TNDR) as a model to study how plant viruses defeat resistance genes. A defined viral population of isolates TSWV-D and TSWV-10, both suppressed by TNDR, was subjected to TNDR selection by serial passage in an N-gene transgenic plant. The genotype analysis demonstrated that the mixed viral population was driven to form a specific reassortant, L(10)M(10)S(D), in the presence of TNDR selection, but remained as a heterogeneous mixture in the absence of the selection. A genotype assay of 120 local lesion isolates from the first, fourth, and seventh transfers confirmed the shift of genomic composition. Further analysis demonstrated that the individual L(10), M(10), and S(D) RNA segments were each selected independently in response to TNDR selection rather than to a mutation or recombination event. Following the seventh transfer on the N-gene transgenic plants, TSWV S RNA remained essentially identical to the S RNA from TSWV-D, indicating that no intermolecular recombination occurred between the two S RNAs from TSWV-10 and TSWV-D nor with the transferred N gene. These results support the hypothesis that TSWV utilizes genome reassortment to adapt to new host genotypes rapidly and that elements from two or more segments of the genome are involved in suppression of the resistance reaction.

Gene silencing without DNA. rna-mediated cross-protection between viruses

Previously, it was shown that the upper leaves of plants infected with nepoviruses and caulimoviruses are symptom free and contain reduced levels of virus. These leaves are said to be recovered. Recovery is associated with RNA-mediated cross-protection against secondary virus infection. Here, by analyzing plants infected with viruses that are quite distinct from the nepovirus or caulimovirus groups, we demonstrate that this RNA-mediated defense is a general response to virus infection. Upon infection with a tobravirus, plants exhibited RNA-mediated cross-protection and recovery, as occurs in nepovirus-infected plants. However, upon infection with a potexvirus, plants exhibited RNA-mediated cross-protection without recovery. In both instances, a transient gene expression assay showed that RNA-mediated cross-protection was functionally equivalent to post-transcriptional gene silencing. Combined, these data provide direct evidence that post-transcriptional gene silencing of nuclear genes is a manifestation of a natural defense mechanism that is induced by a wide range of viruses.

trans-Dominant Inhibition of Geminiviral DNA Replication by Bean Golden Mosaic Geminivirus rep Gene Mutants

ABSTRACT Geminiviruses are a group of single-stranded DNA viruses that cause major losses on a number of important crops throughout the world. Bean golden mosaic virus (BGMV) is a typical bipartite, whitefly-transmitted geminivirus that causes a severe disease on beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) in the Western Hemisphere. The lack of natural resistance to geminiviruses has led to attempts to engineer resistance, particularly through the use of pathogen-derived resistance strategies. The rep gene contains several conserved domains including nucleoside triphosphate (NTP)-binding and DNA-nicking domains and is the only geminiviral gene necessary for replication. Previous analysis by our group and others has demonstrated that the NTP-binding and DNA-nicking domains are necessary for geminiviral DNA replication. The ability of the rep gene and rep gene mutants to interfere with geminiviral DNA replication, when expressed in trans, was examined using a transient assay in a tobacco suspension cell culture system. Wild-type (wt) and mutant rep genes were cloned into plasmids under the control of the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter for in planta expression and coinoculated into tobacco cells with infectious clones of various geminiviruses. The wt rep gene from BGMV-GA was able to support replication of BGMV-GA DNA-B. Several different rep gene mutants, with function-abolishing mutations in the NTP-binding or DNA-nicking domains, were potent trans-dominant inhibitors of geminiviral DNA replication.

Turnip mosaic potyvirus resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana derived by post-transcriptional gene silencing

The coat protein (CP) gene of turnip mosaic potyvirus isolate ESC8 (TuMV-ESC8) was cloned and sequenced. Comparisons of the 867-nucleotide (nt) CP region with those of 11 TuMV isolates showed 86.7-89.3% nucleotide identity and 92.4-95.5% amino acid identity. The CP gene was cloned into a plant expression vector and transformed into Nicotiana benthamiana plants via Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated leaf disk transformation. Progeny from R0 lines was screened for resistance to TuMV-ESC8. Five of 29 tested lines showed TuMV protection in more than 50% of their progeny. Interestingly, some of the resistant plants transformed with the CP gene of TuMV displayed mild mosaicism in the new growing leaves at the later stages of evaluation; but these mosaic symptoms disappeared when the leaves were fully expanded. Collective data from steady-state RNA analysis and nuclear run-on assay of a line showed that the resistance was RNA-mediated through the post-transcriptional gene silencing mechanism.

Specific inhibition of hepatitis B virus replication by sense RNA

We describe effects of sense RNA molecules on hepatitis B virus (HBV) replication and antigen synthesis in transiently transfected cells. When certain subgenomic fragments of HBV were expressed as sense RNA together with a replication-competent genome of HBV, they inhibited HBV replication by up to 75% and HBsAg secretion by up to 60%. The corresponding antisense sequences had a 50% inhibitory effect in one case and no effect in another case. The sense RNA species did not inhibit duck hepatitis B virus (DHBV) replication, suggesting specific inhibitory effects. HBV transcript levels were unaltered in the presence of sense RNA species, consistent with an inhibitory effect mediated at the posttranscriptional level. The inhibition of HBV replication by overexpression of sense RNA derived from the viral genome represents an example of sense cosuppression of an animal virus.

Homology-dependent virus resistance in transgenic plants with the coat protein gene of sweet potato feathery mottle potyvirus: target specificity and transgene methylation

ABSTRACT Nicotiana benthamiana plants were transformed with the coat protein (CP) coding sequence and the 3' nontranslated region (NTR) of the severe strain of sweet potato feathery mottle potyvirus (SPFMV-S). Regenerated lines were screened for virus resistance using recombinant potato virus X (PVX) engineered to contain the sequence homologous to the transgene. Out of 19 transgenic lines, 7 showed virus resistance after inoculation by the recombinant PVX. In most of the resistant lines, relatively low steady-state accumulation of the CP gene mRNA and little or no protein products were observed, suggesting that the resistance was manifested by a post-transcriptional gene-silencing mechanism. The resistant lines could be divided into two groups according to the target specificity of the silencing mechanism; one group recognizing the 3' part of the transgene mRNA and the other not only the 3' part, but also the 5' and the central part of the transgene mRNA. Particular regions of the transgene corresponding to the RNA target in the resistant lines were differentially methylated compared with the transgene sequence in a susceptible line.

Posttranscriptional gene silencing in transgenic sugarcane. Dissection Of homology-dependent virus resistance in a monocot that has a complex polyploid genome

RNA-mediated, posttranscriptional gene silencing has been determined as the molecular mechanism underlying transgenic virus resistance in many plant virus-dicot host plant systems. In this paper we show that transgenic virus resistance in sugarcane (Saccharum spp. hybrid) is based on posttranscriptional gene silencing. The resistance is derived from an untranslatable form of the sorghum mosaic potyvirus strain SCH coat protein (CP) gene. Transgenic sugarcane plants challenged with sorghum mosaic potyvirus strain SCH had phenotypes that ranged from fully susceptible to completely resistant, and a recovery phenotype was also observed. Clones derived from the same transformation event or obtained after vegetative propagation could display different levels of virus resistance, suggesting the involvement of a quantitative component in the resistance response. Most resistant plants displayed low or undetectable steady-state CP transgene mRNA levels, although nuclear transcription rates were high. Increased DNA methylation was observed in the transcribed region of the CP transgenes in most of these plants. Collectively, these characteristics indicate that an RNA-mediated, homology-dependent mechanism is at the base of the virus resistance. This work extends posttranscriptional gene silencing and homology-dependent virus resistance, so far observed only in dicots, to an agronomically important, polyploid monocot.

Mitotic stability of infection-induced resistance to plum pox potyvirus associated with transgene silencing and DNA methylation

Plum pox potyvirus (PPV) infection of transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana plants that expressed the PPV NIb RNA replicase carrying a Gly to Val mutation at the GDD motif (NIbV lines) induced a phenotype of virus resistance and transgene silencing, which was not transmissible to the progeny after self-fertilization (H. S. Guo and J. A. García, Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 10:160-170, 1997). Here, we demonstrate that the induced resistance of NIbV plants is mitotically stable after plant propagation by grafting and by in vitro regeneration. Virus replication or residual virus RNA seem not to be required to maintain transgene silencing and virus resistance. Analysis by PCR (polymerase chain reaction) amplification after treatment with methylation-sensitive restriction nucleases indicates that DNA methylation is associated with establishment and maintenance of transgene silencing and virus resistance. Restoration of transgene activity and susceptibility to PPV in sexual progeny correlated with resetting of transgene DNA methylation. On the basis of these and other published results, we present a general model for post-transcriptional gene silencing in which RNA signals, generated either by a silenced nuclear gene or by virus replication, both activate a specific cytoplasmic RNA degradation pathway and induce changes (in particular, DNA methylation) in homologous nuclear genes that switch them from an active to a silenced status.

Silencing of an aleurone-specific gene in transgenic rice is caused by a rearranged transgene

In rice, silencing of the aleurone-specific Ltp2-gus transgene, causing easily detectable staining patterns on the grain surface, offers a convenient tool to study quantitative aspects of gene silencing in monocots. In this paper we analyzed phenotypes, occurrence, inheritance and environmental effects on the silencing. We also report on the cloning of transgenes, determination of their structure and analysis of transcripts from the transgene loci. The results show that various patterns of silencing appeared in the R2 generation at which most of the transgenes became homozygous and that they were inherited for five generations. In addition, silencing independently occurred in three generations and reversion to full expression was also found. Cloning of transgenes from a silenced L3.3 line demonstrated that this line carried two transgene loci: one carried an intact Ltp2-gus gene and the other carried a rearranged transgene in which part of the gus gene was in the antisense orientation. Analysis of gus transcripts indicated that partial antisense RNA derived from the rearranged transgene was present in silenced lines and was polyadenylated but that it was absent in non-silenced lines. RNA analyses suggested that the Ltp2-gus silencing in the aleurone layer was post-transcriptional and that it may be caused by interaction of partial antisense gus transcripts with normal sense transcripts. Possible involvement of antisense transcripts in post-transcriptional silencing is discussed.

Taming of transposable elements by homology-dependent gene silencing

Transposable elements can invade virgin genomes within a few generations, after which the elements are 'tamed' and retain only limited transpositional activity. Introduction of the I element, a transposon similar to mammalian LINE elements, into Drosophila melanogaster genomes devoid of such elements initially results in high-frequency transposition of the incoming transposon, high mutation rate, chromosomal nondisjunction and female sterility, a syndrome referred to as hybrid dysgenesis (for review, see refs 2-4); a related syndrome has also been described in mammals. High-frequency transposition is transient, as the number of I elements reaches a finite value and transposition ceases after approximately ten generations. It has been proposed that the I elements encode a factor that negatively regulates their own transcription, but evidence for such a mechanism is lacking. Using the hybrid dysgenesis syndrome in Drosophila as a model, we show here that transpositional activity of the I element can be repressed by prior introduction of transgenes expressing a small internal region of the I element. This autoregulation presents features characteristic of homology-dependent gene silencing, a process known as cosuppression. Repression does not require any translatable sequence, its severity correlates with transgene copy number and it develops in a generation-dependent manner via germline transmission of a silencing effector in females only. These results demonstrate that transposable elements are prone to and can be tamed by homology-dependent gene silencing, a process that may have emerged during the course of evolution as a specific defense mechanism against these elements.

Silencing of beta-1,3-glucanase genes in tobacco correlates with an increased abundance of RNA degradation intermediates

Post-transcriptional gene silencing of beta-1,3 glucanase genes in the transgenic tobacco line T17 is characterised by an increased turnover and, as a consequence, reduced levels of gn1 transgene and endogenous beta-1,3 glucanase mRNAs. Here, additional gn1 RNAs, both larger and smaller than the full-length messenger, are shown to accumulate in silenced plants of the transgenic tobacco line T17. The longer-than-full-length gn1 RNAs are the result of cryptic processing of the gn1 messenger. The small gn1 RNAs in silenced plants correspond to distal and proximal parts of the mature gn1 messenger. The proximal RNA products are intact at their 5' extremity, but terminate at different positions at the 3'-end. The distal RNA products contain a poly(A) tail and are truncated to various positions at the 5'-end. These observations indicate that degradation of the mature gn1 transcript does not start at the 5'- or 3'-end, but rather are consistent with degradation of the gn1 transcript starting with an endonucleolytic cleavage followed by internal exonuclease digestion. Importantly, the truncated products are more abundant in silenced plants than in expressing plants. This suggests, together with the previously reported silencing-related increased gn1 mRNA turnover and the similar rates of gn1 transcription in silenced and expressing T17 plants, that the predominant decay route for the gn1 transcripts differs between silenced and expressing conditions.

A counterdefensive strategy of plant viruses: suppression of posttranscriptional gene silencing

Posttranscriptional gene silencing (PTGS) in plants inactivates some aberrant or highly expressed RNAs in a sequence-specific manner in the cytoplasm. A silencing mechanism similar to PTGS appears to function as an adaptive antiviral response. We demonstrate that the P1/HC-Pro polyprotein encoded by tobacco etch virus functions as a suppressor of PTGS. A locus comprised of a highly expressed beta-glucuronidase (GUS) transgene was shown to exhibit PTGS. Genetic crosses and segregation analyses revealed that a P1/ HC-Pro transgene suppressed PTGS of the GUS sequence. Nuclear transcription assays indicated that the silencing suppression activity of P1/HC-Pro was at the posttranscriptional level. These data reveal that plant viruses can condition enhanced susceptibility within a host through interdiction of a potent defense response.

De novo methylation and co-suppression induced by a cytoplasmically replicating plant RNA virus

The relationship between co-suppression and DNA methylation was explored in transgenic plants showing inducible co-suppression following infection with a cytoplasmically replicating RNA virus. Induction resulted in a loss of transgene mRNA and resistance to further infection, factors typical of post-transcriptional gene silencing. In infected plants, de novo methylation of the transgene appeared to precede the onset of resistance and only occurred in plants where the outcome was co-suppression. The methylation was limited to sequences homologous to the viral RNA and occurred at both symmetric and non-symmetric sites on the DNA. Although methylation is predicted to occur in mitotic cells, the virus was found not to access the meristem. A diffusible sequence-specific signal may account for the epigenetic changes in those tissues.

Position-dependent methylation and transcriptional silencing of transgenes in inverted T-DNA repeats: implications for posttranscriptional silencing of homologous host genes in plants

Posttranscriptional silencing of chalcone synthase (Chs) genes in petunia transformants occurs by introducing T-DNAs that contain a promoter-driven or promoterless Chs transgene. With the constructs we used, silencing occurs only by T-DNA loci which are composed of two or more T-DNA copies that are arranged as inverted repeats (IRs). Since we are interested in the mechanism by which these IR loci induce silencing, we have analyzed different IR loci and nonsilencing single-copy (S) T-DNA loci with respect to the expression and methylation of the transgenes residing in these loci. We show that in an IR locus, the transgenes located proximal to the IR center are much more highly methylated than are the distal genes. A strong silencing locus composed of three inverted T-DNAs bearing promoterless Chs transgenes was methylated across the entire locus. The host Chs genes in untransformed plants were moderately methylated, and no change in methylation was detected when the genes were silenced. Run-on transcription assays showed that promoter-driven transgenes located proximal to the center of a particular IR are transcriptionally more repressed than are the distal genes of the same IR locus. Transcription of the promoterless Chs transgenes could not be detected. In the primary transformant, some of the IR loci were detected together with an unlinked S locus. We observed that the methylation and expression characteristics of the transgenes of these S loci were comparable to those of the partner IR loci, suggesting that there has been cross talk between the two types of loci. Despite the similar features, S loci are unable to induce silencing, indicating that the palindromic arrangement of the Chs transgenes in the IR loci is critical for silencing. Since transcriptionally silenced transgenes in IRs can trigger posttranscriptional silencing of the host genes, our data are most consistent with a model of silencing in which the transgenes physically interact with the homologous host gene(s). The interaction may alter epigenetic features other than methylation, thereby impairing the regular production of mRNA.

A transgene with repeated DNA causes high frequency, post-transcriptional suppression of ACC-oxidase gene expression in tomato

Gene silencing with sense genes is an important method for down-regulating the expression of endogenous plant genes, but the frequency of silencing is unpredictable. Fifteen per cent of tomato plants transformed with a 35S-ACC-oxidase ( ACO 1) sense gene had reduced ACC-oxidase activity. However, 96% of plants transformed with an ACC-oxidase sense gene, containing two additional upstream inverted copies of its 5' untranslated region, exhibited reduced ACC-oxidase activity compared to wild-type plants. In the three plants chosen for analysis, there were substantially reduced amounts of both endogenous and transgenic ACO RNA, indicating that this was an example of co-suppression. Ribonuclease protection assays using probes spanning intron-exon borders showed that the reduced accumulation of endogenous ACO mRNA occurred post-transcriptionally since the abundance of unprocessed transcripts was not affected. The ACO1 transgene with the repeated 5'UTR also strongly inhibited the accumulation of RNA from the related ACO 2 gene in flowers, although there is little homology between the 5'UTRs of ACO 1 and ACO 2. These results indicate that although repeated DNA in a transgene greatly enhances the probability of gene silencing of an endogenous gene, it also involves generation of a trans -acting silencing signal produced, at least partly, from sequences external to the repeat.

Transgenes are dispensable for the RNA degradation step of cosuppression

Cosuppression results in the degradation of RNA from host genes and homologous transgenes after transcription in the nucleus. By using grafting experiments, we have shown previously that a systemic signal mediates the propagation of cosuppression of Nia host genes and 35S-Nia2 transgenes from silenced 35S-Nia2 transgenic stocks to nonsilenced 35S-Nia2 transgenic scions but not to wild-type scions. Here, we examined the requirements for triggering and maintenance of cosuppression in various types of scions. Grafting-induced silencing occurred in 35S-Nia2 transgenic lines over-accumulating Nia mRNA whether they are able to spontaneously trigger cosuppression or not and in 35S-Nia2 transgene-free plants over-accumulating host Nia mRNA caused by metabolic derepression. When grafting-induced silenced scions were removed from the silenced stocks and regrafted onto wild-type plants, silencing was not maintained in the 35S-Nia2 transgene-free plants and in the 35S-Nia2 transgenic lines that are not able to trigger cosuppression spontaneously. Conversely, silencing was maintained in the 35S-Nia2 transgenic lines that are able to trigger cosuppression spontaneously. Our results indicate that the presence of a 35S-Nia2 transgene is dispensable for the RNA degradation step of posttranscriptional silencing when host Nia mRNA over-accumulate above the level of wild-type plants. They also suggest that grafting-induced RNA degradation does not result in the production of the systemic silencing signal required for spontaneous triggering and maintenance.

Viral invasion and host defense: strategies and counter-strategies

The outcome of infection of plants by viruses is determined by the net effects of compatibility functions and defense responses. Recent advances reveal that viruses have the capacity to modulate host compatibility and defense functions by a variety of mechanisms.

Initiation and maintenance of virus-induced gene silencing

The phytoene desaturase (PDS) gene of Nicotiana benthamiana was silenced in plants infected with potato virus X (PVX) vectors carrying PDS inserts, and a green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgene was silenced in plants infected with PVX-GFP. This virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) is post-transcriptional and cytoplasmic because it is targeted against exons rather than introns of PDS RNA and against viral RNAs. Although PDS and GFP RNAs are most likely targeted through the same mechanism, the VIGS phenotypes differed in two respects. PDS mRNA was targeted by VIGS in all green tissue of the PVX-PDS-infected plant, whereas PVX-PDS was not affected. In contrast, VIGS of the GFP was targeted against PVX-GFP. Initially, VIGS of the GFP was initiated in all green tissues, as occurred with PDS VIGS. However, after 30 days of infection, the GFP VIGS was no longer initiated in newly emerging leaves, although it was maintained in tissue in which it had already been initiated. Based on these analyses, we propose a model for VIGS in which the initiation of VIGS is dependent on the virus and maintenance of it is virus independent.

Initiation and maintenance of virus-induced gene silencing

The phytoene desaturase (PDS) gene of Nicotiana benthamiana was silenced in plants infected with potato virus X (PVX) vectors carrying PDS inserts, and a green fluorescent protein (GFP) transgene was silenced in plants infected with PVX-GFP. This virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) is post-transcriptional and cytoplasmic because it is targeted against exons rather than introns of PDS RNA and against viral RNAs. Although PDS and GFP RNAs are most likely targeted through the same mechanism, the VIGS phenotypes differed in two respects. PDS mRNA was targeted by VIGS in all green tissue of the PVX-PDS-infected plant, whereas PVX-PDS was not affected. In contrast, VIGS of the GFP was targeted against PVX-GFP. Initially, VIGS of the GFP was initiated in all green tissues, as occurred with PDS VIGS. However, after 30 days of infection, the GFP VIGS was no longer initiated in newly emerging leaves, although it was maintained in tissue in which it had already been initiated. Based on these analyses, we propose a model for VIGS in which the initiation of VIGS is dependent on the virus and maintenance of it is virus independent.

Transgene-promoted epigenetic switches of chalcone synthase activity in petunia plants

Epigenetic variation affecting pigment pattern formation in petunia flowers due to the insertion of transgenes encoding chalcone synthase is described. The loss of pigment formation in petals or parts of petals is due to the post-transcriptional degradation of chalcone synthase RNA, from both the endogenous petunia chalcone synthase genes and from the chalcone synthase transgenes. The RNA cleavage pathway and its control are described. Different epigenetic states of RNA breakdown are correlated with specific cytosine methylation changes in the coding sequences of the genes. The probability, extent and developmental location of chalcone synthase RNA breakdown are related to the number and organization of transgenes in the genome but epigenetic switches that affect RNA turnover probably occur in meristems and between sexual generations. Hypotheses to explain how the transgenes influence the levels of chalcone synthase RNA breakdown and how different epigenetic states are created are discussed.

A model for RNA-mediated gene silencing in higher plants

Homology-dependent gene silencing (HdGS) which is the generic term for transcriptional gene silencing (TGS), post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) and RNA-mediated virus-resistance (RmVR) has been shown to frequently occur in transgenic plants. The role of RNA as a target and initiator of PTGS and RmVR is more and more manifested. Because TGS is assumed to be induced by a DNA-DNA interaction-mediated promoter methylation, a possible involvement of RNA in TGS was not really considered up to now. In this review we attempt to demonstrate that all three types of HdGS could be triggered by one RNA-based mechanism. A model proposing TGS as a consequence of RNA-directed DNA methylation (RdDM) and a refined mRNA threshold mechanism are presented. In contrast to the view that high amounts of mRNA are required we assume that the concentration of RNAs that can serve as efficient templates for a plant-encoded RNA-directed RNA polymerase (RdRP) plays a key role in HdGS and possibly also in natural gene regulation of non-transformed cells. According to this idea a particular information must be encoded to render mRNA turn-over products a suitable RdRP substrate. It will be discussed that such a mechanism could account for the silencing phenomena of poorly transcribed transgenes. Finally, an explanation for the coherency between PTGS and DNA methylation is documented.

RNA-mediated virus resistance in transgenic plants

In recent years the concept of pathogen-derived resistance (PDR) has been successfully exploited for conferring resistance against viruses in many crop plants. Starting with coat protein-mediated resistance, the range has been broadened to the use of other viral genes as a source of PDR. However, in the course of the efforts, often no clear correlation could be made between expression levels of the transgenes and observed virus resistance levels. Several reports mentioned high resistance levels using genes incapable of producing protein, but in these cases, even plants accumulating high amounts of transgene RNA were not most resistant. To accommodate these unexplained observations, a resistance mechanism involving specific breakdown of viral RNAs has been proposed. Recent progress towards understanding the RNA-mediated resistance mechanism and similarities with the co-suppression phenomenon will be discussed.

Tomato Spotted Wilt Virus Resistance in Chrysanthemum Expressing the Viral Nucleocapsid Gene

Three tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) nucleocapsid (N) gene constructs were employed for Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of chrysanthemum (Dendranthema grandiflora) cv. Polaris. These constructs contained either a full-length N gene (pTSWVN+), a full-length N gene encoding a truncated N protein (pTSWVNt), or an antisense version of the full-length N gene (pTSWVN-), all derived from a dahlia isolate of TSWV (TSWV-D). Initial resistance screens were conducted on cuttings made from 152 pTSWVN+, 37 pTSWVNt, and 47 pTSWVN- transformed plants employing a highly virulent, heterologous strain of TSWV (TSWV-GB) isolated from chrysanthemum and vectored by thrips. This screening served to eliminate the majority of TSWV-susceptible transgenic lines. More rigorous resistance tests with three rounds of mechanical inoculation with TSWV-GB identified one pTSWVNt and two pTSWVN- transformed lines that exhibited a total lack of systemic symptoms and no virus accumulation. Six other lines, including some pTSWVN+, exhibited a lack of one or more of the destructive necrotic TSWV symptoms (stem canker and apical bud death) and a delay in symptom expression. Both sense and antisense constructs, therefore, were found to be effective at yielding TSWV resistance in chrysanthemum. Molecular analysis revealed that the highly TSWV-resistant pTSWVNt line had no detectable levels of N protein. All three resistant lines had low levels of N gene transcript and at least three transgene insertion sites within their genomes, although susceptible lines often had a similar number of insertion sites. The generation of Polaris lines resistant to TSWV transmitted either mechanically or by thrips represents the first time a major ornamental crop has been genetically engineered for disease resistance.

Plum pox potyvirus resistance associated to transgene silencing that can be stabilized after different number of plant generations

Nicotiana benthamiana plants were transformed with a fragment of the plum pox potyvirus (PPV) genome that encodes the nuclear inclusion a (NIa) and b (NIb) proteins and the N-terminus of the capsid protein (NIa-NIb-CP). Lines transformed with this PPV genomic fragment harboring mutations in the GDD replicase-motif were also obtained. Plants of NIaDeltaV lines that carry a GDD to VDD mutation in the PPV transgene, were immune to PPV infection. The resistance was highly specific, since it was only partially overcome by a PPV strain different to that from which the transgene was derived, and no resistance was observed after inoculation with a second potyvirus. PPV was not able to replicate in protoplasts isolated from NIaDeltaV transgenic plants, indicating that the resistance was functional at the single cell level. Only a fraction of plants from lines transformed with the NIa-NIb-CP fragment harboring a GDD to ADD mutation (NIaDeltaA lines), were resistant to PPV infection. This same phenotype was observed in plants expressing the wild-type construction (NIaDelta), although the progeny of some non-infected plants seemed to be completely resistant to PPV, independently of the allelic status of the parental plant. In all cases, the resistance phenotype correlated positively with low levels of transgene mRNA accumulation, suggesting that it was mainly due to a gene silencing mechanism. Our results show that, although the transgene was not silenced in all R1 plants from some individual lines, a stable silenced status could be reached in the following generations.

Nicotiana benthamiana plants transformed with the plum pox virus helicase gene are resistant to virus infection

Nicotiana benthamiana Domin. plants were transformed with the cytoplasmic inclusion protein (CI) gene of plum pox potyvirus (PPV) to investigate, whether this non-structural protein would be able to confer resistance. The CI protein is an RNA helicase, which contains a conserved nucleotide binding motif (NTBM) and plays an important role in viral replication. Two gene constructions were developed for plant transformation. The first contains the original coding sequence of the CI gene under the control of 35S-promoter and nos terminator signal, the second is mutated in the NTBM region. Several transgenic plant lines were obtained following Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation. The integration of the viral genes into the plant genome was confirmed using the polymerase chain reaction and the transgene derived mRNAs were detected by Northern blot hybridization. The CI protein in the transgenic plants could not be detected by Western blot analyses. One transgenic line containing the mutated CI gene remained completely symptomless after PPV infection, indicating that the putative defective helicase gene was capable of eliciting virus resistance.

Concurrent suppression of virus replication and rescue of movement-defective virus in transgenic plants expressing the coat protein of potato virus X

A line of transgenic tobacco expressing the coat protein (CP) of potato virus X (PVX) was resistant against a broad spectrum of PVX strains. Inoculation of leaves and protoplasts with PVX expressing the jellyfish green fluorescent protein reporter gene revealed that this resistance mechanism suppressed PVX replication in the initially infected cell and systemic spread of the virus. Cell-to-cell movement was also slower in the resistant plants. The resistance at the level of replication was effective against wild-type PVX and also against movement-defective isolates with a frameshift mutation or deletion in the CP ORF. However, the cell-to-cell movement defect of the mutant viruses was rescued on the resistant plants. Based on these results it is proposed that the primary resistance mechanism is at the level of replication.

Systemic acquired silencing: transgene-specific post-transcriptional silencing is transmitted by grafting from silenced stocks to non-silenced scions

Using grafting procedures, we investigated the transmission of co-suppression of nitrate reductase and nitrite reductase host genes and transgenes and of post-transcriptional silencing of a uidA transgene encoding glucuronidase in tobacco. We demonstrate that silencing is transmitted with 100% efficiency from silenced stocks to non-silenced scions expressing the corresponding transgene. Transmission is unidirectional from stock to scion, transgene specific, locus independent and requires the presence of a transcriptionally active transgene in the target scion. The transmission of co-suppression occurs when silenced stocks and non-silenced target scions are physically separated by up to 30 cm of stem of a non-target wild-type plant. Taken together, these results suggest that a non-metabolic, transgene-specific, diffusable messenger mediates the propagation of de novo post-transcriptional silencing through the plant.

Nontarget DNA sequences reduce the transgene length necessary for RNA-mediated tospovirus resistance in transgenic plants

RNA-mediated virus resistance has recently been shown to be the result of post-transcriptional transgene silencing in transgenic plants. This study was undertaken to characterize the effect of transgene length and nontarget DNA sequences on RNA-mediated tospovirus resistance in transgenic plants. Transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana plants were generated to express different regions of the nucleocapsid (N) protein of tomato spotted wilt (TSWV) tospovirus. Transgenic plants expressing half-gene segments (387-453 bp) of the N gene displayed resistance through post-transcriptional gene silencing. Although smaller N gene segments (92-235 bp) were ineffective in conferring resistance when expressed alone in transgenic plants, these segments conferred resistance when fused to the nontarget green fluorescent protein gene DNA. These results demonstrate that (i) a critical length of N transgene (236-387 bp) is required for a high level of transgene expression and consequent gene silencing, and (ii) the post-transcriptional gene silencing mechanism can trans-inactivate the incoming tospovirus genome with homologous transgene segments that are as short as 110 bp. Therefore, the activation of post-transcriptional transgene silencing requires a significantly larger transgene than is required for the trans-inactivation of the incoming viral genome. These results raise the possibility of developing a simple new strategy for engineering multiple virus resistance in transgenic plants.

Consistent gene silencing in transgenic plants expressing a replicating potato virus X RNA

Tobacco plants were transformed with constructs in which the transgene was a cDNA of replicating potato virus X (PVX) RNA. The constructs, referred to here as amplicons, were the intact genome of PVX and PVX constructs modified to carry the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene either as an additional gene or as a replacement for the coat protein gene (PVX/GUS/CP and PVX/GUS respectively). Transformed plants carrying these constructs displayed several phenotypes that we attribute to post-transcriptional gene silencing. These phenotypes include the absence of viral symptoms, low accumulation of transgene-derived RNA, extreme strain-specific resistance against PVX, low and non-uniform GUS expression (in the PVX/GUS and PVX/GUS/CP plants) and suppression of transiently expressed RNA sharing homology with the transgene. Importantly, the amplicon-mediated gene silencing was exhibited in all lines tested. There was no evidence of gene silencing in seven lines expressing a PVX RNA that was unable to replicate. From these data we conclude that the replicating viral RNA is a potent trigger of gene silencing. Moreover, amplicon-mediated gene silencing provides an important new strategy for the consistent activation of gene silencing in transgenic plants.

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in plants

Overexpression of chimeric transgenes in plants can trigger post-transcriptional gene silencing that is dependent on epigenetic information and physiological conditions. The current view is that unproductive RNA serves as a crucial signal for gene silencing, although direct evidence is lacking for this theory. A signalling cascade then leads to strongly enhanced turnover of all RNAs that share a critical degree of sequence similarity. The molecular details of the mechanism are, however, insufficiently understood to explain the phenomenon completely and to comprehend its biological significance.

Mechanisms and applications of pathogen-derived resistance in transgenic plants

Genes that confer viral pathogen-derived resistance (PDR) include those for coat proteins, replicases, movement proteins, defective interfering RNAs and DNAs, and nontranslated RNAs. In addition to developing disease-resistant plant varieties for agriculture, PDR has increased the understanding of viral pathogenesis and disease. Furthermore, significant advances in elucidating the fundamental principles underlying resistance will lead to second and third generation genes that confer increased levels of sustainable resistance.

RNA-mediated RNA degradation and chalcone synthase A silencing in petunia

Transgenic Petunia plants with a chsA coding sequence under the control of a 35S promoter sometimes lose endogene and transgene chalcone synthase activity and purple flower pigment through posttranscriptional chsA RNA degradation. In these plants, shorter poly(A)+ and poly(A)- chsA RNAs are found, and a 3' end-specific RNA fragment from the endogene is more resistant to degradation. The termini of this RNA fragment are located in a region of complementarity between the chsA 3' coding region and its 3' untranslated region. Equivalent chsA RNA fragments remain in the white flower tissue of a nontransgenic Petunia variety. We present a model involving cycles of RNA-RNA pairing between complementary sequences followed by endonucleolytic RNA cleavages to describe how RNA degradation is likely to be promoted.

RNA as a target and an initiator of post-transcriptional gene silencing in transgenic plants

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in transgenic plants is the manifestation of a mechanism that suppresses RNA accumulation in a sequence-specific manner. The target RNA species may be the products of transgenes, endogenous plant genes or viral RNAs. For an RNA to be a target it is necessary only that it has sequence homology to the sense RNA product of the transgene. There are three current hypotheses to account for the mechanism of post transcriptional gene silencing. These models all require production of an antisense RNA of the RNA targets to account for the specificity of the mechanism. There could be either direct transcription of the antisense RNA from the transgene, antisense RNA produced in response to over expression of the transgene or antisense RNA produced in response to the production of an aberrant sense RNA product of the transgene. To determine which of these models is correct it will be necessary to find out whether transgene methylation, which is frequently associated with the potential of transgenes to confer post-transcriptional gene silencing, is a cause or a consequence of the process.

RNA as a target and an initiator of post-transcriptional gene silencing in transgenic plants

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in transgenic plants is the manifestation of a mechanism that suppresses RNA accumulation in a sequence-specific manner. The target RNA species may be the products of transgenes, endogenous plant genes or viral RNAs. For an RNA to be a target it is necessary only that it has sequence homology to the sense RNA product of the transgene. There are three current hypotheses to account for the mechanism of post transcriptional gene silencing. These models all require production of an antisense RNA of the RNA targets to account for the specificity of the mechanism. There could be either direct transcription of the antisense RNA from the transgene, antisense RNA produced in response to over expression of the transgene or antisense RNA produced in response to the production of an aberrant sense RNA product of the transgene. To determine which of these models is correct it will be necessary to find out whether transgene methylation, which is frequently associated with the potential of transgenes to confer post-transcriptional gene silencing, is a cause or a consequence of the process.

Roles of the sequence encoding tobacco etch virus capsid protein in genome amplification: requirements for the translation process and a cis-active element

The roles of the capsid protein (CP) and the CP coding sequence of tobacco etch potyvirus (TEV) in genome amplification were analyzed. A series of frameshift-stop codon mutations that interrupted translation of the CP coding sequence at various positions were introduced into the TEV genome. A series of 3' deletion mutants that lacked the CP coding sequence beyond each of the frameshift-stop codon mutations were also produced. In addition, a series of 5' CP deletion mutants were generated. Amplification of genomes containing either frameshift-stop codon insertions after codons 1, 59, 103, and 138 or genomes containing the corresponding 3' deletions of the CP coding sequence was reduced by 100- to 1,000-fold relative to that of the parental genome in inoculated protoplasts. In contrast, a mutant containing a frameshift-stop codon after CP position 189 was amplified to 27% of the level of the parental virus, but the corresponding 3' deletion mutant lacking codons 190 to 261 was nonviable. Deletion mutants lacking CP codons 2 to 100, 2 to 150, 2 to 189, and 2 to 210 were amplified relatively efficiently in protoplasts, but a deletion mutant lacking codons 2 to 230 was nonviable. None of the amplification-defective frameshift-stop codon or deletion mutants was rescued in transgenic cells expressing TEV CP, although the transgenic CP was able to rescue intercellular movement defects of replication-competent CP mutants. Coupled with previous results, these data led to the conclusions that (i) TEV genome amplification requires translation to a position between CP codons 138 and 189 but does not require the CP product and (ii) the TEV CP coding sequence contains a cis-active RNA element between codons 211 and 246. The implications of these findings on mechanisms of RNA replication and genome evolution are discussed.